My simple perspective
#31
PR I'm glad you have taken up the DH challenge. I think he is missing Enzo?
#32
(02-27-2019, 08:32 AM)Beano Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 10:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 10:48 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Bookies odds are extremely volatile and are not a prediction on where a team will finish but on what is the likelihood of getting them the most cash.

And the opinions of sports journalist that have Stoke running away with the league and a poll on here suggesting we will finish midtable is a rock solid way of judging where we will finish.

In fairness given the wealth of the Stoke owners, plus the parachute payment together with them keeping some players
with premiership experience, that was a pretty decent call back then. Many of those factors will always give teams that
drop from the premiership good early odds.

I take the point about bookies lowering odds for 'bigger clubs'. Equally though, I would question journalists  impartiality and knowledge. Most journalists write to provoke a response, often with contrarian views. I would also question their knowledge outside the big 6. The bollocks they spouted about berahino towards the end of his career showed they knew nothing. Worse they complacently copied contractual and timeline innacuracies from each other so often they became accepted as 'truth' .

FWIW, I do think and always thought we have one of the best squads in the league and we should go up. It's not perfect and some of the players are obviously not as good as we or they thought, but it is still better than most. 

DM has been given the role based on a mixture of integrity, loyalty and a bloody good run at the end of the season. He deserved his chance, but for a man of his relative inexperience, it is a big chance. He has made mistakes compared to some of the more established managers, but as long as he's willing learn from them - and I believe he is - I would rather have him than any of the other managers we would be in the frame for. 

Ultimately, I believe we should go up and if we don't DM is partly to blame, along with the players and the directors. I don't think it's a sackable offence and I would want him to keep going and keep learning, but he will have to have a bloody good plan for next year, because it will only get harder.
#33
(02-27-2019, 09:42 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 08:32 AM)Beano Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 10:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 10:48 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Bookies odds are extremely volatile and are not a prediction on where a team will finish but on what is the likelihood of getting them the most cash.

And the opinions of sports journalist that have Stoke running away with the league and a poll on here suggesting we will finish midtable is a rock solid way of judging where we will finish.

In fairness given the wealth of the Stoke owners, plus the parachute payment together with them keeping some players
with premiership experience, that was a pretty decent call back then. Many of those factors will always give teams that
drop from the premiership good early odds.

I take the point about bookies lowering odds for 'bigger clubs'. Equally though, I would question journalists  impartiality and knowledge. Most journalists write to provoke a response, often with contrarian views. I would also question their knowledge outside the big 6. The bollocks they spouted about berahino towards the end of his career showed they knew nothing. Worse they complacently copied contractual and timeline innacuracies from each other so often they became accepted as 'truth' .

FWIW, I do think and always thought we have one of the best squads in the league and we should go up. It's not perfect and some of the players are obviously not as good as we or they thought, but it is still better than most. 

DM has been given the role based on a mixture of integrity, loyalty and a bloody good run at the end of the season. He deserved his chance, but for a man of his relative inexperience, it is a big chance. He has made mistakes compared to some of the more established managers, but as long as he's willing learn from them - and I believe he is - I would rather have him than any of the other managers we would be in the frame for. 

Ultimately, I believe we should go up and if we don't DM is partly to blame, along with the players and the directors. I don't think it's a sackable offence and I would want him to keep going and keep learning, but he will have to have a bloody good plan for next year, because it will only get harder.

Great post Fuzzbox and I entirely agree. Have a special k

(02-27-2019, 09:10 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 08:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 08:04 PM)Sandking Wrote: I have pals who support an array of Championship clubs. To a man, they all think we have the best squad in the division and should be nailed on certs for automatic promotion. I usually get the Gibbs, J-Rod, Livermore, Barry all capped by England and Championship hotshot Gayle plus whatever our annual wage bill is, compared to other mere Championship mortals. Of course, they`re citing names from a teamsheet. Crossing the white line is another thing altogether. But there does seem to be a consensus among them, albeit from the outside looking in.

Anti-DM agendas aots on this thread and we haven’t got the best squad it’s pretty average!

Yours Pickled Rick
Arf - obsessed.

I always fancied us for top 2 but just don't think it's a gimme as it never is in the championship so I don't pant wet whenever a point is dropped like you. I certainly never thought of our squad as average but as you post so much nonsense this is probably as accurate as anything you come up with. 

You are a bad judge of squad strengths or best teams though as you had Norwich comong 6th when they were beating all around them. And you are a notoriously bad judge of managers - which bodes well for DM. Most predicted Albion for play offs however and currently it looks like they were correct.

Just pointing out that others post similar thoughts to me but you don't try and distort what they write into anti-DM nonsense. Hypocrisy and double standards aots

As for the rest you're going to have to remind me where my opinion of a manager was poor as all I did was back a manager for half a season too long after two previously successful seasons at the club where he did exactly what the club / owner wanted. You may not have liked them but that means absolutely nothing. I said Pardew was shite btw whilst you tried to justify his appalling record. 

As for Norwich they are doing better than most predicted and fair cop they look like they will get over the line this season.
#34
DH i think your mistake was backing him for at least 12 months to late he should have gone at the end of the season when we coasted to 40 points then once again he decided to down tools once again .
#35
(02-27-2019, 11:04 AM)The liquidator Wrote: DH i think your mistake was  backing him for at least 12 months to late he should have gone at the end of the season when we coasted to 40 points then once again he decided to down tools once again .

He'd probably have him back in charge now.
#36
(02-27-2019, 11:43 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 10:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 09:42 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 08:32 AM)Beano Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 10:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: And the opinions of sports journalist that have Stoke running away with the league and a poll on here suggesting we will finish midtable is a rock solid way of judging where we will finish.

In fairness given the wealth of the Stoke owners, plus the parachute payment together with them keeping some players
with premiership experience, that was a pretty decent call back then. Many of those factors will always give teams that
drop from the premiership good early odds.

I take the point about bookies lowering odds for 'bigger clubs'. Equally though, I would question journalists  impartiality and knowledge. Most journalists write to provoke a response, often with contrarian views. I would also question their knowledge outside the big 6. The bollocks they spouted about berahino towards the end of his career showed they knew nothing. Worse they complacently copied contractual and timeline innacuracies from each other so often they became accepted as 'truth' .

FWIW, I do think and always thought we have one of the best squads in the league and we should go up. It's not perfect and some of the players are obviously not as good as we or they thought, but it is still better than most. 

DM has been given the role based on a mixture of integrity, loyalty and a bloody good run at the end of the season. He deserved his chance, but for a man of his relative inexperience, it is a big chance. He has made mistakes compared to some of the more established managers, but as long as he's willing learn from them - and I believe he is - I would rather have him than any of the other managers we would be in the frame for. 

Ultimately, I believe we should go up and if we don't DM is partly to blame, along with the players and the directors. I don't think it's a sackable offence and I would want him to keep going and keep learning, but he will have to have a bloody good plan for next year, because it will only get harder.

Great post Fuzzbox and I entirely agree. Have a special k

(02-27-2019, 09:10 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 08:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 08:04 PM)Sandking Wrote: I have pals who support an array of Championship clubs. To a man, they all think we have the best squad in the division and should be nailed on certs for automatic promotion. I usually get the Gibbs, J-Rod, Livermore, Barry all capped by England and Championship hotshot Gayle plus whatever our annual wage bill is, compared to other mere Championship mortals. Of course, they`re citing names from a teamsheet. Crossing the white line is another thing altogether. But there does seem to be a consensus among them, albeit from the outside looking in.

Anti-DM agendas aots on this thread and we haven’t got the best squad it’s pretty average!

Yours Pickled Rick
Arf - obsessed.

I always fancied us for top 2 but just don't think it's a gimme as it never is in the championship so I don't pant wet whenever a point is dropped like you. I certainly never thought of our squad as average but as you post so much nonsense this is probably as accurate as anything you come up with. 

You are a bad judge of squad strengths or best teams though as you had Norwich comong 6th when they were beating all around them. And you are a notoriously bad judge of managers - which bodes well for DM. Most predicted Albion for play offs however and currently it looks like they were correct.

Just pointing out that others post similar thoughts to me but you don't try and distort what they write into anti-DM nonsense. Hypocrisy and double standards aots

As for the rest you're going to have to remind me where my opinion of a manager was poor as all I did was back a manager for half a season too long after two previously successful seasons at the club where he did exactly what the club / owner wanted. You may not have liked them but that means absolutely nothing. I said Pardew was shite btw whilst you tried to justify his appalling record. 

As for Norwich they are doing better than most predicted and fair cop they look like they will get over the line this season.
The hypocrisy is all yours in your constant  criticism  of DM - I give my opinion on plenty of threads but you are the only one wailing and crying foul when I don't agree with you on the rare occasion I respond to your prolific negative doom mongering. Again another lie - I never tried to justify Pardews record - I gave him a chance when he got here first which seemed sensible at the time. He proved to be nearly as shite as Pulis which was a shame.

Show me the constant criticism of DM you accuse me and pretty much me alone of. If you are going to state I am back it up with some evidence.

Pardew statically pts wise was the worst manager not just with us but Palace for the 18mths.
#37
(02-27-2019, 12:31 PM)MPickle Rick Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 11:43 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 10:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 09:42 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: I take the point about bookies lowering odds for 'bigger clubs'. Equally though, I would question journalists  impartiality and knowledge. Most journalists write to provoke a response, often with contrarian views. I would also question their knowledge outside the big 6. The bollocks they spouted about berahino towards the end of his career showed they knew nothing. Worse they complacently copied contractual and timeline innacuracies from each other so often they became accepted as 'truth' .

FWIW, I do think and always thought we have one of the best squads in the league and we should go up. It's not perfect and some of the players are obviously not as good as we or they thought, but it is still better than most. 

DM has been given the role based on a mixture of integrity, loyalty and a bloody good run at the end of the season. He deserved his chance, but for a man of his relative inexperience, it is a big chance. He has made mistakes compared to some of the more established managers, but as long as he's willing learn from them - and I believe he is - I would rather have him than any of the other managers we would be in the frame for. 

Ultimately, I believe we should go up and if we don't DM is partly to blame, along with the players and the directors. I don't think it's a sackable offence and I would want him to keep going and keep learning, but he will have to have a bloody good plan for next year, because it will only get harder.

Great post Fuzzbox and I entirely agree. Have a special k

(02-27-2019, 09:10 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote: Arf - obsessed.

I always fancied us for top 2 but just don't think it's a gimme as it never is in the championship so I don't pant wet whenever a point is dropped like you. I certainly never thought of our squad as average but as you post so much nonsense this is probably as accurate as anything you come up with. 

You are a bad judge of squad strengths or best teams though as you had Norwich comong 6th when they were beating all around them. And you are a notoriously bad judge of managers - which bodes well for DM. Most predicted Albion for play offs however and currently it looks like they were correct.

Just pointing out that others post similar thoughts to me but you don't try and distort what they write into anti-DM nonsense. Hypocrisy and double standards aots

As for the rest you're going to have to remind me where my opinion of a manager was poor as all I did was back a manager for half a season too long after two previously successful seasons at the club where he did exactly what the club / owner wanted. You may not have liked them but that means absolutely nothing. I said Pardew was shite btw whilst you tried to justify his appalling record. 

As for Norwich they are doing better than most predicted and fair cop they look like they will get over the line this season.
The hypocrisy is all yours in your constant  criticism  of DM - I give my opinion on plenty of threads but you are the only one wailing and crying foul when I don't agree with you on the rare occasion I respond to your prolific negative doom mongering. Again another lie - I never tried to justify Pardews record - I gave him a chance when he got here first which seemed sensible at the time. He proved to be nearly as shite as Pulis which was a shame.

Show me the constant criticism of DM you accuse me and pretty much me alone of. If you are going to state I am back it up with some evidence.

Pardew statically pts wise was the worst manager not just with us but Palace for the 18mths.
Well you can look at your own posts for evidence - i warn you though it is mind numbing. Really this victim role you are trying to portray is ridiculous given your posting style - I have a sick cow that is more reasonable.

It all seems very self obsessive - the board isnt about you. I'm not just replying to your posts and you can have a look at mine too (much more fun). I wouldn't have bothered on this thread today except you tagged me - presumably it seems to start another argument where you can play the victim - a bit pathetic. 

Pardew was shite for us - I did worry at the time we had left it too late to change from Pulis ball to survive - perhaps DM would have managed it.

For all the bluster you have no evidence that I constantly criticise the manager. If you’re going to accuse someone of something have some proper evidence to back it up.  That’s not me playing the victim I’m just sticking up for myself.
#38
(02-27-2019, 01:13 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:31 PM)MPickle Rick Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 11:43 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote: The hypocrisy is all yours in your constant  criticism  of DM - I give my opinion on plenty of threads but you are the only one wailing and crying foul when I don't agree with you on the rare occasion I respond to your prolific negative doom mongering. Again another lie - I never tried to justify Pardews record - I gave him a chance when he got here first which seemed sensible at the time. He proved to be nearly as shite as Pulis which was a shame.

Show me the constant criticism of DM you accuse me and pretty much me alone of. If you are going to state I am back it up with some evidence.

Pardew statically pts wise was the worst manager not just with us but Palace for the 18mths.
Well you can look at your own posts for evidence - i warn you though it is mind numbing. Really this victim role you are trying to portray is ridiculous given your posting style - I have a sick cow that is more reasonable.

It all seems very self obsessive - the board isnt about you. I'm not just replying to your posts and you can have a look at mine too (much more fun). I wouldn't have bothered on this thread today except you tagged me - presumably it seems to start another argument where you can play the victim - a bit pathetic. 

Pardew was shite for us - I did worry at the time we had left it too late to change from Pulis ball to survive - perhaps DM would have managed it.

For all the bluster you have no evidence that I constantly criticise the manager. If you’re going to accuse someone of something have some proper evidence to back it up.  That’s not me playing the victim I’m just sticking up for myself.
Rubbish. The bluser came from you and the evidence is in your posts - I don't have to show them to you - no one is here for your benefit. But you bleated after one game and have done  so since and you know it. You bought me into this thread so it has nothing yo do with sticking  up for yourself  but just self  obsessed argumentative behaviour. You can dish it out but can't take it when anyone responds in kind.

That’s a resounding no I can’t back my argument up then.
#39
(02-27-2019, 01:13 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:31 PM)MPickle Rick Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 12:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-27-2019, 11:43 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote: The hypocrisy is all yours in your constant  criticism  of DM - I give my opinion on plenty of threads but you are the only one wailing and crying foul when I don't agree with you on the rare occasion I respond to your prolific negative doom mongering. Again another lie - I never tried to justify Pardews record - I gave him a chance when he got here first which seemed sensible at the time. He proved to be nearly as shite as Pulis which was a shame.

Show me the constant criticism of DM you accuse me and pretty much me alone of. If you are going to state I am back it up with some evidence.

Pardew statically pts wise was the worst manager not just with us but Palace for the 18mths.
Well you can look at your own posts for evidence - i warn you though it is mind numbing. Really this victim role you are trying to portray is ridiculous given your posting style - I have a sick cow that is more reasonable.

It all seems very self obsessive - the board isnt about you. I'm not just replying to your posts and you can have a look at mine too (much more fun). I wouldn't have bothered on this thread today except you tagged me - presumably it seems to start another argument where you can play the victim - a bit pathetic. 

Pardew was shite for us - I did worry at the time we had left it too late to change from Pulis ball to survive - perhaps DM would have managed it.

For all the bluster you have no evidence that I constantly criticise the manager. If you’re going to accuse someone of something have some proper evidence to back it up.  That’s not me playing the victim I’m just sticking up for myself.
Rubbish. The bluster came from you and the evidence is in your posts - I don't have to show them to you - no one is here for your benefit. But you bleated after one game and have done  so since and you know it. You bought me into this thread so it has nothing to do with sticking  up for yourself  but just self obsessed argumentative behaviour. You can dish it out but can't take it when anyone responds in kind.

Crect.

Next he'll be crying "the mods are ganging up on me" like last time  Big Grin

Dow give it if you can't take it and all that...
#40
PR - DH doesn't believe in democracy (ref his "The majority are not right" quote) Only his opinion counts!!
He turns almost every debate he gets involved with, into a fully blown argument with his condescending nature.
Why he persists in asking posters to prove this and that is beyond me? Where's his sense of fun and enjoyment?
Sadly he is getting worse. It's a shame, as he does have some excellent knowledge but has turned into Mr Angry.


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)