Silwood
#71
(10-02-2021, 07:43 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-01-2021, 10:11 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Sotv isn't racist.

I can see his point,even if I don't totally agree. But racist je isn't.

The scene that Pindgill describes, and some of Fuzzboxes experiences is what I always thought racism is/was. There is absolutely no place in Society for that, or what Silwood did.

There are too many people in society looking to be offended though, not only by race, but for anything.

I take offence to that.
Reply
#72
(10-01-2021, 04:17 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(09-30-2021, 06:20 PM)Sotv Wrote: Ridiculous sentence. Whilst what he said was offensive and undeniably racist, this is a huge over reaction and I think we all know why.
Let's look at the facts.
He made a.comment that did not incite any violence or a further commissioning of crime.
He did not stalk or directly harass Sawyers. The comment was made on a Facebook group, in fact if the police hadn't shown it to Sawyers chances are he wouldn't have seen it.
So what we have here is a man jailed for 2 months for the crime of calling someone names.
If we allow people to be jailed for nothing more than saying things that make others uncomfortable or are deemed offensive, where do we stop?
As far as I am concerned people should be free under the law to say what they like as long as this doesn't encourage violence. That should go for the likes of Louis Farrakhan, Paul Golding or anyone else. If someone else doesn't like it they are free to argue their case as well. 
Allowing the state to dictate what is and isn't offensive or permitted speech and jailing people for transgressions of this is the road to dictatorship. You only need to see how China uses these laws to understand where this ends up.
The notion we have a good deal of people so whipped up into their own right on frenzy of disgust by the media game that they are cheering on this erosion of a basic liberty is frightening.

I recall as an 8 year playing hopscotch out side our shop on the Dudley Road Winson Green in the late 60s with my brothers sisters neighbours kids who were black & next door shops kids who were white it was 
after Enoch’s “Rivers of blood” speech the NF were marching in Birmingham in support of him.
Number of coaches packed with grown men attending as they slowed down due to traffic outside our shop banged there windows to get our attention they had monkey masks on and were pointing at us and any other person who was not white even as kids we knew they were abusing us!!!…
Sotv your argument is totally ignorant and offensive citing freedom of speech re obvious racism!!…educate your single brain cell Angry
Sotv - IMHO you are an ignorant little twat who really can't see anything beyond your own little cocoon (no offence intended) as a defender of people's rights to express their thoughts no matter how offensive. And if they get bought to book the nastiness of their penned thoughts and opinions should not lead to custodial time as no threat was made to injure or pursue. So stick your opinions where the sun don't shine ... is it alright to call you a little s**t? No harm no foul.
Reply
#73
(10-02-2021, 07:43 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-01-2021, 10:11 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Sotv isn't racist.

I can see his point,even if I don't totally agree. But racist je isn't.

The scene that Pindgill describes, and some of Fuzzboxes experiences is what I always thought racism is/was. There is absolutely no place in Society for that, or what Silwood did.

There are too many people in society looking to be offended though, not only by race, but for anything.

Agree entirely with all this. 

I knew SOTV was on dodgy ground with his response, but got the point of where he’s coming from with his societal standpoint. However, the sheer venom directed to him is something akin to him talking about Sarah Everard and saying he thought Wayne Couzens should have been given no more than community service and we should learn from the Taliban about respecting women.

Racism is horrible and has to be tackled properly with everyone involved. As a white guy of Irish stock I recall some of the stuff I endured as a kid about the thick paddy stuff, the post Bham bombings crap, but the Irish got through it and aren’t even looked at as foreign now. That’s a world different because of white privilege, which does exist. 

I’ve a couple of close friends who aren’t white and we’ve spoken about their experiences in a very candid way. Hearing their stories has made me wince and have been an eye opener. 

However, the level of utter outrage towards SOTV by some I’ve found due to a general inability for people to discuss differences of opinion now. We can all overstep the mark and I had an angry spat with SOTV on Brexit only this week, but have jumped to his defence this time as I’d rather still learn from those who think differently. That’s why I defend him now.

We seem a very angry society and it’s down to a refusal to engage with those you disagree with. It’s why so many don’t enter debate, but instead mutter to likeminded and become more extreme. It’s why America got Trump and to much a lesser degree why we got Brexit.
Reply
#74
Singling someone out for the colour of their skin, their disability or sexual orientation as long as it doesn’t incite violence whilst hiding behind freedom of speech defence is not acceptable in a civilised society. Why anyone would go out of their way to challenge this point of view is puzzling. At some point the right to offend does have consequences where that line is drawn has to be written into law otherwise you end up condoning without recourse bullying, harassment and abuse.
Reply
#75
Maybe I'm being cynical, but I suspect Silwood was probably egged on by his 'mates' from his far right boards. They were probably advising that he could get away with it and poke the courts and the evil woke brigade in the eye. What he may not of realised was they wanted him in prison to provoke exactly this sort of response. A sort of sadder, scruffier 'Rosa Parks' scenario.
Reply
#76
(10-02-2021, 08:41 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Singling someone out for the colour of their skin, their disability or sexual orientation as long as it doesn’t incite violence whilst hiding behind freedom of speech defence is not acceptable in a civilised society. Why anyone would go out of their way to challenge this point of view is puzzling. At some point the right to offend does have consequences where that line is drawn has to be written into law otherwise you end up condoning without recourse bullying, harassment and abuse.

I think the main thrust of his argument was about the sentence and what people might be sent down for in the future. I don't think at any point did he really say that it was acceptable and people should just get on with it. Extra hours of community service should have been given for the stupidity of the "autocorrect" if anything.

A recent-ish example is categorising Irish travellers as a race when they are really just people living a particular way of life. However, that is now law that they can't be discriminated against and you can face legal proceeding if you bar them from your pub, for example, even though many of their habits are at the very least questionable.
Reply
#77
(10-02-2021, 08:41 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Singling someone out for the colour of their skin, their disability or sexual orientation as long as it doesn’t incite violence whilst hiding behind freedom of speech defence is not acceptable in a civilised society. Why anyone would go out of their way to challenge this point of view is puzzling. At some point the right to offend does have consequences where that line is drawn has to be written into law otherwise you end up condoning without recourse bullying, harassment and abuse.

But at what point should it draw legal consequences? Look at the case of the Nottingham airport tweets, or the Harry Miller case in which the high court ruled police actions had a "chilling effect on freedom of speech". It should be possible to discuss this without the floods of invective SOTV has faced. You might say those cases don't involve racism, but the concept of what it is offensive has spread very widely and police advice often isn't very helpful:

https://youtu.be/f4JYHEzb0S8
Reply
#78
(10-02-2021, 08:41 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Singling someone out for the colour of their skin, their disability or sexual orientation as long as it doesn’t incite violence whilst hiding behind freedom of speech defence is not acceptable in a civilised society. Why anyone would go out of their way to challenge this point of view is puzzling. At some point the right to offend does have consequences where that line is drawn has to be written into law otherwise you end up condoning without recourse bullying, harassment and abuse.

Again a great point, which goes above the heads of most on here.

The sotv cunt hasn't answered the question that the Griffiths motto of  "vote labour have nigger for a neighbour" and the bastards who who called our 3 degrees disgusting names should be allowed to do it and then walk out the ground untroubled by the law as it didn't incite violence.

Absolute bollox.

The prick should read books like pitch black and paul cannonville and see what this non violence racism does to the victim.

This sticks and stones bollox is totally wrong and when someone says they were alarmed and distressed like RS said he was, to reach the prosecuting threshold that should be sufficient in a modern society to prosecute, not this racist shit being peddled by this so called Albion fan defending a racist with the old mantra I may not agree with what he says but I will defend his right to say to the death that you used to hear.
Reply
#79
(10-02-2021, 11:41 AM)Squid Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 08:41 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Singling someone out for the colour of their skin, their disability or sexual orientation as long as it doesn’t incite violence whilst hiding behind freedom of speech defence is not acceptable in a civilised society. Why anyone would go out of their way to challenge this point of view is puzzling. At some point the right to offend does have consequences where that line is drawn has to be written into law otherwise you end up condoning without recourse bullying, harassment and abuse.

But at what point should it draw legal consequences? Look at the case of the Nottingham airport tweets, or the Harry Miller case in which the high court ruled police actions had a "chilling effect on freedom of speech". It should be possible to discuss this without the floods of invective SOTV has faced. You might say those cases don't involve racism, but the concept of what it is offensive has spread very widely and police advice often isn't very helpful:

https://youtu.be/f4JYHEzb0S8

I don’t know those cases but my opinion has been consistent throughout the thread. There has to be a line where the law steps in otherwise you will empower people to glibly use racist, homophobic and derogatory terms for the disabled. The government and those within the law set what boundaries they are. If don’t have that deterrent then it’s a free for all and some will not be in a position to argue back and the question should be why they should have to. I do see the dangers of shutting down debate around religion, culture etc but that is not the same as using offensive terms that are solely about someone’s race, ability and sexuality. 

I am all for the right to offend and be offended with regards to choices people make. I think Brexit is an awful idea for example and may have said so on occasion Wink. That is criticising a choice. There is a difference. Whether the law has the balance right is open to debate but I’d rather defend those on the receiving end of mindless racism, homophobia etc than those who went out their way to offend.
Reply
#80
(10-02-2021, 12:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 11:41 AM)Squid Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 08:41 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Singling someone out for the colour of their skin, their disability or sexual orientation as long as it doesn’t incite violence whilst hiding behind freedom of speech defence is not acceptable in a civilised society. Why anyone would go out of their way to challenge this point of view is puzzling. At some point the right to offend does have consequences where that line is drawn has to be written into law otherwise you end up condoning without recourse bullying, harassment and abuse.

But at what point should it draw legal consequences? Look at the case of the Nottingham airport tweets, or the Harry Miller case in which the high court ruled police actions had a "chilling effect on freedom of speech". It should be possible to discuss this without the floods of invective SOTV has faced. You might say those cases don't involve racism, but the concept of what it is offensive has spread very widely and police advice often isn't very helpful:

https://youtu.be/f4JYHEzb0S8

I don’t know those cases but my opinion has been consistent throughout the thread. There has to be a line where the law steps in otherwise you will empower people to glibly use racist, homophobic and derogatory terms for the disabled. The government and those within the law set what boundaries they are. If don’t have that deterrent then it’s a free for all and some will not be in a position to argue back and the question should be why they should have to. I do see the dangers of shutting down debate around religion, culture etc but that is not the same as using offensive terms that are solely about someone’s race, ability and sexuality. 

I am all for the right to offend and be offended with regards to choices people make. I think Brexit is an awful idea for example and may have said so on occasion Wink. That is criticising a choice. There is a difference. Whether the law has the balance right is open to debate but I’d rather defend those on the receiving end of mindless racism, homophobia etc than those who went out their way to offend.
Exactly, I am pro European and anti brexit but we lost the vote, end of.

Do I now get any satisfaction from the shit show unfolding all around us and going cap in hand for foreign workers? No, because we will all suffer the same.

This turn the other cheek free speech for racists is taking us back to the dark ages, when it is bad enough now they way it is, as seen with the abuse given to the 3 black players who missed pens for England in the final.

The worse thing a society can do is not protect its vulnerable citizens, as where do you draw the line.

Is it ok to spread child pornography to other paedos as long it doesn't incite violence?

There used to actual groups in the 70's advocating the lowering of the age of consent and paedophilia, until laws were enacted.

The laws are there for a reason, anyone arguing against them has there own agenda imo.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)