How much difference do managers make?
#11
As has been said depends on the way the club is run. And it is the exceptions that make a real difference.

SGM was an old school manager who literally lifted the club single handedly out of the turd times of the 80's and 90's. Massive difference to the whole direction of the club and its future. Not sure the relative success of the last 20 years could have happened without him.

In contrast under the Peace/Ashworth combo it did feel as if it was the infrastructure that was important and the head coach was expendable with a list of ready replacements on hand should they be required due to.poor form or internal disagreements. Here it is was the DOF that makes the difference.

The Ashworth/Hodgson combination felt like a combination of the two. The DOF with recruitment and Uncle Woy on the pitch. Think we could have lost either and still had a difference maker at the club....we lost both and the rest is history.
Reply
#12
As much as it pains me to say anything against Darren Moore, most managers could have got that 18/19 team promoted. So sometimes it's the negative impact of the manager as much as the positive.
Reply
#13
(10-05-2021, 10:49 AM)Squid Wrote: As much as it pains me to say anything against Darren Moore, most managers could have got that 18/19 team promoted. So sometimes it's the negative impact of the manager as much as the positive.

It was frustrating in many ways. Without Moore we wouldn't have had that team, or the togetherness that was so important.

However there is a case for saying he made too many mistakes which stopped the team going up. Losing Barnes really hurt us.
Reply
#14
Money is the overriding force these days, managers are just another cog in the machine, certainly at the head of the greed trough.

Klopp or Guardiola would have little impact at Norwich, that's why they'll never try.

Further down the leagues, where you have a more even, traditional (skint), set up, they have more influence. Look at Wilder, worked wonders at various lower levels, finally reached the "top" and bang, out of work. Suddenly a bad manager or just crushed by the machine?
Reply
#15
(10-05-2021, 10:49 AM)Squid Wrote: As much as it pains me to say anything against Darren Moore, most managers could have got that 18/19 team promoted. So sometimes it's the negative impact of the manager as much as the positive.

Big Dave put his faith in Graeme Jones and couldn't or wouldn't change the way things were done when it was clear that change was needed. We could be in a similar position with VI if his system gets found out, or is weakened by injuries to key players. He hasn't shown the least element of flexibility in approach so far - maybe because he hasn't needed to.
Reply
#16
(10-05-2021, 10:51 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 10:49 AM)Squid Wrote: As much as it pains me to say anything against Darren Moore, most managers could have got that 18/19 team promoted. So sometimes it's the negative impact of the manager as much as the positive.

It was frustrating in many ways. Without Moore we wouldn't have had that team, or the togetherness that was so important.

However there is a case for saying he made too many mistakes which stopped the team going up. Losing Barnes really hurt us.

Yup. 

Without Moore I doubt we’d have even been near the top 6 that season… he galvanised the place and carried a broken and dysfunctional squad and club through a very tricky summer and was instrumental in not only both Barnes and Gayle signing, but key players giving us one more year.

Had Barnes stayed I think we’d have won promotion, we really struggled to replace his ability to singlehandedly change a game - but the impact Shan had by just instilling some defensive nouse and more direct approach shows how easily the squad could have been better utilised - but without Big Dave we’d have never been anywhere close to that position.

Had we given Shan the No2 job instead of Jones, who knows where we’d have ended up.
Reply
#17
(10-05-2021, 11:51 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 10:51 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 10:49 AM)Squid Wrote: As much as it pains me to say anything against Darren Moore, most managers could have got that 18/19 team promoted. So sometimes it's the negative impact of the manager as much as the positive.

It was frustrating in many ways. Without Moore we wouldn't have had that team, or the togetherness that was so important.

However there is a case for saying he made too many mistakes which stopped the team going up. Losing Barnes really hurt us.

Yup. 

Without Moore I doubt we’d have even been near the top 6 that season… he galvanised the place and carried a broken and dysfunctional squad and club through a very tricky summer and was instrumental in not only both Barnes and Gayle signing, but key players giving us one more year.

Had Barnes stayed I think we’d have won promotion, we really struggled to replace his ability to singlehandedly change a game - but the impact Shan had by just instilling some defensive nouse and more direct approach shows how easily the squad could have been better utilised - but without Big Dave we’d have never been anywhere close to that position.

Had we given Shan the No2 job instead of Jones, who knows where we’d have ended up.

Yes, that's fair.

In terms of players we also had Matt Phillips start the season really strongly for us and then get injured/be replaced by his pea-hearted twin. And talking of pea-hearted, the January recruitment that year didn't have the hoped for impact. There are often so many variables.
Reply
#18
The difference should be huge. But, managers are filtered by the divisions they are working, so in practice, the difference can sometimes appear to marginal.
I am sure most on here have worked with/under/over managers who were vastly different in their abilities. Many will have seen people promoted to their level of incompetence, adding further evidence of the difference that managers can make.
Reply
#19
3.5%, with a small margin of error.
Reply
#20
(10-05-2021, 12:12 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 11:51 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 10:51 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(10-05-2021, 10:49 AM)Squid Wrote: As much as it pains me to say anything against Darren Moore, most managers could have got that 18/19 team promoted. So sometimes it's the negative impact of the manager as much as the positive.

It was frustrating in many ways. Without Moore we wouldn't have had that team, or the togetherness that was so important.

However there is a case for saying he made too many mistakes which stopped the team going up. Losing Barnes really hurt us.

Yup. 

Without Moore I doubt we’d have even been near the top 6 that season… he galvanised the place and carried a broken and dysfunctional squad and club through a very tricky summer and was instrumental in not only both Barnes and Gayle signing, but key players giving us one more year.

Had Barnes stayed I think we’d have won promotion, we really struggled to replace his ability to singlehandedly change a game - but the impact Shan had by just instilling some defensive nouse and more direct approach shows how easily the squad could have been better utilised - but without Big Dave we’d have never been anywhere close to that position.

Had we given Shan the No2 job instead of Jones, who knows where we’d have ended up.

Yes, that's fair.

In terms of players we also had Matt Phillips start the season really strongly for us and then get injured/be replaced by his pea-hearted twin. And talking of pea-hearted, the January recruitment that year didn't have the hoped for impact. There are often so many variables.

Agreed - in fairness, we did well to bring in 4 players that January, and credit to Dowling and the budget holders for trying to keep up the momentum, but replacing both Phillips and Barnes' ability in January was always going to be a tall order. Holgate and Johansen added some of the ingredients we were lacking,  but Murphy and Montero were poor, poor substitutes for Barnes.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)