Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
People tend to get bullied because they are different, whether it's the colour of their skin, their height, weight or the size of their nose and herein lies the problem as it's all dressed up as banter, whereby the truth is that all bullying is hurtful and, if relentless, can have serious consequences in terms of mental health.
You can't get rid of banter, especially in a team environment, as, when it's light hearted and inclusive, it promotes togetherness and comradery. What needs rooting out is bullying in every form and yes, if someone is singled out and bullied because of the colour of their skin it is racism.
Education is the way forward, so that everyone is respected equally, but that is still a very high hill to climb. What I will say though is that we should learn from our kids, as I find they are far more tolerant and respectful than past generations and are far more likely to call out these types of incidents, but they need to be listened to and taken seriously. It's ok saying things were different back in the day, but too many of these institutions are run by people from that very day and that's part of the problem!
Posts: 6,454
Threads: 192
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(11-17-2021, 10:47 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: People tend to get bullied because they are different, whether it's the colour of their skin, their height, weight or the size of their nose and herein lies the problem as it's all dressed up as banter, whereby the truth is that all bullying is hurtful and, if relentless, can have serious consequences in terms of mental health.
You can't get rid of banter, especially in a team environment, as, when it's light hearted and inclusive, it promotes togetherness and comradery. What needs rooting out is bullying in every form and yes, if someone is singled out and bullied because of the colour of their skin it is racism.
Education is the way forward, so that everyone is respected equally, but that is still a very high hill to climb. What I will say though is that we should learn from our kids, as I find they are far more tolerant and respectful than past generations and are far more likely to call out these types of incidents, but they need to be listened to and taken seriously. It's ok saying things were different back in the day, but too many of these institutions are run by people from that very day and that's part of the problem!
Agree education is the best way forward. As long as it is not public school education I venture. It appears (?) there is a distinct correlation between the the bullies and racists and their educational background.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(11-17-2021, 10:52 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (11-17-2021, 10:47 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: People tend to get bullied because they are different, whether it's the colour of their skin, their height, weight or the size of their nose and herein lies the problem as it's all dressed up as banter, whereby the truth is that all bullying is hurtful and, if relentless, can have serious consequences in terms of mental health.
You can't get rid of banter, especially in a team environment, as, when it's light hearted and inclusive, it promotes togetherness and comradery. What needs rooting out is bullying in every form and yes, if someone is singled out and bullied because of the colour of their skin it is racism.
Education is the way forward, so that everyone is respected equally, but that is still a very high hill to climb. What I will say though is that we should learn from our kids, as I find they are far more tolerant and respectful than past generations and are far more likely to call out these types of incidents, but they need to be listened to and taken seriously. It's ok saying things were different back in the day, but too many of these institutions are run by people from that very day and that's part of the problem!
Agree education is the best way forward. As long as it is not public school education I venture. It appears (?) there is a distinct correlation between the the bullies and racists and their educational background. All the way to the boardroom.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(11-17-2021, 10:47 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: People tend to get bullied because they are different, whether it's the colour of their skin, their height, weight or the size of their nose and herein lies the problem as it's all dressed up as banter, whereby the truth is that all bullying is hurtful and, if relentless, can have serious consequences in terms of mental health.
You can't get rid of banter, especially in a team environment, as, when it's light hearted and inclusive, it promotes togetherness and comradery. What needs rooting out is bullying in every form and yes, if someone is singled out and bullied because of the colour of their skin it is racism.
Education is the way forward, so that everyone is respected equally, but that is still a very high hill to climb. What I will say though is that we should learn from our kids, as I find they are far more tolerant and respectful than past generations and are far more likely to call out these types of incidents, but they need to be listened to and taken seriously. It's ok saying things were different back in the day, but too many of these institutions are run by people from that very day and that's part of the problem!
As disappointed as we may be that so much racism goes on this is what keeps things more positive than negative for me, as Bob alludes to, is that kids are far less accepting of any forms of it that we would have been at the same age and obviously a lot more so than my parents' generation. So we are moving in the right direction but still work to be done.
Posts: 7,972
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(11-17-2021, 08:36 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: (11-16-2021, 11:19 PM)Cuzer Wrote: RS
I think you’re reading what you want to again
Bresnans apology is telling? He’s apologized for any part he played in any grief his comments may have caused at any time, but categorically denies any racism?
And yep Balance did speak openly and honestly, it sounded very much warts and all to me, and still it hasn’t been responded to, just another allegation now he failed a drug test, which again he denies
Nothing has been proven, If Rafiq states something without hard evidence it’s pure hearsay until proven, innocent until proven guilty and all that, it’s the country we live in
As mentioned above a lot of this seems like bullying to me, but because he’s a Asian it’s now crossed the line to racism, not bullying
How many years do we want to go back? The world now is a different place, what was considered OK as banter 10 years ago clearly isn’t now, and rightly so
Watch Alf Garnett FFS, it was accepted as funny when aired, now its cringeworthy, the rules have changed, people are more knowledgeable and aware and sensitive to what they say and how it’s interpreted but this has changed only recently, we can’t keep digging up the past when the scenario was so so different
Cuzer
I disagree really strongly with you on this Cuz. But life is about opinions so no desire to fall out! I think some of what you say is true though - that a lot of Brennan’s alleged behaviour looks like bullying. But my take on the statement from Rafiq is that Big Bres targeted him specifically because he was Asian - ergo it was out and out racism. There was the telling part of his evidence where he says Bres blamed him for losing a T20 match because he knocked the bails off accidentally and the oppo hit a six off the extra delivery. Rafiq says the no ball didn’t directly lead to the defeat. But a white colleague - think it was Adam Lyth committed a silly error in a subsequent game that directly contributed to defeat and the reaction from Big Bres was totally different - supportive etc. Rafiq also alleges that Bres, despite being a senior figure in the dressing room took great delight in Ballance and others continuing use of the P word to Rafiq.
Bottom line is whether you believe the guy or not ( I do) it’s clear from his evidence that his career was ruined by all of this so comparing it to the language used in a fucking sitcom from the 1970s is, with respect, utter bollocks if the highest order.
Correct.
There is a world of difference between what is acceptable in the context of a county cricket club in the last decade to the bollocks that went largely unchecked in the 60s, 70s and indeed 80s
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
It’s ok that Rafiq has come out with all this racist stuff and if true it’s totally out of order in today’s climate, but I wonder if the boot was on the other foot has he or his fellow Asians ever said things about white or other people of a different race that is racist, it’s not all about them racism exists amongst all colours and race. It just seems a bit wrong to me that all racism seems to be about black people. It might just be me but it seems to me that everything said by Rafiq is supposed to correct and the the likes of Vaughan, Brennan, and any others named are telling lies and how do you prove this. Yes I do believe something went on and Rafiq is entitled to put his side but is it all true.!!!!!!
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(11-17-2021, 10:52 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (11-17-2021, 10:47 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: People tend to get bullied because they are different, whether it's the colour of their skin, their height, weight or the size of their nose and herein lies the problem as it's all dressed up as banter, whereby the truth is that all bullying is hurtful and, if relentless, can have serious consequences in terms of mental health.
You can't get rid of banter, especially in a team environment, as, when it's light hearted and inclusive, it promotes togetherness and comradery. What needs rooting out is bullying in every form and yes, if someone is singled out and bullied because of the colour of their skin it is racism.
Education is the way forward, so that everyone is respected equally, but that is still a very high hill to climb. What I will say though is that we should learn from our kids, as I find they are far more tolerant and respectful than past generations and are far more likely to call out these types of incidents, but they need to be listened to and taken seriously. It's ok saying things were different back in the day, but too many of these institutions are run by people from that very day and that's part of the problem!
Agree education is the best way forward. As long as it is not public school education I venture. It appears (?) there is a distinct correlation between the the bullies and racists and their educational background. Religion also plays a massive part in our education system and they are all, historically, steeped in racism, misogyny and anti-gay prejudice, to some degree, and this can't be ignored if we want a truly equal society.
Posts: 2,953
Threads: 67
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
12
(11-17-2021, 01:38 PM)wba13 Wrote: It’s ok that Rafiq has come out with all this racist stuff and if true it’s totally out of order in today’s climate, but I wonder if the boot was on the other foot has he or his fellow Asians ever said things about white or other people of a different race that is racist, it’s not all about them racism exists amongst all colours and race. It just seems a bit wrong to me that all racism seems to be about black people. It might just be me but it seems to me that everything said by Rafiq is supposed to correct and the the likes of Vaughan, Brennan, and any others named are telling lies and how do you prove this. Yes I do believe something went on and Rafiq is entitled to put his side but is it all true.!!!!!! Yes racism exists in every society. But you can't divorce racism from power. The power still rests overwhelmingly with white people. And, I agree with above statements, with those from a public school background.
I live near Bradford. In the late 20th century we had gangs going round "P.. bashing" . That's a sad fact.
But a young male relative of mine was attacked by a group of young Asian men, for being white.
Both wrong obviously.
But which happened more often?
As for "proof", there has to be more than one person's allegation. If 3 people say the same thing...is that proof?
It'll have to go through legal channels.
I see, on a separate issue, that the lovely David Bumble Lloyd has issued an apology for what he now sees as racist comments. Anyone who reads what he said in the past can see why he needs to apologise!
Posts: 6,454
Threads: 192
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(11-17-2021, 01:38 PM)wba13 Wrote: It’s ok that Rafiq has come out with all this racist stuff and if true it’s totally out of order in today’s climate, but I wonder if the boot was on the other foot has he or his fellow Asians ever said things about white or other people of a different race that is racist, it’s not all about them racism exists amongst all colours and race. It just seems a bit wrong to me that all racism seems to be about black people. It might just be me but it seems to me that everything said by Rafiq is supposed to correct and the the likes of Vaughan, Brennan, and any others named are telling lies and how do you prove this. Yes I do believe something went on and Rafiq is entitled to put his side but is it all true.!!!!!!
I await the white guy coming out and telling everyone he was pissed on in the showers but for the people of colour to say it's only banter.
I await the white guy who, after losing a child (god forbid) on returning to work has strips torn off him.
I await the white person who is passed over for someone of colour even though it's known that he was the better candidate.
I await the white guy who is forced to perform acts that go against his religion because it is only an exercise in fitting in.
I await the white guy who is the butt end of name calling because it is after all only boys being boys.
I await and I will have empathy with him/her because after all racism is in all communities. It is what gets done about it that needs to be addressed. It should not be laughed at or buried under fabrication and denial. It should not be allowed to go unpunished.
But just now it is clear that the biggest sufferers are people of colour and it has been known to be so for centuries. Doesn't mean we should turn a blind eye and carry on because of past ignorances. But some use that as an excuse to forgive or forget. And that should never be acceptable for any of us.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
11-17-2021, 03:05 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-17-2021, 03:08 PM by Spandaubaggie.)
(11-17-2021, 02:55 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (11-17-2021, 01:38 PM)wba13 Wrote: It’s ok that Rafiq has come out with all this racist stuff and if true it’s totally out of order in today’s climate, but I wonder if the boot was on the other foot has he or his fellow Asians ever said things about white or other people of a different race that is racist, it’s not all about them racism exists amongst all colours and race. It just seems a bit wrong to me that all racism seems to be about black people. It might just be me but it seems to me that everything said by Rafiq is supposed to correct and the the likes of Vaughan, Brennan, and any others named are telling lies and how do you prove this. Yes I do believe something went on and Rafiq is entitled to put his side but is it all true.!!!!!!
I await the white guy coming out and telling everyone he was pissed on in the showers but for the people of colour to say it's only banter.
I await the white guy who, after losing a child (god forbid) on returning to work has strips torn off him.
I await the white person who is passed over for someone of colour even though it's known that he was the better candidate.
I await the white guy who is forced to perform acts that go against his religion because it is only an exercise in fitting in.
I await the white guy who is the butt end of name calling because it is after all only boys being boys.
I await and I will have empathy with him/her because after all racism is in all communities. It is what gets done about it that needs to be addressed. It should not be laughed at or buried under fabrication and denial. It should not be allowed to go unpunished.
But just now it is clear that the biggest sufferers are people of colour and it has been known to be so for centuries. Doesn't mean we should turn a blind eye and carry on because of past ignorances. But some use that as an excuse to forgive or forget. And that should never be acceptable for any of us. It seems what went on in Yorkshire is proper backward.
We are all tribal to a degree but I'm fed up with a massive over-emphasis on race in society.
The problem is an elite- plenty of white people won't get on because they haven't the right school tie.
The most backward racist place is the likes of Eton and where do most PMs go?
Class and lack of opportunity, bullying- it's not just black and white. identity politics is doing society great harm.
yours
A Thick Paddy
|