Ashes
(12-17-2021, 11:13 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(12-17-2021, 10:45 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I have no suggestion for how we improve the batting situation, Burns would have been dropped a long time ago if Zac Crawley wasn't the alternative. Neither should be anywhere near the England test side, yet I've absolutely no idea who should be next in line as barely anyone scores any runs in the CC.

Selecting players that actually play regular red ball cricket would be a good start. This is the real disadvantage of the central contract system we have. Selectors feel obliged to select those under contract regardless of form, or how much red ball cricket (very few matches in most cases) they've played. 

It needs abolishing.  

Let those who want to chase money in white ball cricket auction their services off, and select those who play and perform in County cricket. 

Rob Yates for Warwickshire has just had an unbelievable season with Warwickshire, as have Hain and Burgess (excellent wicket keeper). 

I'd rather see those three in the line up than Burns, Pope and Buttler. 

For the record, Yates is 19, so it's probably a bit of a stretch to give him his first game at Test level during an Ashes tour, but you'll get the point I'm making. Give players who are in form and have relatively recent regular red ball experience, a chance over those who rarely play the form, and are clearly out of nick.  

However, it clearly needs common sense, which the ECB lack.

Central contracts have been overwhelmingly positive since they came in under Fletcher. There's a reason why its the chosen method of all the major cricket boards.

I'm not even sure playing white ball cricket is to blame. A lot of this Australian team has just won the World T20 and the majority will have IPL deals lined up for the spring.

Agree r.e. picking the FC players who are in form but if you look at the stats from the 2021 Championship Pope, Burns and Lawrence are all up there in terms of averages. Pope has potential and is one worth sticking with. I think it's gone for Burns now, but I don't see who the alternative, Jake Libby has scored a lot of runs at Worcester but the jump in quality is huge. Especially when we're shooting ourselves in the foot by picking an unbalanced side to accommodate bowlers who bat a bit and the blame there lies with the coach and the selectors. Although the rot started with Bayliss who spent every spare moment he had in Australia and effectively decided that the County Championship didn't exist.

I've searched the names you've mentioned. Yates whilst young has a career average of 32, Hain 35 and Burgess 34 (as keeper batsman) - none of those are indicative of scoring the volume of runs required at test match level. Predominantly because we expect them to make their runs in April and September when it's 10c and hooping round corners. The ECB have marginalised our FC game in favour of the Blast and now the Hundred. Until we get a decent amount of FC cricket played through July and August we will struggle to produce batsmen who make big runs and capable spin bowlers.

(12-17-2021, 11:19 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(12-17-2021, 10:45 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: A hell of a lot needs to change before we go to the Windies in March otherwise we'll get rolled over there too.

Burns looks cooked. Hameed, Malan and Root have enough credit. Pope if he's serious as a batsman needs to start batting at 5 and let Stokes bat 6. Foakes MUST be given the gloves, picked our best keeper would have probably saved us 150 runs in this match given the timing of Buttlers two drops. It's vital we persevere with a spin option, whether it is Leach (who I would go with), Bess or Parkinson. It gives us far more balance and allows the seamers a break. Throwing Leach in at the Gabba after no test cricket for 11 months tells you all you need to know about Silverwood as a coach. I have no suggestion for how we improve the batting situation, Burns would have been dropped a long time ago if Zac Crawley wasn't the alternative. Neither should be anywhere near the England test side, yet I've absolutely no idea who should be next in line as barely anyone scores any runs in the CC.

This series is going to be another mauling - one test win in Australia in a decade is absolutely pathetic. They've not even been that good throughout that period.

Have always loved cricket, as a kid I was better at that than I was at football, have always followed Worcestershire.
Is there an issue with the coaching at junior level ? My lad had an interest as a child, and joined a local clubs youth section. Was a promising batsman, but was told by the coach to crouch slightly, bat up by his shoulder . I said to him, no, keep the bat down, play straight etc, the coach told me not to interfere, my advice was old fashioned, ok if you want to play like Boycott etc,etc. He also wanted to learn to bowl spin. Again, no `the coaching manual says kids should bowl medium pace, off a short run up`.
Whichever `coach` taught Burns to bat like that should be done under the Trade Description Act.
Said to the lad earlier, regarding your view of the Aussies, this is by no means a great Australia side. Hardly any would get in a `best of` team ahead of Greg Chappell, Alan Border, Steve Waugh, Denis Lillee, Ian Healy etc.

There is a lot of received wisdom that is honestly total bollocks, especially amongst the old school coaches "that's the way it's always been done"

I've always thought the fewer moving parts for batting the better. Head in line, watch the thing, be on your toes to get forward or back and most importantly don't be scared of getting hit. For every Rory Burns there's a Steve Smith. You'd never tell a youngster that's the way to play, to pull off a technique like that you have to be seriously talented.

If your lad wants to bowl spin (I was never a bowler), Shane Warne for all his faults talks really well about this when he's on TV and in his book. Don't worry too much about where it lands, that'll come with practice. The key is putting some revs on the ball and actually trying to turn it. If you're a 'spinner' not trying to turn the ball, you're just a slow bowler. Get him in the nets and get him putting some revs on it.
Reply
(12-17-2021, 11:24 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-17-2021, 11:13 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(12-17-2021, 10:45 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I have no suggestion for how we improve the batting situation, Burns would have been dropped a long time ago if Zac Crawley wasn't the alternative. Neither should be anywhere near the England test side, yet I've absolutely no idea who should be next in line as barely anyone scores any runs in the CC.

Selecting players that actually play regular red ball cricket would be a good start. This is the real disadvantage of the central contract system we have. Selectors feel obliged to select those under contract regardless of form, or how much red ball cricket (very few matches in most cases) they've played. 

It needs abolishing.  

Let those who want to chase money in white ball cricket auction their services off, and select those who play and perform in County cricket. 

Rob Yates for Warwickshire has just had an unbelievable season with Warwickshire, as have Hain and Burgess (excellent wicket keeper). 

I'd rather see those three in the line up than Burns, Pope and Buttler. 

For the record, Yates is 19, so it's probably a bit of a stretch to give him his first game at Test level during an Ashes tour, but you'll get the point I'm making. Give players who are in form and have relatively recent regular red ball experience, a chance over those who rarely play the form, and are clearly out of nick.  

However, it clearly needs common sense, which the ECB lack.

Central contracts have been overwhelmingly positive since they came in under Fletcher. There's a reason why its the chosen method of all the major cricket boards.

I'm not even sure playing white ball cricket is to blame. A lot of this Australian team has just won the World T20 and the majority will have IPL deals lined up for the spring.

Agree r.e. picking the FC players who are in form but if you look at the stats from the 2021 Championship Pope, Burns and Lawrence are all up there in terms of averages. Pope has potential and is one worth sticking with. I think it's gone for Burns now, but I don't see who the alternative, Jake Libby has scored a lot of runs at Worcester but the jump in quality is huge. Especially when we're shooting ourselves in the foot by picking an unbalanced side to accommodate bowlers who bat a bit and the blame there lies with the coach and the selectors. Although the rot started with Bayliss who spent every spare moment he had in Australia and effectively decided that the County Championship didn't exist.

I've searched the names you've mentioned. Yates whilst young has a career average of 32, Hain 35 and Burgess 34 (as keeper batsman) - none of those are indicative of scoring the volume of runs required at test match level. Predominantly because we expect them to make their runs in April and September when it's 10c and hooping round corners. The ECB have marginalised our FC game in favour of the Blast and now the Hundred. Until we get a decent amount of FC cricket played through July and August we will struggle to produce batsmen who make big runs and capable spin bowlers.

Some good points there. Particularly about the timing of when County cricket is played. 

I'm slightly surprised at those figures I'd have guessed Hain, in particular, would've had a higher average. However, having been a member down Warwickshire for some years now, those three play the right way, and have the right temperament, for red ball cricket. Something I can't say about the majority of the current England squad. 

I'm not calling for those three to play for England (although, I'd give Hain a go), I'm just trying to highlight the point regarding selecting players who have found success in the county game. 

How Fowkes isn't our wicket keeper, I'll never know.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
(12-17-2021, 11:24 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-17-2021, 11:13 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(12-17-2021, 10:45 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I have no suggestion for how we improve the batting situation, Burns would have been dropped a long time ago if Zac Crawley wasn't the alternative. Neither should be anywhere near the England test side, yet I've absolutely no idea who should be next in line as barely anyone scores any runs in the CC.

Selecting players that actually play regular red ball cricket would be a good start. This is the real disadvantage of the central contract system we have. Selectors feel obliged to select those under contract regardless of form, or how much red ball cricket (very few matches in most cases) they've played. 

It needs abolishing.  

Let those who want to chase money in white ball cricket auction their services off, and select those who play and perform in County cricket. 

Rob Yates for Warwickshire has just had an unbelievable season with Warwickshire, as have Hain and Burgess (excellent wicket keeper). 

I'd rather see those three in the line up than Burns, Pope and Buttler. 

For the record, Yates is 19, so it's probably a bit of a stretch to give him his first game at Test level during an Ashes tour, but you'll get the point I'm making. Give players who are in form and have relatively recent regular red ball experience, a chance over those who rarely play the form, and are clearly out of nick.  

However, it clearly needs common sense, which the ECB lack.

Central contracts have been overwhelmingly positive since they came in under Fletcher. There's a reason why its the chosen method of all the major cricket boards.

I'm not even sure playing white ball cricket is to blame. A lot of this Australian team has just won the World T20 and the majority will have IPL deals lined up for the spring.

Agree r.e. picking the FC players who are in form but if you look at the stats from the 2021 Championship Pope, Burns and Lawrence are all up there in terms of averages. Pope has potential and is one worth sticking with. I think it's gone for Burns now, but I don't see who the alternative, Jake Libby has scored a lot of runs at Worcester but the jump in quality is huge. Especially when we're shooting ourselves in the foot by picking an unbalanced side to accommodate bowlers who bat a bit and the blame there lies with the coach and the selectors. Although the rot started with Bayliss who spent every spare moment he had in Australia and effectively decided that the County Championship didn't exist.

I've searched the names you've mentioned. Yates whilst young has a career average of 32, Hain 35 and Burgess 34 (as keeper batsman) - none of those are indicative of scoring the volume of runs required at test match level. Predominantly because we expect them to make their runs in April and September when it's 10c and hooping round corners. The ECB have marginalised our FC game in favour of the Blast and now the Hundred. Until we get a decent amount of FC cricket played through July and August we will struggle to produce batsmen who make big runs and capable spin bowlers.

(12-17-2021, 11:19 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(12-17-2021, 10:45 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: A hell of a lot needs to change before we go to the Windies in March otherwise we'll get rolled over there too.

Burns looks cooked. Hameed, Malan and Root have enough credit. Pope if he's serious as a batsman needs to start batting at 5 and let Stokes bat 6. Foakes MUST be given the gloves, picked our best keeper would have probably saved us 150 runs in this match given the timing of Buttlers two drops. It's vital we persevere with a spin option, whether it is Leach (who I would go with), Bess or Parkinson. It gives us far more balance and allows the seamers a break. Throwing Leach in at the Gabba after no test cricket for 11 months tells you all you need to know about Silverwood as a coach. I have no suggestion for how we improve the batting situation, Burns would have been dropped a long time ago if Zac Crawley wasn't the alternative. Neither should be anywhere near the England test side, yet I've absolutely no idea who should be next in line as barely anyone scores any runs in the CC.

This series is going to be another mauling - one test win in Australia in a decade is absolutely pathetic. They've not even been that good throughout that period.

Have always loved cricket, as a kid I was better at that than I was at football, have always followed Worcestershire.
Is there an issue with the coaching at junior level ? My lad had an interest as a child, and joined a local clubs youth section. Was a promising batsman, but was told by the coach to crouch slightly, bat up by his shoulder . I said to him, no, keep the bat down, play straight etc, the coach told me not to interfere, my advice was old fashioned, ok if you want to play like Boycott etc,etc. He also wanted to learn to bowl spin. Again, no `the coaching manual says kids should bowl medium pace, off a short run up`.
Whichever `coach` taught Burns to bat like that should be done under the Trade Description Act.
Said to the lad earlier, regarding your view of the Aussies, this is by no means a great Australia side. Hardly any would get in a `best of` team ahead of Greg Chappell, Alan Border, Steve Waugh, Denis Lillee, Ian Healy etc.

There is a lot of received wisdom that is honestly total bollocks, especially amongst the old school coaches "that's the way it's always been done"

I've always thought the fewer moving parts for batting the better. Head in line, watch the thing, be on your toes to get forward or back and most importantly don't be scared of getting hit. For every Rory Burns there's a Steve Smith. You'd never tell a youngster that's the way to play, to pull off a technique like that you have to be seriously talented.

If your lad wants to bowl spin (I was never a bowler), Shane Warne for all his faults talks really well about this when he's on TV and in his book. Don't worry too much about where it lands, that'll come with practice. The key is putting some revs on the ball and actually trying to turn it. If you're a 'spinner' not trying to turn the ball, you're just a slow bowler. Get him in the nets and get him putting some revs on it.

He doesn`t play now, shame as the university he attends  has a team. But, as a 12 year old, saying he wanted to learn to bowl spin, he got no encouragement.
Reply
More wise words from Ian Chappell this morning.

"Why wouldn't you play your best wicket keeper? Buttler isn't even the best keeper in the squad and his batting isn't good enough to win him the gloves. Bairstow is better at both. But why isn't Foakes playing?"
Reply
(12-18-2021, 08:00 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: More wise words from Ian Chappell this morning.

"Why wouldn't you play your best wicket keeper? Buttler isn't even the best keeper in the squad and his batting isn't good enough to win him the gloves. Bairstow is better at both. But why isn't Foakes playing?"

Buttler is the Huggil of Test cricket, but the Ronaldo of white ball cricket.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
After Root and Malan every batsman has proved they are not up to Test cricket (Stokes can be excused I guess). Buttler doesn't cut it in either of his roles and the batting worry forces selection issues over what bowlers to pick. 150 for 2 to 204 for 8 - appalling and all too familiar.
Reply
Haven't even watched it this morning. This squad is so far behind the Aussies it's embarrassing.
Reply
However bad it gets we will always have the delight that is Stuart Broad batting.
Reply
That worked out really well. Broad and Anderson terrorised the Aussie batters, then Pope and Buttler provided a really strong spine for the batting order. And now we have the world's leading spin bowler in Root to capitalise on the conditions which Lyon found so helpful. What's not to like?
Reply
(12-18-2021, 10:15 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: That worked out really well. Broad and Anderson terrorised the Aussie batters, then Pope and Buttler provided a really strong spine for the batting order. And now we have the world's leading spin bowler in Root to capitalise on the conditions which Lyon found so helpful. What's not to like?

Two years planning and we've turned up at Adelaide with the same attack we did four years ago. 

No spinner. A wicket keeper that can't catch and openers that can't buy a run. 

Side is woefully unbalanced and we will get picked apart by every good side we play in any conditions we play them in until we address this.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)