The Budget… thoughts
#11
Tax credits are necessary because many people want and do work but cannot work full time, and their wage cannot sustain the income needed to support their families and fiddling with a couple of quid on minimum wage wont solve that.

For example if you are a carer and you work more than 16hrs a week you lose any carers allowance / ‘benefits’. These are people who get £70 a week to do a job that goes above and beyond any normal family duties and save the tax payer millions in social care. The notion that a low income family in that situation can ‘wean’ themselves off tax credits shows a complete lack of understanding of the reality of the situation faced by many people in the country. 

I hear a lot about nuance of argument on here but the uplift in the living wage solves nothing for those trapped in the benefit trap. ‘Make work pay’ and such trite slogans hide the reality of a system set-up to punish rather than help people in genuine need.
Reply
#12
I wish Sunik was in charge at Albion. Spend, spend, spend.
Reply
#13
(10-28-2021, 11:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Tax credits are necessary because many people want and do work but cannot work full time, and their wage cannot sustain the income needed to support their families and fiddling with a couple of quid on minimum wage wont solve that.

For example if you are a carer and you work more than 16hrs a week you lose any carers allowance / ‘benefits’. These are people who get £70 a week to do a job that goes above and beyond any normal family duties and save the tax payer millions in social care. The notion that a low income family in that situation can ‘wean’ themselves off tax credits shows a complete lack of understanding of the reality of the situation faced by many people in the country. 

I hear a lot about nuance of argument on here but the uplift in the living wage solves nothing for those trapped in the benefit trap. ‘Make work pay’ and such trite slogans hide the reality of a system set-up to punish rather than help people in genuine need.

Why I think it's important to distinguish those caring at home, from those who don't in this debate.

I used to get fed up with asking for staff to do overtime, to get told, can't do it because I'll lose my Tax Credits. What a ridiculous system that then causes, they COULD easily have earned the money to live, by doing a few hours over contract every week, but they'd rather get a top up from the government which restricts how many hours they are allowed to work.  As said, this isn't carers who have to be home to care, often these were people with a stay at home parent of older kids. It got to the point where in my department I tried to never have older staff that relied on Tax Credits, but young, single people who were able to do overtime when we needed, and wanted to earn more money.
Reply
#14
(10-29-2021, 08:33 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(10-28-2021, 11:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Tax credits are necessary because many people want and do work but cannot work full time, and their wage cannot sustain the income needed to support their families and fiddling with a couple of quid on minimum wage wont solve that.

For example if you are a carer and you work more than 16hrs a week you lose any carers allowance / ‘benefits’. These are people who get £70 a week to do a job that goes above and beyond any normal family duties and save the tax payer millions in social care. The notion that a low income family in that situation can ‘wean’ themselves off tax credits shows a complete lack of understanding of the reality of the situation faced by many people in the country. 

I hear a lot about nuance of argument on here but the uplift in the living wage solves nothing for those trapped in the benefit trap. ‘Make work pay’ and such trite slogans hide the reality of a system set-up to punish rather than help people in genuine need.

Why I think it's important to distinguish those caring at home, from those who don't in this debate.

I used to get fed up with asking for staff to do overtime, to get told, can't do it because I'll lose my Tax Credits. What a ridiculous system that then causes, they COULD easily have earned the money to live, by doing a few hours over contract every week, but they'd rather get a top up from the government which restricts how many hours they are allowed to work.  As said, this isn't carers who have to be home to care, often these were people with a stay at home parent of older kids. It got to the point where in my department I tried to never have older staff that relied on Tax Credits, but young, single people who were able to do overtime when we needed, and wanted to earn more money.

The problem with separating carers from others is the UC system doesn’t do that. It treats both claimants  the same. £70 a week for caring full time is a disgracefully low figure. Most genuine carers work around the clock but there is no flexibility to earn more if time allows from time to time, the system simply punishes people who cannot. I doubt many if any want to be full time carers but circumstances mean they became one. Also partners of said carers will also be dragged into this system if they have to have a degree of flexibility with regards to the hours they work. There is no incentive at a certain threshold to earn more because you get taxed at a rate higher than an MP would relatively speaking if you do. 

Carers and the disabled should be a separate issue but IBS and co lumped everyone together under the UC scheme and it has caused suicide, marriage breakdowns etc and treated people notably the disabled like scroungers. Simplifying the system was a perfectly reasonable premise but it’s been used to weaponise and punish not help people.
Reply
#15
Don't disagree there Derek.
Reply
#16
(10-29-2021, 08:33 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I used to get fed up with asking for staff to do overtime, to get told, can't do it because I'll lose my Tax Credits. 

This.

(10-28-2021, 03:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-28-2021, 10:33 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Too much tax. Too much spending.

With a majority the size they have, they could have gone for a genuinely deep reforming budget; tax simplification, merged PAYE & NI, scrapped Business Rates, scrapped CGT, scrapped Dividend Taxes, scrapped VED, scrapped Fuel Duty, scrapped IHT, scrapped in-work benefits and introduced a Land Value Tax, Road Pricing and a higher Minimum Wage instead.

How I long for the reforming budgets of the 1980s. We've gone full circle.

We're not that far off each other in the way of trying to simplify the ridiculous tax system by the looks of it, I'd add stamp duty to that lot as well. I can see a benefit to reducing in-work benefits but more in the way of weaning people off them with higher minimum wages and restricting businesses using zero hours contracts severely and I'd have had a lot of those simplified rather than scrapped entirely. What does Road Pricing involve Proth?

Properly marketise the roads by replacing VED, Fuel Duty, IPT on Motor Policies with a variable charge on private car use / commercial vehicle use depending on the type of roads used and the time of day. The reduction in duty for buses should allow a precipitous fall in fares for those who wish to travel that way.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)