Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
01-10-2022, 02:30 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-10-2022, 02:33 PM by Shabby Russian.)
(01-10-2022, 12:13 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-10-2022, 11:30 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: When we appoint a manager I think they should get at least a whole season
And in this case probably at least 3 transfer windows.
It's a more difficult question to consider if we were in danger of relegation, but we're not, so to my mind there is no question of sacking Ismael before the season ends.
One of my concerns with the club is that the squad is unbalanced, defensively we have plenty of options but our goal scoring options are limited. And for my money that is the reason we are not in a better position.
That said, a concern is that the summer signings did not begin to address the issue of goal scorers. For example goals from midfield is a problem for us and we bring in Molumby who I believe has only ever scored 1 senior goal. Recruitment should be solving our problems not increasing them.
Are you suggesting that Val was not in control of the summer signings?
Whilst I agree patience is required most of the time, to say they get a whole season regardless, is madness. What if we were to lose say 15 in a row? Surely no manager, new or old can survive a run like that at this level?
The answer is balance. We shouldn't be knee-jerk but neither can we just have blind faith, there has to come a point where change is needed, regardless of contract length or projects.
I have called for his head, mainly after a shoddy performance and a few pints, but I don't really want that outcome as it just de-stabilizes the club, but, he has to find a way of getting things back on track in terms of results. We did it at the start of the season, with the same group of players, so it's in there somewhere, it's his job to bring it back.
If we have a good end to the season and comfortably make the play offs, with signs of clear improvement, then he deserves another window, regardless of what league we are in. If he doesn't, as painful as it may be, we have to start again as time will not be on our side.
I don't know if he is in charge of recruitment.
My point is this is a possible concern I have with him.
I did say I had concerns with him as a manager, but that I am prepared to be patient.
Also I did say it would be a more difficult question on keeping him for the whole season if we were in a relegation fight.But we're not, we haven't come close to losing 15 games on the trot.
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
I would guess that if any manager lost 15 games in a row they'd be sacked. Unless you manage Fort William or something.
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
Whatever and whoever is in charge, our success in the past has been built on TV money, good decision making, managerially sound appointments (mostly  ), good financial management and good quality scouting. Medium to long term plans will only work with TV money or investment so currently we really don't have a choice but to try everything to secure revenue through promotion now or at a push next season.
It's open to debate if we have all or any of the above currently in place. Worryingly I don't think we will progress at all unless we can say we have.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(01-10-2022, 02:30 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (01-10-2022, 12:13 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-10-2022, 11:30 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: When we appoint a manager I think they should get at least a whole season
And in this case probably at least 3 transfer windows.
It's a more difficult question to consider if we were in danger of relegation, but we're not, so to my mind there is no question of sacking Ismael before the season ends.
One of my concerns with the club is that the squad is unbalanced, defensively we have plenty of options but our goal scoring options are limited. And for my money that is the reason we are not in a better position.
That said, a concern is that the summer signings did not begin to address the issue of goal scorers. For example goals from midfield is a problem for us and we bring in Molumby who I believe has only ever scored 1 senior goal. Recruitment should be solving our problems not increasing them.
Are you suggesting that Val was not in control of the summer signings?
Whilst I agree patience is required most of the time, to say they get a whole season regardless, is madness. What if we were to lose say 15 in a row? Surely no manager, new or old can survive a run like that at this level?
The answer is balance. We shouldn't be knee-jerk but neither can we just have blind faith, there has to come a point where change is needed, regardless of contract length or projects.
I have called for his head, mainly after a shoddy performance and a few pints, but I don't really want that outcome as it just de-stabilizes the club, but, he has to find a way of getting things back on track in terms of results. We did it at the start of the season, with the same group of players, so it's in there somewhere, it's his job to bring it back.
If we have a good end to the season and comfortably make the play offs, with signs of clear improvement, then he deserves another window, regardless of what league we are in. If he doesn't, as painful as it may be, we have to start again as time will not be on our side.
I don't know if he is in charge of recruitment.
My point is this is a possible concern I have with him.
I did say I had concerns with him as a manager, but that I am prepared to be patient.
Also I did say it would be a more difficult question on keeping him for the whole season if we were in a relegation fight.But we're not, we haven't come close to losing 15 games on the trot. I didn't say we had, it was merely an example of why "When we appoint a manager I think they should get at least the whole season" is just not viable in such a results based business.
Take out the relegation battle because that is too extreme, what is the lowest you would accept us finishing this year and still think he should survive to have another go?
Posts: 10,435
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(01-10-2022, 03:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whatever and whoever is in charge, our success in the past has been built on TV money, good decision making, managerially sound appointments (mostly ), good financial management and good quality scouting. Medium to long term plans will only work with TV money or investment so currently we really don't have a choice but to try everything to secure revenue through promotion now or at a push next season.
It's open to debate if we have all or any of the above currently in place. Worryingly I don't think we will progress at all unless we can say we have.
I'm not sure where I read it, but somewhere, someone suggested we were holding PL parachute funds back to be able to support 3 seasons in the championship. £33m spend per season. This could account for our reluctance to splash the cash on transfers ?
It would be nice for the club to confirm or deny, but tradition says we don't discuss finances in public.
Posts: 1,036
Threads: 23
Joined: Jan 2019
Tradition is that the club doesn't comment on obvious bollox
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
01-10-2022, 04:41 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-10-2022, 04:45 PM by SW4Baggie.)
(01-10-2022, 03:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whatever and whoever is in charge, our success in the past has been built on TV money, good decision making, managerially sound appointments (mostly ), good financial management and good quality scouting. Medium to long term plans will only work with TV money or investment so currently we really don't have a choice but to try everything to secure revenue through promotion now or at a push next season.
It's open to debate if we have all or any of the above currently in place. Worryingly I don't think we will progress at all unless we can say we have.
It's a good job that good scouting, sound managerial appointments and good financial management are all built on short term, season to season planning.
(01-10-2022, 04:19 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (01-10-2022, 03:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whatever and whoever is in charge, our success in the past has been built on TV money, good decision making, managerially sound appointments (mostly ), good financial management and good quality scouting. Medium to long term plans will only work with TV money or investment so currently we really don't have a choice but to try everything to secure revenue through promotion now or at a push next season.
It's open to debate if we have all or any of the above currently in place. Worryingly I don't think we will progress at all unless we can say we have.
I'm not sure where I read it, but somewhere, someone suggested we were holding PL parachute funds back to be able to support 3 seasons in the championship. £33m spend per season. This could account for our reluctance to splash the cash on transfers ?
It would be nice for the club to confirm or deny, but tradition says we don't discuss finances in public.
Doubt it's quite that arbitrary... Relegated sides get 55% of PL revenue in Y1, 45% in Y2 and 20% in Y3 (so call it £55m, £45m and £20m)
This time round we're receiving 55% in Y1 and 45% in Y2 with nothing in Y3 - so (£55m and £45m) - I reckon we've probably skimmed £10m off this year and will pull another £5m or so off next year so we have enough to cover legacy fees for Grant and the wages we've given the likes of Grady at least in year 3.
Our budget will still reduce next year, and heavily in year 3.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(01-10-2022, 03:51 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-10-2022, 02:30 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (01-10-2022, 12:13 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-10-2022, 11:30 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: When we appoint a manager I think they should get at least a whole season
And in this case probably at least 3 transfer windows.
It's a more difficult question to consider if we were in danger of relegation, but we're not, so to my mind there is no question of sacking Ismael before the season ends.
One of my concerns with the club is that the squad is unbalanced, defensively we have plenty of options but our goal scoring options are limited. And for my money that is the reason we are not in a better position.
That said, a concern is that the summer signings did not begin to address the issue of goal scorers. For example goals from midfield is a problem for us and we bring in Molumby who I believe has only ever scored 1 senior goal. Recruitment should be solving our problems not increasing them.
Are you suggesting that Val was not in control of the summer signings?
Whilst I agree patience is required most of the time, to say they get a whole season regardless, is madness. What if we were to lose say 15 in a row? Surely no manager, new or old can survive a run like that at this level?
The answer is balance. We shouldn't be knee-jerk but neither can we just have blind faith, there has to come a point where change is needed, regardless of contract length or projects.
I have called for his head, mainly after a shoddy performance and a few pints, but I don't really want that outcome as it just de-stabilizes the club, but, he has to find a way of getting things back on track in terms of results. We did it at the start of the season, with the same group of players, so it's in there somewhere, it's his job to bring it back.
If we have a good end to the season and comfortably make the play offs, with signs of clear improvement, then he deserves another window, regardless of what league we are in. If he doesn't, as painful as it may be, we have to start again as time will not be on our side.
I don't know if he is in charge of recruitment.
My point is this is a possible concern I have with him.
I did say I had concerns with him as a manager, but that I am prepared to be patient.
Also I did say it would be a more difficult question on keeping him for the whole season if we were in a relegation fight.But we're not, we haven't come close to losing 15 games on the trot. I didn't say we had, it was merely an example of why "When we appoint a manager I think they should get at least the whole season" is just not viable in such a results based business.
Take out the relegation battle because that is too extreme, what is the lowest you would accept us finishing this year and still think he should survive to have another go?
It's such a vague question that has no definitive answer.
We could finish 10th, but the final handful of games everything clicks giving everyone a lot of hope for the next season.
Or we could qualify for the play offs, but lose heavily over both legs, leaving everyone in despair.
Posts: 852
Threads: 60
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(01-10-2022, 04:41 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (01-10-2022, 03:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whatever and whoever is in charge, our success in the past has been built on TV money, good decision making, managerially sound appointments (mostly ), good financial management and good quality scouting. Medium to long term plans will only work with TV money or investment so currently we really don't have a choice but to try everything to secure revenue through promotion now or at a push next season.
It's open to debate if we have all or any of the above currently in place. Worryingly I don't think we will progress at all unless we can say we have.
It's a good job that good scouting, sound managerial appointments and good financial management are all built on short term, season to season planning.
(01-10-2022, 04:19 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (01-10-2022, 03:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whatever and whoever is in charge, our success in the past has been built on TV money, good decision making, managerially sound appointments (mostly ), good financial management and good quality scouting. Medium to long term plans will only work with TV money or investment so currently we really don't have a choice but to try everything to secure revenue through promotion now or at a push next season.
It's open to debate if we have all or any of the above currently in place. Worryingly I don't think we will progress at all unless we can say we have.
I'm not sure where I read it, but somewhere, someone suggested we were holding PL parachute funds back to be able to support 3 seasons in the championship. £33m spend per season. This could account for our reluctance to splash the cash on transfers ?
It would be nice for the club to confirm or deny, but tradition says we don't discuss finances in public.
Doubt it's quite that arbitrary... Relegated sides get 55% of PL revenue in Y1, 45% in Y2 and 20% in Y3 (so call it £55m, £45m and £20m)
This time round we're receiving 55% in Y1 and 45% in Y2 with nothing in Y3 - so (£55m and £45m) - I reckon we've probably skimmed £10m off this year and will pull another £5m or so off next year so we have enough to cover legacy fees for Grant and the wages we've given the likes of Grady at least in year 3.
Our budget will still reduce next year, and heavily in year 3.
Correct clubs who have spent a single season in the prem only receive 2 years. Three of you’ve had consecutive years.
It’s been alleged we are holding back some monies for year three, but it’s conjecture at best.
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(01-10-2022, 04:41 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (01-10-2022, 03:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whatever and whoever is in charge, our success in the past has been built on TV money, good decision making, managerially sound appointments (mostly ), good financial management and good quality scouting. Medium to long term plans will only work with TV money or investment so currently we really don't have a choice but to try everything to secure revenue through promotion now or at a push next season.
It's open to debate if we have all or any of the above currently in place. Worryingly I don't think we will progress at all unless we can say we have.
It's a good job that good scouting, sound managerial appointments and good financial management are all built on short term, season to season planning.
(01-10-2022, 04:19 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (01-10-2022, 03:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whatever and whoever is in charge, our success in the past has been built on TV money, good decision making, managerially sound appointments (mostly ), good financial management and good quality scouting. Medium to long term plans will only work with TV money or investment so currently we really don't have a choice but to try everything to secure revenue through promotion now or at a push next season.
It's open to debate if we have all or any of the above currently in place. Worryingly I don't think we will progress at all unless we can say we have.
I'm not sure where I read it, but somewhere, someone suggested we were holding PL parachute funds back to be able to support 3 seasons in the championship. £33m spend per season. This could account for our reluctance to splash the cash on transfers ?
It would be nice for the club to confirm or deny, but tradition says we don't discuss finances in public.
Doubt it's quite that arbitrary... Relegated sides get 55% of PL revenue in Y1, 45% in Y2 and 20% in Y3 (so call it £55m, £45m and £20m)
This time round we're receiving 55% in Y1 and 45% in Y2 with nothing in Y3 - so (£55m and £45m) - I reckon we've probably skimmed £10m off this year and will pull another £5m or so off next year so we have enough to cover legacy fees for Grant and the wages we've given the likes of Grady at least in year 3.
Our budget will still reduce next year, and heavily in year 3.
The point is we can’t do any long term strategy that will imo see any real success without the TV parachute payments. We will be hoping for a GM style miracle again as we cut our spending every year to match our budget.
Some are living in a dream land where we get better the longer we stay in the division. I just don’t buy it.
|