Fair Play to Callum Robinson
#41
(10-06-2021, 09:15 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 09:13 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: It's his choice. He is in a position to influence others though, so why does he need to tell the world about his choice?

He was asked in a press conference on international duty, following Klopp’s comments. And they kept asking him about it. Eventually the media were told to stick to football.

If that's the case, I feel sorry for him, but the irish FA (or whoever) should have had him better briefed. A simple pre-planned answer of "nobody within the squad is going to be be discussing their personal medical details" would have done it.
Reply
#42
(10-06-2021, 10:53 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 09:28 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Most people don’t give a shit either way. Have it or don’t have it, most don’t care and accept it’s personal. Like all medical decisions.

There’s a few morons on either side who gleefully jump on negative stories about the other side. But I hated typing that because there should be no sides. It’s personal choice. I’d bet 95% of people dont give other people’s choices a single seconds thought. That’s called being normal.

There is no logic whatsoever to this argument. If your choices impact on others then of course you will care. People who refuse to get vaccinated are putting others, mostly the vulnerable at greater risk than they would be if they have had the vaccine. We can quibble about the percentages but this not just about the individual it’s about society as a whole.

I don’t know what world you live in but I don’t think many people are bothered whether others have it or not. You may think it’s illogical but no one I know gives a toss about hanging around with people who have, or haven’t. They totally respect their choices and dont feel it’s their business. I dont think your medical choices are any of my business, even if it benefits society as a whole. You could argue that you could be forced to give up a kidney as it could save a life and benefit society, but I don’t think that’s right either. Bodily autonomy is fundamental IMO. You can bleat about it as much as you want but people put their own bodies first, and make their own decisions.

The only thing I’ve found is people who don’t want it yet are fed up with being labelled by media and social media. But as we all know, social media is like that. Extremes.

Perhaps we mix with different people. Most people I know care about the impact their decisions might have on others weaker / more vulnerable than themselves.
Reply
#43
(10-06-2021, 11:07 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:53 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 09:28 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Most people don’t give a shit either way. Have it or don’t have it, most don’t care and accept it’s personal. Like all medical decisions.

There’s a few morons on either side who gleefully jump on negative stories about the other side. But I hated typing that because there should be no sides. It’s personal choice. I’d bet 95% of people dont give other people’s choices a single seconds thought. That’s called being normal.

There is no logic whatsoever to this argument. If your choices impact on others then of course you will care. People who refuse to get vaccinated are putting others, mostly the vulnerable at greater risk than they would be if they have had the vaccine. We can quibble about the percentages but this not just about the individual it’s about society as a whole.

I don’t know what world you live in but I don’t think many people are bothered whether others have it or not. You may think it’s illogical but no one I know gives a toss about hanging around with people who have, or haven’t. They totally respect their choices and dont feel it’s their business. I dont think your medical choices are any of my business, even if it benefits society as a whole. You could argue that you could be forced to give up a kidney as it could save a life and benefit society, but I don’t think that’s right either. Bodily autonomy is fundamental IMO. You can bleat about it as much as you want but people put their own bodies first, and make their own decisions.

The only thing I’ve found is people who don’t want it yet are fed up with being labelled by media and social media. But as we all know, social media is like that. Extremes.

Perhaps we mix with different people. Most people I know care about the impact their decisions might have on others more weaker / more vulnerable than themselves.

They isolate if ill. They take tests where required. But they don’t judge people on their decisions on vaccines. They’re normal.

So, if someone said next week can you donate a kidney as it saves a life, it benefits society, what would you say? Yes or no? Be honest.

And whatever you’d do, how many people would say yes? And of those who didn’t want to, would they be slagged off for being selfish and not caring about others? After all, donating a kidney would save a life…. It would benefit others…

I’ll be honest I’d say no. I’m keeping my kidneys. That’s selfish maybe, or maybe it’s just my body my choice. I’m putting that above another person. I reckon no one would ever judge me for that. But when it comes to bodily autonomy and vaccines, people are judged and called selfish by people like you. It’s a nonsense and it’s been whipped up by the government and media.
Reply
#44
(10-06-2021, 10:44 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:37 AM)wba13 Wrote: My opinion is he is totally wrong not to have the vaccine, perhaps I’m being selfish but as I’m vulnerable I’m glad I’m not in his list of friends or relatives who go close by him. For all we know he could be a carrier and with his skin tone I think I’m right in saying he is more vulnerable to catching it. Another thing from a selfish point is having caught it twice he has missed matches so and put others at risk. For me it’s wrong when it’s proved the vaccine does a job why not take it instead of putting yourself, your family and anyone you come in contact with at risk.

Anyone can be a carrier. Vaxed or not. Had it previously or not. Literally anyone.

The vaccine severely limits bad cases of the disease.

Yes I know. But would rather be next to someone who’s been vaccinated and a carrier than next to someone not vaccinated and a carrier.
As for the raciest’s online who are now giving him grief hope there all caught and have the same sentence as Silwood scum all of them.
Reply
#45
(10-06-2021, 11:11 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 11:07 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:53 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 09:28 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Most people don’t give a shit either way. Have it or don’t have it, most don’t care and accept it’s personal. Like all medical decisions.

There’s a few morons on either side who gleefully jump on negative stories about the other side. But I hated typing that because there should be no sides. It’s personal choice. I’d bet 95% of people dont give other people’s choices a single seconds thought. That’s called being normal.

There is no logic whatsoever to this argument. If your choices impact on others then of course you will care. People who refuse to get vaccinated are putting others, mostly the vulnerable at greater risk than they would be if they have had the vaccine. We can quibble about the percentages but this not just about the individual it’s about society as a whole.

I don’t know what world you live in but I don’t think many people are bothered whether others have it or not. You may think it’s illogical but no one I know gives a toss about hanging around with people who have, or haven’t. They totally respect their choices and dont feel it’s their business. I dont think your medical choices are any of my business, even if it benefits society as a whole. You could argue that you could be forced to give up a kidney as it could save a life and benefit society, but I don’t think that’s right either. Bodily autonomy is fundamental IMO. You can bleat about it as much as you want but people put their own bodies first, and make their own decisions.

The only thing I’ve found is people who don’t want it yet are fed up with being labelled by media and social media. But as we all know, social media is like that. Extremes.

Perhaps we mix with different people. Most people I know care about the impact their decisions might have on others more weaker / more vulnerable than themselves.

They isolate if ill. They take tests where required. But they don’t judge people on their decisions on vaccines. They’re normal.

So, if someone said next week can you donate a kidney as it saves a life, it benefits society, what would you say? Yes or no? Be honest.

And whatever you’d do, how many people would say yes? And of those who didn’t want to, would they be slagged off for being selfish and not caring about others? After all, donating a kidney would save a life…. It would benefit others…

I’ll be honest I’d say no. I’m keeping my kidneys. That’s selfish maybe, or maybe it’s just my body my choice. I’m putting that above another person. I reckon no one would ever judge me for that. But when it comes to bodily autonomy and vaccines, people are judged and called selfish by people like you. It’s a nonsense and it’s been whipped up by the government and media.

You are comparing a kidney transplant with a vaccine! Your argument has gone from illogical to bonkers! I haven't been influenced by anyone in government over this, if they said it was raining I would have to go outside and check for myself such is my antipathy and lack of trust in them. I just wanted to protect myself and others from getting ill from Covid as have the vast majority of the people I know. As I said we do seem to be mixing in very different circles.
Reply
#46
If having had it twice means he is just as capable of fighting off the virus as a double-jabbed person, then theres no difference to him personally.

It is not known how much transmission is reduced if you are jabbed, or if you have recovered from it and not been jabbed. Some say there is no difference, some say there is. Who knows? 

If CR has been informed, or made an informed decision, that having the jab makes no difference to your 'immunity' or likelihood of transmitting it, then he's made that choice and i respect it. 

What needs to be known is whether that belief is correct, but i don't think anybody does.
Reply
#47
(10-06-2021, 11:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 11:11 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 11:07 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:53 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: There is no logic whatsoever to this argument. If your choices impact on others then of course you will care. People who refuse to get vaccinated are putting others, mostly the vulnerable at greater risk than they would be if they have had the vaccine. We can quibble about the percentages but this not just about the individual it’s about society as a whole.

I don’t know what world you live in but I don’t think many people are bothered whether others have it or not. You may think it’s illogical but no one I know gives a toss about hanging around with people who have, or haven’t. They totally respect their choices and dont feel it’s their business. I dont think your medical choices are any of my business, even if it benefits society as a whole. You could argue that you could be forced to give up a kidney as it could save a life and benefit society, but I don’t think that’s right either. Bodily autonomy is fundamental IMO. You can bleat about it as much as you want but people put their own bodies first, and make their own decisions.

The only thing I’ve found is people who don’t want it yet are fed up with being labelled by media and social media. But as we all know, social media is like that. Extremes.

Perhaps we mix with different people. Most people I know care about the impact their decisions might have on others more weaker / more vulnerable than themselves.

They isolate if ill. They take tests where required. But they don’t judge people on their decisions on vaccines. They’re normal.

So, if someone said next week can you donate a kidney as it saves a life, it benefits society, what would you say? Yes or no? Be honest.

And whatever you’d do, how many people would say yes? And of those who didn’t want to, would they be slagged off for being selfish and not caring about others? After all, donating a kidney would save a life…. It would benefit others…

I’ll be honest I’d say no. I’m keeping my kidneys. That’s selfish maybe, or maybe it’s just my body my choice. I’m putting that above another person. I reckon no one would ever judge me for that. But when it comes to bodily autonomy and vaccines, people are judged and called selfish by people like you. It’s a nonsense and it’s been whipped up by the government and media.

You are comparing a kidney transplant with a vaccine! Your argument has gone from illogical to bonkers! I haven't been influenced by anyone in government over this, if they said it was raining I would have to go outside and check for myself such is my antipathy and lack of trust in them. I just wanted to protect myself and others from getting ill from Covid as have the vast majority of the people I know. As I said we do seem to be mixing in very different circles.

It’s not bonkers at all. It’s not illogical. It’s about your body your choice and I’m giving a different example. It’s not for you to decide what is ok to be selfish about in terms of your body, and what’s not ok. You can’t draw the line where you feel like it and judge people based on your line. Well you can, but no one will give a shit as they’ll have their own personal line.

As I’ve said, people I know take tests if required, and isolate with symptoms. They don’t judge people on their vaccine choice. They’re normal. That goes for work mates, my oldest mates, white, black, Asian mates, my family, my mrs family, no one judges anyone. It’s normal.

So answer me, would you donate a kidney? It’s for the benefit of society and you can live with one kidney. It’s the exact logic you keep preaching, that it’s not about the individual, it’s a benefit to society. Donating that kidney benefits another person. It’s the same logic. So are you ok with that? Don’t be so fucking selfish!

It’s exactly the same logic. Benefit society as a whole over your individual choice. And if you don’t donate the kidney, tell me why. Tell me why that’s not selfish. You’re putting your own body choice first. Like Callum Robinson.
Reply
#48
(10-06-2021, 11:07 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:53 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 09:28 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Most people don’t give a shit either way. Have it or don’t have it, most don’t care and accept it’s personal. Like all medical decisions.

There’s a few morons on either side who gleefully jump on negative stories about the other side. But I hated typing that because there should be no sides. It’s personal choice. I’d bet 95% of people dont give other people’s choices a single seconds thought. That’s called being normal.

There is no logic whatsoever to this argument. If your choices impact on others then of course you will care. People who refuse to get vaccinated are putting others, mostly the vulnerable at greater risk than they would be if they have had the vaccine. We can quibble about the percentages but this not just about the individual it’s about society as a whole.

I don’t know what world you live in but I don’t think many people are bothered whether others have it or not. You may think it’s illogical but no one I know gives a toss about hanging around with people who have, or haven’t. They totally respect their choices and dont feel it’s their business. I dont think your medical choices are any of my business, even if it benefits society as a whole. You could argue that you could be forced to give up a kidney as it could save a life and benefit society, but I don’t think that’s right either. Bodily autonomy is fundamental IMO. You can bleat about it as much as you want but people put their own bodies first, and make their own decisions.

The only thing I’ve found is people who don’t want it yet are fed up with being labelled by media and social media. But as we all know, social media is like that. Extremes.

Perhaps we mix with different people. Most people I know care about the impact their decisions might have on others weaker / more vulnerable than themselves.

Step away from the mirror, Derek, step away from the mirror...
Reply
#49
Fair play to Callum Robinson, he’s come out and told the world that he’s basically an idiot (same as any other anti vaxxers).
Reply
#50
(10-06-2021, 11:37 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 11:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 11:11 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 11:07 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:53 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I don’t know what world you live in but I don’t think many people are bothered whether others have it or not. You may think it’s illogical but no one I know gives a toss about hanging around with people who have, or haven’t. They totally respect their choices and dont feel it’s their business. I dont think your medical choices are any of my business, even if it benefits society as a whole. You could argue that you could be forced to give up a kidney as it could save a life and benefit society, but I don’t think that’s right either. Bodily autonomy is fundamental IMO. You can bleat about it as much as you want but people put their own bodies first, and make their own decisions.

The only thing I’ve found is people who don’t want it yet are fed up with being labelled by media and social media. But as we all know, social media is like that. Extremes.

Perhaps we mix with different people. Most people I know care about the impact their decisions might have on others more weaker / more vulnerable than themselves.

They isolate if ill. They take tests where required. But they don’t judge people on their decisions on vaccines. They’re normal.

So, if someone said next week can you donate a kidney as it saves a life, it benefits society, what would you say? Yes or no? Be honest.

And whatever you’d do, how many people would say yes? And of those who didn’t want to, would they be slagged off for being selfish and not caring about others? After all, donating a kidney would save a life…. It would benefit others…

I’ll be honest I’d say no. I’m keeping my kidneys. That’s selfish maybe, or maybe it’s just my body my choice. I’m putting that above another person. I reckon no one would ever judge me for that. But when it comes to bodily autonomy and vaccines, people are judged and called selfish by people like you. It’s a nonsense and it’s been whipped up by the government and media.

You are comparing a kidney transplant with a vaccine! Your argument has gone from illogical to bonkers! I haven't been influenced by anyone in government over this, if they said it was raining I would have to go outside and check for myself such is my antipathy and lack of trust in them. I just wanted to protect myself and others from getting ill from Covid as have the vast majority of the people I know. As I said we do seem to be mixing in very different circles.

It’s not bonkers at all. It’s not illogical. It’s about your body your choice and I’m giving a different example. It’s not for you to decide what is ok to be selfish about in terms of your body, and what’s not ok. You can’t draw the line where you feel like it and judge people based on your line. Well you can, but no one will give a shit as they’ll have their own personal line.

As I’ve said, people I know take tests if required, and isolate with symptoms. They don’t judge people on their vaccine choice. They’re normal. That goes for work mates, my oldest mates, white, black, Asian mates, my family, my mrs family, no one judges anyone. It’s normal.

So answer me, would you donate a kidney? It’s for the benefit of society and you can live with one kidney. It’s the exact logic you keep preaching, that it’s not about the individual, it’s a benefit to society. Donating that kidney benefits another person. It’s the same logic. So are you ok with that? Don’t be so fucking selfish!

It’s exactly the same logic. Benefit society as a whole over your individual choice. And if you don’t donate the kidney, tell me why. Tell me why that’s not selfish. You’re putting your own body choice first. Like Callum Robinson.

It’s a ludicrous comparison. You can argue it’s not but it is. You know we will never agree on this and I make zero apologies for my position as you will no doubt. I think this is very much a agree to differ moment ir it’ll descend into an argument.

(10-06-2021, 11:43 AM)baggiebloke Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 11:07 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:53 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 10:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2021, 09:28 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Most people don’t give a shit either way. Have it or don’t have it, most don’t care and accept it’s personal. Like all medical decisions.

There’s a few morons on either side who gleefully jump on negative stories about the other side. But I hated typing that because there should be no sides. It’s personal choice. I’d bet 95% of people dont give other people’s choices a single seconds thought. That’s called being normal.

There is no logic whatsoever to this argument. If your choices impact on others then of course you will care. People who refuse to get vaccinated are putting others, mostly the vulnerable at greater risk than they would be if they have had the vaccine. We can quibble about the percentages but this not just about the individual it’s about society as a whole.

I don’t know what world you live in but I don’t think many people are bothered whether others have it or not. You may think it’s illogical but no one I know gives a toss about hanging around with people who have, or haven’t. They totally respect their choices and dont feel it’s their business. I dont think your medical choices are any of my business, even if it benefits society as a whole. You could argue that you could be forced to give up a kidney as it could save a life and benefit society, but I don’t think that’s right either. Bodily autonomy is fundamental IMO. You can bleat about it as much as you want but people put their own bodies first, and make their own decisions.

The only thing I’ve found is people who don’t want it yet are fed up with being labelled by media and social media. But as we all know, social media is like that. Extremes.

Perhaps we mix with different people. Most people I know care about the impact their decisions might have on others weaker / more vulnerable than themselves.

Step away from the mirror, Derek, step away from the mirror...

Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: