The birch
#21
(10-07-2021, 11:31 AM)AmsterdamBaggie Wrote:
(10-07-2021, 11:07 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: It's simpler than that, Atomic.

If they are guilty of something that would command a whole of life term, then don't spend millions keeping and rehabilitating them, there is no point. Just hang them instead.

Capital punishment is more expensive than life time incarceration due to the legal fees, appeals, etc.

and it would be set to double in cost if we used the electric chair or gassing them!
Reply
#22
(10-07-2021, 11:07 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: It's simpler than that, Atomic.

If they are guilty of something that would command a whole of life term, then don't spend millions keeping and rehabilitating them, there is no point. Just hang them instead.

No amount of "justified" hangings can make up for the execution of an individual found guilty only to be later discovered innocent. That's the bottom line for me.  No justice system is perfect and I've no reason to believe wrongful convictions have suddenly become rare as rocking horse shit.
Reply
#23
I don't believe many convicts died from the birch ?

Hold it, just remembered Morgan Freeman did in "Unforgiven"
Reply
#24
(10-07-2021, 12:03 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: I don't believe many convicts died from the birch ?

Hold it, just remembered Morgan Freeman did in "Unforgiven"

I rest my case!
Reply
#25
Liberal, hand wringing, woke do-gooder calling.

My kids wouldn't "kick a guide dog" because they are looked after and cared for and have been given a decent understanding of right and wrong. Also they like dogs.
You can only imagine the kind of home a kid who thinks it's funny to hoof a guide dog might come from. Alternatively he might have a lovely home life and just be a little cnut, however, you do need to take these things into consideration when dishing out punishment particularly with the yoofs.

Couzens does just appears to be a piece of general human excrement for whome hanging or a bullet would be too good. Hung, drawn and quartered maybe?
Reply
#26
(10-07-2021, 11:30 AM)Sotv Wrote:
(10-07-2021, 11:22 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-07-2021, 11:10 AM)Sotv Wrote: If as a society we profess killing to be wrong, how can we justify state killing of its own citizens?

It's a bit like telling your kids "Don't fucking swear you little bastards"

If they are guilty, strip them of their rights. Treat them like dogs, they deserve no more.

that doesn't get around the problem of the hypocrisy of killing people because you think killing people is wrong though.

I don't think killing some people is wrong. A dog that attacks and maybe kills or maims a child, wham - dead. Some nut job who murders someone else, maybe even a few other someones, cushy number in solitary at our expense. Then again I firmly believe that assisted suicide is a good thing too, someone will no doubt disagree, but as with the dog example, dog seriously ill, suffering, oh Mr Vet can you finish it off please... humans, no you keep suffering me old China... humans are animals, no matter what anyone comes up with to try and move us away from the fact.

(10-07-2021, 01:40 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: Liberal, hand wringing, woke do-gooder calling.

My kids wouldn't "kick a guide dog" because they are looked after and cared for and have been given a decent understanding of right and wrong. Also they like dogs.
You can only imagine the kind of home a kid who thinks it's funny to hoof a guide dog might come from. Alternatively he might have a lovely home life and just be a little cnut, however, you do need to take these things into consideration when dishing out punishment particularly with the yoofs.

Couzens does just appears to be a piece of general human excrement for whome hanging or a bullet would be too good. Hung, drawn and quartered maybe?

So, if you come from a shitty home then you should be allowed to act like a cunt and get away with it? Hmmmm. it's like that prim and proper Oxford (I think) student who murdered her boyfriend then got let off because she had a glittering medical career ahead of her and would benefit more people...
Reply
#27
Not necessarily related to crime but I'm sure in years to come, with an ever-growing elderly population in many countries, I'm sure we'll see the rules on assisted suicide relaxed to some extent.
Reply
#28
(10-07-2021, 11:31 AM)AmsterdamBaggie Wrote:
(10-07-2021, 11:07 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: It's simpler than that, Atomic.

If they are guilty of something that would command a whole of life term, then don't spend millions keeping and rehabilitating them, there is no point. Just hang them instead.

Capital punishment is more expensive than life time incarceration due to the legal fees, appeals, etc.

Not if you cap them 30 seconds after conviction.
Reply
#29
(10-08-2021, 07:55 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(10-07-2021, 11:30 AM)Sotv Wrote:
(10-07-2021, 11:22 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-07-2021, 11:10 AM)Sotv Wrote: If as a society we profess killing to be wrong, how can we justify state killing of its own citizens?

It's a bit like telling your kids "Don't fucking swear you little bastards"

If they are guilty, strip them of their rights. Treat them like dogs, they deserve no more.

that doesn't get around the problem of the hypocrisy of killing people because you think killing people is wrong though.

I don't think killing some people is wrong. A dog that attacks and maybe kills or maims a child, wham - dead. Some nut job who murders someone else, maybe even a few other someones, cushy number in solitary at our expense. Then again I firmly believe that assisted suicide is a good thing too, someone will no doubt disagree, but as with the dog example, dog seriously ill, suffering, oh Mr Vet can you finish it off please... humans, no you keep suffering me old China... humans are animals, no matter what anyone comes up with to try and move us away from the fact.

(10-07-2021, 01:40 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: Liberal, hand wringing, woke do-gooder calling.

My kids wouldn't "kick a guide dog" because they are looked after and cared for and have been given a decent understanding of right and wrong.  Also they like dogs.
You can only imagine the kind of home a kid who thinks it's funny to hoof a guide dog might come from. Alternatively he might have a lovely home life and just be a little cnut, however, you do need to take these things into consideration when dishing out punishment particularly with the yoofs.

Couzens does just appears to be a piece of general human excrement for whome hanging or a bullet would be too good.  Hung, drawn and quartered maybe?

So, if you come from a shitty home then you should be allowed to act like a cunt and get away with it? Hmmmm. it's like that prim and proper Oxford (I think) student who murdered her boyfriend then got let off because she had a glittering medical career ahead of her and would benefit more people...

No, as I said it just needs to be taken into consideration. 

If said yoof has an adult at home who is also never more happy than when being cruel to animals, and/or humans, then this needs to be considered.  Behaviour and standards like that tends to be learnt.  In my experience working with young people if you find aggressive or anti-social behaviour the source is easily tracked.  But not every single instance.
Reply
#30
Should these people breathe another breath ?
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-birmingham-58834218
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: