Covid Vaccination ID
(07-21-2021, 10:18 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: Why is only a 3 month period of immunity being assumed if you have actually had Covid?

Dunno Greek islands allow 6 months.

I know one thing, if this goes ahead there’ll be a load of illegal raves popping up.
Reply
(07-21-2021, 10:22 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 10:18 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: Why is only a 3 month period of immunity being assumed if you have actually had Covid?

Dunno Greek islands allow 6 months.

I know one thing, if this goes ahead there’ll be a load of illegal raves popping up.

The best kind of rave imo  Cool
Reply
(07-21-2021, 10:13 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 08:23 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 07:21 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Out of interest how many of the bodily autonomy brigade would use said autonomy to refuse a vaccine that by every metric, will make you safer in the current climate?

Given I've taken the piss out of anti-vax loons for years, understand that the Covid vaccines have been approved quicker than normal as they were given permission to undergo regulatory compliance checks in parallel instead of sequentially, know that there have been hundreds of millions of people with the vaccine now with no substantial side effects and have been jabbed, no I would not refuse the vaccine.

I just don't like the idea of the state blackmailing citizens nor the potential for a two-tier society developing, not to mention the issue of feature creep. And I don't see how this is going to address the issue of the anti-vax loons being anti-vax loons as all this will do well entrench their views by socially isolating them and would push people affected by restrictions who aren't anti-vax loons towards them increasing the risk of radicalisation.

Good points. It won’t change the mind of those who don’t want it, not many anyway. And it will entrench views of some.

And it is the state overstepping the mark.

The thin end of the wedge too. What’s next? Shops? Not allowed out their house? Wear a badge to say unvaccinated? Round them up and put them in certain towns? Why stop at covid? Wear a badge to say you’ve got an STI in case you’re out on the pull? I know I’m giving extreme stupid examples but the whole thing turns my stomach tbh.

Fixed it for you, throughout all this you are lacking on any plan or ideas to stop the increasing numbers in hospital though. Testing on a large scale is impractical for venues, evidence of having had it seems reasonable but is only delaying the inevitable jab as people are unlikely to keep re-infecting every 3 months (or 6 months if you like - I went with the CDC US advice for travel time) but it does solve the short term problem.

More spread = more infections = more in hospital = more deaths (not just covid), that carries a bit more weight than an individuals right to get out on a Saturday night.

(07-21-2021, 10:22 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 10:18 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: Why is only a 3 month period of immunity being assumed if you have actually had Covid?

Dunno Greek islands allow 6 months.

I know one thing, if this goes ahead there’ll be a load of illegal raves popping up.

There are already aren't there, that's always been the case.
Reply
So does the vaccine offer longer immunity? In view of the booster talk it doesn't seem to.

Will everyone be queuing up for top-ups every few months? I know plenty of people who had had both jabs who say they won't have any more so I assume they will fall into the outcasts of society if there passport is not renewed.
Reply
They may be stupid examples to you but they’re examples of the thicker end of the wedge, to illustrate a point. 12 months ago if someone would have suggested coercing vaccination to get in places I think everyone would have thought they were insane. It’s not going to end at nightclubs. It’s not going to be temporary IMO. And it’s not going to end with the covid jab.

I don’t see why testing in impractical, it was literally used at the test events.

I genuinely hope people really kick off about this. I think it’s disgusting and I can only think those in favour have lost their mind through fear of this disease and 24/7 coverage of it.

As for the raves, there’ll be a huge increase, and underground parties/pubs. Then police time will be taken up raiding these rather than catching criminals. It’s insanity. I hope starmer has the balls to vote it down along with the inevitable bunch of 50 ish tories who will. Thank god for the Lib Dem’s IMO. Not very often i say that.

(07-21-2021, 10:45 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: So does the vaccine offer longer immunity? In view of the booster talk it doesn't seem to.

Will everyone be queuing up for top-ups every few months? I know plenty of people who had had both jabs who say they won't have any more so I assume they will fall into the outcasts of society if there passport is not renewed.

Same here. I know one who had the first and won’t have another. I can’t believe people can’t see how this is going to creep.

The answer always given is what else do we do about hospital numbers. I don’t know. But what I’d say baggy1 is if this gets worse and worse, and the science says that’s it you can’t go out, no family, stay in other than half hour walk a day for 5 years, would you support this? After all there’s no other option. The science and the numbers in hospital say that’s it. Online shopping only, wfh and not go out at all.

Theoretical (and you’ll say stupid), but what would be your stance if the stats and science said this was the situation? Where would you draw the line on freedom of choice in this theoretical scenario?
Reply
(07-21-2021, 10:50 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: They may be stupid examples to you but they’re examples of the thicker end of the wedge, to illustrate a point. 12 months ago if someone would have suggested coercing vaccination to get in places I think everyone would have thought they were insane. It’s not going to end at nightclubs. It’s not going to be temporary IMO. And it’s not going to end with the covid jab.

I don’t see why testing in impractical, it was literally used at the test events.

I genuinely hope people really kick off about this. I think it’s disgusting and I can only think those in favour have lost their mind through fear of this disease and 24/7 coverage of it.

As for the raves, there’ll be a huge increase, and underground parties/pubs. Then police time will be taken up raiding these rather than catching criminals. It’s insanity. I hope starmer has the balls to vote it down along with the inevitable bunch of 50 ish tories who will. Thank god for the Lib Dem’s IMO. Not very often i say that.


Test events had preparations in place and facilities with plenty of staff to check the results, do you think the average nightclub is going to employ a team outside the venue checking the validity of every test or jab passport every night until we get this under control, or do you think they are going to say 'sod that, jab passport only - show on the door to Val on reception'. It's impractical.

And if you think police catch criminals these days you really are still at the 90s raves.
Reply
(07-21-2021, 10:58 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 10:50 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: They may be stupid examples to you but they’re examples of the thicker end of the wedge, to illustrate a point. 12 months ago if someone would have suggested coercing vaccination to get in places I think everyone would have thought they were insane. It’s not going to end at nightclubs. It’s not going to be temporary IMO. And it’s not going to end with the covid jab.

I don’t see why testing in impractical, it was literally used at the test events.

I genuinely hope people really kick off about this. I think it’s disgusting and I can only think those in favour have lost their mind through fear of this disease and 24/7 coverage of it.

As for the raves, there’ll be a huge increase, and underground parties/pubs. Then police time will be taken up raiding these rather than catching criminals. It’s insanity. I hope starmer has the balls to vote it down along with the inevitable bunch of 50 ish tories who will. Thank god for the Lib Dem’s IMO. Not very often i say that.


Test events had preparations in place and facilities with plenty of staff to check the results, do you think the average nightclub is going to employ a team outside the venue checking the validity of every test or jab passport every night until we get this under control, or do you think they are going to say 'sod that, jab passport only - show on the door to Val on reception'. It's impractical.

And if you think police catch criminals these days you really are still at the 90s raves.

Well I’d like the police to have as much time as possible catching criminals! Silly me.

The average nightclub is dead against the suggested blackmail, and I hope there’s plenty who rebel.
Reply
(07-21-2021, 10:50 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:


The answer always given is what else do we do about hospital numbers. I don’t know. But what I’d say baggy1 is if this gets worse and worse, and the science says that’s it you can’t go out, no family, stay in other than half hour walk a day for 5 years, would you support this? After all there’s no other option. The science and the numbers in hospital say that’s it. Online shopping only, wfh and not go out at all.

Theoretical (and you’ll say stupid), but what would be your stance if the stats and science said this was the situation? Where would you draw the line on freedom of choice in this theoretical scenario?

You appear to be ignoring the improvements that we have seen from the jabs, they have reduced numbers to the point that they are the minority in hospital now. There are still 5 or 6M people not vaccinated at the moment, that is a huge pool to get 30k from. We will always have people in hospital with it, I would say for the next 5 years based on the Spanish Flu, but jabs keep those numbers down until we get that herd immunity. And yes we will need boosters, and as much as people say they aren't going to do it the longer we will be in this mess.

It is embarrassingly simple - we have to do something, refusing a jab on moral grounds aint going to make one jot of difference to the virus. The less people jabbed with regular boosters, the more will be in hospital and the more we will be shut down. Those are the real choices and if people don't like them they need to find a solution, doing nothing isn't that solution.
Reply
(07-21-2021, 11:05 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 10:50 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:


The answer always given is what else do we do about hospital numbers. I don’t know. But what I’d say baggy1 is if this gets worse and worse, and the science says that’s it you can’t go out, no family, stay in other than half hour walk a day for 5 years, would you support this? After all there’s no other option. The science and the numbers in hospital say that’s it. Online shopping only, wfh and not go out at all.

Theoretical (and you’ll say stupid), but what would be your stance if the stats and science said this was the situation? Where would you draw the line on freedom of choice in this theoretical scenario?

You appear to be ignoring the improvements that we have seen from the jabs, they have reduced numbers to the point that they are the minority in hospital now. There are still 5 or 6M people not vaccinated at the moment, that is a huge pool to get 30k from. We will always have people in hospital with it, I would say for the next 5 years based on the Spanish Flu, but jabs keep those numbers down until we get that herd immunity. And yes we will need boosters, and as much as people say they aren't going to do it the longer we will be in this mess.

It is embarrassingly simple - we have to do something, refusing a jab on moral grounds aint going to make one jot of difference to the virus. The less people jabbed with regular boosters, the more will be in hospital and the more we will be shut down. Those are the real choices and if people don't like them they need to find a solution, doing nothing isn't that solution.

My example isn’t going to happen, I know that. It was theoretical. Im asking because you always base your stance totally on science and numbers in hospital (fair enough). I’m wondering in a worse scenario like I’ve described, what would them be your stance? At what point would you say bollocks I’m not doing what the government tells me to/blackmails me to?

Just completely theoretical. Because I believe this is the stance with many people. They see their choices and freedoms being chipped away at (even though as you say it’s backed up by science, and I don’t agree with those who complain about very small ‘hardships’). So in a worse scenario, theoretically, is there anything you wouldn’t do that the government asked you to to help the situation?
Reply
(07-21-2021, 11:00 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 10:58 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 10:50 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: They may be stupid examples to you but they’re examples of the thicker end of the wedge, to illustrate a point. 12 months ago if someone would have suggested coercing vaccination to get in places I think everyone would have thought they were insane. It’s not going to end at nightclubs. It’s not going to be temporary IMO. And it’s not going to end with the covid jab.

I don’t see why testing in impractical, it was literally used at the test events.

I genuinely hope people really kick off about this. I think it’s disgusting and I can only think those in favour have lost their mind through fear of this disease and 24/7 coverage of it.

As for the raves, there’ll be a huge increase, and underground parties/pubs. Then police time will be taken up raiding these rather than catching criminals. It’s insanity. I hope starmer has the balls to vote it down along with the inevitable bunch of 50 ish tories who will. Thank god for the Lib Dem’s IMO. Not very often i say that.


Test events had preparations in place and facilities with plenty of staff to check the results, do you think the average nightclub is going to employ a team outside the venue checking the validity of every test or jab passport every night until we get this under control, or do you think they are going to say 'sod that, jab passport only - show on the door to Val on reception'. It's impractical.

And if you think police catch criminals these days you really are still at the 90s raves.

Well I’d like the police to have as much time as possible catching criminals! Silly me.

The average nightclub is dead against the suggested blackmail, and I hope there’s plenty who rebel.

Seriously, do you think the Police have time to catch criminals these days? The West Mids was stripped of officers in the last 20 years and stations closed down all of the time. My boss had her car nicked off the drive and a CSO came out 4 days later.

And the average nightclub will be against it, not on a moral ground but on the knowledge that they will not just lose customers that haven't been jabbed but also that al those underage drinkers won't be able to show a jab - that's purely financial.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)