Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(01-09-2022, 07:40 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (01-09-2022, 07:19 PM)TartanRug Wrote: (01-09-2022, 04:53 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-09-2022, 01:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: To clarify where I am...I haven't said anything about the manager getting the sack. I don't care who the manager is, what style he plays as long as the results match the resources they have. I didn't criticise or blame Bilic or Allardyce whilst we were in the Prem for our relegation as it was and I used the worn out phrase a lot akin to moving the deckchairs around on the Titanic. I did question whether Moore, Bilic and Val are getting enough out the squads at their disposal because we can and should be competing with the resources we have had for promotion. I don't think that's an unfair position to take and frankly football managers are well looked after whether they are a success or failure so the violin will be a small one, compared to say a ICU Doctor or Nurse in terms me caring one way or the other if they stay or leave.
I also don't think the current criticism is worse than it was for Allardyce, Pulis or Robson towards the end. Or for that matter the Little, Irvine, Gould, Buckley etc. Sadly I'm now old enough to remember the bad old days and fans moaned just as much then. More recently the stick I got personally for supporting Pulis during his tenure, which in the end turned sour was far worse than anyone supporting the current manager is getting. Some of that was understandable given I was deliberately confrontational at times but some of the criticism was completely irrational and hate filled.
Football support is completely irrational and the game itself is pretty meaningless when you stand back from it. The only thing social media has taught me about our own support is we aren't different, we aren't special we are just a group of individuals who see the world in a myriad of different ways. It has taken me a long time to accept this but the last five or so of years has made me accept it's true.
The current boss is getting far more slack than his results and everything deserve, his current win percentage is down on both Slav and Moore.
Having Gayle/JRod/Pereira/Grady (the good version) might be the reason for this.
Barnes too.
Both Moore and Billic’s squads had individuals of far greater ability than Vals.
So that's not down to the manager?? He liked and got Hugill, Reach, Molumby, Bryan, Mowatt are you suggesting that his view on players is limited to only those who run a lot and put effort in, rather than wanting those who can actually play? He loves Livermore and won't drop him unless forced to... I love the way the stuff gets twisted on here.
Facts, which all the alleged pragmatists (remember them? You were all them when it was all results that matter, not so long back that either FFS), Six's last 3 months have been garbage with results to match. If that's not being pragmatic then please, the next time it turns back into the results being the only thing that matter, just don't bother.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
01-10-2022, 09:18 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-10-2022, 09:20 AM by Sliced.)
(01-10-2022, 09:00 AM)MassDebater Wrote: So that's not down to the manager?? He liked and got Hugill, Reach, Molumby, Bryan, Mowatt are you suggesting that his view on players is limited to only those who run a lot and put effort in, rather than wanting those who can actually play? He loves Livermore and won't drop him unless forced to... I love the way the stuff gets twisted on here.
Facts, which all the alleged pragmatists (remember them? You were all them when it was all results that matter, not so long back that either FFS), Six's last 3 months have been garbage with results to match. If that's not being pragmatic then please, the next time it turns back into the results being the only thing that matter, just don't bother.
So you think Val walked through the door and laid it on the table to the board saying: "Here's an idea guys, let's sell our best player and then replace him exclusively with loans and frees"? Of course you don't, but it doesnt fit your narrative. We'd promised Pereira he could leave in January, months before Val got anywhere near the job and then basically filled the holes in the squad with the remit of "we're not paying any transfers fees this summer". That's a small pool to choose from. Despite this Mowatt on a free was arguably the free signing of the summer.
Val doesn't choose our budgets, I thought that was obvious but apparently not
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(01-10-2022, 09:18 AM)Sliced Wrote: (01-10-2022, 09:00 AM)MassDebater Wrote: So that's not down to the manager?? He liked and got Hugill, Reach, Molumby, Bryan, Mowatt are you suggesting that his view on players is limited to only those who run a lot and put effort in, rather than wanting those who can actually play? He loves Livermore and won't drop him unless forced to... I love the way the stuff gets twisted on here.
Facts, which all the alleged pragmatists (remember them? You were all them when it was all results that matter, not so long back that either FFS), Six's last 3 months have been garbage with results to match. If that's not being pragmatic then please, the next time it turns back into the results being the only thing that matter, just don't bother.
So you think Val walked through the door and laid it on the table to the board saying: "Here's an idea guys, let's sell our best player and then replace him exclusively with loans and frees"? Of course you don't, but it doesnt fit your narrative. We'd promised Pereira he could leave in January, months before Val got anywhere near the job and then basically filled the holes in the squad with the remit of "we're not paying any transfers fees this summer". That's a small pool to choose from. Despite this Mowatt on a free was arguably the free signing of the summer.
Val doesn't choose our budgets, I thought that was obvious but apparently not
So Slav and Dave DID choose our budgets? I give up. It's the same thing, they just seem to have better input into the level of loanees we got in. Pretty much none of us knew what MP was going to be like, so that was seen as a bit of a gamble, but Slav got who he wanted in. I'm guessing here, but I suspect given how low MP's wages were that we probably paid less for his loan than we've paid for Hugills...
Mowatt has looked great and has also looked out of his depth this season.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
01-10-2022, 09:32 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-10-2022, 09:35 AM by Ted Maul.)
Give Val BDs or Bilic' team and he wins the league.
We were promoted in spite of Bilic and BD has finally found his level with Sheffield Wednesday.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
01-10-2022, 09:35 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-10-2022, 09:37 AM by Sliced.)
Are you intentionally pretending to not understand? Slav's budget was bigger than Val's, Dave's budget was bigger than Val's. Slav brought in 7 players that we paid transfer fees for, we had a much higher wage budget whereby we could attract a greater pool of players. Yes we sold players at the end of that season, but we actually got reasonable transfer fees for players when we had a higher quality of squad and then we actively reinvested that money. We could afford to bring in Grosicki and pay him 40k per week to sit on the bench that season. Slav had a few flops too but when you can pay fees for 7 players and then get another 5 in on loan without too much worry about wages then you've got a lot more chance of getting things right.
It's like trying to argue that "Thomas Farke should've be performing at the same level as Guardiola, they both got the players they want in"
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(01-10-2022, 09:32 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Give Val BDs or Bilic' team and he wins the league.
We were promoted in spite of Val and BD has finally found his level with Sheffield Wednesday.
You really think that Six would know how to utilise Pereira? He's shown with Grady that he really doesn't know what to do up that end, so don't get why you assume he'd suddenly do things differently?
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
01-10-2022, 09:40 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-10-2022, 09:41 AM by Ted Maul.)
(01-10-2022, 09:36 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-10-2022, 09:32 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Give Val BDs or Bilic' team and he wins the league.
We were promoted in spite of Val and BD has finally found his level with Sheffield Wednesday.
You really think that Six would know how to utilise Pereira? He's shown with Grady that he really doesn't know what to do up that end, so don't get why you assume he'd suddenly do things differently?
Imagine this system, which is the best we've looked defensively for years with Barnes - Gayle - Rodriguez upfront. Be miles clear.
Imagine Bilic' team if it didn't concede so many stupid goals and could see out a game? No wonder we looked woeful when we got promoted. We were unfit and disorganised but it's OK as we had a few players who could do stepovers. Fact is, we couldn't do the basics.
We've done it to death. You don't like Val's style, it's not the best. But he's done more good that harm this season and based on our start of season predictions this was our weakest squad at this level for years. We're about where we should be, if we'd have had a striker we'd be even higher. The criticism is fine, but your ignorance to the positives just makes you look saft.
Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
01-10-2022, 09:40 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-10-2022, 09:43 AM by Lillwall's left foot.)
(01-10-2022, 09:18 AM)Sliced Wrote: (01-10-2022, 09:00 AM)MassDebater Wrote: So that's not down to the manager?? He liked and got Hugill, Reach, Molumby, Bryan, Mowatt are you suggesting that his view on players is limited to only those who run a lot and put effort in, rather than wanting those who can actually play? He loves Livermore and won't drop him unless forced to... I love the way the stuff gets twisted on here.
Facts, which all the alleged pragmatists (remember them? You were all them when it was all results that matter, not so long back that either FFS), Six's last 3 months have been garbage with results to match. If that's not being pragmatic then please, the next time it turns back into the results being the only thing that matter, just don't bother.
So you think Val walked through the door and laid it on the table to the board saying: "Here's an idea guys, let's sell our best player and then replace him exclusively with loans and frees"? Of course you don't, but it doesnt fit your narrative. We'd promised Pereira he could leave in January, months before Val got anywhere near the job and then basically filled the holes in the squad with the remit of "we're not paying any transfers fees this summer". That's a small pool to choose from. Despite this Mowatt on a free was arguably the free signing of the summer.
Val doesn't choose our budgets, I thought that was obvious but apparently not We all have our own view. Thsts all good. Mine are just based on what we read/hear.
Seems to me Val bought Mowatt with him and wanted Dike, but the price was too high in the summer. So he's said to the board....keep your money in your pocket until December as this young fella is worth the wait. So holding back the Dike cash he presents a list of requirements to our recruitment team.
They offer Hugill for CF, its not worked out but i see the reasoning as a stop gap..he had a good season for QPR just a couple of seasons ago, watch the clips he looked confident, strong, sharp and hungry. A totally different player to the one we've seen.
Val also wanted a LCB and Clarke was a no brainer, we most likely took on Molomby, as a punt, as a result of discussions around Clarke. Bryan was taken on as cover, again a cheap option totally backfiring.
Reach is a West Brom recruitment team signing if I've ever seen one. Ticks a lot of the boxes, 28 year old utility player with no resale value who came gratis.
These may all have been on Vals wishlist, but Val he has publically commented recently, before bringing in Dike, that we need to change the way we recruit. Moving away from taking on experienced players just because they are available and creating capital assets. Which shapes my views above.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
My rule of thumb is that the closer to the game a comment is made, the more likely it is to be irrational.
I'm in the not totally convinced by Ismael, but prepared to be patient camp. Because the alternative is that the managerial job becomes a revolving door, where each successive manager gets less time in the job.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(01-10-2022, 10:27 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: My rule of thumb is that the closer to the game a comment is made, the more likely it is to be irrational.
I'm in the not totally convinced by Ismael, but prepared to be patient camp. Because the alternative is that the managerial job becomes a revolving door, where each successive manager gets less time in the job. That's where I am, I desperately want him to succeed because I want us to succeed, but, at present it's hard to be optimistic because nothing really changes.
The question regarding patience with the rebuild project and this is a genuine question, not a dig at anyone, is how long do you give it?
If 2 wins in 12 becomes 2 in 24, should we still have faith. 2 in 30?
It's one thing to belittle fans who are frustrated and claim they can't see the bigger picture but, what if they can and Val is simply not the man?
To be honest my opinion on the manager changes on a regular basis, based on results, performances etc., and I don't apologise for that, he's just a bloke, I don't really have any affinity towards him. Same with the players, judge them on the job they do as I see it. Of course that may differ to other people's view but that's what makes this place interesting.
|