AFGHANISTAN
#41
(08-16-2021, 10:54 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:  I did not defend the Soviets and I did not state they “bravely” did anything. It was political pragmatism. I merely pointed out that when the west decided to back the Mujahadeen they only helped sustain and create a monster equally as deadly and unpleasant as the regime they sought to remove.

Are you new here?

In this ‘MY’ truth era, you mustn’t point out or deny other’s the right to falsely interpret and embellish, erroneously, what you write.  
Reply
#42
(08-17-2021, 07:10 AM)JOK Wrote:
(08-16-2021, 10:54 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:  I did not defend the Soviets and I did not state they “bravely” did anything. It was political pragmatism. I merely pointed out that when the west decided to back the Mujahadeen they only helped sustain and create a monster equally as deadly and unpleasant as the regime they sought to remove.

Are you new here?

In this ‘MY’ truth era, you mustn’t point out or deny other’s the right to falsely interpret and embellish, erroneously, what you write.  

Apologies. I have always been slightly naïve and I admit my ridiculously stupid error. Mea culpa.
Reply
#43
It really is a shocker that in todays world there is still a substantial movement in parts of the world that has the views of the Taliban. To have a group that can have that much influence they can get control of a country with a population of nearly 40M is beyond belief in a world where we are supposed to be more informed, tolerant and accepting of others differences (I know).

As for the military action 20 years ago, it was obviously a knee jerk reaction to 9/11 and done to win popularity in the US by Bush but does anyone know of a military solution that ended up improving a situation (WWII could be but beyond that), but what were the options. Let Al-Quaeda claim victory and impress disadvantaged individuals from around the globe to rise up, that can be dealt with (see Syria) but lasting solutions for what happens next is the part that alludes the powers every time.

The UN seems toothless and for issues such as this useless. God knows where this leaves us, or more importantly the civilians of Afghanistan - I would pray for them if I thought there was a God that would solve this and protect them.
Reply
#44
(08-17-2021, 08:17 AM)baggy1 Wrote: It really is a shocker that in todays world there is still a substantial movement in parts of the world that has the views of the Taliban. To have a group that can have that much influence they can get control of a country with a population of nearly 40M is beyond belief in a world where we are supposed to be more informed, tolerant and accepting of others differences (I know).

As for the military action 20 years ago, it was obviously a knee jerk reaction to 9/11 and done to win popularity in the US by Bush but does anyone know of a military solution that ended up improving a situation (WWII could be but beyond that), but what were the options. Let Al-Quaeda claim victory and impress disadvantaged individuals from around the globe to rise up, that can be dealt with (see Syria) but lasting solutions for what happens next is the part that alludes the powers every time.

The UN seems toothless and for issues such as this useless. God knows where this leaves us, or more importantly the civilians of Afghanistan - I would pray for them if I thought there was a God that would solve this and protect them.

Malaya. Aden. But they were a long time ago and far away and anyway the wench is ...

And tbf it also involved getting the locals onside.
Reply
#45
It's very much like MO earlier.
The USA should have negotiated a take over for the tribe leaders and Taliban before they pulled out.
Saving many innocent lives and destruction.
Promoting a free for all was stupidity, Biden thought it was a vote winner. I see Pakistan supporting the take over, strongly backed by the Chinese. Let's see how many votes he gets for that.
Reply
#46
Taking over a country as the USA did for the sake of a small amount of terrorists was lunacy.

How they have left is even worse though. Very least they should have managed it to get out anyone who has worked with them and felt under threat from taliban.
Reply
#47
Bad deal all around, but after twenty years of attrition and fatigue it's hard to see an alternative. In the US there's no appetite for ground troops. One solution might have been to have kept NATO troops at the airbase, as a guarantee. However, with captured weaponry and rockets galore, it's no longer feasible (and maybe never was). The best we can hope for is the transition to settle speedily and for soft words on Kabul by the taleban to be representative of action.

...And working to speedily resettle vulnerable groups abroad.
Reply
#48
Action in Afghanistan was the right thing to do after 9/11, We should have had colonial power over Afghanistan and perhaps make it a state shared by US and UK.
Reply
#49
(08-17-2021, 11:18 AM)Madness Wrote: Action in Afghanistan was the right thing to do after 9/11, We should have had colonial power over Afghanistan and perhaps make it a state shared by US and UK.

Have you time travelled from the early 19th century and ended up in the 21st by mistake or something?
Reply
#50
(08-17-2021, 11:18 AM)Madness Wrote: Action in Afghanistan was the right thing to do after 9/11, We should have had colonial power over Afghanistan and perhaps make it a state shared by US and UK.

Why not actually flip it and look how China deal with the situation?

Both could a lot from China IMO (Belt and Road initiative will actually improve Afghanistan long term)

Always a different narrative when China involved.

Example 1:

When China cracks down on Alibaba to reduce systemic financial risk & ensure consumer data privacy, US media portrays it as moves by a scared CPC (or Xi) flexing power

When US cracks down on Facebook or banks, US media lauds it as consumer safety & reduced risk

Double standards


Systemic racism IMO
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: