Never should have been in the job
#11
(03-10-2019, 08:51 AM)Sliced Wrote: Maybe I should have said decent chance. Being 4th at this point leaves us with a better chance than the majority of the league does it not?

Time will tell whether it was the right call. I'll correct you though, the majority of the microcosm of this board think it was the right call. Basically everyone outside of this can see how sacking a man who turned us from an absolute joke into the 3rd highest scorers in the football league, sitting in the the playoff places a few games before the end of the season is probably a dumb as fuck decision.

As I've said, losing 4-0 to Leeds was talked about for about an hour or so by anyone outside of ourselves and Leeds fans. This is an embarrassment on a larger scale and unfortunately this time it's not the players and manager who have embarrassed themselves; it's firstly the club and secondly our fans. Three games FFS

Slice the fans didn’t get Moore the sack if anything his status at the club gave him far more leeway than other managers would have had. Since Christmas at home results have been pretty poor and results far from convincing. Can we argue we have been unlucky! Not at all if anything we have had quite a bit of good fortune. 

I personally would have allowed DM until the summer to see if he could turn things around and alter the tactics that had become a cliche of themselves in home matches but the club clearly felt they had to act and with no sign of the management changing or even tweaking our approach u think it was an understandable if harsh decision.
Reply
#12
(03-10-2019, 12:25 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 12:21 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: The club have embarrassed themselves, anyone who disagrees, is a moron, and I feel sorry for you.

Loffin, I’m a moron then, I’ve been told.


Arf, me too then, still at least we have the comfort of knowing, that we've been diagnosed by an expert.   Cool
Reply
#13
(03-10-2019, 09:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 08:51 AM)Sliced Wrote: Maybe I should have said decent chance. Being 4th at this point leaves us with a better chance than the majority of the league does it not?

Time will tell whether it was the right call. I'll correct you though, the majority of the microcosm of this board think it was the right call. Basically everyone outside of this can see how sacking a man who turned us from an absolute joke into the 3rd highest scorers in the football league, sitting in the the playoff places a few games before the end of the season is probably a dumb as fuck decision.

As I've said, losing 4-0 to Leeds was talked about for about an hour or so by anyone outside of ourselves and Leeds fans. This is an embarrassment on a larger scale and unfortunately this time it's not the players and manager who have embarrassed themselves; it's firstly the club and secondly our fans. Three games FFS

Slice the fans didn’t get Moore the sack if anything his status at the club gave him far more leeway than other managers would have had. Since Christmas at home results have been pretty poor and results far from convincing. Can we argue we have been unlucky! Not at all if anything we have had quite a bit of good fortune. 

I personally would have allowed DM until the summer to see if he could turn things around and alter the tactics that had become a cliche of themselves in home matches but the club clearly felt they had to act and with no sign of the management changing or even tweaking our approach u think it was an understandable if harsh decision.

Home have been poor and away have been fantastic, Leeds aside. You can't just block out 50% of our fixtures. The fans didn't get Moore the sack but the reaction is embarrassing. The idea that Darren Moore had nothing to do with us being 4th in the league is absolutely insane, whether you think there are others who could be pushing us higher or not, and yet I've seen comments that we've been "diabolical all season", I've seen people saying "thank fuck for that" and we're not talking about individuals.....many many people, mainly on social media.

The way it's been done also is just shocking and yet aside from a small pocket of our fans there's absolutely no one taking issue with how we're treating someone who gave so much to the club, and a man who genuinely cares as much about Albion as we do.

And I can't agree that we didn't tweak our approach. Our formation was completely different yesterday. It didn't work, but it was different. Similarly earlier in the season when things got stale we ditched 3 at the back and then went on a fantastic run of form. As I've said elsewhere, it's literally happened before and we came out smelling of roses. There's no reason why it wouldn't happen again. 10 points from 4 games and then 3 games were enough to decide that we wouldn't turn it around? That's insanity.

How did he get more leeway than other managers? How is it possible to have less leeway!? Maybe after 2 bad games they'd be sacked. Darren's status as being new to the management game undoubtedly meant his wages were less than someone with more experience. This makes him easier to get rid of, not more difficult
Reply
#14
I didn't want Darren to get the job initially because I knew one day there'd be a time when he'd get the bullet, most likely in ugly circumstances, and tarnish his stature at the club. And so it has come to pass. That said, he definitely earned the right to be given the job given what he did at the end of last season.

I have to agree with Derek and Mr V sadly. Our tactics for best part of the campaign have needed changing. We all see it before us on the pitch yet nothing was being done about it. Though maybe dumping just Jones and promoting Shan would have been a better thing to do instead?
Reply
#15
(03-10-2019, 09:47 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 09:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 08:51 AM)Sliced Wrote: Maybe I should have said decent chance. Being 4th at this point leaves us with a better chance than the majority of the league does it not?

Time will tell whether it was the right call. I'll correct you though, the majority of the microcosm of this board think it was the right call. Basically everyone outside of this can see how sacking a man who turned us from an absolute joke into the 3rd highest scorers in the football league, sitting in the the playoff places a few games before the end of the season is probably a dumb as fuck decision.

As I've said, losing 4-0 to Leeds was talked about for about an hour or so by anyone outside of ourselves and Leeds fans. This is an embarrassment on a larger scale and unfortunately this time it's not the players and manager who have embarrassed themselves; it's firstly the club and secondly our fans. Three games FFS

Slice the fans didn’t get Moore the sack if anything his status at the club gave him far more leeway than other managers would have had. Since Christmas at home results have been pretty poor and results far from convincing. Can we argue we have been unlucky! Not at all if anything we have had quite a bit of good fortune. 

I personally would have allowed DM until the summer to see if he could turn things around and alter the tactics that had become a cliche of themselves in home matches but the club clearly felt they had to act and with no sign of the management changing or even tweaking our approach u think it was an understandable if harsh decision.

Home have been poor and away have been fantastic, Leeds aside. You can't just block out 50% of our fixtures. The fans didn't get Moore the sack but the reaction is embarrassing. The idea that Darren Moore had nothing to do with us being 4th in the league is absolutely insane, whether you think there are others who could be pushing us higher or not, and yet I've seen comments that we've been "diabolical all season", I've seen people saying "thank fuck for that" and we're not talking about individuals.....many many people, mainly on social media.

The way it's been done also is just shocking and yet aside from a small pocket of our fans there's absolutely no one taking issue with how we're treating someone who gave so much to the club, and a man who genuinely cares as much about Albion as we do.

And I can't agree that we didn't tweak our approach. Our formation was completely different yesterday. It didn't work, but it was different. Similarly earlier in the season when things got stale we ditched 3 at the back and then went on a fantastic run of form. As I've said elsewhere, it's literally happened before and we came out smelling of roses. There's no reason why it wouldn't happen again. 10 points from 4 games and then 3 games were enough to decide that we wouldn't turn it around? That's insanity.

How did he get more leeway than other managers? How is it possible to have less leeway!? Maybe after 2 bad games they'd be sacked. Darren's status as being new to the management game undoubtedly meant his wages were less than someone with more experience. This makes him easier to get rid of, not more difficult

Slice the decision to employ a club stalwart was flawed as it would always end in tears no matter what the circumstances. I havent changed my mind on this since the decision. 

We tweaked the formation not the approach. We still tried to make average defenders play out from the back and when they were put under pressure the team struggled time and time again at home. We stopped doing this tactic to such an extent and it yielded results but we slowly but surely reverted to it again fir whatever reason. It didn’t work at home and the very audible boos at the end of the match showed the frustration of the fans. 

As I said he deserved the season particularly as it was the clubs decision to employ an inexperienced manager but it’s hapoened and there were reasons for it.
Reply
#16
(03-10-2019, 09:54 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I didn't want Darren to get the job initially because I knew one day there'd be a time when he'd get the bullet, most likely in ugly circumstances, and tarnish his stature at the club. And so it has come to pass. That said, he definitely earned the right to be given the job given what he did at the end of last season.

I have to agree with Derek and Mr V sadly. Our tactics for best part of the campaign have needed changing. We all see it before us on the pitch yet nothing was being done about it. Though maybe dumping just Jones and promoting Shan would have been a better thing to do instead?

Agree completely Moore & Shan would have got us over the line this season imvho.
Reply
#17
(03-10-2019, 09:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 08:51 AM)Sliced Wrote: Maybe I should have said decent chance. Being 4th at this point leaves us with a better chance than the majority of the league does it not?

Time will tell whether it was the right call. I'll correct you though, the majority of the microcosm of this board think it was the right call. Basically everyone outside of this can see how sacking a man who turned us from an absolute joke into the 3rd highest scorers in the football league, sitting in the the playoff places a few games before the end of the season is probably a dumb as fuck decision.

As I've said, losing 4-0 to Leeds was talked about for about an hour or so by anyone outside of ourselves and Leeds fans. This is an embarrassment on a larger scale and unfortunately this time it's not the players and manager who have embarrassed themselves; it's firstly the club and secondly our fans. Three games FFS

Slice the fans didn’t get Moore the sack if anything his status at the club gave him far more leeway than other managers would have had. Since Christmas at home results have been pretty poor and results far from convincing. Can we argue we have been unlucky! Not at all if anything we have had quite a bit of good fortune. 

I personally would have allowed DM until the summer to see if he could turn things around and alter the tactics that had become a cliche of themselves in home matches but the club clearly felt they had to act and with no sign of the management changing or even tweaking our approach u think it was an understandable if harsh decision.

I don't think that's true Derek, pretty much from the get go this season some posters  have been criticising him, which I found strange.

Between the 2 Leeds games we had a run of 17 games, winning 10, drawing 5 and only losing 2. A series of results that most fan groups would kill for, not ours apparently. And contrary to what Mark Jenkins thinks, that's some consistency.

It seems to me that there is a section of posters on here who have believed all season that any positive results were despite Darren Moore and negative results were because of him . If our fans did really give Moore leeway, the next one better not lose any games.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)