After 65 years of supporting....
#21
Fortune, Long, Rondon, fuck even Anichebe when he was fit, would be loving this.
Reply
#22
Funny thread this, maybe Ferenc is having a crisis. Cheer up mate, there's worse things happening in the news than the Baggies being top of the Championship!!

I understand the doubts about the system, the inflexibility, the apparent lack of entertainment value. But it's much more ambitious football than Pulisball - he is notorious for concentrating on shape, on winning the ball in a narrow space outside our penalty box and basically neglecting any semblance of forward play in training. Shocking that his "anti-football" has kept him employed for so many years.

Now which of our other recent coaches had a style of play, a plan that was both entertaining and winning? Bilic for sure, but his decline was entirely of his own making. Clarke, RDM, Mowbray were easy on the eye. Don't tell me Hodgson had us playing nice football FFS. Very functional. They all had their moments but none were long term. I just don't think things are as bad right now as Ferenc says.
Reply
#23
(10-16-2021, 11:27 AM)Squid Wrote:
(10-16-2021, 11:21 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(10-16-2021, 11:02 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The football is no better than under Pulis, it’s remarkable how many pretend it is because the high press is fashionable. I didn’t care for most of TPS tenure and I don’t care now, it’s a results based game and so far the results are good. We haven’t played attractive football with any regularity for decades, arguably our most successful periods have been when we have been at our most pragmatic for at least 40yrs.

Disagree about the Pulis comparison.

Much more attacking intent, much higher line of engagement, no strikers isolated by 40 yards.

It's direct, that's the only comparison.

Yes. I fail to see the Pulis comparison either. The ball was constantly going in the box yesterday, there just wasn't anyone on the end of it.

The comparison is with the entertainment value. There have been a number of matches this season that are just as dull as many TP games against much lower opposition. I really don’t care how we play but I can see the point that those who prefer a more sophisticated style of play are making. Lumping the ball in the box isn’t particularly great to watch and neither is turning the ball around the corner and into the channels from midfield aimlessly and frenetically.
Reply
#24
Derek Hardballs Wrote:
Squid Wrote:
Birdman1811 Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:The football is no better than under Pulis, it’s remarkable how many pretend it is because the high press is fashionable. I didn’t care for most of TPS tenure and I don’t care now, it’s a results based game and so far the results are good. We haven’t played attractive football with any regularity for decades, arguably our most successful periods have been when we have been at our most pragmatic for at least 40yrs.

Disagree about the Pulis comparison.

Much more attacking intent, much higher line of engagement, no strikers isolated by 40 yards.

It's direct, that's the only comparison.

Yes. I fail to see the Pulis comparison either. The ball was constantly going in the box yesterday, there just wasn't anyone on the end of it.

The comparison is with the entertainment value. There have been a number of matches this season that are just as dull as many TP games against much lower opposition. I really don’t care how we play but I can see the point that those who prefer a more sophisticated style of play are making. Lumping the ball in the box isn’t particularly great to watch and neither is turning the ball around the corner and into the channels from midfield aimlessly and frenetically.
I'm not buying this Pulis comparison either, DH. The football under TP was always turgid and most games  he didn't even attempt to win, (including annoyingly, the home game against worst villa side in memory). Val has us straining to win every game. I will agree it isn't pretty although it does have it's moments, Sheff Utd, Luton, Bournemouth were all very entertaining.
I also was bought up with the free flowing football of the 60s and witnessed the excitement of the late 70's. I was told by my grandad, Albion always had this reputation, Albion being the entertainers and Wolves were the powerhouses. Times have changed now and with the normal tenure of a manager being less than 2 years, I don't see anyone putting anything but their own methods first.
Reply
#25
(10-16-2021, 01:43 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:
Squid Wrote:
Birdman1811 Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:The football is no better than under Pulis, it’s remarkable how many pretend it is because the high press is fashionable. I didn’t care for most of TPS tenure and I don’t care now, it’s a results based game and so far the results are good. We haven’t played attractive football with any regularity for decades, arguably our most successful periods have been when we have been at our most pragmatic for at least 40yrs.

Disagree about the Pulis comparison.

Much more attacking intent, much higher line of engagement, no strikers isolated by 40 yards.

It's direct, that's the only comparison.

Yes. I fail to see the Pulis comparison either. The ball was constantly going in the box yesterday, there just wasn't anyone on the end of it.

The comparison is with the entertainment value. There have been a number of matches this season that are just as dull as many TP games against much lower opposition. I really don’t care how we play but I can see the point that those who prefer a more sophisticated style of play are making. Lumping the ball in the box isn’t particularly great to watch and neither is turning the ball around the corner and into the channels from midfield aimlessly and frenetically.
I'm not buying this Pulis comparison either, DH. The football under TP was always turgid and most games  he didn't even attempt to win, (including annoyingly, the home game against worst villa side in memory). Val has us straining to win every game. I will agree it isn't pretty although it does have it's moments, Sheff Utd, Luton, Bournemouth were all very entertaining.
I also was bought up with the free flowing football of the 60s and witnessed the excitement of the late 70's. I was told by my grandad, Albion always had this reputation, Albion being the entertainers and Wolves were the powerhouses. Times have changed now and with the normal tenure of a manager being less than 2 years, I don't see anyone putting anything but their own methods first.

We won a number of games, playing decent football under Pulis it’s a myth that always played with no attacking intent.
Reply
#26
Without digging up old ground, and remember I supported Pulis longer than most.

We really did go for the draw far too often when the win was gift wrapped, that fucking Villa game being prime example, League 1 teams could steamroller them, we stood off and held on valiantly for a draw...

There is a massive difference in style and intent between Val and Pulis, neither are ever going to warm the hearts of football purists though, and that's ok.
Reply
#27
Derek Hardballs Wrote:
Tom Joad Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:
Squid Wrote:
Birdman1811 Wrote:Disagree about the Pulis comparison.

Much more attacking intent, much higher line of engagement, no strikers isolated by 40 yards.

It's direct, that's the only comparison.

Yes. I fail to see the Pulis comparison either. The ball was constantly going in the box yesterday, there just wasn't anyone on the end of it.

The comparison is with the entertainment value. There have been a number of matches this season that are just as dull as many TP games against much lower opposition. I really don’t care how we play but I can see the point that those who prefer a more sophisticated style of play are making. Lumping the ball in the box isn’t particularly great to watch and neither is turning the ball around the corner and into the channels from midfield aimlessly and frenetically.
I'm not buying this Pulis comparison either, DH. The football under TP was always turgid and most games  he didn't even attempt to win, (including annoyingly, the home game against worst villa side in memory). Val has us straining to win every game. I will agree it isn't pretty although it does have it's moments, Sheff Utd, Luton, Bournemouth were all very entertaining.
I also was bought up with the free flowing football of the 60s and witnessed the excitement of the late 70's. I was told by my grandad, Albion always had this reputation, Albion being the entertainers and Wolves were the powerhouses. Times have changed now and with the normal tenure of a manager being less than 2 years, I don't see anyone putting anything but their own methods first.

We won a number of games, playing decent football under Pulis it’s a myth that always played with no attacking intent.
I'm genuinely struggling to remember those but we can agree to disagree Big Grin
Reply
#28
(10-16-2021, 01:55 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Without digging up old ground, and remember I supported Pulis longer than most.

We really did go for the draw far too often when the win was gift wrapped, that fucking Villa game being prime example, League 1 teams could steamroller them, we stood off and held on valiantly for a draw...

There is a massive difference in style and intent between Val and Pulis, neither are ever going to warm the hearts of football purists though, and that's ok.

It’s not the intent it’s what transpires. We intend to play high pressing, attacking football but the result is often far more pleasing than the game itself. I genuinely don’t care but I didn’t see much difference in excitement / entertainment levels against Stoke, Blues and the Posh as I did under TP. One clearly sets out to win more than the other but it doesn’t make it anymore enjoyable to watch.
Reply
#29
(10-16-2021, 02:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-16-2021, 01:55 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Without digging up old ground, and remember I supported Pulis longer than most.

We really did go for the draw far too often when the win was gift wrapped, that fucking Villa game being prime example, League 1 teams could steamroller them, we stood off and held on valiantly for a draw...

There is a massive difference in style and intent between Val and Pulis, neither are ever going to warm the hearts of football purists though, and that's ok.

It’s not the intent it’s what transpires. We intend to play high pressing, attacking football but the result is often far more pleasing than the game itself. I genuinely don’t care but I didn’t see much difference in excitement / entertainment levels against Stoke, Blues and the Posh as I did under TP. One clearly sets out to win more than the other but it doesn’t make it anymore enjoyable to watch.

There we do agree.
Reply
#30
I didn't go last night and couldn't bring myself to watch it. My dad phoned me at the end, and he was annoyed with the pile of crap he'd watched. I said, let me guess; we lumped it forward, rushed at it, and there was no end product and it was boring. He said exactly. I replied, it's like bad parks football, hoof and chase, and that the fact i didn't watch it and described it pretty accurately shows how crap it is.

He actually said he thought it was the worst he'd ever seen, I said come on we had Pulis, which he agreed was worse. He's been a fan since the 1950s, he thinks it's an utter shambles and utterly boring to watch. We both agreed that getting promoted with this side, manager and 'way of playing' could see us doing worse than Derby did.

Some of us need more than just winning, which I know is an unpopular view on here. Six has his work cut out and needs to provide more than flukey wins.

(10-16-2021, 01:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-16-2021, 01:43 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:
Squid Wrote:
Birdman1811 Wrote:Disagree about the Pulis comparison.

Much more attacking intent, much higher line of engagement, no strikers isolated by 40 yards.

It's direct, that's the only comparison.

Yes. I fail to see the Pulis comparison either. The ball was constantly going in the box yesterday, there just wasn't anyone on the end of it.

The comparison is with the entertainment value. There have been a number of matches this season that are just as dull as many TP games against much lower opposition. I really don’t care how we play but I can see the point that those who prefer a more sophisticated style of play are making. Lumping the ball in the box isn’t particularly great to watch and neither is turning the ball around the corner and into the channels from midfield aimlessly and frenetically.
I'm not buying this Pulis comparison either, DH. The football under TP was always turgid and most games  he didn't even attempt to win, (including annoyingly, the home game against worst villa side in memory). Val has us straining to win every game. I will agree it isn't pretty although it does have it's moments, Sheff Utd, Luton, Bournemouth were all very entertaining.
I also was bought up with the free flowing football of the 60s and witnessed the excitement of the late 70's. I was told by my grandad, Albion always had this reputation, Albion being the entertainers and Wolves were the powerhouses. Times have changed now and with the normal tenure of a manager being less than 2 years, I don't see anyone putting anything but their own methods first.

We won a number of games, playing decent football under Pulis it’s a myth that always played with no attacking intent.

Pulis won less than 30% of the matches he was manager for. He drew exactly the same percentage of games as he won, that kind of backs up the lack of intent to win.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)