Posts: 293
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
The fanbase seems totally split on should val stay. I think he is doing OK and hopefully things can get better.
Here are the issues:
He has no plan b: Whilst he does not move hardly ever from his 3 4 3 the tactics have evolved, At the start of the season it was 100 miles an hour intense press. That has evolved into a blended style where we retain the ball much more and attempt to pass through the lines. Whilst formation is rigid throughout the club the style of play has many different plans
He is a long ball merchant: The defenders at the start of the season were obviously told to lamp it forward as soon as they could so we could press high if we didnt win the ball. We have changed but he is happy to lamp it up, particularly if the defender needs to get rid
He has his favorites: I think he clarified his comments regarding Livermore, that may have been an language issue. The players are monitored to within an inch of their lives. I would imagine he plays who produces the best stats. That being said, he does not seem to take notice of form and both wing backs look like they are way underperforming and in reach and TGH we have adequate replacements.
We lack quality: Yep, no doubt. We fucked up last year when we committed the best part of £40m on three players for the same position. It left us with limited money to refresh the squad. No one could imagine that Hugil would be this bad. I think in his last full season with QPR he got double figures goals
A striker wont make a difference: If we had won 2-0 at Derby and Barsnley then we would be currently the form team and no one can say we didnt deserve this. A new striker does not need to have scored all four goals but maybe one or two. A proper number 9 who got the chances robinson and hugil had would have easily scored in both games. Plus someone who knows the role would have been in better positions when the ball came into the and create space and lay offs for others
I am happy for Val to be given time. The season is by no means a disaster and the right signing or signings may just push us over the line
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
12-29-2021, 10:52 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-29-2021, 10:56 AM by SW4Baggie.)
Agree with this.
Val was naive in believing the same tactics he employed with Barnsley would work here and has had to tweak them during competitive games. His failure to realise teams would deny our press and consider a point a good result was a massive underestimation, and for me, his biggest mistake to date but he has rectified it, but doesn’t have the personel to make it work yet.
As I’ve just posted on another thread, based on performances in the last 10 games, we ought to have 6 more points than we do… had we had a striker even remotely capable of scoring routine chances there would be absolutely no pressure on Val other than a few dissenting voices believing it’s still the 70s and we ought to be playing the type of sexy swashbuckling football that didn’t win us anything.
If this was our last 10 results, we’d practically be top.
Derby 0 - WBA 1
Barnsley 0 - WBA 2
WBA 3 - Reading 1
Coventry 1 - WBA 1
WBA 1 - Forest 1
Blackpool 2 - WBA 3
Hudds 1 - WBA 1
WBA 1 - Boro 1
WBA 2 - Hull 0
Fulham 3 - WBA 1
Posts: 1,149
Threads: 75
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
4
for a high pressing team we have a pitiful number of players in the opposition box when we finally manage to get a decent cross in.
You don't need to be a world class striker to be capable of shinning the ball in from six yards. You just need to be there.
The lack of numbers if and when the ball arrives gives defenders an easy time.
Added to that is that when we do get numbers in the box, the quality of crossing and the inability to beat the first man has been abysmal of late.
Posts: 10,524
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
(12-29-2021, 10:52 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Agree with this.
Val was naive in believing the same tactics he employed with Barnsley would work here and has had to tweak them during competitive games. His failure to realise teams would deny our press and consider a point a good result was a massive underestimation, and for me, his biggest mistake to date but he has rectified it, but doesn’t have the personel to make it work yet.
As I’ve just posted on another thread, based on performances in the last 10 games, we ought to have 6 more points than we do… had we had a striker even remotely capable of scoring routine chances there would be absolutely no pressure on Val other than a few dissenting voices believing it’s still the 70s and we ought to be playing the type of sexy swashbuckling football that didn’t win us anything.
If this was our last 10 results, we’d practically be top.
Derby 0 - WBA 1
Barnsley 0 - WBA 2
WBA 3 - Reading 1
Coventry 1 - WBA 1
WBA 1 - Forest 1
Blackpool 2 - WBA 3
Hudds 1 - WBA 1
WBA 1 - Boro 1
WBA 2 - Hull 0
Fulham 3 - WBA 1
If my Aunty had bollox…
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(12-29-2021, 11:05 AM)Dumbo Wrote: (12-29-2021, 10:52 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Agree with this.
Val was naive in believing the same tactics he employed with Barnsley would work here and has had to tweak them during competitive games. His failure to realise teams would deny our press and consider a point a good result was a massive underestimation, and for me, his biggest mistake to date but he has rectified it, but doesn’t have the personel to make it work yet.
As I’ve just posted on another thread, based on performances in the last 10 games, we ought to have 6 more points than we do… had we had a striker even remotely capable of scoring routine chances there would be absolutely no pressure on Val other than a few dissenting voices believing it’s still the 70s and we ought to be playing the type of sexy swashbuckling football that didn’t win us anything.
If this was our last 10 results, we’d practically be top.
Derby 0 - WBA 1
Barnsley 0 - WBA 2
WBA 3 - Reading 1
Coventry 1 - WBA 1
WBA 1 - Forest 1
Blackpool 2 - WBA 3
Hudds 1 - WBA 1
WBA 1 - Boro 1
WBA 2 - Hull 0
Fulham 3 - WBA 1
If my Aunty had bollox…
If we played your auntie up top we’d have 5 more…
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(12-29-2021, 10:46 AM)petty sniper Wrote: The fanbase seems totally split on should val stay. I think he is doing OK and hopefully things can get better.
Here are the issues:
He has no plan b: Whilst he does not move hardly ever from his 3 4 3 the tactics have evolved, At the start of the season it was 100 miles an hour intense press. That has evolved into a blended style where we retain the ball much more and attempt to pass through the lines. Whilst formation is rigid throughout the club the style of play has many different plans
He is a long ball merchant: The defenders at the start of the season were obviously told to lamp it forward as soon as they could so we could press high if we didnt win the ball. We have changed but he is happy to lamp it up, particularly if the defender needs to get rid
He has his favorites: I think he clarified his comments regarding Livermore, that may have been an language issue. The players are monitored to within an inch of their lives. I would imagine he plays who produces the best stats. That being said, he does not seem to take notice of form and both wing backs look like they are way underperforming and in reach and TGH we have adequate replacements.
We lack quality: Yep, no doubt. We fucked up last year when we committed the best part of £40m on three players for the same position. It left us with limited money to refresh the squad. No one could imagine that Hugil would be this bad. I think in his last full season with QPR he got double figures goals
A striker wont make a difference: If we had won 2-0 at Derby and Barsnley then we would be currently the form team and no one can say we didnt deserve this. A new striker does not need to have scored all four goals but maybe one or two. A proper number 9 who got the chances robinson and hugil had would have easily scored in both games. Plus someone who knows the role would have been in better positions when the ball came into the and create space and lay offs for others
I am happy for Val to be given time. The season is by no means a disaster and the right signing or signings may just push us over the line
Agree. Just one thing, re the style of football. I believe we would be equally frustrated if we took 200 tippy tippy passes and failed to score. (and we would fail!)
The long ball doesn't have to be a dull watch, but for it to be entertaining, it needs to have a threat.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(12-29-2021, 11:01 AM)Offside Wrote: for a high pressing team we have a pitiful number of players in the opposition box when we finally manage to get a decent cross in.
You don't need to be a world class striker to be capable of shinning the ball in from six yards. You just need to be there.
The lack of numbers if and when the ball arrives gives defenders an easy time.
Added to that is that when we do get numbers in the box, the quality of crossing and the inability to beat the first man has been abysmal of late. This is exactly the issue which I’ve been hammering.
The crosses generally lead to nothing more than someone taking a pot shot from outside the area that cannons off the defenders legs. When did you last see 4 or 5 making runs into the box. Most of the time the ball goes in and there’s one or two bodies being outnumbered.
This is pivotal to our issues and why it hasn’t been noted on a greater scale bewilders me.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(12-29-2021, 10:46 AM)petty sniper Wrote: The fanbase seems totally split on should val stay. I think he is doing OK and hopefully things can get better.
Here are the issues:
He has no plan b: Whilst he does not move hardly ever from his 3 4 3 the tactics have evolved, At the start of the season it was 100 miles an hour intense press. That has evolved into a blended style where we retain the ball much more and attempt to pass through the lines. Whilst formation is rigid throughout the club the style of play has many different plans
He is a long ball merchant: The defenders at the start of the season were obviously told to lamp it forward as soon as they could so we could press high if we didnt win the ball. We have changed but he is happy to lamp it up, particularly if the defender needs to get rid
He has his favorites: I think he clarified his comments regarding Livermore, that may have been an language issue. The players are monitored to within an inch of their lives. I would imagine he plays who produces the best stats. That being said, he does not seem to take notice of form and both wing backs look like they are way underperforming and in reach and TGH we have adequate replacements.
We lack quality: Yep, no doubt. We fucked up last year when we committed the best part of £40m on three players for the same position. It left us with limited money to refresh the squad. No one could imagine that Hugil would be this bad. I think in his last full season with QPR he got double figures goals
A striker wont make a difference: If we had won 2-0 at Derby and Barsnley then we would be currently the form team and no one can say we didnt deserve this. A new striker does not need to have scored all four goals but maybe one or two. A proper number 9 who got the chances robinson and hugil had would have easily scored in both games. Plus someone who knows the role would have been in better positions when the ball came into the and create space and lay offs for others
I am happy for Val to be given time. The season is by no means a disaster and the right signing or signings may just push us over the line
Excellent post, my thoughts exactly. Still quietly confident Val will get us up this season.
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
With Val having a hissy fit after the Derby game.
Maybe just maybe he will wield the axe.
Old saying
Change the people or change the people.
Posts: 388
Threads: 37
Joined: Jun 2021
Reputation:
0
If he doesn't make changes next game people will begin to think he's all piss n wind .
|