Poll: Are the club right to sack Darren Moore.
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Yes
51.95%
80 51.95%
No
48.05%
74 48.05%
Total 154 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Right decision?
#61
Similar result to brexit = another divided fan base & bad atmosphere around the club
Reply
#62
(03-10-2019, 10:48 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Well that's just on here (and just those that voted so far). 
Outside looking in more seem to think No - but whilst being more detached can give a better perspective sometimes, it also could be not having the whole picture.
Ultimately it will look right if we go up and wrong if we don't.

In a flash one hour poll on SSN last night, over 40,000 people voted, 91% said it was a bad decision, but hey what the fuck do they know?
Reply
#63
(03-10-2019, 10:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 10:23 AM)Lillwall\s left foot Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 10:06 AM)petty sniper Wrote: No.  

I thought this was a reboot in the closed season to give the club an identity and part of a long term plan.   Instead it appears that the club took the cheap easy option to employ a manager with no experience and ditch him when the going got a little rough.  If that was the case then why did they give him the job if there is no room to develop.

Also this concept of there is no room for sentiment in football is the biggest load of bollocks ever.  If there is no sentiment then why am I wasting my time following the Albion.  That is something i do out of sentiment, if not Liverpool or Man City would get my support this year.

Guess you have 53% who have no room for sentiment and 47% who tmake a more thoughtful stance and think there is more to it than just short termism.  I'm sure I've seen those statistics some where before???

Long term stability with an ever decreasing budget will yield better results?


I guess i've just lost faith in the budget being directly related to quality. Over the last few years we've emptied the coffers, ending up in our overdraft, spending more and more money on ever increasing salaries for average players who will have limited sell on value.....their true quality has been shown this year.  Livermore, Jrod, Dawson, Barry (Good player but 38!) are decent players but please dont tell me they are PL quality.  Hegazi I really like but he lacks a turn of pace (not something required in a TP team),  Gibbs level of performance has really dropped recently and Phillips, who can be top quality, is almost a liability with his injuries.    That's what our PL budget had left us with....a number of one paced and technically limited senior pros on the books playing alongside loanees who will all disappear back to their clubs at the end of the year.   Quite a legacy from all those years of PL income.  Maybe I'm feeling overly pessimistic today but further years of short terminism leaves me cold.  

I thought we were looking at a long term project of bringing through the kids and looking for young hungry players with greater technicall ability to play a progressive brand of football....no matter what division.  But I guess that's just sentimental.
Reply
#64
(03-10-2019, 11:04 AM)Lillwall\s left foot Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 10:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 10:23 AM)Lillwall\s left foot Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 10:06 AM)petty sniper Wrote: No.  

I thought this was a reboot in the closed season to give the club an identity and part of a long term plan.   Instead it appears that the club took the cheap easy option to employ a manager with no experience and ditch him when the going got a little rough.  If that was the case then why did they give him the job if there is no room to develop.

Also this concept of there is no room for sentiment in football is the biggest load of bollocks ever.  If there is no sentiment then why am I wasting my time following the Albion.  That is something i do out of sentiment, if not Liverpool or Man City would get my support this year.

Guess you have 53% who have no room for sentiment and 47% who tmake a more thoughtful stance and think there is more to it than just short termism.  I'm sure I've seen those statistics some where before???

Long term stability with an ever decreasing budget will yield better results?


I guess i've just lost faith in the budget being directly related to quality. Over the last few years we've emptied the coffers, ending up in our overdraft, spending more and more money on ever increasing salaries for average players who will have limited sell on value.....their true quality has been shown this year.  Livermore, Jrod, Dawson, Barry (Good player but 38!) are decent players but please dont tell me they are PL quality.  Hegazi I really like but he lacks a turn of pace (not something required in a TP team),  Gibbs level of performance has really dropped recently and Phillips, who can be top quality, is almost a liability with his injuries.    That's what our PL budget had left us with....a number of one paced and technically limited senior pros on the books playing alongside loanees who will all disappear back to their clubs at the end of the year.   Quite a legacy from all those years of PL income.  Maybe I'm feeling overly pessimistic today but further years of short terminism leaves me cold.  

I thought we were looking at a long term project of bringing through the kids and looking for young hungry players with greater technicall ability to play a progressive brand of football....no matter what division.  But I guess that's just sentimental.

Well put. 
Imo the results have been almost secondary to getting the club back.
And now they've gone and thrown it all away...
We'll get some more short term managers, over the coming years, and I think we're now doomed to wallow around the lower reaches.
But much more importantly, I'm heading back to not caring in a pulis Ball kind of way...
It's Lai's club, not ours. And it shows.
Reply
#65
We could have kept Moore but demanded he got rid of Jones.

I'm on the outside looking in but it all seemed to go pear-shaped when we lost Barnes and other teams worked us out especially at home.
An SGM type alongside BD would have been a decent shout.  

Who knows maybe the option of staying on without Jones was offered to him and he turned it down.

Just thinking aloud.
Reply
#66
(03-10-2019, 10:48 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Ultimately it will look right if we go up and wrong if we don't.

I was thinking more long term, I’d rather not go up until we are ready if we are only going up to collect the cash and not compete. It pains me to look at the fingered mob up the road but they are playing good football and have ambition. We will never know if Mooro with the youth coming through would have built us into a force. I’m confident that would have been our only way of making up ground as the gooch is not a sugar Daddy.
Reply
#67
It deeply saddens me, because Darren's an Albion great in my mind and always will be, but I think we had to if we wanted a good chance of going up. The tactics employed just haven't been suitable for this group of players. I'm really struggling to think of many game where we were convincing winners. Even QPR at home was very shaky in the first half. Results against the likes of Forest and Wednesday and Blues owed a lot to luck or individual brilliance. Some games, had we been playing in the Prem, we'd have lost the game before half-time. Performances since Boxing Day have been gradually worsening. Darren's biggest contribution has come off the field, where divisions have been healed and team spirit seems to have been generated. An incredibly reluctant 'yes' from me.
Reply
#68
A definite no on all levels. But hopefully the twats have a great alternative lined up and will act quickly. Fat fucking chance.
Reply
#69
(03-10-2019, 12:21 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: It deeply saddens me, because Darren's an Albion great in my mind and always will be, but I think we had to if we wanted a good chance of going up. The tactics employed just haven't been suitable for this group of players. I'm really struggling to think of many game where we were convincing winners. Even QPR at home was very shaky in the first half. Results against the likes of Forest and Wednesday and Blues owed a lot to luck or individual brilliance. Some games, had we been playing in the Prem, we'd have lost the game before half-time. Performances since Boxing Day have been gradually worsening. Darren's biggest contribution has come off the field, where divisions have been healed and team spirit seems to have been generated. An incredibly reluctant 'yes' from me.

I think the decision to sack BD was the correct one on balance.  I have never been convinced by the style/tactics – right from the start I called  a lot of it “lucky bag football” but a lot of folk were happy to see us get out of scrapes late on simply because it wasn’t Pulis in charge.  The "not Pulis" comments were a constant early on.  And, to be fair, we occasionally played some very good stuff.  But we have never looked convincing - something has looked wrong.

It looks like a lot of folk now seem to realize all is not well based on the lack of nous and after losing Barnes but remain loyal to BD.  I can see that “from the heart”.  Whether the decision is correct on football grounds will be determined by history.  I wish it had not come this pass.
Reply
#70
(03-10-2019, 01:13 PM)hudds Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 12:21 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: It deeply saddens me, because Darren's an Albion great in my mind and always will be, but I think we had to if we wanted a good chance of going up. The tactics employed just haven't been suitable for this group of players. I'm really struggling to think of many game where we were convincing winners. Even QPR at home was very shaky in the first half. Results against the likes of Forest and Wednesday and Blues owed a lot to luck or individual brilliance. Some games, had we been playing in the Prem, we'd have lost the game before half-time. Performances since Boxing Day have been gradually worsening. Darren's biggest contribution has come off the field, where divisions have been healed and team spirit seems to have been generated. An incredibly reluctant 'yes' from me.

I think the decision to sack BD was the correct one on balance.  I have never been convinced by the style/tactics – right from the start I called  a lot of it “lucky bag football” but a lot of folk were happy to see us get out of scrapes late on simply because it wasn’t Pulis in charge.  The "not Pulis" comments were a constant early on.  And, to be fair, we occasionally played some very good stuff.  But we have never looked convincing - something has looked wrong.

It looks like a lot of folk now seem to realize all is not well based on the lack of nous and after losing Barnes but remain loyal to BD.  I can see that “from the heart”.  Whether the decision is correct on football grounds will be determined by history.  I wish it had not come this pass.

+1
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)