Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
So last night was a complete and utter disaster, but that has been coming for a while now.
What worries me is the fact that it's very, very basic stuff that's going wrong. People are doing the usual of blaming the formation and such, however there is a little more to it than that.
4-3-3 is one of the best formations in modern football for a reason, a solid defensive base, numbers in attack and a fluid set up allowing players to cover ground to fill holes without pulling the team out of shape. The problem is that it requires a few things. Mobile, skilled full backs on both sides, with Holgate and Gibbs we are fine, not with Tosin in one of those positions. a midfield of 3 players, of which one can be immobile but needs a very good range of passing or physicality, Barry, Livermore or Field can do that. 2 energetic box to box players, comfortable in and out of possession in all three thirds of the pitch. Johanson has shown at Fulham he can do that, Harper potentially can do it, Morrison can as can Phillips strangely enough, though I was surprised by the way he adapted so well to that earlier in the season. In attack at least one needs to be prepared to do a lot of running to link the midfield up and the wide areas, 2 preferably, but if the midfield and full backs are good enough, you can have an almost traditional partnership with one other doing the donkey work, Rodriguez, Gayle and HRK should therefore be fine.
Problem is we don't play like that, our midfield is far too static and lacking energy or drive. Gayle wanders too far wide since no one is going there from midfield and last night Tosin wasn't getting up the pitch at all. This is stuff people managing Sunday League clubs should know, it worries me our trained and experienced coaches don't seem able to see it. We can't have Barry and Livermore in midfield together in a 3, especially when Livermore is so out of form and shape. Harper looks shell shocked, as the only midfielder running it's no surprise. Gayle is wasted having to drift out wide, and Rodriguez has to come so deep for the ball he may as well play in midfield. HRK has to do all the donkey work but he has no one to then pass it to in a better position, so fair play to him, has to draw a foul and does so. Basic stuff that anyone can see. Moore and Jones for some reason can't see it, or think it will miraculously change.
As for the subs last night. Wow. Just.... Wow. Incompetence bordering on negligence. Taking off our one mobile midfielder for Mozza was fine, though a little late. The only attacker looking likely to do anything, swapped for a wide player who is so unpredictable he doesn't know what he's doing half the time. And of course, Barry, looking likely to be sent off, replaced with Field when we needed energy and drive, at that point we'd have been better going for broke and throwing Murphy on and lumping long balls into the wide channels. All later than needed, all thrown on with no real plan it seems. At half time Livermore or Barry should have been off for Morrison, and we'd have looked better, I'm 90% certain of that, and at 2-0 down you can come back.
I'm not saying Moore out, he still deserves some time, but there are concerns and he needs to address them. I don't care what he said after the game, all managers just say random stuff after the game, rarely is it even close to what they really think or said to the players. If we end the season like this, then I may be more open to changing the manager, this is basic stuff, Sunday League level stuff.
Play offs at best this season, and I can't see us winning them.
And finally, neither Hegazi or Dawson are ball playing defenders, I get wanting to play it from the back when we can, and at times it's perfectly fine, but if they aren't sure, there is nothing wrong with a clearance out wide and long. Nothing.
Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
433 is fine with a mobile midfield. Playing Barry and Livermore we don't have that. Also last night we played with 3 centre forwards up front as opposed to one centre forward and 2 natural wingers.
Posts: 1,130
Threads: 164
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(03-02-2019, 09:13 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: So last night was a complete and utter disaster, but that has been coming for a while now.
What worries me is the fact that it's very, very basic stuff that's going wrong. People are doing the usual of blaming the formation and such, however there is a little more to it than that.
4-3-3 is one of the best formations in modern football for a reason, a solid defensive base, numbers in attack and a fluid set up allowing players to cover ground to fill holes without pulling the team out of shape. The problem is that it requires a few things. Mobile, skilled full backs on both sides, with Holgate and Gibbs we are fine, not with Tosin in one of those positions. a midfield of 3 players, of which one can be immobile but needs a very good range of passing or physicality, Barry, Livermore or Field can do that. 2 energetic box to box players, comfortable in and out of possession in all three thirds of the pitch. Johanson has shown at Fulham he can do that, Harper potentially can do it, Morrison can as can Phillips strangely enough, though I was surprised by the way he adapted so well to that earlier in the season. In attack at least one needs to be prepared to do a lot of running to link the midfield up and the wide areas, 2 preferably, but if the midfield and full backs are good enough, you can have an almost traditional partnership with one other doing the donkey work, Rodriguez, Gayle and HRK should therefore be fine.
Problem is we don't play like that, our midfield is far too static and lacking energy or drive. Gayle wanders too far wide since no one is going there from midfield and last night Tosin wasn't getting up the pitch at all. This is stuff people managing Sunday League clubs should know, it worries me our trained and experienced coaches don't seem able to see it. We can't have Barry and Livermore in midfield together in a 3, especially when Livermore is so out of form and shape. Harper looks shell shocked, as the only midfielder running it's no surprise. Gayle is wasted having to drift out wide, and Rodriguez has to come so deep for the ball he may as well play in midfield. HRK has to do all the donkey work but he has no one to then pass it to in a better position, so fair play to him, has to draw a foul and does so. Basic stuff that anyone can see. Moore and Jones for some reason can't see it, or think it will miraculously change.
As for the subs last night. Wow. Just.... Wow. Incompetence bordering on negligence. Taking off our one mobile midfielder for Mozza was fine, though a little late. The only attacker looking likely to do anything, swapped for a wide player who is so unpredictable he doesn't know what he's doing half the time. And of course, Barry, looking likely to be sent off, replaced with Field when we needed energy and drive, at that point we'd have been better going for broke and throwing Murphy on and lumping long balls into the wide channels. All later than needed, all thrown on with no real plan it seems. At half time Livermore or Barry should have been off for Morrison, and we'd have looked better, I'm 90% certain of that, and at 2-0 down you can come back.
I'm not saying Moore out, he still deserves some time, but there are concerns and he needs to address them. I don't care what he said after the game, all managers just say random stuff after the game, rarely is it even close to what they really think or said to the players. If we end the season like this, then I may be more open to changing the manager, this is basic stuff, Sunday League level stuff.
Play offs at best this season, and I can't see us winning them.
And finally, neither Hegazi or Dawson are ball playing defenders, I get wanting to play it from the back when we can, and at times it's perfectly fine, but if they aren't sure, there is nothing wrong with a clearance out wide and long. Nothing.
Continuing playing both Barry and Livermore together is criminal. We the fans have been saying this for a while now. The worrying thing for me is our management team continuing with it.
Posts: 4,751
Threads: 374
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
Said the same last night birdmon our midfield is far too static to play the way we do but GJ/BD are too stubborn to change tactics to suit the players. Square pegs in round holes and all that.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(03-02-2019, 09:31 AM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote: (03-02-2019, 09:13 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: So last night was a complete and utter disaster, but that has been coming for a while now.
What worries me is the fact that it's very, very basic stuff that's going wrong. People are doing the usual of blaming the formation and such, however there is a little more to it than that.
4-3-3 is one of the best formations in modern football for a reason, a solid defensive base, numbers in attack and a fluid set up allowing players to cover ground to fill holes without pulling the team out of shape. The problem is that it requires a few things. Mobile, skilled full backs on both sides, with Holgate and Gibbs we are fine, not with Tosin in one of those positions. a midfield of 3 players, of which one can be immobile but needs a very good range of passing or physicality, Barry, Livermore or Field can do that. 2 energetic box to box players, comfortable in and out of possession in all three thirds of the pitch. Johanson has shown at Fulham he can do that, Harper potentially can do it, Morrison can as can Phillips strangely enough, though I was surprised by the way he adapted so well to that earlier in the season. In attack at least one needs to be prepared to do a lot of running to link the midfield up and the wide areas, 2 preferably, but if the midfield and full backs are good enough, you can have an almost traditional partnership with one other doing the donkey work, Rodriguez, Gayle and HRK should therefore be fine.
Problem is we don't play like that, our midfield is far too static and lacking energy or drive. Gayle wanders too far wide since no one is going there from midfield and last night Tosin wasn't getting up the pitch at all. This is stuff people managing Sunday League clubs should know, it worries me our trained and experienced coaches don't seem able to see it. We can't have Barry and Livermore in midfield together in a 3, especially when Livermore is so out of form and shape. Harper looks shell shocked, as the only midfielder running it's no surprise. Gayle is wasted having to drift out wide, and Rodriguez has to come so deep for the ball he may as well play in midfield. HRK has to do all the donkey work but he has no one to then pass it to in a better position, so fair play to him, has to draw a foul and does so. Basic stuff that anyone can see. Moore and Jones for some reason can't see it, or think it will miraculously change.
As for the subs last night. Wow. Just.... Wow. Incompetence bordering on negligence. Taking off our one mobile midfielder for Mozza was fine, though a little late. The only attacker looking likely to do anything, swapped for a wide player who is so unpredictable he doesn't know what he's doing half the time. And of course, Barry, looking likely to be sent off, replaced with Field when we needed energy and drive, at that point we'd have been better going for broke and throwing Murphy on and lumping long balls into the wide channels. All later than needed, all thrown on with no real plan it seems. At half time Livermore or Barry should have been off for Morrison, and we'd have looked better, I'm 90% certain of that, and at 2-0 down you can come back.
I'm not saying Moore out, he still deserves some time, but there are concerns and he needs to address them. I don't care what he said after the game, all managers just say random stuff after the game, rarely is it even close to what they really think or said to the players. If we end the season like this, then I may be more open to changing the manager, this is basic stuff, Sunday League level stuff.
Play offs at best this season, and I can't see us winning them.
And finally, neither Hegazi or Dawson are ball playing defenders, I get wanting to play it from the back when we can, and at times it's perfectly fine, but if they aren't sure, there is nothing wrong with a clearance out wide and long. Nothing.
Continuing playing both Barry and Livermore together is criminal. We the fans have been saying this for a while now. The worrying thing for me is our management team continuing with it. Livermore left of the 3???!!! Unbelievable.
Posts: 7,412
Threads: 124
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
What's basically gone wrong is fucking Puell, recalled Barnes & fucked us completely, yet still got the bullet.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Losing Barnes did hurt, but we have a squad capable of coping. The management team are failing to use it properly.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(03-02-2019, 09:13 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: So last night was a complete and utter disaster, but that has been coming for a while now.
What worries me is the fact that it's very, very basic stuff that's going wrong. People are doing the usual of blaming the formation and such, however there is a little more to it than that.
4-3-3 is one of the best formations in modern football for a reason, a solid defensive base, numbers in attack and a fluid set up allowing players to cover ground to fill holes without pulling the team out of shape. The problem is that it requires a few things. Mobile, skilled full backs on both sides, with Holgate and Gibbs we are fine, not with Tosin in one of those positions. a midfield of 3 players, of which one can be immobile but needs a very good range of passing or physicality, Barry, Livermore or Field can do that. 2 energetic box to box players, comfortable in and out of possession in all three thirds of the pitch. Johanson has shown at Fulham he can do that, Harper potentially can do it, Morrison can as can Phillips strangely enough, though I was surprised by the way he adapted so well to that earlier in the season. In attack at least one needs to be prepared to do a lot of running to link the midfield up and the wide areas, 2 preferably, but if the midfield and full backs are good enough, you can have an almost traditional partnership with one other doing the donkey work, Rodriguez, Gayle and HRK should therefore be fine.
Problem is we don't play like that, our midfield is far too static and lacking energy or drive. Gayle wanders too far wide since no one is going there from midfield and last night Tosin wasn't getting up the pitch at all. This is stuff people managing Sunday League clubs should know, it worries me our trained and experienced coaches don't seem able to see it. We can't have Barry and Livermore in midfield together in a 3, especially when Livermore is so out of form and shape. Harper looks shell shocked, as the only midfielder running it's no surprise. Gayle is wasted having to drift out wide, and Rodriguez has to come so deep for the ball he may as well play in midfield. HRK has to do all the donkey work but he has no one to then pass it to in a better position, so fair play to him, has to draw a foul and does so. Basic stuff that anyone can see. Moore and Jones for some reason can't see it, or think it will miraculously change.
As for the subs last night. Wow. Just.... Wow. Incompetence bordering on negligence. Taking off our one mobile midfielder for Mozza was fine, though a little late. The only attacker looking likely to do anything, swapped for a wide player who is so unpredictable he doesn't know what he's doing half the time. And of course, Barry, looking likely to be sent off, replaced with Field when we needed energy and drive, at that point we'd have been better going for broke and throwing Murphy on and lumping long balls into the wide channels. All later than needed, all thrown on with no real plan it seems. At half time Livermore or Barry should have been off for Morrison, and we'd have looked better, I'm 90% certain of that, and at 2-0 down you can come back.
I'm not saying Moore out, he still deserves some time, but there are concerns and he needs to address them. I don't care what he said after the game, all managers just say random stuff after the game, rarely is it even close to what they really think or said to the players. If we end the season like this, then I may be more open to changing the manager, this is basic stuff, Sunday League level stuff.
Play offs at best this season, and I can't see us winning them.
And finally, neither Hegazi or Dawson are ball playing defenders, I get wanting to play it from the back when we can, and at times it's perfectly fine, but if they aren't sure, there is nothing wrong with a clearance out wide and long. Nothing. Well said, Birdy.
Posts: 10,524
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
Is it really that bad?
Moore definitely has made some baffling decisions the last 2 games and needs to up his tactical in-game management...but he has shown he can do that this season.
Before Leeds/Sheff we were on a brilliant run. Stoke, Forest, Villa and QPR and we were all raving about how good we were. The last 2 defeats hurt/mean a little more because it was against 2 direct rivals.
Is it really that bad?
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(03-02-2019, 09:57 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Is it really that bad?
Moore definitely has made some baffling decisions the last 2 games and needs to up his tactical in-game management...but he has shown he can do that this season.
Before Leeds/Sheff we were on a brilliant run. Stoke, Forest, Villa and QPR and we were all raving about how good we were. The last 2 defeats hurt/mean a little more because it was against 2 direct rivals.
Is it really that bad?
Yes I'd say so.
We've relied on individual brilliance a little more often that I'd like this season. Which is fine, Moore is still learning, however our home form is a concern, and all that above applies to us at home, and the last two games have been truly dire.
|