Match Fred
You’re one down and he brings Grady off instead of a defender while Clarke seems to be playing most of the game in their half. VI is a fuckwit
Reply
(11-20-2021, 05:09 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Our major problem is that at least 2 of the front 3 are not good enough. Today, even when down to 10 men, we dominated and looked ok until the final third. But then, no movement up front, Diangana and Phillips were anonymous and lightweight and too often we had nobody looking to attack a cross. Special mention for the ref who seemed to apply different rules for the 2 teams. Free kick whenever a Huddersfield player went down, rarely gave us anything. Nonsense red card too.

Sounds about right. It's why I can't get the frustration about formation when I'm watching players play poorly. Would a different formation magically stop players hiding and being unable to pass? I doubt it.
Reply
(11-20-2021, 05:13 PM)Black Lake Victoria Wrote: I was castigated by some a couple of months ago when I posted on here that I would be over the moon if we made the play-offs....it's not rocket science; the squad we have is nowhere good enough, the players we brought in the last transfer window were on the whole from the bargain basement at the Happy Shopper store

And yet we're in the wankest second tier for ten years or more.

We really ought to be good enough for the top three, even with the ordinariness we added.

Hugill dreadful, Reach ordinary (one good game), Clarke OK, fortunately left-footed, but injury prone...

In fact I'm agreeing with you. Refer back to Camp 3 comment earlier in thread....
Reply
(11-20-2021, 05:16 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-20-2021, 05:09 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Our major problem is that at least 2 of the front 3 are not good enough. Today, even when down to 10 men, we dominated and looked ok until the final third. But then, no movement up front, Diangana and Phillips were anonymous and lightweight and too often we had nobody looking to attack a cross. Special mention for the ref who seemed to apply different rules for the 2 teams. Free kick whenever a Huddersfield player went down, rarely gave us anything. Nonsense red card too.

Sounds about right. It's why I can't get the frustration about formation when I'm watching players play poorly. Would a different formation magically stop players hiding and being unable to pass? I doubt it.

Thing is, our passing has actually improved in the last few weeks. HOWEVER, it's probably worse now in the final third. For me, we seem to keep wanting to cross it, when we have no player who is any good at getting onto crosses.
Reply
Joking aside, while I’d love to see Roy or Farke come in, it’s irrelevant if we don’t get a proper striker in January. We’d probably be 6-9 points better off with a Gayle (the version of 4-5 years ago). It’s not rocket science and we are paying the price for that blatant recruitment failure.
Reply
(11-20-2021, 05:13 PM)Black Lake Victoria Wrote: I was castigated by some a couple of months ago when I posted on here that I would be over the moon if we made the play-offs....it's not rocket science; the squad we have is nowhere good enough, the players we brought in the last transfer window were on the whole from the bargain basement at the Happy Shopper store

+1. We've got a few half decent players (at this level) but are so weak in vital areas. The manager isn't blameless but anyone who thinks we'll be vastly better under someone else (especially the kind of garbage we'd probably replace him with) is kidding themselves IMO
Reply
(11-20-2021, 05:20 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(11-20-2021, 05:13 PM)Black Lake Victoria Wrote: I was castigated by some a couple of months ago when I posted on here that I would be over the moon if we made the play-offs....it's not rocket science; the squad we have is nowhere good enough, the players we brought in the last transfer window were on the whole from the bargain basement at the Happy Shopper store

+1. We've got a few half decent players (at this level) but are so weak in vital areas. The manager isn't blameless but anyone who thinks we'll be vastly better under someone else (especially the kind of garbage we'd probably replace him with) is kidding themselves IMO

Agreed.
Reply
He is becoming an issue though. Robinson for Ireland looks like the Robinson who tore Chelsea apart twice last season. Under Ismael he looks a lost sheep. Likewise Diangana.
Reply
(11-20-2021, 05:29 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: He is becoming an issue though. Robinson for Ireland looks like the Robinson who tore Chelsea apart twice last season. Under Ismael he looks a lost sheep. Likewise Diangana.

Grady looked like that since lockdown.
Reply
I don’t buy the squad is poor, compared to all but Fulham and Bournemouth most managers in this division would be very happy to have our squad. The table reflects the complete dearth in quality in the Championship this season. The fact we are still third is testament to that.

My thoughts on our manager, aren’t particularly positive because we are very one dimensional. It took barely a handful of games to work out that by sitting deep and playing through our ludicrously high line we are both vulnerable and impotent in attack. We have four players in Diangana, Robinson, Grant and Phillips who have decent pace and skill who would suit a counter attacking team but they aren’t suited to playing against a teams that sit deep. Then we have a midfield who have all the guile and inventiveness of a brick. Hardly surprising that if you defend set pieces well against us then we create very little from that area of the pitch. At the back we don’t have the centre halves to look defensively solid with a high line, it’s too slow to do the job properly. This may seem like I’m contradicting my opinion on the squad but I’m not, I’m questioning wtf we are playing a formation and tactics that many in our squad are unsuited to. It seems pretty obvious to me that we would be better on the counter attack than this trendy high press / or weird hybrid where we try abs have possession without having any idea how to break down teams.

The squad is disjointed but it’s really not that bad relatively speaking, it’s just not been managed in a way that gets the best out of it currently.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: