Adil Rashid
#21
I'm not sure that racism is widespread in English cricket. Obviously, those affected will know more, and may provide anecdotal evidence to prove that it is unfortunately prevalent. But England have selected a number of British Asain players, as well as black players, throughout the years, surely they wouldn't have been called up if the whole set up was institutionally racist. I know it's not as simple as that, but it's just a thought.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#22
I actually know of someone doing a PhD into why Asians are well-represented at youth level, but not at senior standard. From what I know of his fieldwork so far, he wouldn't find these recent revelations surprising.
Reply
#23
(11-15-2021, 05:21 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I'm not sure that racism is widespread in English cricket. Obviously, those affected will know more, and may provide anecdotal evidence to prove that it is unfortunately prevalent.  But England have selected a number of British Asain players, as well as black players, throughout the years, surely they wouldn't have been called up if the whole set up was institutionally racist. I know it's not as simple as that, but it's just a thought.

I think the issue is more at county level in academies. Do players from Asian background (who form a large part of the cricketing community in much of the country) get a fair crack at the opportunities, or do the counties still prefer to give contracts to Anglo-Saxon grammar school boys?

It's also a disappointment that Caribbean communities have fallen out of love with cricket, both in the West Indies and the UK. That's often attributed to the increase in popularity of American sports, and the relative accessibility of a lucrative career in basketball etc from the West indies.

Having thought about it, I'll add to this. I do think Asian players have to do more to get selected for England. Saqib Mahmood was on fire for England's scratch ODI side in the summer. He made it into a Test squad, never played and is not in the Ashes squad. Does anyone think the elderly Anderson and Broad and the pedestrian Overton will cause the Aussies the slightest bother? Are they really going to replace the injured Archer and Stone effectively? If Mahmood had been white British or maybe South African/Zimbabwean etc, he'd be in the squad IMO.
Reply
#24
(11-15-2021, 05:30 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:21 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I'm not sure that racism is widespread in English cricket. Obviously, those affected will know more, and may provide anecdotal evidence to prove that it is unfortunately prevalent.  But England have selected a number of British Asain players, as well as black players, throughout the years, surely they wouldn't have been called up if the whole set up was institutionally racist. I know it's not as simple as that, but it's just a thought.

Having thought about it, I'll add to this. I do think Asian players have to do more to get selected for England. Saqib Mahmood was on fire for England's scratch ODI side in the summer. He made it into a Test squad, never played and is not in the Ashes squad. Does anyone think the elderly Anderson and Broad and the pedestrian Overton will cause the Aussies the slightest bother? Are they really going to replace the injured Archer and Stone effectively? If Mahmood had been white British or maybe South African/Zimbabwean etc, he'd be in the squad IMO.

You may have a point, however, there is no way that England would ever not take Anderson and Broad.  I'm not at all sold on Overton. Wood is a liability in terms of being injury prone.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#25
(11-15-2021, 05:56 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:30 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:21 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I'm not sure that racism is widespread in English cricket. Obviously, those affected will know more, and may provide anecdotal evidence to prove that it is unfortunately prevalent.  But England have selected a number of British Asain players, as well as black players, throughout the years, surely they wouldn't have been called up if the whole set up was institutionally racist. I know it's not as simple as that, but it's just a thought.

Having thought about it, I'll add to this. I do think Asian players have to do more to get selected for England. Saqib Mahmood was on fire for England's scratch ODI side in the summer. He made it into a Test squad, never played and is not in the Ashes squad. Does anyone think the elderly Anderson and Broad and the pedestrian Overton will cause the Aussies the slightest bother? Are they really going to replace the injured Archer and Stone effectively? If Mahmood had been white British or maybe South African/Zimbabwean etc, he'd be in the squad IMO.

You may have a point, however, there is no way that England would ever not take Anderson and Broad.  I'm not at all sold on Overton. Wood is a liability in terms of being injury prone.

With the huge experience these two have and with so many bowlers injured, plus the fact that Wood, Stokes and Woakes have all had injury issues, Broad and Anderson definitely merit their places. But I do think they are both pretty much finished (especially Jimmy who hardly took a second innings wicket all summer long). They've never done well in Oz and I'm not expecting them to this winter. If the quick bowlers had been available, would both of the old fellows be on the plane as well? We'll never know.
Reply
#26
(11-15-2021, 05:30 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:21 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I'm not sure that racism is widespread in English cricket. Obviously, those affected will know more, and may provide anecdotal evidence to prove that it is unfortunately prevalent.  But England have selected a number of British Asain players, as well as black players, throughout the years, surely they wouldn't have been called up if the whole set up was institutionally racist. I know it's not as simple as that, but it's just a thought.

I think the issue is more at county level in academies. Do players from Asian background (who form a large part of the cricketing community in much of the country) get a fair crack at the opportunities, or do the counties still prefer to give contracts to Anglo-Saxon grammar school boys?

It's also a disappointment that Caribbean communities have fallen out of love with cricket, both in the West Indies and the UK. That's often attributed to the increase in popularity of American sports, and the relative accessibility of a lucrative career in basketball etc from the West indies.

Having thought about it, I'll add to this. I do think Asian players have to do more to get selected for England. Saqib Mahmood was on fire for England's scratch ODI side in the summer. He made it into a Test squad, never played and is not in the Ashes squad. Does anyone think the elderly Anderson and Broad and the pedestrian Overton will cause the Aussies the slightest bother? Are they really going to replace the injured Archer and Stone effectively? If Mahmood had been white British or maybe South African/Zimbabwean etc, he'd be in the squad IMO.
Take it from me as FACT ... I know of at least several incidents relating to a much supported county on here where better, no significantly better, British Asian academy players were overlooked and released and drifted out of the county scene in favour of white British players.
Reply
#27
(11-15-2021, 02:17 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 01:22 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Rafiq's ongoing silence to Gary Ballances statement needs addressing ASAP

You can't pick and choose the past, what was said and when it suits your timescales, the fact he's not responsed to a very open, frank and no doubt difficult statement is piss poor

As for Vaughan, always had an Ego the size of Yorkshire itself, " too many of you lot" I deemed from day one as referring to Asian cricketers, if he's deemed racist for that comment, he's nowhere to go

The fact Essex are now going back to 2001 to bring up comments, what next, the Jamaicans from the 60's moving over to London and being racially abused? You'll need to send 50,000 to jail for using terms which nowadays are found offesnive, too much of a "me too" movement going on for me, but that's just my take on it

Cuzer
Oh let's turn this onto the victims. So Cuzer.

I shouldn't have expected a logical response from you should I really?

Cuzer

(11-15-2021, 06:06 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:30 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:21 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I'm not sure that racism is widespread in English cricket. Obviously, those affected will know more, and may provide anecdotal evidence to prove that it is unfortunately prevalent.  But England have selected a number of British Asain players, as well as black players, throughout the years, surely they wouldn't have been called up if the whole set up was institutionally racist. I know it's not as simple as that, but it's just a thought.

I think the issue is more at county level in academies. Do players from Asian background (who form a large part of the cricketing community in much of the country) get a fair crack at the opportunities, or do the counties still prefer to give contracts to Anglo-Saxon grammar school boys?

It's also a disappointment that Caribbean communities have fallen out of love with cricket, both in the West Indies and the UK. That's often attributed to the increase in popularity of American sports, and the relative accessibility of a lucrative career in basketball etc from the West indies.

Having thought about it, I'll add to this. I do think Asian players have to do more to get selected for England. Saqib Mahmood was on fire for England's scratch ODI side in the summer. He made it into a Test squad, never played and is not in the Ashes squad. Does anyone think the elderly Anderson and Broad and the pedestrian Overton will cause the Aussies the slightest bother? Are they really going to replace the injured Archer and Stone effectively? If Mahmood had been white British or maybe South African/Zimbabwean etc, he'd be in the squad IMO.
Take it from me as FACT ... I know of at least several incidents relating to a much supported county on here where better, no significantly better, British Asian academy players were overlooked and released and drifted out of the county scene in favour of white British players.

Come on then mouth, back it up with facts, sorry FACTS?

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#28
(11-15-2021, 06:06 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:30 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:21 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I'm not sure that racism is widespread in English cricket. Obviously, those affected will know more, and may provide anecdotal evidence to prove that it is unfortunately prevalent.  But England have selected a number of British Asain players, as well as black players, throughout the years, surely they wouldn't have been called up if the whole set up was institutionally racist. I know it's not as simple as that, but it's just a thought.

I think the issue is more at county level in academies. Do players from Asian background (who form a large part of the cricketing community in much of the country) get a fair crack at the opportunities, or do the counties still prefer to give contracts to Anglo-Saxon grammar school boys?

It's also a disappointment that Caribbean communities have fallen out of love with cricket, both in the West Indies and the UK. That's often attributed to the increase in popularity of American sports, and the relative accessibility of a lucrative career in basketball etc from the West indies.

Having thought about it, I'll add to this. I do think Asian players have to do more to get selected for England. Saqib Mahmood was on fire for England's scratch ODI side in the summer. He made it into a Test squad, never played and is not in the Ashes squad. Does anyone think the elderly Anderson and Broad and the pedestrian Overton will cause the Aussies the slightest bother? Are they really going to replace the injured Archer and Stone effectively? If Mahmood had been white British or maybe South African/Zimbabwean etc, he'd be in the squad IMO.
Take it from me as FACT ... I know of at least several incidents relating to a much supported county on here where better, no significantly better, British Asian academy players were overlooked and released and drifted out of the county scene in favour of white British players.

Perhaps you could name them.  The counties are very underrepresented in terms of state educated players, which is why it is good to see Chris Woakes doing well
Reply
#29
(11-15-2021, 06:05 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:56 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:30 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:21 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I'm not sure that racism is widespread in English cricket. Obviously, those affected will know more, and may provide anecdotal evidence to prove that it is unfortunately prevalent.  But England have selected a number of British Asain players, as well as black players, throughout the years, surely they wouldn't have been called up if the whole set up was institutionally racist. I know it's not as simple as that, but it's just a thought.

Having thought about it, I'll add to this. I do think Asian players have to do more to get selected for England. Saqib Mahmood was on fire for England's scratch ODI side in the summer. He made it into a Test squad, never played and is not in the Ashes squad. Does anyone think the elderly Anderson and Broad and the pedestrian Overton will cause the Aussies the slightest bother? Are they really going to replace the injured Archer and Stone effectively? If Mahmood had been white British or maybe South African/Zimbabwean etc, he'd be in the squad IMO.

You may have a point, however, there is no way that England would ever not take Anderson and Broad.  I'm not at all sold on Overton. Wood is a liability in terms of being injury prone.

With the huge experience these two have and with so many bowlers injured, plus the fact that Wood, Stokes and Woakes have all had injury issues, Broad and Anderson definitely merit their places. But I do think they are both pretty much finished (especially Jimmy who hardly took a second innings wicket all summer long). They've never done well in Oz and I'm not expecting them to this winter. If the quick bowlers had been available, would both of the old fellows be on the plane as well? We'll never know.

I think Mahmood is the "next cab of the rank" as they say, I was surprised he wasn't taken to Oz, Overton has gone before and done little, it's classic Englad as he offers a bit with the bat so we'll take him, a proper 100% but until he bowls at high 80's and not low 80's he's going to find test cricket a challenge, especially on those Oz pitches

Mahmood was superb when England C team rolled Pakistan in the ODI series, problem is if you look at his 4 day form for Lancashire pre Ashes squad selection he really returned bang average figures and I'm sure this worked against him when they made the final decision

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#30
Gzbaggy Wrote:
rsbaggy2 Wrote:
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
KratosBaggie Wrote:I'm not sure that racism is widespread in English cricket. Obviously, those affected will know more, and may provide anecdotal evidence to prove that it is unfortunately prevalent.  But England have selected a number of British Asain players, as well as black players, throughout the years, surely they wouldn't have been called up if the whole set up was institutionally racist. I know it's not as simple as that, but it's just a thought.

I think the issue is more at county level in academies. Do players from Asian background (who form a large part of the cricketing community in much of the country) get a fair crack at the opportunities, or do the counties still prefer to give contracts to Anglo-Saxon grammar school boys?

It's also a disappointment that Caribbean communities have fallen out of love with cricket, both in the West Indies and the UK. That's often attributed to the increase in popularity of American sports, and the relative accessibility of a lucrative career in basketball etc from the West indies.

Having thought about it, I'll add to this. I do think Asian players have to do more to get selected for England. Saqib Mahmood was on fire for England's scratch ODI side in the summer. He made it into a Test squad, never played and is not in the Ashes squad. Does anyone think the elderly Anderson and Broad and the pedestrian Overton will cause the Aussies the slightest bother? Are they really going to replace the injured Archer and Stone effectively? If Mahmood had been white British or maybe South African/Zimbabwean etc, he'd be in the squad IMO.
Take it from me as FACT ... I know of at least several incidents relating to a much supported county on here where better, no significantly better, British Asian academy players were overlooked and released and drifted out of the county scene in favour of white British players.

Perhaps you could name them.  The counties are very underrepresented in terms of state educated players, which is why it is good to see Chris Woakes doing well
Yep, back in the 70s a load of us young scallies from the council estate were turned away at our local league as they just wanted the grammar school boys. The same lads we could beat with one hand tied behind our backs. Cricket has a long history of picking the silver spoon kids. This YCCC argument is just that, a YCCC matter. Looking at my local club,I see a very well integrated sport. Room for improvement?  Maybe.  Totally racist, not a chance.  Those saying English cricket is institutionally racist might want to try a year in Australia.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)