Posts: 7,971
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
01-02-2022, 08:25 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-02-2022, 08:35 PM by MancBaggie.)
Watched from the press gantry today with some of the academy staff. The manager wants to make changes but the most he is getting this window is another CM. He is also targeting another CB - for some reason. Woodrow well down the list
Derek is right - we are frittering away our current advantage and should have more points per game with this squad and should be 2nd/3rd. Talking of using resources - which of our players is actually playing well at the moment?? Can’t think of 1. Marks
SJ 5. Genuinely can’t recall a more gormless decision maker. Incredibly bad 2nd half. The pass to himself was keystone cops
TGH 5. Weakest game yet. Bullied by the Wolves loanee and under the ball a lot
Townsend. 4.5. Really off it today - lucky to get away with that turn inside 2 half and ignoring the cross and delivery poor
Clarke. 6. Steady enough bar that error. Not sure I’d have hooked him - didn’t seem injured
Kipre 5.5. Slack and v last ditch today. Caught down sides first half - better 2nd
Bartley 6. Mixed game. Not in position early enough so gave away numerous cheap throws/corners. Gave it away terribly 2 half
Mowatt 5.5. V average and poor delivery before what was a red. Ponderous and then lunged. Needless
Jake 6. Just not good enough and rarely picks up 2nd balls or plays a penetrative pass. Effort is good
Callum 6. Good finish and made decent runs 2 half. Cardiff CM filled the space/ screened in front of him all 90. Should still be doing better given his previous form
Grant. 6. Dreadful first 45 - good assist and effort 2nd. He is just so limited - save for that shift to his right and shot.
Fellows. 5. Effort and touch there but muscled all game. We improved after he went off
Grady 7. Only marginal positive today. Best I’ve seen him on right and sparked that 15 min spell. Wrongly played through middle in the 10 men.
Reach 6. Tried to drive us forward but undermined by poor delivery and Townsend making similar runs/ taking his space.
Molomby 6. Right sub and gave us a little more energy. Booking marginalised him - but he took one for the team tbf as Cardiff were breaking
Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Posts: 10,524
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
Agree mostly. Thought Grant was our best player though. As I said on another thread, he was the only player trying to force the issue, take on a man and look to make things happen.
Overall. Absolute shite.
Posts: 7,971
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(01-02-2022, 08:40 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Agree mostly. Thought Grant was our best player though. As I said on another thread, he was the only player trying to force the issue, take on a man and look to make things happen.
Overall. Absolute shite.
A candidate for MOTM but the bar was low. His effort was there 2nd half. Just too many passes executed badly or poor end product.
It was yet another lukewarm overall performance- prob 5.5/10
Posts: 10,524
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
(01-02-2022, 08:42 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: (01-02-2022, 08:40 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Agree mostly. Thought Grant was our best player though. As I said on another thread, he was the only player trying to force the issue, take on a man and look to make things happen.
Overall. Absolute shite.
A candidate for MOTM but the bar was low. His effort was there 2nd half. Just too many passes executed badly or poor end product.
It was yet another lukewarm overall performance- prob 5.5/10
Call it as it was mate. Wank.
Im struggling to think back over the course of the season where our manager has made one tactical change, substitution or decision that has influenced the game to go in our way.
Posts: 27,981
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
Interesting point about muscle, doesn’t just apply to Fellows though. I thought the entire team was out-muscled and physically dominated by a big Cardiff side for the entire match.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
Good summary Manc and interesting comments re any incomings, with Lai there today he saw as much as anybody how we need extra players
Marks for me
SJ 4 - I’ve said all season he just smacks of somebody who doesn’t want to be here and has no desire to sign a new contract, links with 3-4 clubs and most recently Brighton, just cash in and take what we can now
TGH 4 Plenty of endeavor but struggled today, up against Cardiffs best player in the Wolves loaned, Green was it?
Townsend 4 Is quickly challenging Furlong for being bang out of form, playing with no composure or confidence, final ball shocking
Clarke 6 Our best centre half for me, one error but won all his aerial duels, understand Val wanted to go attacking by bringing Reack on but Clarke could have replaced Bartley in the centre for me
Bartley 5 Another one with shot confidence, just looks uncomfortable in possession and uncomfortable in his role
Kipre 6 Plays because of his ability to pick a pass and carry the ball forward, no issue him cure for me, in on merit
Livermore 5 Plenty of effort and passion as always but just slows us down and a passenger currently, really should be left out but won’t be with Mowatts 3 game ban
Mowatt 6 Don’t see the criticism myself, maybe it’s the shit around him that makes him shine for me but we create from nowhere except him from midfield, will be a massive loss unless Moloumby steps up, saft red not helped by Reach standing idly by instead of taking the ball
Fellows 5 Tidy in possession and quick feet displayed which he has but was bullied and crowded out, rightly hooked but will learn from it, one to watch moving forward
Robbo 6* Everything about Robbo, frustrating at times but great movement, quality finish and superb effort in the first half forcing a great save, plays every week for me
Grant 6. Terrible first half a lot better 2nd, him and Robbo either side of Dike has to be the way forward unless we get any fresh blood
Subs
Grady 6 lively and a shame we went to 10 as affected his impact when came more centrally
Reach 5 Understood the sub but Reach’s final ball was very poor in the main
Moloumby 5 Should have started alongside Mowatt for me, need his legs and ability to move forward
We are a team who play differently in the 2nd half,regardless of the HT score, it has to be tactical to play a little solid and pedestrian first half and clearly more narrow taking less risks. It was evident as soon as the 2nd half started Kipre and Clarke play a lot wider, pushing the two wing backs further forward, also the strikers move a lot more, often dropping deeper as our system becomes more fluid. We have to find a way to be more expansive from the get go at home as we know now with the exception of a few sides everybody will come here to park the bus, waste time and frustrate
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
The system never changes, it’s just the personnel within the system. If we have a limited number of squad options then it all becomes very predictable unless you try and mix up the formation or how we play.
It was fine when we were winning week in week out, but clearly now it’s gone stale.
When Dike plays we’ll really find out just how many of our problems were due to the system and how many were due to players not finishing chances. Dike was brought in to fit the system, so there’s no way the system will change.
Posts: 7,971
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(01-02-2022, 09:23 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Good summary Manc and interesting comments re any incomings, with Lai there today he saw as much as anybody how we need extra players
Marks for me
SJ 4 - I’ve said all season he just smacks of somebody who doesn’t want to be here and has no desire to sign a new contract, links with 3-4 clubs and most recently Brighton, just cash in and take what we can now
TGH 4 Plenty of endeavor but struggled today, up against Cardiffs best player in the Wolves loaned, Green was it?
Townsend 4 Is quickly challenging Furlong for being bang out of form, playing with no composure or confidence, final ball shocking
Clarke 6 Our best centre half for me, one error but won all his aerial duels, understand Val wanted to go attacking by bringing Reack on but Clarke could have replaced Bartley in the centre for me
Bartley 5 Another one with shot confidence, just looks uncomfortable in possession and uncomfortable in his role
Kipre 6 Plays because of his ability to pick a pass and carry the ball forward, no issue him cure for me, in on merit
Livermore 5 Plenty of effort and passion as always but just slows us down and a passenger currently, really should be left out but won’t be with Mowatts 3 game ban
Mowatt 6 Don’t see the criticism myself, maybe it’s the shit around him that makes him shine for me but we create from nowhere except him from midfield, will be a massive loss unless Moloumby steps up, saft red not helped by Reach standing idly by instead of taking the ball
Fellows 5 Tidy in possession and quick feet displayed which he has but was bullied and crowded out, rightly hooked but will learn from it, one to watch moving forward
Robbo 6* Everything about Robbo, frustrating at times but great movement, quality finish and superb effort in the first half forcing a great save, plays every week for me
Grant 6. Terrible first half a lot better 2nd, him and Robbo either side of Dike has to be the way forward unless we get any fresh blood
Subs
Grady 6 lively and a shame we went to 10 as affected his impact when came more centrally
Reach 5 Understood the sub but Reach’s final ball was very poor in the main
Moloumby 5 Should have started alongside Mowatt for me, need his legs and ability to move forward
We are a team who play differently in the 2nd half,regardless of the HT score, it has to be tactical to play a little solid and pedestrian first half and clearly more narrow taking less risks. It was evident as soon as the 2nd half started Kipre and Clarke play a lot wider, pushing the two wing backs further forward, also the strikers move a lot more, often dropping deeper as our system becomes more fluid. We have to find a way to be more expansive from the get go at home as we know now with the exception of a few sides everybody will come here to park the bus, waste time and frustrate
Cuzer
Yep - Giles I think it was from Wolves.
Interesting point on solidity first half and being more expansive second. We have been losing/ at 0-0 in a lot of home games since September
Posts: 2,824
Threads: 190
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation:
8
Reassuring that he wants a CM (having already found a forward). At least this manager is watching the same game as we are.
|