Avoiding the jab
#41
(10-04-2021, 05:40 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 05:17 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 04:55 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 04:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote: What makes you think that isn't effective at reducing transmission?

Just going on the pure number of jabbed people catching Covid. I know 3 households where one of the members caught Covid and then within a few days the rest of the family caught it too. These weren't old people who may have waning immunity either. 

As I said previously with waning immunity, length of time from when jabbed, strength of individuals immune system etc it is hard to determine just how effective the jabs are. 

The fact that boosters are already required only 6 months after the second jab tells it own story surely.

People who are jabbed will still run the chance of getting covid, the jab just reduces the chance of them getting it. That's got nothing to do with transmission - if someone in your vicinity gets covid and you are exposed to it then you will likely get it, the symptoms will likely be reduced from they would be if you hadn't had the jab but that's it.

It's hard to determine how effective the jabs are because it is so new, nothing else. And of course we will have waning immunity, its a jab not a shield for life in the same way that we have flu vaccine boosters.

So basically you just have a feeling that it isn't effective at reducing transmission, there's nothing to back that up.
Isn't that what transmission is?

And we don't have flu vaccine boosters. We have a different flu vaccine each year for different strains not the same one as the year before.

The key word is 'reduced'. The vaccine will reduce the likelihood of transmission, it won't remove transmission, so people who get transmitted covid will possibly transmit the virus, but that is reduced because 1stly they may be immune to it from the vaccine and therefore not transmit it at all, or 2ndly they may not have as many symptoms that mean it will be transmitted. For instance they may not cough as much and therefore don't expel as much of the virus as someone who coughs, which logically means they won't transmit it as much (reduced transmission).

And they tweak the flu vaccine, they don't replace it each year and start again.
Reply
#42
(10-02-2021, 07:13 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: How do we view the Anti-vaxers ?
The papers are reporting 5 England players have refused to take a Covid jab ?
Is it -
Madness, Stupidity, Sensible, freedom of choice?

If someone does not want to have the vaccine an antivaxxer or someone who simply does not want it?
Reply
#43
(10-04-2021, 06:44 PM)coxy134 Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 07:13 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: How do we view the Anti-vaxers ?
The papers are reporting 5 England players have refused to take a Covid jab ?
Is it -
Madness, Stupidity, Sensible, freedom of choice?

If someone does not want to have the vaccine an antivaxxer or someone who simply does not want it?

Indeed. A point I made many months ago over on the politics board. Unfortunately, as so often happens, the term anti vaxxer has now been framed into a phrase to lump people into one group. Divide and conquer.

I know a lot who have not had the covid vaccine. Literally none are anti vax in general. All have different reasons for not wanting it. All have had previous vaccines in their life. Many just wish to wait a bit with this one for a bit more long term data, or feel they are low risk of covid, or have had a relative who has had a bad reaction and are genuinely worried, or wish to wait and see how its going to work long term (eg annual boosters), or many other reasons. But they are pigeonholed into being "anti vax".

The media and government has tried to ensure that we're pigeonholed into two groups. Vax or anti vax. No nuance, no understanding that people have different views and that bodily autonomy is a very personal thing. Personally I don't think its anyone's business and would never pressure them to have it.

I feared this division would happen, and I am convinced its going to get a lot worse. Wait til the domestic vaccine passports come in (which they will, Plan B my ass - its Plan A really), there'll be even bigger divisions and bigger problems then IMO.
Reply
#44
(10-04-2021, 07:09 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 06:44 PM)coxy134 Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 07:13 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: How do we view the Anti-vaxers ?
The papers are reporting 5 England players have refused to take a Covid jab ?
Is it -
Madness, Stupidity, Sensible, freedom of choice?

If someone does not want to have the vaccine an antivaxxer or someone who simply does not want it?

Indeed. A point I made many months ago over on the politics board. Unfortunately, as so often happens, the term anti vaxxer has now been framed into a phrase to lump people into one group. Divide and conquer.

I know a lot who have not had the covid vaccine. Literally none are anti vax in general. All have different reasons for not wanting it. All have had previous vaccines in their life. Many just wish to wait a bit with this one for a bit more long term data, or feel they are low risk of covid, or have had a relative who has had a bad reaction and are genuinely worried, or wish to wait and see how its going to work long term (eg annual boosters), or many other reasons. But they are pigeonholed into being "anti vax".

The media and government has tried to ensure that we're pigeonholed into two groups. Vax or anti vax. No nuance, no understanding that people have different views and that bodily autonomy is a very personal thing. Personally I don't think its anyone's business and would never pressure them to have it.

I feared this division would happen, and I am convinced its going to get a lot worse. Wait til the domestic vaccine passports come in (which they will, Plan B my ass - its Plan A really), there'll be even bigger divisions and bigger problems then IMO.

Thats my concern (had my first by the way awaiting my second) lad at football had a go at a mate of mine as he is apprehensive about it accusing him of being an antivaxxer. Funnily enough the lad who had a go played that night knowing his daughter was covid positive.
Reply
#45
(10-04-2021, 07:09 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 06:44 PM)coxy134 Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 07:13 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: How do we view the Anti-vaxers ?
The papers are reporting 5 England players have refused to take a Covid jab ?
Is it -
Madness, Stupidity, Sensible, freedom of choice?

If someone does not want to have the vaccine an antivaxxer or someone who simply does not want it?

Indeed. A point I made many months ago over on the politics board. Unfortunately, as so often happens, the term anti vaxxer has now been framed into a phrase to lump people into one group. Divide and conquer.

I know a lot who have not had the covid vaccine. Literally none are anti vax in general. All have different reasons for not wanting it. All have had previous vaccines in their life. Many just wish to wait a bit with this one for a bit more long term data, or feel they are low risk of covid, or have had a relative who has had a bad reaction and are genuinely worried, or wish to wait and see how its going to work long term (eg annual boosters), or many other reasons. But they are pigeonholed into being "anti vax".

The media and government has tried to ensure that we're pigeonholed into two groups. Vax or anti vax. No nuance, no understanding that people have different views and that bodily autonomy is a very personal thing. Personally I don't think its anyone's business and would never pressure them to have it.

I feared this division would happen, and I am convinced its going to get a lot worse. Wait til the domestic vaccine passports come in (which they will, Plan B my ass - its Plan A really), there'll be even bigger divisions and bigger problems then IMO.

What are they waiting to see? Don’t have the vaccine don’t work with the vulnerable… simple. If previous generations had been so reluctant to have jabs many diseases would now be still rife within the community. People would rather listen to drivel on social media, it’s akin to visiting the ‘Wise Woman’ in Blackadder!
Reply
#46
(10-04-2021, 07:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 07:09 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 06:44 PM)coxy134 Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 07:13 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: How do we view the Anti-vaxers ?
The papers are reporting 5 England players have refused to take a Covid jab ?
Is it -
Madness, Stupidity, Sensible, freedom of choice?

If someone does not want to have the vaccine an antivaxxer or someone who simply does not want it?

Indeed. A point I made many months ago over on the politics board. Unfortunately, as so often happens, the term anti vaxxer has now been framed into a phrase to lump people into one group. Divide and conquer.

I know a lot who have not had the covid vaccine. Literally none are anti vax in general. All have different reasons for not wanting it. All have had previous vaccines in their life. Many just wish to wait a bit with this one for a bit more long term data, or feel they are low risk of covid, or have had a relative who has had a bad reaction and are genuinely worried, or wish to wait and see how its going to work long term (eg annual boosters), or many other reasons. But they are pigeonholed into being "anti vax".

The media and government has tried to ensure that we're pigeonholed into two groups. Vax or anti vax. No nuance, no understanding that people have different views and that bodily autonomy is a very personal thing. Personally I don't think its anyone's business and would never pressure them to have it.

I feared this division would happen, and I am convinced its going to get a lot worse. Wait til the domestic vaccine passports come in (which they will, Plan B my ass - its Plan A really), there'll be even bigger divisions and bigger problems then IMO.

What are they waiting to see? Don’t have the vaccine don’t work with the vulnerable… simple. If previous generations had been so reluctant to have jabs many diseases would now be still rife within the community.

Waiting to see any long term effects. Other pharmaceuticals have been withdrawn further down the line so it’s hardly bonkers. It’s their opinion.

In terms of sacking care workers, that’s a different point. But IMO it may well cause a shortage crisis. So it’s not “simple” unless you ignore the (possible) knock on effects, which you’re clearly happy to do.

I personally don’t think it’ll stop at care workers, but time will tell. My guess is Nhs next, then other jobs after.

In terms of your last point, as I’ve said they’d all agree in respect of many diseases, and are pro vax in general. They just don’t want this one at present, and that’s their business. Flu has not been eradicated… yet Ive never heard anyone say this about the flu vaccine. No one has ever blinked an eye or cared if others haven’t had it. Covid isn’t flu, I’m well aware, but the fact remains if more had been flu jabbed every year, there’s be less flu deaths. Yet there’s never been coercion like this, never been abuse of people not wanting it, never been a label attached to them etc etc….

And your final point… presuming they aren’t having it due to someone on social media. You’ve pigeonholed them. That’s not the reason. They just have a different opinion to you on their own body. But you’ve demonstrated perfectly my point about division, and lumping people into groups. You could not have illustrated it better, removing all nuance. Yep, they must be getting their opinion off Facebook! Obviously! (Shakes head)
Reply
#47
(10-04-2021, 07:09 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 06:44 PM)coxy134 Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 07:13 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: How do we view the Anti-vaxers ?
The papers are reporting 5 England players have refused to take a Covid jab ?
Is it -
Madness, Stupidity, Sensible, freedom of choice?

If someone does not want to have the vaccine an antivaxxer or someone who simply does not want it?

Indeed. A point I made many months ago over on the politics board. Unfortunately, as so often happens, the term anti vaxxer has now been framed into a phrase to lump people into one group. Divide and conquer.

I know a lot who have not had the covid vaccine. Literally none are anti vax in general. All have different reasons for not wanting it. All have had previous vaccines in their life. Many just wish to wait a bit with this one for a bit more long term data, or feel they are low risk of covid, or have had a relative who has had a bad reaction and are genuinely worried, or wish to wait and see how its going to work long term (eg annual boosters), or many other reasons. But they are pigeonholed into being "anti vax".

The media and government has tried to ensure that we're pigeonholed into two groups. Vax or anti vax. No nuance, no understanding that people have different views and that bodily autonomy is a very personal thing. Personally I don't think its anyone's business and would never pressure them to have it.

I feared this division would happen, and I am convinced its going to get a lot worse. Wait til the domestic vaccine passports come in (which they will, Plan B my ass - its Plan A really), there'll be even bigger divisions and bigger problems then IMO.

Absolutely right
Reply
#48
(10-04-2021, 07:33 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 07:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 07:09 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 06:44 PM)coxy134 Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 07:13 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: How do we view the Anti-vaxers ?
The papers are reporting 5 England players have refused to take a Covid jab ?
Is it -
Madness, Stupidity, Sensible, freedom of choice?

If someone does not want to have the vaccine an antivaxxer or someone who simply does not want it?

Indeed. A point I made many months ago over on the politics board. Unfortunately, as so often happens, the term anti vaxxer has now been framed into a phrase to lump people into one group. Divide and conquer.

I know a lot who have not had the covid vaccine. Literally none are anti vax in general. All have different reasons for not wanting it. All have had previous vaccines in their life. Many just wish to wait a bit with this one for a bit more long term data, or feel they are low risk of covid, or have had a relative who has had a bad reaction and are genuinely worried, or wish to wait and see how its going to work long term (eg annual boosters), or many other reasons. But they are pigeonholed into being "anti vax".

The media and government has tried to ensure that we're pigeonholed into two groups. Vax or anti vax. No nuance, no understanding that people have different views and that bodily autonomy is a very personal thing. Personally I don't think its anyone's business and would never pressure them to have it.

I feared this division would happen, and I am convinced its going to get a lot worse. Wait til the domestic vaccine passports come in (which they will, Plan B my ass - its Plan A really), there'll be even bigger divisions and bigger problems then IMO.

What are they waiting to see? Don’t have the vaccine don’t work with the vulnerable… simple. If previous generations had been so reluctant to have jabs many diseases would now be still rife within the community.

Waiting to see any long term effects. Other pharmaceuticals have been withdrawn further down the line so it’s hardly bonkers. It’s their opinion.

In terms of sacking care workers, that’s a different point. But IMO it may well cause a shortage crisis. So it’s not “simple” unless you ignore the (possible) knock on effects, which you’re clearly happy to do.

I personally don’t think it’ll stop at care workers, but time will tell. My guess is Nhs next, then other jobs after.

In terms of your last point, as I’ve said they’d all agree in respect of many diseases, and are pro vax in general. They just don’t want this one at present, and that’s their business. Flu has not been eradicated… yet Ive never heard anyone say this about the flu vaccine. No one has ever blinked an eye or cared if others haven’t had it. Covid isn’t flu, I’m well aware, but the fact remains if more had been flu jabbed every year, there’s be less flu deaths. Yet there’s never been coercion like this, never been abuse of people not wanting it, never been a label attached to them etc etc….

And your final point… presuming they aren’t having it due to someone on social media. You’ve pigeonholed them. That’s not the reason. They just have a different opinion to you on their own body. But you’ve demonstrated perfectly my point about division, and lumping people into groups. You could not have illustrated it better, removing all nuance. Yep, they must be getting their opinion off Facebook! Obviously! (Shakes head)

I don’t respect their opinion i can’t be more honest than that. I can do nuanced arguments and be very liberal about this and go on about their civil liberties and rights but I’m bored of those banging the drum for putting their rights above those of the genuinely vulnerable. I will never agree with you on this as this is not a hypothetical argument for people I know.
Reply
#49
(10-04-2021, 06:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 05:40 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 05:17 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 04:55 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 04:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote: What makes you think that isn't effective at reducing transmission?

Just going on the pure number of jabbed people catching Covid. I know 3 households where one of the members caught Covid and then within a few days the rest of the family caught it too. These weren't old people who may have waning immunity either. 

As I said previously with waning immunity, length of time from when jabbed, strength of individuals immune system etc it is hard to determine just how effective the jabs are. 

The fact that boosters are already required only 6 months after the second jab tells it own story surely.

People who are jabbed will still run the chance of getting covid, the jab just reduces the chance of them getting it. That's got nothing to do with transmission - if someone in your vicinity gets covid and you are exposed to it then you will likely get it, the symptoms will likely be reduced from they would be if you hadn't had the jab but that's it.

It's hard to determine how effective the jabs are because it is so new, nothing else. And of course we will have waning immunity, its a jab not a shield for life in the same way that we have flu vaccine boosters.

So basically you just have a feeling that it isn't effective at reducing transmission, there's nothing to back that up.
Isn't that what transmission is?

And we don't have flu vaccine boosters. We have a different flu vaccine each year for different strains not the same one as the year before.

The key word is 'reduced'. The vaccine will reduce the likelihood of transmission, it won't remove transmission, so people who get transmitted covid will possibly transmit the virus, but that is reduced because 1stly they may be immune to it from the vaccine and therefore not transmit it at all, or 2ndly they may not have as many symptoms that mean it will be transmitted. For instance they may not cough as much and therefore don't expel as much of the virus as someone who coughs, which logically means they won't transmit it as much (reduced transmission).

And they tweak the flu vaccine, they don't replace it each year and start again.

Yes that is correct- to be a better match for the most likely strain they expect to be prevalent. Have they tweaked the Covid booster or is it still aimed at the Alpha?

(10-04-2021, 08:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 07:33 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 07:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 07:09 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 06:44 PM)coxy134 Wrote: If someone does not want to have the vaccine an antivaxxer or someone who simply does not want it?

Indeed. A point I made many months ago over on the politics board. Unfortunately, as so often happens, the term anti vaxxer has now been framed into a phrase to lump people into one group. Divide and conquer.

I know a lot who have not had the covid vaccine. Literally none are anti vax in general. All have different reasons for not wanting it. All have had previous vaccines in their life. Many just wish to wait a bit with this one for a bit more long term data, or feel they are low risk of covid, or have had a relative who has had a bad reaction and are genuinely worried, or wish to wait and see how its going to work long term (eg annual boosters), or many other reasons. But they are pigeonholed into being "anti vax".

The media and government has tried to ensure that we're pigeonholed into two groups. Vax or anti vax. No nuance, no understanding that people have different views and that bodily autonomy is a very personal thing. Personally I don't think its anyone's business and would never pressure them to have it.

I feared this division would happen, and I am convinced its going to get a lot worse. Wait til the domestic vaccine passports come in (which they will, Plan B my ass - its Plan A really), there'll be even bigger divisions and bigger problems then IMO.

What are they waiting to see? Don’t have the vaccine don’t work with the vulnerable… simple. If previous generations had been so reluctant to have jabs many diseases would now be still rife within the community.

Waiting to see any long term effects. Other pharmaceuticals have been withdrawn further down the line so it’s hardly bonkers. It’s their opinion.

In terms of sacking care workers, that’s a different point. But IMO it may well cause a shortage crisis. So it’s not “simple” unless you ignore the (possible) knock on effects, which you’re clearly happy to do.

I personally don’t think it’ll stop at care workers, but time will tell. My guess is Nhs next, then other jobs after.

In terms of your last point, as I’ve said they’d all agree in respect of many diseases, and are pro vax in general. They just don’t want this one at present, and that’s their business. Flu has not been eradicated… yet Ive never heard anyone say this about the flu vaccine. No one has ever blinked an eye or cared if others haven’t had it. Covid isn’t flu, I’m well aware, but the fact remains if more had been flu jabbed every year, there’s be less flu deaths. Yet there’s never been coercion like this, never been abuse of people not wanting it, never been a label attached to them etc etc….

And your final point… presuming they aren’t having it due to someone on social media. You’ve pigeonholed them. That’s not the reason. They just have a different opinion to you on their own body. But you’ve demonstrated perfectly my point about division, and lumping people into groups. You could not have illustrated it better, removing all nuance. Yep, they must be getting their opinion off Facebook! Obviously! (Shakes head)

I don’t respect their opinion i can’t be more honest than that. I can do nuanced arguments and be very liberal about this and go on about their civil liberties and rights but I’m bored of those banging the drum for putting their rights above those of the genuinely vulnerable. I will never agree with you on this as this is not a hypothetical argument for people I know.

And therein lies the crux of the matter. Never mind social media - you are reaching your view on what you personally experience or the experience of people you actually know  And for others the ongoing adverse reactions from the first jab is not hypothetical either yet they are thrown in the social media anti vaxxer demographic. And expected to run the risk of worse reactions still if they wish to engage in parts of society once Plan B kicks into gear. 

Ask yourself this - so far 49 million have had a jab but only 45 million second jabs so far and yet everyone should have been double jabbed by now apart from the kids. That gap will close but I would bet there will be around a million that only take one jab. Why is that? Surely they can't be anti vaxxers otherwise they would not have had one jab so tell me why they won't have the second. Are they just idiots willingly restricting their own movements or is there another reason?
Reply
#50
(10-04-2021, 08:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 07:33 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 07:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 07:09 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 06:44 PM)coxy134 Wrote: If someone does not want to have the vaccine an antivaxxer or someone who simply does not want it?

Indeed. A point I made many months ago over on the politics board. Unfortunately, as so often happens, the term anti vaxxer has now been framed into a phrase to lump people into one group. Divide and conquer.

I know a lot who have not had the covid vaccine. Literally none are anti vax in general. All have different reasons for not wanting it. All have had previous vaccines in their life. Many just wish to wait a bit with this one for a bit more long term data, or feel they are low risk of covid, or have had a relative who has had a bad reaction and are genuinely worried, or wish to wait and see how its going to work long term (eg annual boosters), or many other reasons. But they are pigeonholed into being "anti vax".

The media and government has tried to ensure that we're pigeonholed into two groups. Vax or anti vax. No nuance, no understanding that people have different views and that bodily autonomy is a very personal thing. Personally I don't think its anyone's business and would never pressure them to have it.

I feared this division would happen, and I am convinced its going to get a lot worse. Wait til the domestic vaccine passports come in (which they will, Plan B my ass - its Plan A really), there'll be even bigger divisions and bigger problems then IMO.

What are they waiting to see? Don’t have the vaccine don’t work with the vulnerable… simple. If previous generations had been so reluctant to have jabs many diseases would now be still rife within the community.

Waiting to see any long term effects. Other pharmaceuticals have been withdrawn further down the line so it’s hardly bonkers. It’s their opinion.

In terms of sacking care workers, that’s a different point. But IMO it may well cause a shortage crisis. So it’s not “simple” unless you ignore the (possible) knock on effects, which you’re clearly happy to do.

I personally don’t think it’ll stop at care workers, but time will tell. My guess is Nhs next, then other jobs after.

In terms of your last point, as I’ve said they’d all agree in respect of many diseases, and are pro vax in general. They just don’t want this one at present, and that’s their business. Flu has not been eradicated… yet Ive never heard anyone say this about the flu vaccine. No one has ever blinked an eye or cared if others haven’t had it. Covid isn’t flu, I’m well aware, but the fact remains if more had been flu jabbed every year, there’s be less flu deaths. Yet there’s never been coercion like this, never been abuse of people not wanting it, never been a label attached to them etc etc….

And your final point… presuming they aren’t having it due to someone on social media. You’ve pigeonholed them. That’s not the reason. They just have a different opinion to you on their own body. But you’ve demonstrated perfectly my point about division, and lumping people into groups. You could not have illustrated it better, removing all nuance. Yep, they must be getting their opinion off Facebook! Obviously! (Shakes head)

I don’t respect their opinion i can’t be more honest than that. I can do nuanced arguments and be very liberal about this and go on about their civil liberties and rights but I’m bored of those banging the drum for putting their rights above those of the genuinely vulnerable. I will never agree with you on this as this is not a hypothetical argument for people I know.

And they’re probably bored of being called anti vaxxers and being told they’re making their decision based on Facebook. They’re probably bored of people giving your argument about the vulnerable while wondering why this was never ever done before regarding influenza, as no one has ever been accused of putting their rights above the vulnerable, despite influenza killing thousands each year. And I doubt they respect your opinion either. So people being bored of each other isn’t really relevant.

Me? I’m bored of the division created. In fact I’m not bored, I’m genuinely concerned.

I know you won’t agree, and nor will you ever be able to come up with a solution when it comes to possible shortages of staff in care sectors. Then it’ll be the nhs…. Imagine sacking healthcare workers in a pandemic, that wouldn’t be possible would it? Yes if they’re “anti vaxxers”, sack them, selfish bastards!! Selfish bastards that were on the front line with no proper PPE and didn’t complain once. Looking after the elderly and vulnerable as covid raced through the care homes and hospitals. They got on with it and were at the front end of risk, while the middle classes sat at home on their computers loving the fact they hadn’t got to commute to fucking work. Now many of those same people are cheering on sacking those care staff if they don’t make the same decision on a vaccine? Gross, it turns my stomach to be honest. I’m one of the lucky ones who could also sit at home on my computer working, but I’m quite disgusted with the division being stirred up when it comes to this. The government and media have encouraged it, and IMO huge numbers have fallen for it. It’s horrible.

(10-04-2021, 08:46 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 06:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 05:40 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 05:17 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 04:55 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: Just going on the pure number of jabbed people catching Covid. I know 3 households where one of the members caught Covid and then within a few days the rest of the family caught it too. These weren't old people who may have waning immunity either. 

As I said previously with waning immunity, length of time from when jabbed, strength of individuals immune system etc it is hard to determine just how effective the jabs are. 

The fact that boosters are already required only 6 months after the second jab tells it own story surely.

People who are jabbed will still run the chance of getting covid, the jab just reduces the chance of them getting it. That's got nothing to do with transmission - if someone in your vicinity gets covid and you are exposed to it then you will likely get it, the symptoms will likely be reduced from they would be if you hadn't had the jab but that's it.

It's hard to determine how effective the jabs are because it is so new, nothing else. And of course we will have waning immunity, its a jab not a shield for life in the same way that we have flu vaccine boosters.

So basically you just have a feeling that it isn't effective at reducing transmission, there's nothing to back that up.
Isn't that what transmission is?

And we don't have flu vaccine boosters. We have a different flu vaccine each year for different strains not the same one as the year before.

The key word is 'reduced'. The vaccine will reduce the likelihood of transmission, it won't remove transmission, so people who get transmitted covid will possibly transmit the virus, but that is reduced because 1stly they may be immune to it from the vaccine and therefore not transmit it at all, or 2ndly they may not have as many symptoms that mean it will be transmitted. For instance they may not cough as much and therefore don't expel as much of the virus as someone who coughs, which logically means they won't transmit it as much (reduced transmission).

And they tweak the flu vaccine, they don't replace it each year and start again.

Yes that is correct- to be a better match for the most likely strain they expect to be prevalent. Have they tweaked the Covid booster or is it still aimed at the Alpha?

(10-04-2021, 08:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 07:33 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 07:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-04-2021, 07:09 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Indeed. A point I made many months ago over on the politics board. Unfortunately, as so often happens, the term anti vaxxer has now been framed into a phrase to lump people into one group. Divide and conquer.

I know a lot who have not had the covid vaccine. Literally none are anti vax in general. All have different reasons for not wanting it. All have had previous vaccines in their life. Many just wish to wait a bit with this one for a bit more long term data, or feel they are low risk of covid, or have had a relative who has had a bad reaction and are genuinely worried, or wish to wait and see how its going to work long term (eg annual boosters), or many other reasons. But they are pigeonholed into being "anti vax".

The media and government has tried to ensure that we're pigeonholed into two groups. Vax or anti vax. No nuance, no understanding that people have different views and that bodily autonomy is a very personal thing. Personally I don't think its anyone's business and would never pressure them to have it.

I feared this division would happen, and I am convinced its going to get a lot worse. Wait til the domestic vaccine passports come in (which they will, Plan B my ass - its Plan A really), there'll be even bigger divisions and bigger problems then IMO.

What are they waiting to see? Don’t have the vaccine don’t work with the vulnerable… simple. If previous generations had been so reluctant to have jabs many diseases would now be still rife within the community.

Waiting to see any long term effects. Other pharmaceuticals have been withdrawn further down the line so it’s hardly bonkers. It’s their opinion.

In terms of sacking care workers, that’s a different point. But IMO it may well cause a shortage crisis. So it’s not “simple” unless you ignore the (possible) knock on effects, which you’re clearly happy to do.

I personally don’t think it’ll stop at care workers, but time will tell. My guess is Nhs next, then other jobs after.

In terms of your last point, as I’ve said they’d all agree in respect of many diseases, and are pro vax in general. They just don’t want this one at present, and that’s their business. Flu has not been eradicated… yet Ive never heard anyone say this about the flu vaccine. No one has ever blinked an eye or cared if others haven’t had it. Covid isn’t flu, I’m well aware, but the fact remains if more had been flu jabbed every year, there’s be less flu deaths. Yet there’s never been coercion like this, never been abuse of people not wanting it, never been a label attached to them etc etc….

And your final point… presuming they aren’t having it due to someone on social media. You’ve pigeonholed them. That’s not the reason. They just have a different opinion to you on their own body. But you’ve demonstrated perfectly my point about division, and lumping people into groups. You could not have illustrated it better, removing all nuance. Yep, they must be getting their opinion off Facebook! Obviously! (Shakes head)

I don’t respect their opinion i can’t be more honest than that. I can do nuanced arguments and be very liberal about this and go on about their civil liberties and rights but I’m bored of those banging the drum for putting their rights above those of the genuinely vulnerable. I will never agree with you on this as this is not a hypothetical argument for people I know.

And therein lies the crux of the matter. Never mind social media - you are reaching your view on what you personally experience or the experience of people you actually know  And for others the ongoing adverse reactions from the first jab is not hypothetical either yet they are thrown in the social media anti vaxxer demographic. And expected to run the risk of worse reactions still if they wish to engage in parts of society once Plan B kicks into gear. 

Ask yourself this - so far 49 million have had a jab but only 45 million second jabs so far and yet everyone should have been double jabbed by now apart from the kids. That gap will close but I would bet there will be around a million that only take one jab. Why is that? Surely they can't be anti vaxxers otherwise they would not have had one jab so tell me why they won't have the second. Are they just idiots willingly restricting their own movements or is there another reason?

Give it 8 months and the triple vaccinated will be slagging off the double jabbed and calling them anti vaxxers and blaming them for the 5th wave. It’ll come.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)