Harper - Johansen
#1
When we all picked our side for tonight think I was alone in going Johansen over Harper, tonight summed up exactly the reason why

Big game you need the players who have the experience

Harper is a top top talent but he doesn’t take games by the scruff of the neck and for the first 35 tonight the game just passed him by, he looked lethargic ,followed the ball and the play, created nothing and barely put a challenge in all night

Should have been used from the bench tonight, big mistake from Moore from me that, real shame to lose Murphy too just as he was hitting form

Crap tonight given it was such a big game but we are so predictable at home, not won all year I think is the stat, and similar to Forest, Wednesday and many others we give them a goal head start and continue to play like the away side at home, must have a plan B at home, I’d rather see us go 3412 or at least change to it, we need Gayle and Jayrod through the middle

Marks 

Johnson 6 good handling from crosses, getting heaps for distribution when clearly following orders

Holgate 6 final ball let him down

Gibbs 6 Such a player but why is he not getting to the byeline anymore, everything seems to come down our right

Dawson 5 did ok against the physical Sharp

Hegazi 6 pick of the two, shame we lost him

Barry 4 Nothing went for him tonight, sides that crowd him quickly cause us problems

Harper 5 nothing for first half, improved in 2nd but static without ball

Livermore 6 six for effort, kept trying but a ball winner at best

Jayrod 5 Nothing worked for him, offered little

Gayle 5 One of those games where it’s crying out to play him centrally

Phillips 6 Encouraging return to the side

Subs

Montero 6 lively when given the ball in right areas

Tosin 7* Medine really put it on him and he bossed that battle and passed out from the back better than any of the others, difficult game to come off the bench but thought he did very well

Edwards 6 not enough time

Can’t afford to lose at Leeds

Cuzer
Reply
#2
Agree with all that.
Reply
#3
Same here.
Reply
#4
Good post
In the form of his life.
Reply
#5
As much as I detest Tosin I would agree he was MOTM.

I may be a bit radical here but there is a formation called 4-4-2 which would put Gayle and J Rod central together. Montero and Phillips wide. Obviously it isn’t so sexy as Hoolahan or Harper as flash nine but doubtless more effective.
Reply
#6
How would 4-4-2 help link the attack and midfield? That's the issue. We don't hot balls out wide which that sort of style relies on.
Reply
#7
Yep, pretty much spot on. Harper very much looked like a youth team player today
Reply
#8
(02-23-2019, 09:23 PM)clem4england Wrote: As much as I detest Tosin I would agree he was MOTM.

I may be a bit radical here but there is a formation called 4-4-2 which would put Gayle and J Rod central together. Montero and Phillips wide. Obviously it isn’t so sexy as Hoolahan or Harper as flash nine but doubtless more effective.

The best formation the current set of players would suit is 4.2.3.1

Gayle up top with JRod as the centre of the 3 behind him with Murphy/Montero/Phillips as the choice out wide.
Reply
#9
You’re such a know it all prick Cuzer. Always right aren’t you
Reply
#10
It does make you realise how important HRK is to 4-3-3. He is infuriating at times but when it clicks he offers a lot to the team. I think shifting Phillips back to midfield should help link up play to the attack and try Gayle in the middle with Rodriguez and Montero/Murphy and allow them more freedom to swap central and wide positions to create space. Agree with the comment about Gibbs - allow him to get forward more he can fucking cross a ball. Get Holgate on extra crossing practice all week!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)