"David's Law"
#21
(10-29-2021, 08:17 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Emotive falsehood? I've heard it all now.

The trouble with people who spout on about cancel culture and free speech is that in a very Orwellian way they want to do the opposite, and curtail debate. They want the right to make controversial points but get into a huge huff when others disagree with them.

It’s not about getting into a huff when others disagree, you’ve tried to minimize the effects of cancel culture previously by claiming it’s just people disagreeing. 
Go and tell Kathleen Stock who has just been forced to resign from her post at Sussex university after facing a campaign of intimidation and bullying which included not only twitter pile ons but sticker and poster campaigns naming and abusing her, that it’s just people disagreeing. 
Maybe it was “just people disagreeing” that led to Peter Boghossian being forced to resign after publishing papers critical of much of the theory behind “woke” thinking?
Or perhaps you think the rape and death threats along with concerted efforts to get her books removed from libraries were people “just disagreeing” with JK Rowling?
Debate and discussion is one thing, attempting to remove people from their jobs and attack their ability to earn a living, as well as making personal attacks and threats are not fine. 
It’s most definitely those who advocate cancel culture or make excuses and pretend it doesn’t exist that are the Orwellian’s.
Reply
#22
No one denies that bullying and intimidation are wrong, but to claim it is one sided as you want to do is painfully wide of the mark.

Take the current furore around transgender issues , do you think for one minute trans people do not receive threats and intimidation. As I said on another thread I went to senior school between 1973 and 1980, there was no one in my time there who admitted to being gsy, let alone transgender. The level of abuse, intimidation and violence they would have been subjected to would have made their lives intolerable...that's real cancel culture.

It is very sad that in these days people who live in the public spotlight are subject to so much abuse and vile threats, but there are laws to protect them against the worst of this, reference the recent prosecution made against a man who made threats against Angela Rayner.
Reply
#23
Oh there is definitely abuse on both sides but we were talking specifically about cancel culture, maybe i muddied the water a bit by adding on the part about threats and abuse.
From what I’ve seen, it seems the “woke” side go for people’s jobs and careers a lot more.
Agree we do live in better times now as far as acceptance of minorities is concerned, unfortunately it’s often people who are not part of a minority group who are the loudest cheerleaders for the barmier end of arguments of how to approach living in a diverse society.
Good to see Rayner herself recognise her own language has let her down in the past, it’s refreshing to see a politician not afraid to say they were wrong.
Reply
#24
(10-29-2021, 04:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-29-2021, 03:27 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-29-2021, 08:17 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Emotive falsehood? I've heard it all now.

The trouble with people who spout on about cancel culture and free speech is that in a very Orwellian way they want to do the opposite, and curtail debate. They want the right to make controversial points but get into a huge huff when others disagree with them.

The pile-ons to Tory MPs over this issue have been appalling. Particularly when said issue is not understood by the instigators of the pile on or those who choose to pile on. It's beyond pathetic.

…and yet you seemed quite comfortable supporting campaigns that made an art form out of misdirection, pinning the blame on everyone from judge’s to teachers, gaslighting the general public and declaring a war on woke for the last five or so years. These divisive tactics can’t be turned on and off like a tap when it suits. 

Water companies should invest properly in their infrastructure and the health of the environment first, their shareholders a long way back second. All the bill did / does is float a poop down poop creek for future generations to clean up. I assume the 22 Tory MPs who rebelled are wrong too? Rivers Trust
This^ STW do some good work, but ultimately the bottom line is profit. It's the same with all public utilities, sooner they are taken back into public ownership, and accountability restored the better.
Reply
#25
(11-03-2021, 12:44 PM)igorbalis Wrote:
(10-29-2021, 04:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-29-2021, 03:27 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-29-2021, 08:17 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Emotive falsehood? I've heard it all now.

The trouble with people who spout on about cancel culture and free speech is that in a very Orwellian way they want to do the opposite, and curtail debate. They want the right to make controversial points but get into a huge huff when others disagree with them.

The pile-ons to Tory MPs over this issue have been appalling. Particularly when said issue is not understood by the instigators of the pile on or those who choose to pile on. It's beyond pathetic.

…and yet you seemed quite comfortable supporting campaigns that made an art form out of misdirection, pinning the blame on everyone from judge’s to teachers, gaslighting the general public and declaring a war on woke for the last five or so years. These divisive tactics can’t be turned on and off like a tap when it suits. 

Water companies should invest properly in their infrastructure and the health of the environment first, their shareholders a long way back second. All the bill did / does is float a poop down poop creek for future generations to clean up. I assume the 22 Tory MPs who rebelled are wrong too? Rivers Trust
This^ STW do some good work, but ultimately the bottom line is profit. It's the same with all public utilities, sooner they are taken back into public ownership, and accountability restored the better.

That's not really the hallmark of a public business, to be honest.
Reply
#26
The reality is that the great privatisation experiment is working in some part where there is competition, BT, Electric and Gas, however where there isn't competition then it fails (Water, Trains, Healthcare) and this has to be recognised and acted upon. It really isn't one size fits all and we have to learn lessons and use them to improve the provision.
Reply
#27
(11-03-2021, 01:46 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The reality is that the great privatisation experiment is working in some part where there is competition, BT, Electric and Gas, however where there isn't competition then it fails (Water, Trains, Healthcare) and this has to be recognised and acted upon. It really isn't one size fits all and we have to learn lessons and use them to improve the provision.

We are getting a long way from the OP, but I would be interested to know in which way the customer is benefiting from the privatisation of electricity and gas. It can't be competition, because the events of recent weeks has shown that it is a difficult market for new businesses to enter and survive.
And the customer, how have we benefitted.  Essentially the product is the same whoever the supplier is. Differentiation between suppliers can only be achieved through a complex list of different tariffs, which rewards the financial savvy, and disadvantages the vulnerable who often have no choice as to which tariff they will be put on.
Reply
#28
(11-03-2021, 02:36 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(11-03-2021, 01:46 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The reality is that the great privatisation experiment is working in some part where there is competition, BT, Electric and Gas, however where there isn't competition then it fails (Water, Trains, Healthcare) and this has to be recognised and acted upon. It really isn't one size fits all and we have to learn lessons and use them to improve the provision.

We are getting a long way from the OP, but I would be interested to know in which way the customer is benefiting from the privatisation of electricity and gas. It can't be competition, because the events of recent weeks has shown that it is a difficult market for new businesses to enter and survive.
And the customer, how have we benefitted.  Essentially the product is the same whoever the supplier is. Differentiation between suppliers can only be achieved through a complex list of different tariffs, which rewards the financial savvy, and disadvantages the vulnerable who often have no choice as to which tariff they will be put on.

Exactly. Putting a countries utilities into the hands of shareholders, many of which don’t even live or use the services they provide is rank stupidity. It has done feck all to improve infrastructure as the bottom line is simply to make cash.
Reply
#29
(11-03-2021, 02:36 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(11-03-2021, 01:46 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The reality is that the great privatisation experiment is working in some part where there is competition, BT, Electric and Gas, however where there isn't competition then it fails (Water, Trains, Healthcare) and this has to be recognised and acted upon. It really isn't one size fits all and we have to learn lessons and use them to improve the provision.

We are getting a long way from the OP, but I would be interested to know in which way the customer is benefiting from the privatisation of electricity and gas. It can't be competition, because the events of recent weeks has shown that it is a difficult market for new businesses to enter and survive.
And the customer, how have we benefitted.  Essentially the product is the same whoever the supplier is. Differentiation between suppliers can only be achieved through a complex list of different tariffs, which rewards the financial savvy, and disadvantages the vulnerable who often have no choice as to which tariff they will be put on.

The events of the recent weeks would have impacted on the customer whoever the ownership was and are unique in the history of energy supply. There has to be a move to renewable energy and there have been some strides in that direction that wouldn't have got the investment from any of the governments from that last 40 years. 

Agreed on the 2nd part and this needs to be addressed through the regulator providing a standardised approach for each company to communicate. But again having too much choice isn't the problem, it's having the clarity and ability to choose in an informed manner.
Reply
#30
(11-03-2021, 02:36 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(11-03-2021, 01:46 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The reality is that the great privatisation experiment is working in some part where there is competition, BT, Electric and Gas, however where there isn't competition then it fails (Water, Trains, Healthcare) and this has to be recognised and acted upon. It really isn't one size fits all and we have to learn lessons and use them to improve the provision.

We are getting a long way from the OP, but I would be interested to know in which way the customer is benefiting from the privatisation of electricity and gas. It can't be competition, because the events of recent weeks has shown that it is a difficult market for new businesses to enter and survive.
And the customer, how have we benefitted.  Essentially the product is the same whoever the supplier is. Differentiation between suppliers can only be achieved through a complex list of different tariffs, which rewards the financial savvy, and disadvantages the vulnerable who often have no choice as to which tariff they will be put on.

Adding a layer between those in charge of regulation and those in charge of implementation is a good thing, as shown by the Cornish water scandal pre-privatisation where there was water contamination by the Cornish water board and nothing was done to address the issue or punish those who caused it because those who did it were those who were dishing out the punishment. That's why utilities being in public ownership isn't necessarily a good thing.

Ultimately I'm supportive of municipal utilities and cooperatives but it's also incredibly difficult to setup and manage a million different utility departments is an inefficient nightmare, and the more you centralise those utilities the bigger the state and the higher the risk of corruption. There's also the risk of the state cutting much needed improvements as they're worried about politics which in turn results in worse outcomes of provision for those utilities, see the Thatcher government fucking up telecoms by pulling funding for optical fibres, had they stumped the money up the UK would be the king of digital services with everyone getting up to 10Gbps internet speeds in 2021 but that's only in a parallel universe.

Public ownership of utilities always seems to me as though it's a wishy washy idealist and typical left wing ideal that falls apart at any level of scrutiny.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: