Funding Social Care
#31
I'm not afraid to say it.

If you've got to pensionable age, and haven't even bothered to get a private pension, or pay into a decent work pension, it's your own fault, not the government's. I'm now blessed of course with my NHS pension, I also have a small, but high risk/yield private pension as an extra. I'll also inherit a decent amount from my parents which will be invested.

Especially those now coming to pensionable age, they've had ample opportunity and chances, if you can't afford to retire, then you don't get to.

Cruel I know, but there is little reason for people coming to pension age now, haven't managed to do anything.

They can certainly still pay tax.
Reply
#32
(07-21-2021, 02:43 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm not afraid to say it.

If you've got to pensionable age, and haven't even bothered to get a private pension, or pay into a decent work pension, it's your own fault, not the government's. I'm now blessed of course with my NHS pension, I also have a small, but high risk/yield private pension as an extra. I'll also inherit a decent amount from my parents which will be invested.

Especially those now coming to pensionable age, they've had ample opportunity and chances, if you can't afford yo retire, then you don't get to.

Cruel I know, but there is little reason for people coming yo pension age now, haven't managed to do anything.

They can certainly still pay tax.

Not exactly going to have much of a pension on £67 per week which is what a carer gets for looking after someone full time. Saving the government thousands in care costs and rewarded with very little.
Reply
#33
(07-21-2021, 02:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 02:43 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm not afraid to say it.

If you've got to pensionable age, and haven't even bothered to get a private pension, or pay into a decent work pension, it's your own fault, not the government's. I'm now blessed of course with my NHS pension, I also have a small, but high risk/yield private pension as an extra. I'll also inherit a decent amount from my parents which will be invested.

Especially those now coming to pensionable age, they've had ample opportunity and chances, if you can't afford yo retire, then you don't get to.

Cruel I know, but there is little reason for people coming yo pension age now, haven't managed to do anything.

They can certainly still pay tax.

Not exactly going to have much of a pension on £67 per week which is what a carer gets for looking after someone full time. Saving the government thousands in care costs and rewarded with very little.

Yeah there we have some agreement for sure, and there is a glaring issue with the current model.

I should have clarified, I am solely on about those "that worked all my adult life" types. Not those that have been unable to work for various reasons.
Reply
#34
(07-21-2021, 11:42 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: That isn't how this works.

JOK's figures are irrelevant, you can't interpolate median incomes to tax distribution as you ignore compounded bands, a mean would be better but even then it's on a scale. You're also forgetting that everyone is liable to pay income tax. The Lib Dems already costed a penny in the pound income tax increase and it was £5bn per annum as per 2017 with everyone from pensioners to 18 year olds being liable instead of just those under 66. The issue of fairness is that the Tories want only those under 66 to pay for the costs of those over 66 instead of everyone helping to pay. That's not even to mention that people on lower incomes pay a higher proportion of NI from their salary than the wealthiest regardless.

If you want to justify tax increases to pay for social care, the only way it can possibly fair is for it to be based on income tax. Increasing NI is taking the piss and protecting the incomes of the wealthy and pensioners at the expense of young workers.

BB is right.

(07-21-2021, 02:43 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm now blessed of course with my NHS pension

If we're talking about fairness don't get me onto the risk / valuation / tax treatment of public sector pensions vs private sector pensions - another huge schism developing.
Reply
#35
(07-21-2021, 03:39 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 11:42 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: That isn't how this works.

JOK's figures are irrelevant, you can't interpolate median incomes to tax distribution as you ignore compounded bands, a mean would be better but even then it's on a scale. You're also forgetting that everyone is liable to pay income tax. The Lib Dems already costed a penny in the pound income tax increase and it was £5bn per annum as per 2017 with everyone from pensioners to 18 year olds being liable instead of just those under 66. The issue of fairness is that the Tories want only those under 66 to pay for the costs of those over 66 instead of everyone helping to pay. That's not even to mention that people on lower incomes pay a higher proportion of NI from their salary than the wealthiest regardless.

If you want to justify tax increases to pay for social care, the only way it can possibly fair is for it to be based on income tax. Increasing NI is taking the piss and protecting the incomes of the wealthy and pensioners at the expense of young workers.

BB is right.

(07-21-2021, 02:43 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm now blessed of course with my NHS pension

If we're talking about fairness don't get me onto the risk / valuation / tax treatment of public sector pensions vs private sector pensions - another huge schism developing.

And again, definately some agreement there too.
Reply
#36
The nurses getting their 1.5% pay cut would say that it's not a race to the bottom and there's value in collectivism rather than blindly voting for the same football team every year.

Oops. 3%.

As you were
Reply
#37
(07-21-2021, 11:42 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 10:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Using JOKs figures of average of £16k a year that is an extra 1p on £3.5k amounting to £35 for the c.10M pensioners equates to £350M (the old weekly payment to the EU coincidently Wink ) 

Taking into account the annual UK Tax income of £550Bn that is an extra 0.1% generated by taxing pensioners. Well worth it  Rolleyes

That isn't how this works.

JOK's figures are irrelevant, you can't interpolate median incomes to tax distribution as you ignore compounded bands, a mean would be better but even then it's on a scale. You're also forgetting that everyone is liable to pay income tax. The Lib Dems already costed a penny in the pound income tax increase and it was £5bn per annum as per 2017 with everyone from pensioners to 18 year olds being liable instead of just those under 66. The issue of fairness is that the Tories want only those under 66 to pay for the costs of those over 66 instead of everyone helping to pay. That's not even to mention that people on lower incomes pay a higher proportion of NI from their salary than the wealthiest regardless.

You were comparing one extreme with another (and not that accurately, really)


The figures I posted show that the reality is somewhat different than you were portraying. Simply put, the average 18 year old has an income higher than the average pensioner and remember, the very fact it’s an average means that many youngsters are earning more than £18 k and many pensioners are living on far less than £15k. A teen on the minimum wage will pay an extra £22.64 NI per year; barely a couple of ‘E’s or a spliff not even entry to an illegal rave. ( well, I get the impression that sweeping generalisations are perfectly acceptable to use. Angel )

Your £50 k pa 66 year olds are also paying income tax! Again, if a pensioner is picking up £50 thousand p.a. they get no state handouts for social care. If you have capital (not just income but total capital) over £23,250 you are liable for the full cost of care. Any property you may have is only ‘disregarded’ for the first 12 weeks to give you time to decide how you are going to allocate its value in regard to paying for your care.

My 99 year old mom has her state pension and the little bit of pension she receives from my late dad’s work’s pension all taken off her to pay towards her care home costs bar a small sum for ‘pocket money’ to pay for her hair do, pedicure and the occasional snack treats. Not quite living in the lap of luxury.  Having lived in a council house all her life she had no assets.)

I understand the view that increasing taxes rather than NI will catch all those with an income is fairer. It is actually the employers who pay a higher proportion as they continue with contributions after the employee has reached the upper cut off, so raising the UEL would make more sense and ensure that those on higher incomes contribute more.

Citing averages is more relevant than using the two extremes as you did.

(07-21-2021, 03:39 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 11:42 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: JOK's figures are irrelevant, 

BB is right.


No he isn’t!
 
Do you believe that all 18 / 19 year olds are earning less than the minimum wage?
Are you in agreement that many pensioners have investments that will return an income of £42,800 p.a.?
Do you agree, then, that working teens are “paying” for such pensioner’s social care?
Reply
#38
No, what's happened here is that you've completely misread what I've put, which was to highlight how one situation would be subject to tax increases and the other would not. And, as I've said repeatedly, I'm perfectly fine with an income tax increase instead of an NI increase as it's fairer. Now, either engage the point or fuck off
Reply
#39
BB is right again.
Reply
#40
(07-23-2021, 07:21 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, what's happened here is that you've completely misread what I've put, which was to highlight how one situation would be subject to tax increases and the other would not. And, as I've said repeatedly, I'm perfectly fine with an income tax increase instead of an NI increase as it's fairer. Now, either engage the point or fuck off

A bit harsh BB tbf
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)