Snodgrass
#21
(10-23-2021, 09:36 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(10-23-2021, 09:34 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(10-23-2021, 09:30 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Rondon was marginally better than MAF, but yes, his finishing was too often wayward. Mind, getting an average of one chance a game will ruin any strikers scoring record....

A chance every month you mean!

I always wonder if he had to try to remember his team mates faces after the game, spending so long not seeing anyone....

Big Grin
Reply
#22
(10-23-2021, 09:23 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(10-23-2021, 07:04 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Gayle is not the player we need IMO. We have Grant/Robinson/Diang/Phillips vying for the wide attackers and Gayle isn’t going to play through the middle in a 343.

We need a better Hugill, someone to hold it up and find a player, and have a finish in them. A Rondon / MAF type of player.

Dike / Woodrow / Even the lad Delap from City.

I'm not having this!!! Whatever qualities Rondon and MAF had when they played for us, "having a finish in them" was definitely not amongst them. Both had a very poor conversion rate of the chances that came their way. Reinventing history to suit your narrative is entirely pointless.

Hugill should have scored at least two today, the fact that he didn't underlines his limitations. But how often did we say exactly the same about MAF and Rondon? The rosy glow of nostalgia has obviously improved them in your recollection. Their missed chances got us relegated.

At this level Rondon would score buckets. MAF did a brilliant job bringing others into play, maybe not a great finished concedes but you’re missing the point. 

This system needs someone to bring the wide forwards and full backs into play. That’s the quality we need and those aforementioned did just that. That said MAD and Rondon would have scored 3 today.
Reply
#23
(10-23-2021, 07:21 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Agree with all the above but back to the OP. Snodgrass was superb today. The odd rusty error  apart, he offered so much.
One of those players that has got better with age. Started off, early career as a non descript. Then he honed his trade playing wide and consistently improving his set pieces to the point he was an essential part of whatever team he played for. Popular everywhere he has been, that tells us something, Big Sam tried him in the middle of our unbalanced squad and he showed just enough to deserve another go. If he stays fit, he will finish this season as an established first teamer.
Wasn't he a regular competitor with dorrans for a Scotland midfield spot?
Odd how their careers have gone in different directions.
I always thought that Dorrans would make it in the PL... but he didn't really.
Reply
#24
(10-23-2021, 08:06 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Would have liked to see ? GH get on the pitch today.

Have to strike a balance with kids… throwing them on when the game is won is often not the best thing… they need to understand the pressure of first team football.

That being said, there wasn’t really an opportunity to… he always uses the subs to change two of the forwards on 60, and that won’t change… then both Clarke and Townsend took knocks and we were better safe than sorry  bringing them off.

Had Townsend not taken a knock I agree it would have been ideal to give him 10 mins or so for Furlong. I do find it very odd that Kean Bryan and Reach are both on the bench ahead of Ingram.
Reply
#25
I am amazed any Albion fan has beef with Rondon, he was fantastic for uus in such a terrible system

He owes us absolutely fuck all

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#26
(10-23-2021, 07:19 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Mbaye Diagne would thrive in this team.

Good question.
Reply
#27
(10-23-2021, 10:16 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(10-23-2021, 09:23 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(10-23-2021, 07:04 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Gayle is not the player we need IMO. We have Grant/Robinson/Diang/Phillips vying for the wide attackers and Gayle isn’t going to play through the middle in a 343.

We need a better Hugill, someone to hold it up and find a player, and have a finish in them. A Rondon / MAF type of player.

Dike / Woodrow / Even the lad Delap from City.

I'm not having this!!! Whatever qualities Rondon and MAF had when they played for us, "having a finish in them" was definitely not amongst them. Both had a very poor conversion rate of the chances that came their way. Reinventing history to suit your narrative is entirely pointless.

Hugill should have scored at least two today, the fact that he didn't underlines his limitations. But how often did we say exactly the same about MAF and Rondon? The rosy glow of nostalgia has obviously improved them in your recollection. Their missed chances got us relegated.

At this level Rondon would score buckets. MAF did a brilliant job bringing others into play, maybe not a great finished concedes but you’re missing the point. 

This system needs someone to bring the wide forwards and full backs into play. That’s the quality we need and those aforementioned did just that. That said MAD and Rondon would have scored 3 today.

Actually I thought Hugill did OK as a target man, holding the ball up and laying it off. I'm surprised if you're suggesting he was weak in that area. MAF and big Sal could both have done better for sure - but my beef is with your assertion that they both "had a finish in them". They weren't/aren't finishers, they didn't have that knack of turning every chance, or even half chance, into a goal. And I accept that Rondon in particular hardly had any chances come his way. But I saw him miss a few.

Your final comment is pure speculation and would be inadmissable as evidence  Big Grin
Reply
#28
Snodgrass gave us the composure we've lacked, so unfortunate not to score. 

More of a normal performance yesterday, not gung-ho/headless.
Reply
#29
(10-24-2021, 12:14 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-23-2021, 08:06 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Would have liked to see ? GH get on the pitch today.

Have to strike a balance with kids… throwing them on when the game is won is often not the best thing… they need to understand the pressure of first team football.

That being said, there wasn’t really an opportunity to… he always uses the subs to change two of the forwards on 60, and that won’t change… then both Clarke and Townsend took knocks and we were better safe than sorry  bringing them off.

Had Townsend not taken a knock I agree it would have been ideal to give him 10 mins or so for Furlong. I do find it very odd that Kean Bryan and Reach are both on the bench ahead of Ingram.

Gardner-Hickman plays in Townsend's position, not Furlong's, so could have come on instead of Reach.
Reply
#30

(10-24-2021, 09:32 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(10-23-2021, 10:16 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(10-23-2021, 09:23 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(10-23-2021, 07:04 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Gayle is not the player we need IMO. We have Grant/Robinson/Diang/Phillips vying for the wide attackers and Gayle isn’t going to play through the middle in a 343.

We need a better Hugill, someone to hold it up and find a player, and have a finish in them. A Rondon / MAF type of player.

Dike / Woodrow / Even the lad Delap from City.

I'm not having this!!! Whatever qualities Rondon and MAF had when they played for us, "having a finish in them" was definitely not amongst them. Both had a very poor conversion rate of the chances that came their way. Reinventing history to suit your narrative is entirely pointless.

Hugill should have scored at least two today, the fact that he didn't underlines his limitations. But how often did we say exactly the same about MAF and Rondon? The rosy glow of nostalgia has obviously improved them in your recollection. Their missed chances got us relegated.

At this level Rondon would score buckets. MAF did a brilliant job bringing others into play, maybe not a great finished concedes but you’re missing the point. 

This system needs someone to bring the wide forwards and full backs into play. That’s the quality we need and those aforementioned did just that. That said MAD and Rondon would have scored 3 today.

Actually I thought Hugill did OK as a target man, holding the ball up and laying it off. I'm surprised if you're suggesting he was weak in that area. MAF and big Sal could both have done better for sure - but my beef is with your assertion that they both "had a finish in them". They weren't/aren't finishers, they didn't have that knack of turning every chance, or even half chance, into a goal. And I accept that Rondon in particular hardly had any chances come his way. But I saw him miss a few.

Your final comment is pure speculation and would be inadmissable as evidence  Big Grin

Hugill did play well, but against better sides he will and has struggled and you can’t have 5 golden chances a game to score a single goal. 

Evidentially:

Rondon 1in 4 across his Orem seasons. 1 in 3 for Newcastle. 
MAF 1 in 3 across 80 games for us in prem and champ. 
Hugill 1 in 5 across the last three seasons (inc his best ever season) over 107 games. 

Are we really suggesting a) Rondon wouldn’t be prolific in the champ? b) even MAF has more of a finish in him than Hugill?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: