Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
07-31-2021, 12:56 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-31-2021, 12:57 PM by Kit Kat Chunky.)
Now the pre-season is coming to end, and politics seem to have gone away from the main board, I thought I would pop my head above the parapet again for Duffers to take aim
Over the past 2 weeks, the way I see it :-
1. Sealprick is on his way. I only hope the Seals spunk their £100M in the way that Spurs dealt with the Bale money. They only made a profit on one player they brought from those proceeds, and that was Chadwank........
2. Ken seems very charming, but S4A still aren't happy. The club are going to have to declare a dividend, to clear the inter-company loan. By my maths that will need us to declare a profit of £5M, pay Corp Tax of £1M, so that the minority shareholders can receive a payout of c£500K. If that is in West Brom's best interests, they should hold their heads in shame. Their actions are no better than those of our former owner in my eyes.
3. The E&D completely do not understand the background to the above, and are mis-reporting history. They are running a column that claims that others (I choose my words carefully) are suggesting the offending loan was used to purchase shares by JRP. My recollection of history is that a rights/consolidation issue was held, underwritten by a loan from Barclays Bank. Those whose shareholding was below the minimum were given the option to purchase more shares in a 10 for 1 consolidation, or the club (not JRP) would buy the shares back, and cancel the shares. Less shares in existence led to an increased shareholding for JRP. I'm sure the share guru Prag will correct if I'm wrong on that. I usually am!!
Bring on the kick off on Friday Night. I can't wait.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(07-31-2021, 12:56 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Now the pre-season is coming to end, and politics seem to have gone away from the main board, I thought I would pop my head above the parapet again for Duffers to take aim 
Over the past 2 weeks, the way I see it :-
1. Sealprick is on his way. I only hope the Seals spunk their £100M in the way that Spurs dealt with the Bale money. They only made a profit on one player they brought from those proceeds, and that was Chadwank........
2. Ken seems very charming, but S4A still aren't happy. The club are going to have to declare a dividend, to clear the inter-company loan. By my maths that will need us to declare a profit of £5M, pay Corp Tax of £1M, so that the minority shareholders can receive a payout of c£500K. If that is in West Brom's best interests, they should hold their heads in shame. Their actions are no better than those of our former owner in my eyes.
3. The E&D completely do not understand the background to the above, and are mis-reporting history. They are running a column that claims that others (I choose my words carefully) are suggesting the offending loan was used to purchase shares by JRP. My recollection of history is that a rights/consolidation issue was held, underwritten by a loan from Barclays Bank. Those whose shareholding was below the minimum were given the option to purchase more shares in a 10 for 1 consolidation, or the club (not JRP) would buy the shares back, and cancel the shares. Less shares in existence led to an increased shareholding for JRP. I'm sure the share guru Prag will correct if I'm wrong on that. I usually am!!
Bring on the kick off on Friday Night. I can't wait.
Do you mean the owners or the minority shareholders?
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(07-31-2021, 05:55 PM)Squid Wrote: (07-31-2021, 12:56 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Now the pre-season is coming to end, and politics seem to have gone away from the main board, I thought I would pop my head above the parapet again for Duffers to take aim 
Over the past 2 weeks, the way I see it :-
1. Sealprick is on his way. I only hope the Seals spunk their £100M in the way that Spurs dealt with the Bale money. They only made a profit on one player they brought from those proceeds, and that was Chadwank........
2. Ken seems very charming, but S4A still aren't happy. The club are going to have to declare a dividend, to clear the inter-company loan. By my maths that will need us to declare a profit of £5M, pay Corp Tax of £1M, so that the minority shareholders can receive a payout of c£500K. If that is in West Brom's best interests, they should hold their heads in shame. Their actions are no better than those of our former owner in my eyes.
3. The E&D completely do not understand the background to the above, and are mis-reporting history. They are running a column that claims that others (I choose my words carefully) are suggesting the offending loan was used to purchase shares by JRP. My recollection of history is that a rights/consolidation issue was held, underwritten by a loan from Barclays Bank. Those whose shareholding was below the minimum were given the option to purchase more shares in a 10 for 1 consolidation, or the club (not JRP) would buy the shares back, and cancel the shares. Less shares in existence led to an increased shareholding for JRP. I'm sure the share guru Prag will correct if I'm wrong on that. I usually am!!
Bring on the kick off on Friday Night. I can't wait.
Do you mean the owners or the minority shareholders?
Minority Shareholders. The owners dividend will most likely stay within the group structure. It's a common arrangement.
Posts: 1,060
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
Firstly, paying a dividend has no impact on corporation tax. If we make a profit we pay tax regardless of whether any dividend is paid ( though we will have brought forward losses to reduce any tax payable on last year’s profit). Secondly, the minority shareholders are not looking for a dividend, in fact they have stated they’re not happy with this suggestion though they have no way of stopping it.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(07-31-2021, 12:56 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Now the pre-season is coming to end, and politics seem to have gone away from the main board, I thought I would pop my head above the parapet again for Duffers to take aim 
Over the past 2 weeks, the way I see it :-
1. Sealprick is on his way. I only hope the Seals spunk their £100M in the way that Spurs dealt with the Bale money. They only made a profit on one player they brought from those proceeds, and that was Chadwank........
2. Ken seems very charming, but S4A still aren't happy. The club are going to have to declare a dividend, to clear the inter-company loan. By my maths that will need us to declare a profit of £5M, pay Corp Tax of £1M, so that the minority shareholders can receive a payout of c£500K. If that is in West Brom's best interests, they should hold their heads in shame. Their actions are no better than those of our former owner in my eyes.
3. The E&D completely do not understand the background to the above, and are mis-reporting history. They are running a column that claims that others (I choose my words carefully) are suggesting the offending loan was used to purchase shares by JRP. My recollection of history is that a rights/consolidation issue was held, underwritten by a loan from Barclays Bank. Those whose shareholding was below the minimum were given the option to purchase more shares in a 10 for 1 consolidation, or the club (not JRP) would buy the shares back, and cancel the shares. Less shares in existence led to an increased shareholding for JRP. I'm sure the share guru Prag will correct if I'm wrong on that. I usually am!!
Bring on the kick off on Friday Night. I can't wait.
You most likely missed the bitches bitching about me. So nowt new. As you were
Posts: 236
Threads: 4
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
(07-31-2021, 06:48 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Firstly, paying a dividend has no impact on corporation tax. If we make a profit we pay tax regardless of whether any dividend is paid ( though we will have brought forward losses to reduce any tax payable on last year’s profit). Secondly, the minority shareholders are not looking for a dividend, in fact they have stated they’re not happy with this suggestion though they have no way of stopping it.
I think the point KKC was making (he will no doubt correct me if I’m wrong) was that we’d have to make a profit of £5m and then after tax the remaining funds available to distribute as a dividend would be sufficient to pay off the loan. And as Lai controls all the various entities within the structure all they will have achieved (other than getting a £500k dividend for themselves) is to get him to move his own money around the club.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
07-31-2021, 07:37 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-31-2021, 07:39 PM by Kit Kat Chunky.)
(07-31-2021, 06:48 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Firstly, paying a dividend has no impact on corporation tax. If we make a profit we pay tax regardless of whether any dividend is paid ( though we will have brought forward losses to reduce any tax payable on last year’s profit). Secondly, the minority shareholders are not looking for a dividend, in fact they have stated they’re not happy with this suggestion though they have no way of stopping it.
I'm fully aware when Corp is payable, and also how you mitigate profit by managing the amortisation of players contracts. We have to have distributable reserves to pay a dividend.
S4A may be saying they don't want a divi, but they are acknowledging they cannot prevent it. The club are having to do this to make the problem go away.
When I was a shareholder I wouldn't join S4A. I thought they were a group of self centred wankers with an agenda. I've seen nothing in this whole episode to change my opinion.
(07-31-2021, 07:22 PM)Juan Quidonqui Wrote: (07-31-2021, 06:48 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Firstly, paying a dividend has no impact on corporation tax. If we make a profit we pay tax regardless of whether any dividend is paid ( though we will have brought forward losses to reduce any tax payable on last year’s profit). Secondly, the minority shareholders are not looking for a dividend, in fact they have stated they’re not happy with this suggestion though they have no way of stopping it.
I think the point KKC was making (he will no doubt correct me if I’m wrong) was that we’d have to make a profit of £5m and then after tax the remaining funds available to distribute as a dividend would be sufficient to pay off the loan. And as Lai controls all the various entities within the structure all they will have achieved (other than getting a £500k dividend for themselves) is to get him to move his own money around the club.
I couldn't have put it better myself
Posts: 2,144
Threads: 75
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
You missed the discussion on invisible users.
Posts: 1,060
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(07-31-2021, 07:22 PM)Juan Quidonqui Wrote: (07-31-2021, 06:48 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Firstly, paying a dividend has no impact on corporation tax. If we make a profit we pay tax regardless of whether any dividend is paid ( though we will have brought forward losses to reduce any tax payable on last year’s profit). Secondly, the minority shareholders are not looking for a dividend, in fact they have stated they’re not happy with this suggestion though they have no way of stopping it.
I think the point KKC was making (he will no doubt correct me if I’m wrong) was that we’d have to make a profit of £5m and then after tax the remaining funds available to distribute as a dividend would be sufficient to pay off the loan. And as Lai controls all the various entities within the structure all they will have achieved (other than getting a £500k dividend for themselves) is to get him to move his own money around the club.
Absolutely (and we actually have enough distributable reserves to pay a dividend before any 2020/21 profit is declared). All that a dividend would go is to reduce any cash we have by whatever is the amount going to the minority shareholders while any payment due to Lai would cancel out his loan plus interest. This is explicitly not what the shareholders want but was always the very logical way the Board could get the loan paid off.
Posts: 236
Threads: 4
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
Maybe that’s all part of Lai’s cunning plan. Provide a ‘solution’ to get the loan paid off as S4A have requested - but in the process, as S4A are the only ones who have gained (via the £500k dividend they receive) it makes them look like greedy bastards and any support they may have from others soon evaporates. Lai may consider that £500k to stop all the questions is a small price to pay. Sly little bugger.
|