MP to Al-Hilal
(08-05-2021, 11:47 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Laughing at the comments saying WBA have f***** up here! 

No they havent. 

You can only sell to a buyer and they generally will only pay what they want to pay. A player is worth what a buyer values them at. 

Those slating the club….. again…..

Ask yourself these questions:

Why were sporting happy to sell for pennies (in reality) - £8m
Why were WBA the only club willing to pay the £8m but only 12 months down the line IF we went up?
Why were other clubs not interested in taking him after a decent season in the Bundesliga? 
Why were no other clubs interested in MP after a very good season in the premier league? 

People in Football circles talk to each other - make no mistake.  We took a gamble on him knowing that it was a minimal fee in relative terms offset against £8.7m transfer fee 12 months down the line.  

We went up so another £4.5m top up to reach the £8.7m fee was easily done with promotion.

We earned circa £100m as a club getting promoted and with that secured the future of the club for a number of years, covered the losses of covid and are now on a sound financial footing.

1 year later the same player wants to leave.
1 year later we have a new manager with a different philosophy.
1 year later we are in the championship and flex down wages come into play…usually around 50% reduction.

We only receive 1 concrete offer of double the money we spent on this player only 1 year ago. 

We have a manager who’s not that fussed on him. 

We have a player who wants to go and earn £77k a week, near as damn it treble his earnings for the coming season. 

I’d say the club hasn’t fu**** up one bit.

What you haven't taken into account is that MP was involved in 17 of our PL goals last season which was up there with some of the best midfielders in the top flight.In a team that had the worst XG out of any team in the league (some going that dont you think?)+ Whilst signing a new lengthy contract. 

I'd say the club have fu**** up BIG TIME!      

Oh an by my reckoning there are over 3weeks left in the transfer window (which in the way we've operated within it in the past is a eternity)
Reply
(08-05-2021, 11:57 AM)MrFizz Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 11:47 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Laughing at the comments saying WBA have f***** up here! 

No they havent. 

You can only sell to a buyer and they generally will only pay what they want to pay. A player is worth what a buyer values them at. 

Those slating the club….. again…..

Ask yourself these questions:

Why were sporting happy to sell for pennies (in reality) - £8m
Why were WBA the only club willing to pay the £8m but only 12 months down the line IF we went up?
Why were other clubs not interested in taking him after a decent season in the Bundesliga? 
Why were no other clubs interested in MP after a very good season in the premier league? 

People in Football circles talk to each other - make no mistake.  We took a gamble on him knowing that it was a minimal fee in relative terms offset against £8.7m transfer fee 12 months down the line.  

We went up so another £4.5m top up to reach the £8.7m fee was easily done with promotion.

We earned circa £100m as a club getting promoted and with that secured the future of the club for a number of years, covered the losses of covid and are now on a sound financial footing.

1 year later the same player wants to leave.
1 year later we have a new manager with a different philosophy.
1 year later we are in the championship and flex down wages come into play…usually around 50% reduction.

We only receive 1 concrete offer of double the money we spent on this player only 1 year ago. 

We have a manager who’s not that fussed on him. 

We have a player who wants to go and earn £77k a week, near as damn it treble his earnings for the coming season. 

I’d say the club hasn’t fu**** up one bit.

Thats your opinion RW and i respect it.

However other clubs in this situation seemingly manage to get somewhere near their valuation for a player. Of course they didn't openly plead poverty and desperation, like we did.

MP, his agent and Al Hilal have took advantage of this, took advantage of our supposedly weak financial position (thanks to our owners), our lack of football people in critical positions, and right royally  torn us a new arsehole.

My opinion.

Correct Fizz. Wages are normally in line with the fee paid and the length of unexpired contract. This is so out of line it's worth dialling 999. How on earth can a club value a player is worth paying such huge wages to,  (according to MP), but make such a derisory offer to the seller? 
As for no one is interested. We'll never know. Things are only just moving. Villa, Norwich and Southampton have already shown how to set a selling price.
I love our club as much as anyone and way more than I ever ought to, but this deal stinks as bad as the allegations revealed a month ago. Oddly enough, it involves all the same people too.
Reply
(08-05-2021, 12:04 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Does anyone genuinly think other clubs care what is said in press conferences?

Agents, coaches and players talk, a lot. I know, I have a friend who coaches at a premier league club, I hear all sorts about other clubs because everyone knows each others business.

Spot on. 

He’s £17m for a reason. Just like he was £8.7 two years ago and we weren’t happy to pay it initially.
Reply
(08-05-2021, 12:29 PM)Anew Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 11:47 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Laughing at the comments saying WBA have f***** up here! 

No they havent. 

You can only sell to a buyer and they generally will only pay what they want to pay. A player is worth what a buyer values them at. 

Those slating the club….. again…..

Ask yourself these questions:

Why were sporting happy to sell for pennies (in reality) - £8m
Why were WBA the only club willing to pay the £8m but only 12 months down the line IF we went up?
Why were other clubs not interested in taking him after a decent season in the Bundesliga? 
Why were no other clubs interested in MP after a very good season in the premier league? 

People in Football circles talk to each other - make no mistake.  We took a gamble on him knowing that it was a minimal fee in relative terms offset against £8.7m transfer fee 12 months down the line.  

We went up so another £4.5m top up to reach the £8.7m fee was easily done with promotion.

We earned circa £100m as a club getting promoted and with that secured the future of the club for a number of years, covered the losses of covid and are now on a sound financial footing.

1 year later the same player wants to leave.
1 year later we have a new manager with a different philosophy.
1 year later we are in the championship and flex down wages come into play…usually around 50% reduction.

We only receive 1 concrete offer of double the money we spent on this player only 1 year ago. 

We have a manager who’s not that fussed on him. 

We have a player who wants to go and earn £77k a week, near as damn it treble his earnings for the coming season. 

I’d say the club hasn’t fu**** up one bit.

What you haven't taken into account is that MP was involved in 17 of our PL goals last season which was up there with some of the best midfielders in the top flight.In a team that had the worst XG out of any team in the league (some going that dont you think?)+ Whilst signing a new lengthy contract. 

I'd say the club have fu**** up BIG TIME!      

Oh an by my reckoning there are over 3weeks left in the transfer window (which in the way we've operated within it in the past is a eternity)

There was nobody else in for Grant, and he'd gone on strike in a bid to force move to us through.... Hudds still got £16m out of us, despite not having a pot to piss in to pay their players. Not a hugely different scenario, but they managed to extract well over the odds for their asset.

Sorry Ronnie, I get the massive money waved in front of MP's nose reduced our wiggle room, but we have sold a player for much less than he's worth after allowing a club and player bully us into a sale... and as for the  fact we got him for a reduced fee, that really doesn't impact what he's worth now.
Reply
(08-05-2021, 12:29 PM)Anew Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 11:47 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Laughing at the comments saying WBA have f***** up here! 

No they havent. 

You can only sell to a buyer and they generally will only pay what they want to pay. A player is worth what a buyer values them at. 

Those slating the club….. again…..

Ask yourself these questions:

Why were sporting happy to sell for pennies (in reality) - £8m
Why were WBA the only club willing to pay the £8m but only 12 months down the line IF we went up?
Why were other clubs not interested in taking him after a decent season in the Bundesliga? 
Why were no other clubs interested in MP after a very good season in the premier league? 

People in Football circles talk to each other - make no mistake.  We took a gamble on him knowing that it was a minimal fee in relative terms offset against £8.7m transfer fee 12 months down the line.  

We went up so another £4.5m top up to reach the £8.7m fee was easily done with promotion.

We earned circa £100m as a club getting promoted and with that secured the future of the club for a number of years, covered the losses of covid and are now on a sound financial footing.

1 year later the same player wants to leave.
1 year later we have a new manager with a different philosophy.
1 year later we are in the championship and flex down wages come into play…usually around 50% reduction.

We only receive 1 concrete offer of double the money we spent on this player only 1 year ago. 

We have a manager who’s not that fussed on him. 

We have a player who wants to go and earn £77k a week, near as damn it treble his earnings for the coming season. 

I’d say the club hasn’t fu**** up one bit.

What you haven't taken into account is that MP was involved in 17 of our PL goals last season which was up there with some of the best midfielders in the top flight.In a team that had the worst XG out of any team in the league (some going that dont you think?)+ Whilst signing a new lengthy contract. 

I'd say the club have fu**** up BIG TIME!      

Oh an by my reckoning there are over 3weeks left in the transfer window (which in the way we've operated within it in the past is a eternity)

There was nobody else in for Grant, and he'd gone on strike in a bid to force move to us through.... Hudds still got £16m out of us, despite not having a pot to piss in to pay their players. Not a hugely different scenario, but they managed to extract well over the odds for their asset.

Sorry Ronnie, I get the massive money waved in front of MP's nose reduced our wiggle room, but we have sold a player for much less than he's worth after allowing a club and player bully us into a sale... and as for the  fact we got him for a reduced fee, that really doesn't impact what he's worth now.
Reply
Great post Ronnie. Fair points and I do agree with most it.

I’d like to reply in the spirit of the board to it by saying: “Hi Ken!” though.
Reply
(08-05-2021, 12:58 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 12:29 PM)Anew Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 11:47 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Laughing at the comments saying WBA have f***** up here! 

No they havent. 

You can only sell to a buyer and they generally will only pay what they want to pay. A player is worth what a buyer values them at. 

Those slating the club….. again…..

Ask yourself these questions:

Why were sporting happy to sell for pennies (in reality) - £8m
Why were WBA the only club willing to pay the £8m but only 12 months down the line IF we went up?
Why were other clubs not interested in taking him after a decent season in the Bundesliga? 
Why were no other clubs interested in MP after a very good season in the premier league? 

People in Football circles talk to each other - make no mistake.  We took a gamble on him knowing that it was a minimal fee in relative terms offset against £8.7m transfer fee 12 months down the line.  

We went up so another £4.5m top up to reach the £8.7m fee was easily done with promotion.

We earned circa £100m as a club getting promoted and with that secured the future of the club for a number of years, covered the losses of covid and are now on a sound financial footing.

1 year later the same player wants to leave.
1 year later we have a new manager with a different philosophy.
1 year later we are in the championship and flex down wages come into play…usually around 50% reduction.

We only receive 1 concrete offer of double the money we spent on this player only 1 year ago. 

We have a manager who’s not that fussed on him. 

We have a player who wants to go and earn £77k a week, near as damn it treble his earnings for the coming season. 

I’d say the club hasn’t fu**** up one bit.

What you haven't taken into account is that MP was involved in 17 of our PL goals last season which was up there with some of the best midfielders in the top flight.In a team that had the worst XG out of any team in the league (some going that dont you think?)+ Whilst signing a new lengthy contract. 

I'd say the club have fu**** up BIG TIME!      

Oh an by my reckoning there are over 3weeks left in the transfer window (which in the way we've operated within it in the past is a eternity)

There was nobody else in for Grant, and he'd gone on strike in a bid to force move to us through.... Hudds still got £16m out of us, despite not having a pot to piss in to pay their players. Not a hugely different scenario, but they managed to extract well over the odds for their asset.

Sorry Ronnie, I get the massive money waved in front of MP's nose reduced our wiggle room, but we have sold a player for much less than he's worth after allowing a club and player bully us into a sale... and as for the  fact we got him for a reduced fee, that really doesn't impact what he's worth now.

So you want a disruptive player in the squad in the hope someone stumps up 20-30m and pays the player nearly 80k a week? At the same time you will be moaning about the depth of the squad and presumably the lack of money we have for players.

Righteo… nurse!
Reply
(08-05-2021, 07:46 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 07:37 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Let's look at it this way.

We doubled the fee we paid for a player, a player who doesn't want to play for us, the manager doesn't want, and with time to spend the money.

The only club he wants to go to is Al-Hilal so there was never going to be a bidding war, no prem club wants to even talk to his representives.

Yes it sucks its under the value most of us would place, but a player is only worth what someone will pay, and no one thought he was worth much more.

Shit situation, but the money in is enough to do the squad building we need, and get us promoted, and the riches from promotion are a lot more.

Glad when he's gone now tbh, shown his true colours this summer. Though fans will never have a bad word said against him it seems.

Let's look at it this way.

We've sold a player for less than half what clubs have sold equivalent players for in this window.

We gave in to a player's demands and set a precedent for any future player who wants to leave.

After starting the summer with allegations our owner was openly trying to defraud the club of revenue by offering MP to clubs in China at a cut price fee in return for a large backhander, we've sold our star player significantly under market value to a club in a country where our owner has sizeable business interests which have already had a questionable influence in the running of our club.

MP is of course not blameless in this - and maybe in years to come he'll realise that he's old himself short and taken the dodgy cash - but the club have shown their true colours here, and we are weak, spineless and only concerned about lining our owners' pockets.
What worries me is if the Saudis have this much influence over Lai, how many more of our prized assets could go the same way , very worrying times and for me this stinks of corruption and if ever proven you just know it will be the club and us fans that suffer the consequences. You can just see it can't you, the Vile only hours away from the taxman putting them into liquidation then their jam kicks in and come up smelling of roses,,,and us shafted out of the league due to some far east/middle east dodgy dealings.
Reply
A player is only worth what buyers will pay! Simple as that.

Clubs know, including WBA believe it or not, if bigger bids are on the way or have a chance. Agents will know even earlier…..it’s football! 

IF huge IF leic were interested they’d have signalled a price. Same with Villa -
Never happening as got matey from Norwich.  West Ham made an offer…. 

To go and play for Leic for example he’d easily have picked up £50-60k per week.   

Do you really think his agent NOT MP (make no mistake) would have been pushing the Saudi deal if he knew premier league offers were on the table…. of course he wouldn’t! 

This was the only viable deal available for MP, Agent and WBA. 

We haven’t f**** up!  It’s the market! It’s his reputation in the game.  It’s his contract. It’s the fact we’re selling from the championship and not the premier league.  

We should be happy to double our money, have an unhappy player gone and have the time to reinvest some of the money in good time, not on deadline day.
Reply
(08-05-2021, 12:29 PM)Anew Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 11:47 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Laughing at the comments saying WBA have f***** up here! 

No they havent. 

You can only sell to a buyer and they generally will only pay what they want to pay. A player is worth what a buyer values them at. 

Those slating the club….. again…..

Ask yourself these questions:

Why were sporting happy to sell for pennies (in reality) - £8m
Why were WBA the only club willing to pay the £8m but only 12 months down the line IF we went up?
Why were other clubs not interested in taking him after a decent season in the Bundesliga? 
Why were no other clubs interested in MP after a very good season in the premier league? 

People in Football circles talk to each other - make no mistake.  We took a gamble on him knowing that it was a minimal fee in relative terms offset against £8.7m transfer fee 12 months down the line.  

We went up so another £4.5m top up to reach the £8.7m fee was easily done with promotion.

We earned circa £100m as a club getting promoted and with that secured the future of the club for a number of years, covered the losses of covid and are now on a sound financial footing.

1 year later the same player wants to leave.
1 year later we have a new manager with a different philosophy.
1 year later we are in the championship and flex down wages come into play…usually around 50% reduction.

We only receive 1 concrete offer of double the money we spent on this player only 1 year ago. 

We have a manager who’s not that fussed on him. 

We have a player who wants to go and earn £77k a week, near as damn it treble his earnings for the coming season. 

I’d say the club hasn’t fu**** up one bit.

What you haven't taken into account is that MP was involved in 17 of our PL goals last season which was up there with some of the best midfielders in the top flight.In a team that had the worst XG out of any team in the league (some going that dont you think?)+ Whilst signing a new lengthy contract. 

I'd say the club have fu**** up BIG TIME!      

Oh an by my reckoning there are over 3weeks left in the transfer window (which in the way we've operated within it in the past is a eternity)

Spot on, Ronnie completely blinkered with his thoughts here

Makes ZERO sense to sell now, if the fee is 17m all we have to do is reject it

Even telling MP in the summer he could leave a fee of 25-30m nobody would have had no issue with, especially MP

Yes we need to sell to buy, well allegedly but accepting such a low market figure for our most prized asset is shocking business

Say what you like about Roland and I was hardly his biggest fan he would have been sold for closer to double that under his watch

Yes, we’ve fucked up here!

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)