Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(11-06-2021, 11:59 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (11-06-2021, 11:55 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Is Val doing the absolute utmost he could with this squad?
It's a "No" from me. They are above average Championship players looking average at best some of the time. The coach has to take some responsibility for days of under-achievement like today.
How can he be blamed for players not being able to do the basics though?
People keep talking about a Plan B.
Today we had little problem getting through their midfield. We also got the ball into their box plenty. But our front three were by and large, useless. A formation change wouldn't have helped that.
Apparently it's Val's fault Robinson cannot complete the most simple of passes because he scored against some part-timers for Ireland.
If anything, I could pick at our set-pieces, as if we're struggling to score, we need those to be better. However, I suspect that players are doing it all during training, but can't replicate it on matchday.
Posts: 1,039
Threads: 48
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
I've been generally quiet this season and am at a 7/10 overall for Val based on results so far moreso than performances.
We're just about in the mix for autos still with a long way to go and, the Fulham game aside, have never been out of games. Val certainly in for me and as said above things haven't been rosy at board level and the Pereira, Barry and Ferguson issues have magnified our deficiencies so Val is doing a good job at focusing on what he has. Players seem motivated and never seem to hide so you've got players working hard in a system that seems to both create chances (eventually) but do find ourselves often exposed, that Swansea game particularly paramount to showing how to carve out chance after chance against us. I can live with all that as it's impossible to be perfect and whilst we're in the championship, even though teams can expose us, they're not guaranteed to score bucketfuls against us.
The problem for me is that the chances we create are rarely good chances and the goals that come about are just keep battling until a chance eventually falls. This has worked in our favour in several games but it feels like we make harder work of it than it should be and pretty much all the forwards and midfielders aren't showing much of their strengths in the system itself. Grant does literally nothing except for score goals, Diangana hasn't been able to shine, Robinson often comes deep so we lose a player, the midfielders generally don't support the attack, Hugill doesn't help himself but doesn't get the support, Phillips has generally been a consistent 6/10, Snodgrass poor, and the fullbacks don't seem to have the same impact on the attack as they did.
The point is, there's zero fluidity and Val isn't playing a system to allow anyone to play to their strengths. We look like a team that have never played together and have gone backwards the further the season has gone on. Anyone who's worked for a big company as a cog in a machine role can empathise with players that are doing a job that's necessary but doesn't fulfil either what they want to do or utilise their strengths so it would not surprise me if they were getting a bit bored by the effort at this point.
Just to add, without Johnstone, I'm not sure we'd even be in the top 6. I see many post-match ratings where he gets a 6 and 'nothing to do' but he is an excellent keeper that has saved our skin many a time. So many times has he been super quick off his line to stop those balls over the top. It doesn't count as a shot but I don't think our other keepers have the confidence to do what he does and do it so successfully.
What do I hope from Val going forward? I'm not really sure what I'd do personally but utilising the strengths of the players to create more chances rather than win the ball and hope it goes to someone. That's where we've been poorest.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Good point about Johnstone.
He goes in January, kiss promotion goodbye. Our best player by a country mile, best keeper in this league by said country mile too.
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(11-07-2021, 02:04 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Good point about Johnstone.
He goes in January, kiss promotion goodbye. Our best player by a country mile, best keeper in this league by said country mile too.
That’s an interesting discussion point. His importance to us is magnified by our inability to score at the other end, a problem that we can only fix in January by signing a striker, which we quite probably can only achieve by selling Johnstone !
Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
11-07-2021, 09:21 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-07-2021, 09:46 AM by Lillwall's left foot.)
There is a feeling of uncertainty around the club at the moment, at all levels. This uncertainty is impacting on our trust in the manager.
There is uncertainty around our ownership. The club is worth half what they paid for it. Even on promotion it seems unlikely they will recover their investment. Are they ever going to cut their losses or will the club just stay in this limbo indefinitely? The leadership feels weak and uninterested with a lack of football knowledge at the top. Not an ideal situation for a manager to work in.
There is uncertainty about where we are in the pecking order; we are the Albion, a PL team last year and one of the favourites to go back up surely? However, our recruitment in the summer was that of a mid table champ club, as was losing our only creative force for half of what he was worth and not finding a replacement. From paying over the odds for Zahore and Grant to that dodgy deal to China and the Ferguson/Barry debacles our recent transfer business has looked poor to amateurish. The manager needs better support, but where\who from?
There is uncertainty around expectations. When Slav came in were told he had two years to get us up, and mainly due to the impact of MP and a pre injury Grady we over achieved (albeit limping over the line), however by over achieving we were unprepared for the PL. So what are the expectations for Val? He has a four year contract. The board have squirelled away money to ensure we are financially secure should we fail to get promotion, so If ever an appointment suggestion a longer term plan this is it? But against this there is a feeling that failure to win immediate promotion will leave us a step closer to becoming championship also rans as our financial advantage erodes. Are we really all in on this manager? shit or bust? The manager would benefit from us better understanding the owners expectations.
And finally, Val's style of play. We know how he wants to play, and it was great to see us smashing teams in those first few games. However, he has had to develop this hybrid style as a reaction to the opposition tactics and the deficiencies of players in key positions. I can see where he wants to go with this, a combination of passing out from the back with bursts of high press direct play, but at the moment it's not effective and his inflexibility is frustrating fans. However I don't see other high press managers changing their philosophies. It took Klipperty time to bring in the players he needed to make his system work, but was backed to do it. Bielsa was another that took time to hit the jackpot.
I feel confident that a few QUALITY additions at CF and CM would make a huge difference to the effectiveness of Val's play but have little confidence he will be backed in the window. January will help to provide some clarity. In the meantime, given the circumstances in which Val is working I think he needs our full support.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(11-07-2021, 12:13 AM)Squid Wrote: (11-06-2021, 11:59 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (11-06-2021, 11:55 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Is Val doing the absolute utmost he could with this squad?
It's a "No" from me. They are above average Championship players looking average at best some of the time. The coach has to take some responsibility for days of under-achievement like today.
How can he be blamed for players not being able to do the basics though?
People keep talking about a Plan B.
Today we had little problem getting through their midfield. We also got the ball into their box plenty. But our front three were by and large, useless. A formation change wouldn't have helped that.
Apparently it's Val's fault Robinson cannot complete the most simple of passes because he scored against some part-timers for Ireland.
If anything, I could pick at our set-pieces, as if we're struggling to score, we need those to be better. However, I suspect that players are doing it all during training, but can't replicate it on matchday.
When most of these same players failed to perform for Sam Allardyce, many posters on here were quick to blame Allardyce for "losing them". Why is Ismael absolved of all blame for sending out a team that can't "do the basics"? Is he working on these weaknesses in training? Could he freshen up his attack with a youngster or two? Doing the same every week doesn't seem to be working consistently.
Posts: 3,903
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(11-07-2021, 08:52 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (11-07-2021, 02:04 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Good point about Johnstone.
He goes in January, kiss promotion goodbye. Our best player by a country mile, best keeper in this league by said country mile too.
That’s an interesting discussion point. His importance to us is magnified by our inability to score at the other end, a problem that we can only fix in January by signing a striker, which we quite probably can only achieve by selling Johnstone !
Problem is with our current track record on sales we will be screwed over and he will go for an absolute pittance, and then we probably won't get paid.
Posts: 10,860
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(11-07-2021, 12:49 AM)HLS Wrote: I've been generally quiet this season and am at a 7/10 overall for Val based on results so far moreso than performances.
We're just about in the mix for autos still with a long way to go and, the Fulham game aside, have never been out of games. Val certainly in for me and as said above things haven't been rosy at board level and the Pereira, Barry and Ferguson issues have magnified our deficiencies so Val is doing a good job at focusing on what he has. Players seem motivated and never seem to hide so you've got players working hard in a system that seems to both create chances (eventually) but do find ourselves often exposed, that Swansea game particularly paramount to showing how to carve out chance after chance against us. I can live with all that as it's impossible to be perfect and whilst we're in the championship, even though teams can expose us, they're not guaranteed to score bucketfuls against us.
The problem for me is that the chances we create are rarely good chances and the goals that come about are just keep battling until a chance eventually falls. This has worked in our favour in several games but it feels like we make harder work of it than it should be and pretty much all the forwards and midfielders aren't showing much of their strengths in the system itself. Grant does literally nothing except for score goals, Diangana hasn't been able to shine, Robinson often comes deep so we lose a player, the midfielders generally don't support the attack, Hugill doesn't help himself but doesn't get the support, Phillips has generally been a consistent 6/10, Snodgrass poor, and the fullbacks don't seem to have the same impact on the attack as they did.
The point is, there's zero fluidity and Val isn't playing a system to allow anyone to play to their strengths. We look like a team that have never played together and have gone backwards the further the season has gone on. Anyone who's worked for a big company as a cog in a machine role can empathise with players that are doing a job that's necessary but doesn't fulfil either what they want to do or utilise their strengths so it would not surprise me if they were getting a bit bored by the effort at this point.
Just to add, without Johnstone, I'm not sure we'd even be in the top 6. I see many post-match ratings where he gets a 6 and 'nothing to do' but he is an excellent keeper that has saved our skin many a time. So many times has he been super quick off his line to stop those balls over the top. It doesn't count as a shot but I don't think our other keepers have the confidence to do what he does and do it so successfully.
What do I hope from Val going forward? I'm not really sure what I'd do personally but utilising the strengths of the players to create more chances rather than win the ball and hope it goes to someone. That's where we've been poorest.
Totally agree with this. Great post.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(11-06-2021, 11:59 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (11-06-2021, 11:55 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Is Val doing the absolute utmost he could with this squad?
It's a "No" from me. They are above average Championship players looking average at best some of the time. The coach has to take some responsibility for days of under-achievement like today.
And with those above average championship players he is attaining above average championship results.
The problem is that there are few, maybe only one, players who are of premiership quality.
Is he getting the best out of this squad, I don't know for sure, but I think he is results wise.
Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
11-07-2021, 09:51 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-07-2021, 09:51 AM by Lillwall's left foot.)
(11-07-2021, 09:37 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (11-07-2021, 12:13 AM)Squid Wrote: (11-06-2021, 11:59 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (11-06-2021, 11:55 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Is Val doing the absolute utmost he could with this squad?
It's a "No" from me. They are above average Championship players looking average at best some of the time. The coach has to take some responsibility for days of under-achievement like today.
How can he be blamed for players not being able to do the basics though?
People keep talking about a Plan B.
Today we had little problem getting through their midfield. We also got the ball into their box plenty. But our front three were by and large, useless. A formation change wouldn't have helped that.
Apparently it's Val's fault Robinson cannot complete the most simple of passes because he scored against some part-timers for Ireland.
If anything, I could pick at our set-pieces, as if we're struggling to score, we need those to be better. However, I suspect that players are doing it all during training, but can't replicate it on matchday.
When most of these same players failed to perform for Sam Allardyce, many posters on here were quick to blame Allardyce for "losing them". Why is Ismael absolved of all blame for sending out a team that can't "do the basics"? Is he working on these weaknesses in training? Could he freshen up his attack with a youngster or two? Doing the same every week doesn't seem to be working consistently.
for me, whether you were behind FS's appointment or not, there was more an all round acknowledgement that the players just wern't good enough.
|