Pensions
#51
Why I made a point of successive governments, not aiming at any party, both Labour and Conservative have proven to be awful choices for governing the country.
Reply
#52
Birdman1811 Wrote:Why I made a point of successive governments, not aiming at any party, both Labour and Conservative have proven to be awful choices for governing the country.

I don't disagree entirely but; In the election of 2010 (I think), I had an interest in a small business which was staffed by 3 workers, all from the wrong side of the tracks and most definitely they were products of their environment. Kids, absent partners, problems AOTS. They all did a decent job for us though and were good to socialise with too. Not one of them voted. I pointed out, one party was not perfect but had instigated the working tax credits that they needed to be able to continue to work part time. The other main party was for an austerity project that would almost certainly be to their detriment. The reply was "Nah, they're all the same".
There was a huge difference in the two leading parties yet people still decided not to see it.
Reply
#53
(09-09-2021, 06:42 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Birdman1811 Wrote:Why I made a point of successive governments, not aiming at any party, both Labour and Conservative have proven to be awful choices for governing the country.

I don't disagree entirely but; In the election of 2010 (I think), I had an interest in a small business which was staffed by 3 workers, all from the wrong side of the tracks and most definitely they were products of their environment. Kids, absent partners, problems AOTS. They all did a decent job for us though and were good to socialise with too. Not one of them voted. I pointed out, one party was not perfect but had instigated the working tax credits that they needed to be able to continue to work part time. The other main party was for an austerity project that would almost certainly be to their detriment. The reply was "Nah, they're all the same".
There was a huge difference in the two leading parties yet people still decided not to see it.

Sadly that's a too familiar story. No party connects well with the young and disenfranchised.
Reply
#54
(09-09-2021, 06:42 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: There was a huge difference in the two leading parties yet people still decided not to see it.

That's not quite true is it?

Both parties came to the 2010 election on a pro-austerity platform. THe major difference at the time was that the Tories pledged to protect the NHS (peace be upon it) budget, whereas Brown didn't. IIRC you really couldn't get a cigarette paper between the parties on economic policy in 2010.
Reply
#55
The extent of public sector cuts made under the coalition were in line with the 2010 Labour manifesto. The Tories wanted to cut a lot more but were held in check by the Lib Dems.
Reply
#56
(09-09-2021, 07:42 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 07:38 AM)JOK Wrote: Are you really saying there are no “career ladders” in the work place now?   
The vast majority didn’t have a work’s pension
.
The overwhelming number of “decent jobs” now, do not require a degree. 
Yep, they had, really secure jobs, from which you could be arbitrarily fired without recourse and little to no redundancy.
No minimum or living wage.

People in the 60s and 70s didn’t work hard at school then?
So, no one under 55 voted for leaving the E.U.?
We were ‘saddled’ with the decision to join the EEC and there was no vote, at all, to have a say!
We were ‘saddled’ with  
the Maastricht Treaty, again, not public say!
We were ‘saddled’ with the Schengen Agreement and again no public plebiscite.
We were ‘saddled’ with the country engaging in illegal and needless wars.
We were ‘saddled’ with foundation hospitals and school academies.  I don’t think you can use the argument that the older generations were NOT ‘saddled’ with decisions that they didn’t support or were not to their advantage.
Are you arguing that we should only be making decisions which are to the advantage of one demographic at the expense of another group? 

Try and consider that people who voted against your view re the EU were “thinking what was best for the generations after them.”
just because you think an idea is “idiotic” doesn’t necessarily make you right.

Ok…I imagine this will upset a few on here but the point is generational not on a personal / individual. Try and remember that when potentially replying.

What?   (And I get accused of "Sh*t" replies)
So, your posts aren’t just meant to “upset” a few on here, your pleased to upset, misrepresent and be disrespectful to entire generations.

Again, no rebuttals to the points in my post!
 
Just explain, what, in the 70s and 80s, could the average person on the street have done to alleviate today’s ‘problems’ ?
 
Perhaps we shouldn’t have had the unions constantly agitating and damaging the economy for all those terrible increases in terms and conditions and perks you now enjoy. (See it is all Red Robbo’s and Len McCluskey’s fault)
 
Perhaps if we had kept wages low for the working class there wouldn’t have been a growth of home ownership so keeping prices down (supposedly). People wouldn’t have been able to get on the property ladder then. Oh, hang on, you want younger people to be able to afford their own home! Bit of a dichotomy there. You want all these young uns to be able to buy their own home but all these young uns wanting to buy their own home pushes prices up due to supply and demand. We could release more Green Belt for housing but no, hang on again, you don’t won’t the government to force the use of Green Belt (which you erroneously tried to infer was happening in a previous thread)

Now, please, pretty please, how about addressing some of my observations and defending your views.
Reply
#57
(09-11-2021, 07:02 AM)JOK Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 07:42 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 07:38 AM)JOK Wrote: Are you really saying there are no “career ladders” in the work place now?   
The vast majority didn’t have a work’s pension
.
The overwhelming number of “decent jobs” now, do not require a degree. 
Yep, they had, really secure jobs, from which you could be arbitrarily fired without recourse and little to no redundancy.
No minimum or living wage.

People in the 60s and 70s didn’t work hard at school then?
So, no one under 55 voted for leaving the E.U.?
We were ‘saddled’ with the decision to join the EEC and there was no vote, at all, to have a say!
We were ‘saddled’ with  
the Maastricht Treaty, again, not public say!
We were ‘saddled’ with the Schengen Agreement and again no public plebiscite.
We were ‘saddled’ with the country engaging in illegal and needless wars.
We were ‘saddled’ with foundation hospitals and school academies.  I don’t think you can use the argument that the older generations were NOT ‘saddled’ with decisions that they didn’t support or were not to their advantage.
Are you arguing that we should only be making decisions which are to the advantage of one demographic at the expense of another group? 

Try and consider that people who voted against your view re the EU were “thinking what was best for the generations after them.”
just because you think an idea is “idiotic” doesn’t necessarily make you right.

Ok…I imagine this will upset a few on here but the point is generational not on a personal / individual. Try and remember that when potentially replying.

What?   (And I get accused of "Sh*t" replies)
So, your posts aren’t just meant to “upset” a few on here, your pleased to upset, misrepresent and be disrespectful to entire generations.

Again, no rebuttals to the points in my post!
 
Just explain, what, in the 70s and 80s, could the average person on the street have done to alleviate today’s ‘problems’ ?
 
Perhaps we shouldn’t have had the unions constantly agitating and damaging the economy for all those terrible increases in terms and conditions and perks you now enjoy. (See it is all Red Robbo’s and Len McCluskey’s fault)
 
Perhaps if we had kept wages low for the working class there wouldn’t have been a growth of home ownership so keeping prices down (supposedly). People wouldn’t have been able to get on the property ladder then. Oh, hang on, you want younger people to be able to afford their own home! Bit of a dichotomy there. You want all these young uns to be able to buy their own home but all these young uns wanting to buy their own home pushes prices up due to supply and demand. We could release more Green Belt for housing but no, hang on again, you don’t won’t the government to force the use of Green Belt (which you erroneously tried to infer was happening in a previous thread)

Now, please, pretty please, how about addressing some of my observations and defending your views.

Ok…I imagine this will upset a few on here but the point is generational not on a personal / individual. Try and remember that when potentially replying.
Reply
#58
(09-11-2021, 07:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 07:42 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ok…I imagine this will upset a few on here but the point is generational not on a personal / individual. Try and remember that when potentially replying.


Ok…I imagine this will upset a few on here but the point is generational not on a personal / individual. Try and remember that when potentially replying.

Yet another very mature and insightful repost. You regularly post inflammatory comments (in this case ageist, not to mention inaccurate) but won’t debate them on a discussion board.
Of course, the reason you constantly refuse to engage and defend your drivel is that you simply never can. I have lost count of the times you have been asked to defend your proclamations but you have simply ignored the questions or abandoned your very own threads.
So, we now, in this case, know your assertions of how easy and comfortable life was for previous generations was rubbish and that describing entire generations as selfish is ridiculous.
Reply
#59
(09-12-2021, 08:04 AM)JOK Wrote:
(09-11-2021, 07:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 07:42 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ok…I imagine this will upset a few on here but the point is generational not on a personal / individual. Try and remember that when potentially replying.


Ok…I imagine this will upset a few on here but the point is generational not on a personal / individual. Try and remember that when potentially replying.

Yet another very mature and insightful repost. You regularly post inflammatory comments (in this case ageist, not to mention inaccurate) but won’t debate them on a discussion board.
Of course, the reason you constantly refuse to engage and defend your drivel is that you simply never can. I have lost count of the times you have been asked to defend your proclamations but you have simply ignored the questions or abandoned your very own threads.
So, we now, in this case, know your assertions of how easy and comfortable life was for previous generations was rubbish and that describing entire generations as selfish is ridiculous.

Ok…I imagine this will upset a few on here but the point is generational not on a personal / individual. Try and remember that when potentially replying.
Reply
#60
(09-12-2021, 08:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-12-2021, 08:04 AM)JOK Wrote:
(09-11-2021, 07:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-09-2021, 07:42 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ok…I imagine this will upset a few on here but the point is generational not on a personal / individual. Try and remember that when potentially replying.
Ok…I imagine this will upset a few on here but the point is generational not on a personal / individual. Try and remember that when potentially replying.

So, we now, in this case, we know your assertions of how easy and comfortable life was for previous generations was rubbish and that describing entire generations as selfish is ridiculous.

Ok…I imagine this will upset a few on here but the point is generational not on a personal / individual. Try and remember that when potentially replying.

OK, …wins argument that your pronouncements and beliefs on this point are indefensible !  Walks away dusting my hands.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: