Just done.
#71
On reflection, we always have to have someone to blame. That's the nature of our fans.
Over the years
Owners, Managers, Players alike.
Some have been IMO blamed for anything or everything.
Some have come through it others not.
Johnstone, Livermore, Phillips, Hugill currently and Zohore, Sawyer's, Chadli, even Brunt over the last few seasons.
Constructive criticism has been replaced by a strange destructive influence - although I was all for Val at the beginning of the season I believe he has failed and I cannot see where the improvement is coming from. Yes he's had no real financial support, but he took the job fully knowing what was at his disposal.
Changing managers is a last resort, but a managers position is governed by results. 
The small crowd yesterday was to be expected. 
FAC game against an unattractive side, in winter with Covid and a miserable damp grey day. 
We are WBA and our support will never fade.
Losing to the other Albion felt nothing like the Woking loss.
Lastly our neighbors have secured owners who have thrown millions to get them promoted, but are they ever going to win anything. Nope. 
All things considered things are not great but we are still in the race.
Reply
#72
To save time just a list of responses…

We have won two games in twelve, scored six goals and had six players sent off… not acceptable no matter how it is dressed up. Particularly when you consider the teams we have played.

Since Megson pulled off a miracle, the club has only progressed through TV money, without it our entire business model is in tatters. Take a look at our commercial activity and fan base and then think in a few years time where we will be if the parachute payments have dried up. As much as Ashworth etc got plaudits for where we are it was Peace and Sky’s money that gave us the edge over our comparative rivals.

We are apparently now building a long term strategy around a young manager who has had one decent season in the Championship with Barnsley. This seems to be the new narrative. If this strategy if indeed it is true was under the management of Hodgson as an example then it would be a decent one but entrusting rebuilding an entire football department around a young manager with no experience to do what Ferguson did at Man Utd on a lot smaller scale is far too much to ask of anyone. His focus should be on promotion nothing more, nothing less.

I have doubts that anything good will happen with us staying in the Championship any longer than a season or two at most. Rebuilding the infrastructure behind the scenes of the football department is obviously crucial to our long term future but that should not be muddled with tying the future success of the club to a young manager that in CV terms has done very little to justify that trust. We have to have more than just a manager on a long term contract for that to succeed and we need success at first team level now not in two, three seasons to afford for that to happen if we carry on being a self sufficient club.

We have lost kids to other clubs ahem Villa because they can offer them and their families more money. That’s the greedy, ugly truth of football. It has very little to do with seeing a clear path into the first team and even if it did, the fact we have to have TV money to compete means we will see more experienced players on bigger wages in key positions because we cannot carry players at Prem level whilst they are learning their trade. It all comes down to money. Our academy was built on TV money everything we have achieved has been through shrewd investment in TV money, which is why we need promotion not in two, three, four, five years but asap. Depressing but true.

Be it Mowbray, Pulis, Bilic or Val results over the relative short term will determine their position. for good or bad. Let’s leave the whose the bestest, most reasonable, sensible, fervent support bobbins for another day.
Reply
#73
(01-08-2022, 08:19 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-08-2022, 08:18 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(01-08-2022, 07:53 PM)Duffers Wrote: What’s really pathetic is the number of our lot on Twitter getting pissy because Brighton call themselves Albion too.

Their official account posted THE Albion with the final score.
To me Utd are Man Utd not West Ham, Newcastle or Sheff Utd. Would suggest most football fans outside Sussex would say the same about us being the Albion.

I think you need to get out more.

I think CIM makes a valid point. I believe you live in London - how many West Ham fans do you hear say they support 'United'? I've never even heard them sing 'United' at games. 

We are, and hopefully always will be, THE Albion.
Reply
#74
(01-09-2022, 11:48 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: To save time just a list of responses…

We have won two games in twelve, scored six goals and had six players sent off… not acceptable no matter how it is dressed up. Particularly when you consider the teams we have played.

Since Megson pulled off a miracle, the club has only progressed through TV money, without it our entire business model is in tatters. Take a look at our commercial activity and fan base and then think in a few years time where we will be if the parachute payments have dried up. As much as Ashworth etc got plaudits for where we are it was Peace and Sky’s money that gave us the edge over our comparative rivals. 

We are apparently now building a long term strategy around a young manager who has had one decent season in the Championship with Barnsley. This seems to be the new narrative. If this strategy if indeed it is true was under the management of Hodgson as an example then it would be a decent one but entrusting rebuilding an entire football department around a young manager with no experience to do what Ferguson did at Man Utd on a lot smaller scale is far too much to ask of anyone. His focus should be on promotion nothing more, nothing less.

I have doubts that anything good will happen with us staying in the Championship any longer than a season or two at most. Rebuilding the infrastructure behind the scenes of the football department is obviously crucial to our long term future but that should not be muddled with tying the future success of the club to a young manager that in CV terms has done very little to justify that trust. We have to have more than just a manager on a long term contract for that to succeed and we need success at first team level now not in two, three seasons to afford for that to happen if we carry on being a self sufficient club.

We have lost kids to other clubs ahem Villa because they can offer them and their families more money. That’s the greedy, ugly truth of football. It has very little to do with seeing a clear path into the first team and even if it did, the fact we have to have TV money to compete means we will see more experienced players on bigger wages in key positions because we cannot carry players at Prem level whilst they are learning their trade. It all comes down to money. Our academy was built on TV money everything we have achieved has been through shrewd investment in TV money, which is why we need promotion not in two, three, four, five years but asap. Depressing but true.

Be it Mowbray, Pulis, Bilic or Val results over the relative short term will determine their position. for good or bad. Let’s leave the whose the bestest, most reasonable, sensible, fervent support bobbins for another day.

But at the risk of going round in circles,  what's the answer?
Reply
#75
(01-09-2022, 11:13 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-09-2022, 11:00 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Self entitlement and delusion has nothing to do with it. 

We’ve won 2 games in the last 12. Have as many sendings off, as we do goals in that time. The questioning of the manager is completely justified.

I argued that we should have given Slav more time and let him build us up (cue the mystics who will claim 'he was off anyway and didn't want to stay')... I suspect most of the Valites / Sixers / Ismaelogues were the ones shouting to get rid... Swings and roundabouts on here, now they're all for giving someone with a terrible recent record more time. Dave got sacked and we were in a far less worrying state, and at least didn't have almost half a team that has had reds. I'm glad that I paid almost no attention to yesterday's game.

I'm really not surprised that we had a sub 9k attendance yesterday, I think the actual majority have lost faith in Six, when Dave was here and we played Wigan in the 3rd round, we managed over 15k. Yes there's been Covid, but that hadn't affected the early season attendances, for me yesterday's attendance is mostly down to what Six has done to us, a lot probably expected him to just play the kids like against Arsenal, it would have probably been better if he had!

So you were happy to give Slav more time (despite a similar run of poor results in the Champ, a totally unfit team getting hammered every week in the Prem) but Val (a hard working team, great defensive record, only lacking goals) must go?

I for one wasn't particularly Slav out. I liked the guy. I wanted a fitter team yes, but saw no point in getting rid as we were doomed anyway.

What would the point be of sacking a manager now? In January? With little time to instill yet another way of playing and little time to identify and sign anyone to fit it?
Reply
#76
Firstly I should post more when pissed.

I think the issue I continue to have is the idea you have to be strongly for or against - it’s the loss of balance.

Is our current form and discipline good? Absolutely not. It’s poor. However, if you contextualise this ie this core group were poor last 15 games in the champ last time, many were bombed out by Sam, minimal financial support in the summer etc etc - then you can see all was not rosy whoever came in.

On balance the manage is doing things we want, integrating the academy, trying to develop a pathway to the first team, implementing a style of play from kids to seniors etc etc. in the meantime we also sit 4th. We now have a striker we’ve been crying out for.

My point remains judge him in May, promotion is the main and primary metric yes, but not the only one.

Finally, trying to use the attendance as an indicator of support for Val is Abhorrent. As soon as the draw was made the commercial team were doing Richardson Suite for £75 a pop. They knew as Remi said, that this would not be an attractive tie in the heart of winter. Can we stop with the correlation. When the causes are far broader.
Reply
#77
My last post for a while most probably.

It's not criticism that bothers me, I will always discuss with people around that when it's sensible.

It's the absolute vendetta that EVERYTHING is the managers fault, this is worse than the 90's, football worse than Pulis, he knows nothing hyperbole.

A post today that he's at fault we couldn't take the game to Brighton with 9.5 players, made up of kids and squad cover players. I fucking despair.

I'm out for a while, probably until the end of the season, if we do get promoted, I expect lots of humble pie, but I know their won't be, it will be promotion in spite of the manager blah blah blah, fucking bollocks.
Reply
#78
foreveralbion Wrote:Jesus wept.  Levels I'm at where I'm agreeing with Derek.

What is the point of this place If you can't vent about the club?

Its happened forever but nowadays its more prominent cos of the Internet.

On the whole this website pisses over other mediums when it comes to opinions on the albion.

Don't think our fan base is anymore entitled than it was 20vyears ago.

Agreed.
Were some of you not around in the Saunders, late Buckley and Little eras ?
Things were just a poisonous amongst the fans base. In fact, there used to be a lot much inter-Albion fan conflict in and round the ground and pre match pubs with rows and even fights fairly regular at the worst times.
Reply
#79
(01-09-2022, 12:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: My last post for a while most probably.

It's not criticism that bothers me, I will always discuss with people around that when it's sensible.

It's the absolute vendetta that EVERYTHING is the managers fault, this is worse than the 90's, football worse than Pulis, he knows nothing hyperbole.

A post today that he's at fault we couldn't take the game to Brighton with 9.5 players, made up of kids and squad cover players. I fucking despair.

I'm out for a while, probably until the end of the season, if we do get promoted, I expect lots of humble pie, but I know their won't be, it will be promotion in spite of the manager blah blah blah, fucking bollocks.

I wouldn't take it so personally, fella. I'm lucky in that I'm not tied to the Web all day, but I can take most of this with a pinch of salt. I have ups and downs on here and luckily reckon there are other things that really matter.
Reply
#80
(01-09-2022, 12:34 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(01-09-2022, 12:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: My last post for a while most probably.

It's not criticism that bothers me, I will always discuss with people around that when it's sensible.

It's the absolute vendetta that EVERYTHING is the managers fault, this is worse than the 90's, football worse than Pulis, he knows nothing hyperbole.

A post today that he's at fault we couldn't take the game to Brighton with 9.5 players, made up of kids and squad cover players. I fucking despair.

I'm out for a while, probably until the end of the season, if we do get promoted, I expect lots of humble pie, but I know their won't be, it will be promotion in spite of the manager blah blah blah, fucking bollocks.

I wouldn't take it so personally, fella. I'm lucky in that I'm not tied to the Web all day, but I can take most of this with a pinch of salt. I have ups and downs on here and luckily reckon there are other things that really matter.

Yep. I disagree with the 'It's all Vals fault' brigade but they are entitled to that opinion. The arguments aren't personal (at least i hope not). We all care about Th'Albiyun and want the best for it, nothing more.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)