Villa accounts
(03-06-2019, 09:02 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-06-2019, 08:44 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-06-2019, 08:22 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-06-2019, 06:36 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Accounts now online.  Very hard to make sense of them because of the way they’ve split things between the various companies, but wage bill up £12m to £73m!

I haven't the time to look at the accounts properly, but £73M of wages is 107% of turnover.

The key is within the Strategic Report, which says that "The Directors are actively seeking to implement actions to avoid future breaches of FFP rules, and the Directors believe they will remain compliant with EFL P&S regulations for the 2018/19 season".

This tells me that they have either a loophole, or there will be a fire sale. No mention of special dispensation, and they can't hope to achieve compliance with their previous losses, and losses this year. There is also the possibility of a rule change, which they are allegedly pushing for tomorrow at the EFL monthly meeting, or a revaluation of Seal City given it's asset value in the sale to Xia was less than it's book value.

A couple of quick points, in addition to Pragmatists thoughts - The new owners have repaid almost £70M of debt, and have committed to future support of the club. They do now have deep pockets. They invested almost £12M in youth and community schemes - this is excluded from P&S calculations, so can be added back. These losses are after a £40M parachute. The club only generates c£25M without the parachute. You can expect a massive gap in their forecasts that are about to be presented in March for this season and into next season now the parachutes have all but disappeared. They have not revalued the ground within these statements, either. Their squad will have to be very different next year if they don't fluke the play-offs.

Finally a cautionary note - we are going to have similar issues in 2 years time if we don't escape. Our wage bill is also unsustainable without the parachutes. I don't think we will breach FFP because we haven't spunked money beyond our means, but we can't sign players with contracts that extend beyond the parachute. I think we will see more loan players next year rather than signings if we push again to return to The Prem.

A fire sale isn’t possible to deal with 2018/9 losses.  Their year end is 31st May and they can’t sell any players before the new transfer window opens after year, so nothing they do on the player sale front can have any impact on the 2018/9 figures.  They could, however, sell or revalue the ground (or training ground) before 31st May.

With 2018/9 being the third and final year of parachute payments, and it being c£25m lower than in 2017/8, their figures for 2018/9 can only be a lot worse than 2017/8 and their wage bill won’t be too much different. And of course their 2018/9 figures will be the 2nd year of the next 3-year FFP cycle, as well as being the first year of the subsequent 3-year cycle.  They are likely to actually have to make a sizeable PROFIT in 2019/20 and 2020/21 to stay within FFP, never mind containing losses.   A huge fire sale of the squad is totally unavoidable, and they can only sell their property assets once.

It's been suggested they will re-value the assets rather than sell, Prag.

If you look back, it's not dis-similar to Blues. They bust FFP with the March 2018 forecasts (as did a few other clubs). The first action was soft embargo, whilst the club offloaded assets. Blues stuck two fingers up and signed Pedersen, which has seen the well documented issues. 

I personally think that signing the keeper in January, and the sale/loan back of the full back was in anticipation of what might be coming. I think if they sell a couple of players at the end of the season, they may well achieve forbearance of the league, as I think Sheff Wednesday did. 

What is clear is that they can't correct the historic problems overnight - but this season they have shown no signs of cutting their major overhead which is wages. This is what I think will cause the EFL to censure them. As you correctly state, they would have to make a massive profit to correct matters on the 3 year cycle, but I think EFL will as a minimum want to see them achieve a 12 month plan of £13M losses (including the required equity injection), and they will be nowhere near this. They would have to roughly halve the wage bill to get even close.

Totally agree. Their actions since the summer don’t seem to be indicating that they’ve taken it seriously enough.  My guess is that they banked in selling Grealish in January and his injury killed that option. A said for c£20m+ would have made a massive FFP difference.
Reply
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/47468115
Reply
(03-06-2019, 09:20 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-06-2019, 09:02 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-06-2019, 08:44 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-06-2019, 08:22 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-06-2019, 06:36 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Accounts now online.  Very hard to make sense of them because of the way they’ve split things between the various companies, but wage bill up £12m to £73m!

I haven't the time to look at the accounts properly, but £73M of wages is 107% of turnover.

The key is within the Strategic Report, which says that "The Directors are actively seeking to implement actions to avoid future breaches of FFP rules, and the Directors believe they will remain compliant with EFL P&S regulations for the 2018/19 season".

This tells me that they have either a loophole, or there will be a fire sale. No mention of special dispensation, and they can't hope to achieve compliance with their previous losses, and losses this year. There is also the possibility of a rule change, which they are allegedly pushing for tomorrow at the EFL monthly meeting, or a revaluation of Seal City given it's asset value in the sale to Xia was less than it's book value.

A couple of quick points, in addition to Pragmatists thoughts - The new owners have repaid almost £70M of debt, and have committed to future support of the club. They do now have deep pockets. They invested almost £12M in youth and community schemes - this is excluded from P&S calculations, so can be added back. These losses are after a £40M parachute. The club only generates c£25M without the parachute. You can expect a massive gap in their forecasts that are about to be presented in March for this season and into next season now the parachutes have all but disappeared. They have not revalued the ground within these statements, either. Their squad will have to be very different next year if they don't fluke the play-offs.

Finally a cautionary note - we are going to have similar issues in 2 years time if we don't escape. Our wage bill is also unsustainable without the parachutes. I don't think we will breach FFP because we haven't spunked money beyond our means, but we can't sign players with contracts that extend beyond the parachute. I think we will see more loan players next year rather than signings if we push again to return to The Prem.

A fire sale isn’t possible to deal with 2018/9 losses.  Their year end is 31st May and they can’t sell any players before the new transfer window opens after year, so nothing they do on the player sale front can have any impact on the 2018/9 figures.  They could, however, sell or revalue the ground (or training ground) before 31st May.

With 2018/9 being the third and final year of parachute payments, and it being c£25m lower than in 2017/8, their figures for 2018/9 can only be a lot worse than 2017/8 and their wage bill won’t be too much different. And of course their 2018/9 figures will be the 2nd year of the next 3-year FFP cycle, as well as being the first year of the subsequent 3-year cycle.  They are likely to actually have to make a sizeable PROFIT in 2019/20 and 2020/21 to stay within FFP, never mind containing losses.   A huge fire sale of the squad is totally unavoidable, and they can only sell their property assets once.

It's been suggested they will re-value the assets rather than sell, Prag.

If you look back, it's not dis-similar to Blues. They bust FFP with the March 2018 forecasts (as did a few other clubs). The first action was soft embargo, whilst the club offloaded assets. Blues stuck two fingers up and signed Pedersen, which has seen the well documented issues. 

I personally think that signing the keeper in January, and the sale/loan back of the full back was in anticipation of what might be coming. I think if they sell a couple of players at the end of the season, they may well achieve forbearance of the league, as I think Sheff Wednesday did. 

What is clear is that they can't correct the historic problems overnight - but this season they have shown no signs of cutting their major overhead which is wages. This is what I think will cause the EFL to censure them. As you correctly state, they would have to make a massive profit to correct matters on the 3 year cycle, but I think EFL will as a minimum want to see them achieve a 12 month plan of £13M losses (including the required equity injection), and they will be nowhere near this. They would have to roughly halve the wage bill to get even close.

Totally agree. Their actions since the summer don’t seem to be indicating that they’ve taken it seriously enough.  My guess is that they banked in selling Grealish in January and his injury killed that option. A said for c£20m+ would have made a massive FFP difference.

You can't see anything other than a Grealish sale balancing the books. In terms of other saleable assets, McGinn has a value, the rest is bobbins. Grealish could be next the next Alex Cropley ( I hope not for his sake) and be worthless. 

Interesting times ahead, but you just get the feeling that they will somehow come out smelling of roses.
Reply
They've been on a downward spiral for nearly a decade now - will it ever end? These reports are not good news in anyway.
Reply
(03-06-2019, 11:17 AM)MGalea Wrote: They've been on a downward spiral for nearly a decade now - will it ever end?  These reports are not good news in anyway.

Depends on which club you support  Big Grin
Reply
Deep pockets or not you do have to wonder why the fuck Sawiris and Edens wanted in at Villa. I'm sure there's a decent upside if Villa do eventually go up but looking at what they've already ploughed in (£68m to cover losses, £12m on youth development etc) and looking at the fact they are going to have to slash their wage bill one would assume they ain't going to go up next season.

By the time they do go up, say in 3 or 4 years time will the outlay at that point be retrievable? They'll be in for the tune of £300m by that time I'd imagine.

This is a tough old division to get out of and next season there will be 3 freshly relegated clubs with nice fat bank balances, having a proper roll of the dice again, to contend with.

I'd love to see them hit hard but in any case they ain't going anywhere anytime soon imo. Rich owners or not.
Reply
They probably "wanted in at Villa" because they think they can get them promoted to the Premier League. That would guarantee £250 million
Reply
(03-07-2019, 07:17 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: They probably "wanted in at Villa" because they think they can get them promoted to the Premier League. That would guarantee £250 million

250m that you then have to pay straight back out....
Reply
(03-07-2019, 07:19 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 07:17 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: They probably "wanted in at Villa" because they think they can get them promoted to the Premier League. That would guarantee £250 million

250m that you then have to pay straight back out....

I was just about to post that.  The money goes to the club, not to the owners, and the money gets paid out in transfer fees, wages, agent fees and compensation to sacked managers.  There’s nothing left for shareholders so I can’t see them ever getting their money back.

This point comes up quite a lot. “You need to be in the Premier League to access the money”.  From a supporter’s perspective and from (most) shareholders’ perspectives, the money is a myth. It all evaporated into others’ pockets.
Reply
(03-07-2019, 07:32 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 07:19 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote:
(03-07-2019, 07:17 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: They probably "wanted in at Villa" because they think they can get them promoted to the Premier League. That would guarantee £250 million

250m that you then have to pay straight back out....

I was just about to post that.  The money goes to the club, not to the owners, and the money gets paid out in transfer fees, wages, agent fees and compensation to sacked managers.  There’s nothing left for shareholders so I can’t see them ever getting their money back.

This point comes up quite a lot. “You need to be in the Premier League to access the money”.  From a supporter’s perspective and from (most) shareholders’ perspectives, the money is a myth. It all evaporated into others’ pockets.

This was my point. I can only assume that given the dire financial shit they were in under Xia that they bought the club for peanuts and think if they turn it around quickly and establish it as a premier league force they can sell for a handsome profit down the line.

I just can't see it happening in the time frame they do. They will be so far out of pocket when/if that time comes that any sale would come to nowhere near their outlay.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)