Will the ESL happen anyway?
#11
As long as we wouldn't get the fucking B teams playing in the Prem then they can fuck off imo. But once they go they are gone for good.

There will still be buyers for the football rights for the Prem. OK not on the same scale but package it up and brand it and it'll be decent.

The main issue is those fishy fuckers and the dog heads will become the main players!  Big Grin
Reply
#12
A European super league needs to happen, and almost certainly will ... at some point.
The problem, I think, with the proposal is that it didn't go far enough. (Well, and the terrible plan for it).

Whether it replaces the Champions League as well as the Premiership for those clubs that join the ESL will have a huge impact on those clubs that can't join it.
Whether there are promotions and relegations to the ESL will also prove to be problematic.

What will never happen, but might be interesting is if the ESL is actually two leagues: ESL 1 & ESL 2. The top 16-20 clubs in the top ESL1 league, with then another 16-20 clubs in the ESL2 league below. All with promotion and relegation between them. And, then below ESL2, we have national leagues, in which clubs compete to go into playoffs for promotion to ESL 2. The clubs that finish bottom of ESL 2 get relegated, with some parachute payments.

As long as payments from sponsors are more equitably shared than they are now, then the whole football landscape could be financially healthy. The huge gap between the top 6, and the next pack is huge. And then the gaps continue throughout the leagues. For years we have been (financially) at the top of the Championship, and bottom of the Premiership. We can't generally compete financially with say Everton, whilst being easily better off than so many clubs in the championship.
Reply
#13
The sooner it happens the better if you ask me.
Reply
#14
Esl can't start quick enough for me. As long as they are not allowed to stay in the prem in any shape or form it can only be of benefit long term to us
Reply
#15
If creation of the ESL led to the legalising of being able to punch a bloke wearing a Barcelona shirt in Cradley Heath High Street then I'm all for it.
Reply
#16
(09-07-2021, 10:18 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: If creation of the ESL led to the legalising of being able to punch a bloke wearing a Barcelona shirt in Cradley Heath High Street then I'm all for it.

That's outrageous. What's your problem with Cradley Heath??

Ommer 'em Cradley  Big Grin Big Grin
Reply
#17
(09-07-2021, 09:50 AM)ghanaian_baggie Wrote: A European super league needs to happen, and almost certainly will ... at some point.
The problem, I think, with the proposal is that it didn't go far enough. (Well, and the terrible plan for it).

Whether it replaces the Champions League as well as the Premiership for those clubs that join the ESL will have a huge impact on those clubs that can't join it.
Whether there are promotions and relegations to the ESL will also prove to be problematic.

What will never happen, but might be interesting is if the ESL is actually two leagues: ESL 1 & ESL 2. The top 16-20 clubs in the top ESL1 league, with then another 16-20 clubs in the ESL2 league below. All with promotion and relegation between them. And, then below ESL2, we have national leagues, in which clubs compete to go into playoffs for promotion to ESL 2. The clubs that finish bottom of ESL 2 get relegated, with some parachute payments.

As long as payments from sponsors are more equitably shared than they are now, then the whole football landscape could be financially healthy. The huge gap between the top 6, and the next pack is huge. And then the gaps continue throughout the leagues. For years we have been (financially) at the top of the Championship, and bottom of the Premiership. We can't generally compete financially with say Everton, whilst being easily better off than so many clubs in the championship.

The flaw in this approach is that you could have teams from the same country continually getting promoted and teams from other countries getting relegated, which in effect would unbalance the leagues of those who are left...

E.g. first 3 years, say Leicester, West Ham, Everton all earn promotion, with some Spanish sides getting relegated each year, how could the national leagues keep restructuring to account for it? It just wouldn't be viable. As it currently is, barring clubs imploding and going out of business we know in advance how many teams will be in each of our divisions.

What they'd likely need to do is have one team promoted to ESL2 and each of the worst teams from each country in it being relegated back... So if there's five countries in it, each year one of each of that country's teams would go up and down, and you'd then need the same with ESL1 as well.
Reply
#18
(09-07-2021, 10:18 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: If creation of the ESL led to the legalising of being able to punch a bloke wearing a Barcelona shirt in Cradley Heath High Street then I'm all for it.

I'd allow exemptions for those dating back to when Barça were donating some of the proceeds from shirt sales to Unicef. It's easy enough to distinguish and you could still issue a warning.
Reply
#19
(09-07-2021, 10:29 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(09-07-2021, 09:50 AM)ghanaian_baggie Wrote: A European super league needs to happen, and almost certainly will ... at some point.
The problem, I think, with the proposal is that it didn't go far enough. (Well, and the terrible plan for it).

Whether it replaces the Champions League as well as the Premiership for those clubs that join the ESL will have a huge impact on those clubs that can't join it.
Whether there are promotions and relegations to the ESL will also prove to be problematic.

What will never happen, but might be interesting is if the ESL is actually two leagues: ESL 1 & ESL 2. The top 16-20 clubs in the top ESL1 league, with then another 16-20 clubs in the ESL2 league below. All with promotion and relegation between them. And, then below ESL2, we have national leagues, in which clubs compete to go into playoffs for promotion to ESL 2. The clubs that finish bottom of ESL 2 get relegated, with some parachute payments.

As long as payments from sponsors are more equitably shared than they are now, then the whole football landscape could be financially healthy. The huge gap between the top 6, and the next pack is huge. And then the gaps continue throughout the leagues. For years we have been (financially) at the top of the Championship, and bottom of the Premiership. We can't generally compete financially with say Everton, whilst being easily better off than so many clubs in the championship.

The flaw in this approach is that you could have teams from the same country continually getting promoted and teams from other countries getting relegated, which in effect would unbalance the leagues of those who are left...

E.g. first 3 years, say Leicester, West Ham, Everton all earn promotion, with some Spanish sides getting relegated each year, how could the national leagues keep restructuring to account for it? It just wouldn't be viable. As it currently is, barring clubs imploding and going out of business we know in advance how many teams will be in each of our divisions.

What they'd likely need to do is have one team promoted to ESL2 and each of the worst teams from each country in it being relegated back... So if there's five countries in it, each year one of each of that country's teams would go up and down, and you'd then need the same with ESL1 as well.

You are right, I hadn't deeply thought it out. But there would be several ways around this problem. Overall, whilst we have competitive games in the Premiership, the overall result generally depends on the value of the squad/players wages. It always has, barring a Leicester where several stars aligned for them.
Reply
#20
(09-07-2021, 10:18 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: If creation of the ESL led to the legalising of being able to punch a bloke wearing a Barcelona shirt in Cradley Heath High Street then I'm all for it.

This in a nutshell. Post of the year baggiebloke!

(09-07-2021, 10:29 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(09-07-2021, 09:50 AM)ghanaian_baggie Wrote: A European super league needs to happen, and almost certainly will ... at some point.
The problem, I think, with the proposal is that it didn't go far enough. (Well, and the terrible plan for it).

Whether it replaces the Champions League as well as the Premiership for those clubs that join the ESL will have a huge impact on those clubs that can't join it.
Whether there are promotions and relegations to the ESL will also prove to be problematic.

What will never happen, but might be interesting is if the ESL is actually two leagues: ESL 1 & ESL 2. The top 16-20 clubs in the top ESL1 league, with then another 16-20 clubs in the ESL2 league below. All with promotion and relegation between them. And, then below ESL2, we have national leagues, in which clubs compete to go into playoffs for promotion to ESL 2. The clubs that finish bottom of ESL 2 get relegated, with some parachute payments.

As long as payments from sponsors are more equitably shared than they are now, then the whole football landscape could be financially healthy. The huge gap between the top 6, and the next pack is huge. And then the gaps continue throughout the leagues. For years we have been (financially) at the top of the Championship, and bottom of the Premiership. We can't generally compete financially with say Everton, whilst being easily better off than so many clubs in the championship.

The flaw in this approach is that you could have teams from the same country continually getting promoted and teams from other countries getting relegated, which in effect would unbalance the leagues of those who are left...

E.g. first 3 years, say Leicester, West Ham, Everton all earn promotion, with some Spanish sides getting relegated each year, how could the national leagues keep restructuring to account for it? It just wouldn't be viable. As it currently is, barring clubs imploding and going out of business we know in advance how many teams will be in each of our divisions.

What they'd likely need to do is have one team promoted to ESL2 and each of the worst teams from each country in it being relegated back... So if there's five countries in it, each year one of each of that country's teams would go up and down, and you'd then need the same with ESL1 as well.
This thread in general, and the post above in particular,  shows the flaws and the level of involvement for all clubs in the top pyramids.

It's incredibly complex and requires a great deal of politics. We need competitive divisions where the gaps are bridgeable.  

I wonder how Arsenal would feel becoming the Norwich or Albion of the new set-up?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: