Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(11-09-2021, 02:00 PM)Sotv Wrote: (11-09-2021, 12:09 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-09-2021, 12:01 PM)Fido Wrote: (11-09-2021, 11:48 AM)Sotv Wrote: (11-09-2021, 11:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote: It's debatable that the savings will outweigh the extra costs of being a independent nation not able to pull on the pooled resources. For that net contribution we actually got some 'free' services that we will now have to create.
So we've gone from 'sunlit uplands' and '£350M a week for the NHS' to 'it's not as bad as some said'. That was well worth the cost then. Or conversely we have gone from £4,500 a year worse off, the need for an emergency budget and economic collapse to being in at least as a good a position as EU member states, no emergency budget and not being £4,500 a year worse off. Foreign companies such as Nissan have also underlined their commitment to a post Brexit UK.
What we have gained is the removal of a huge excuse used by politicians of all parties for unpopular decisions.
£350 million a week for the NHS was never promised and most of us who voted to leave never believed we would be spending that sum on the health service.
So given that the evidence suggests we are no worse off, just exactly why is it some people still seem insistent on telling us how terrible everything is and looking to blame everything on Brexit? Could it be that some can't just accept they were wrong and were fooled by the lies of the remain campaign given they have spent the last 5 years calling leave voters stupid for believing lies?
Quite.
And you may have noticed I don't point out how bad off we are, because ultimately it makes no difference we are where we are now. But I will point out that it was a completely pointless exercise as it does make it more expensive to trade with, and visit the EU now. So as a country the best we are hoping for is its a bit 'meh' whereas for the individuals and businesses it is a pain in the arse. So we've gone through it all to make ourselves a bit less well off - great.
Gaining an excuse for politicians is not really a win as we appear to believe the shit they come out with anyway, and they can blatantly lie and fill their own, and their mates, pockets but I would lay good odds on you still voting for them next time. Really?
"All of which could have happened whilst we were in the EU so as you were. We are worse off from leaving, it means nothing what any politician said either way, there are no benefits to leaving apart from ideological ones."
Remainer pre Brexit 'facts' come true. (wbaunofficial.org.uk)
"So basically, we've spent billions of pounds and wasted 5 years of our lives to be a little bit worse off? That was worth it."
Brexit Gains 2 (wbaunofficial.org.uk)
And it's not an excuse for politicians we have gained, quite the opposite. Voting to leave has removed an excuse they could previously fall back on.
Yeah really, I'm not saying that the sky is falling in, I'm saying simply that we are a bit worse off. I'm saying this because it's true and based on the long running question of where we are better off. It really is a simple fact now, I don't think anyone can argue that point any more - I'm also saying that highlights it was a waste of time.
And, here is the key point, whilst people keep running around saying we are better off we will never improve the position. So I'm asking you to take your head out of the sand, realise it's all a bit shit and a waste of time, but lets work to improving the situation.
Posts: 1,972
Threads: 136
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(11-09-2021, 02:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-09-2021, 02:00 PM)Sotv Wrote: (11-09-2021, 12:09 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (11-09-2021, 12:01 PM)Fido Wrote: (11-09-2021, 11:48 AM)Sotv Wrote: Or conversely we have gone from £4,500 a year worse off, the need for an emergency budget and economic collapse to being in at least as a good a position as EU member states, no emergency budget and not being £4,500 a year worse off. Foreign companies such as Nissan have also underlined their commitment to a post Brexit UK.
What we have gained is the removal of a huge excuse used by politicians of all parties for unpopular decisions.
£350 million a week for the NHS was never promised and most of us who voted to leave never believed we would be spending that sum on the health service.
So given that the evidence suggests we are no worse off, just exactly why is it some people still seem insistent on telling us how terrible everything is and looking to blame everything on Brexit? Could it be that some can't just accept they were wrong and were fooled by the lies of the remain campaign given they have spent the last 5 years calling leave voters stupid for believing lies?
Quite.
And you may have noticed I don't point out how bad off we are, because ultimately it makes no difference we are where we are now. But I will point out that it was a completely pointless exercise as it does make it more expensive to trade with, and visit the EU now. So as a country the best we are hoping for is its a bit 'meh' whereas for the individuals and businesses it is a pain in the arse. So we've gone through it all to make ourselves a bit less well off - great.
Gaining an excuse for politicians is not really a win as we appear to believe the shit they come out with anyway, and they can blatantly lie and fill their own, and their mates, pockets but I would lay good odds on you still voting for them next time. Really?
"All of which could have happened whilst we were in the EU so as you were. We are worse off from leaving, it means nothing what any politician said either way, there are no benefits to leaving apart from ideological ones."
Remainer pre Brexit 'facts' come true. (wbaunofficial.org.uk)
"So basically, we've spent billions of pounds and wasted 5 years of our lives to be a little bit worse off? That was worth it."
Brexit Gains 2 (wbaunofficial.org.uk)
And it's not an excuse for politicians we have gained, quite the opposite. Voting to leave has removed an excuse they could previously fall back on.
Yeah really, I'm not saying that the sky is falling in, I'm saying simply that we are a bit worse off. I'm saying this because it's true and based on the long running question of where we are better off. It really is a simple fact now, I don't think anyone can argue that point any more - I'm also saying that highlights it was a waste of time.
And, here is the key point, whilst people keep running around saying we are better off we will never improve the position. So I'm asking you to take your head out of the sand, realise it's all a bit shit and a waste of time, but lets work to improving the situation. so you have been saying we are worse off, just not to the extremes of some.
I'd say that removing that huge excuse from our politicians is a gain. Not all gains can be quantified in terms of finances.
I agree that we need to work towards improving our position, which makes me wonder why many on the losing side of the vote have spent so much time and energy trying to reverse the decision, castigating those they don't agree with and seeking to paint the situation in the worst possible light by jumping on anything at all as an excuse to roll out their tired "Brexshit" nonsense.
I think its time the remain camp stopped taking the ostrich position. There was a vote, they lost and instead of trying to move on so many of them have instead sought to sow division and have been busy throwing their toys out of their prams.
Anyway, this is clearly going to go round in circles, too many on both sides have bound up much of their own identities with if they are leavers or remainers and therefore will never want to acknowledge the other side may have valid points.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
So everything is ok then and this is as good as it gets - yay, feel much better now. Surely the only one's in the 'ostrich position' are those that don't see any problems since we left. The remainers aren't burying their heads and not seeing all the benefits that we have gained, or are there some other gains apart from taking away the EU excuse from the politicians that you will vote for no matter what.
Posts: 1,972
Threads: 136
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(11-09-2021, 03:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote: So everything is ok then and this is as good as it gets - yay, feel much better now. Surely the only one's in the 'ostrich position' are those that don't see any problems since we left. The remainers aren't burying their heads and not seeing all the benefits that we have gained, or are there some other gains apart from taking away the EU excuse from the politicians that you will vote for no matter what.
whatever benefits may be pointed out will be denied by the remain side, its been like this ever since they lost.
For one, i'm pleased we no longer subscribe to a racist immigration policy that prioritised white Europeans over Asian or African people.
The lowest paid in society are now looking at wage increases as the source for cheap east European labour dries up. Dunno about you but i'm quite happy to pay a few extra pence on a bottle of wine etc in order to ensure better wages for those on low pay.
By your own admission we are no worse off so i really don't get why leaving still remains an issue for you unless it has to do with your identity.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
As this has turned into a full-on Brexit debate, here's my tuppence worth.
One thing no-one can hide from is the Irish issue. We don't want to be part of the EU any more, so there has to be an enhanced border somewhere. We don't want to reimpose one between Ulster and Eire, for reasons of simple common sense and convenience as well as the fragile peace process. But there is deep-seated opposition to any increased border controls between Great Britain and Ulster, again for trade and political/historic reasons.
The only three ways in which this could be resolved were:
1 - An absolutely free trade agreement between UK and EU, whereby no additional checks were demanded or required by either side. We were told this could "easily" be achieved because it wouldn't be in EU's interests to refuse. But did anyone really believe that line?
2 - Re-Unification of Ireland, UK relinquishes any rights over Ulster. Not going to happen.
3 - UK retakes Ireland and incorporates it into UK. Even less likely.
This was flagged up by Remain and dismissed by the Leave campaign as part of "Project Fear". But here we are, Article 16 about to be invoked. It's going to get very nasty. Suspension of the entire trade deal would fuck us over very badly. No-one from Leave said our intention was to not trade with EU any more, it was always said that everything could carry on as normal. Not seeing that from where I sit.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
11-09-2021, 03:43 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-09-2021, 03:44 PM by baggy1.)
(11-09-2021, 03:16 PM)Sotv Wrote: (11-09-2021, 03:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote: So everything is ok then and this is as good as it gets - yay, feel much better now. Surely the only one's in the 'ostrich position' are those that don't see any problems since we left. The remainers aren't burying their heads and not seeing all the benefits that we have gained, or are there some other gains apart from taking away the EU excuse from the politicians that you will vote for no matter what.
whatever benefits may be pointed out will be denied by the remain side, its been like this ever since they lost.
For one, i'm pleased we no longer subscribe to a racist immigration policy that prioritised white Europeans over Asian or African people.
The lowest paid in society are now looking at wage increases as the source for cheap east European labour dries up. Dunno about you but i'm quite happy to pay a few extra pence on a bottle of wine etc in order to ensure better wages for those on low pay.
By your own admission we are no worse off so i really don't get why leaving still remains an issue for you unless it has to do with your identity.
Can't see where I have said we are no worse off, I've repeatedly said we are worse off but that's where we are so lets recognise the position and work our way out of it.
And it really takes some form of contortion to make out that free movement was a racist immigration policy, well done on that one, that took some doing. And don't want to point this out but Europe isn't just a lot of white folk heading for the UK, say it quietly in the conservative club this saturday night but Europeans include all sorts of races, creeds and colours as well, who'd have thunk it, eh. Good job we closed those borders then!
The low pay issue is easily sorted by taking away zero hours contracts and raising the minimum wage, we didn't have to take away the pool of talent that were readily available to pay taxes in this country to do that, the ability to put in those measures was always there.
Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
11-09-2021, 04:57 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-09-2021, 04:57 PM by JOK.)
(11-09-2021, 09:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So what you are saying is that leaving the EU made no difference, glad we spent all that time and money on it when we needed it elsewhere as you have highlighted.
No what I’m saying is, all the things the board’s extreme, vitriol spouting, pessimist-in-chief continually spews as proof that being out of the E.U. is evidence that leaving was wrong, are in fact ridiculous. Whilst inventing inflammatory policies and quotes (“Told to go back to their own country”) is, I believe, designed to increase division and an exaggerated impression of racism.
I will continue to call out this blaming of every poor state of affairs on Brexit or one specific political party, and in isolation from the rest of the world, for the blinkered ideology it is.
I will not be bounced into judging differences, benefits or detriments after just 10 months.
Glad you concur that all the examples I cited have nothing to do with Brexit.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(11-09-2021, 04:57 PM)JOK Wrote: (11-09-2021, 09:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So what you are saying is that leaving the EU made no difference, glad we spent all that time and money on it when we needed it elsewhere as you have highlighted.
No what I’m saying is, all the things the board’s extreme, vitriol spouting, pessimist-in-chief continually spews as proof that being out of the E.U. is evidence that leaving was wrong, are in fact ridiculous. Whilst inventing inflammatory policies and quotes (“Told to go back to their own country”) is, I believe, designed to increase division and an exaggerated impression of racism.
I will continue to call out this blaming of every poor state of affairs on Brexit or one specific political party, and in isolation from the rest of the world, for the blinkered ideology it is.
I will not be bounced into judging differences, benefits or detriments after just 10 months.
Glad you concur that all the examples I cited have nothing to do with Brexit.
When do you feel will be a good period to judge any of those items?
Posts: 2,502
Threads: 567
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(11-09-2021, 03:19 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: As this has turned into a full-on Brexit debate, here's my tuppence worth.
One thing no-one can hide from is the Irish issue. We don't want to be part of the EU any more, so there has to be an enhanced border somewhere. We don't want to reimpose one between Ulster and Eire, for reasons of simple common sense and convenience as well as the fragile peace process. But there is deep-seated opposition to any increased border controls between Great Britain and Ulster, again for trade and political/historic reasons.
The only three ways in which this could be resolved were:
1 - An absolutely free trade agreement between UK and EU, whereby no additional checks were demanded or required by either side. We were told this could "easily" be achieved because it wouldn't be in EU's interests to refuse. But did anyone really believe that line?
2 - Re-Unification of Ireland, UK relinquishes any rights over Ulster. Not going to happen.
3 - UK retakes Ireland and incorporates it into UK. Even less likely.
This was flagged up by Remain and dismissed by the Leave campaign as part of "Project Fear". But here we are, Article 16 about to be invoked. It's going to get very nasty. Suspension of the entire trade deal would fuck us over very badly. No-one from Leave said our intention was to not trade with EU any more, it was always said that everything could carry on as normal. Not seeing that from where I sit. If anyone wants to understand " the Irish issue " it might be helpful if they understood a third of Ulster is in the Republic.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(11-09-2021, 05:26 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote: (11-09-2021, 03:19 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: As this has turned into a full-on Brexit debate, here's my tuppence worth.
One thing no-one can hide from is the Irish issue. We don't want to be part of the EU any more, so there has to be an enhanced border somewhere. We don't want to reimpose one between Ulster and Eire, for reasons of simple common sense and convenience as well as the fragile peace process. But there is deep-seated opposition to any increased border controls between Great Britain and Ulster, again for trade and political/historic reasons.
The only three ways in which this could be resolved were:
1 - An absolutely free trade agreement between UK and EU, whereby no additional checks were demanded or required by either side. We were told this could "easily" be achieved because it wouldn't be in EU's interests to refuse. But did anyone really believe that line?
2 - Re-Unification of Ireland, UK relinquishes any rights over Ulster. Not going to happen.
3 - UK retakes Ireland and incorporates it into UK. Even less likely.
This was flagged up by Remain and dismissed by the Leave campaign as part of "Project Fear". But here we are, Article 16 about to be invoked. It's going to get very nasty. Suspension of the entire trade deal would fuck us over very badly. No-one from Leave said our intention was to not trade with EU any more, it was always said that everything could carry on as normal. Not seeing that from where I sit. If anyone wants to understand " the Irish issue " it might be helpful if they understood a third of Ulster is in the Republic.
So my woeful lack of geographical knowledge is the issue here, not the valid point I made about the resolution of the "Irish Brexit issue"? Thanks for clearing that up.
|