Funding Social Care
#21
What this has to do with anything BB is how many retired people are on £50k? That must be a minuscule amount of people relatively.
Reply
#22
No shit, the number of pensioners with a £50k income isn't the point though. The issue is that those pensioners with a £50k income who can afford a tax rise and will benefit from an increase in publicly funded social care as part of their demographic will not have an increase to their tax but an 18 year old on £10k will be having their tax increased instead. How is that fair? Why is NI going up when pensioners, regardless of their income, don't pay it? Why couldn't this have been funded via a penny in the pound income tax increase? You can substitute more reasonable numbers instead and the point doesn't change, a nursing graduate in London on £24k a year is having their tax increased to cover this while a pensioner with a £20k income living in North Wales isn't.
Reply
#23
(07-21-2021, 10:05 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No shit, the number of pensioners with a £50k income isn't the point though. The issue is that those pensioners with a £50k income who can afford a tax rise and will benefit from an increase in publicly funded social care as part of their demographic will not have an increase to their tax but an 18 year old on £10k will be having their tax increased instead. How is that fair? Why is NI going up when pensioners, regardless of their income, don't pay it? Why couldn't this have been funded via a penny in the pound income tax increase?

You completely miss the point that nobody, of any age, not working  pays NI - it is basically a tax on work.
Should pensioners in work pay NI - yes they should but I doubt anyone that is getting 50k a year will be employed
And why should there be a lower level of NI for those who earn above a certain amount ?
Reply
#24
The question is more: Are there any on £50k or even £40k.

The point is valid though about the youngsters but pitting young against old is another divide the country could do without. This is simply the wealthy being protected and benefitting again, nothing to do with their age.
Reply
#25
(07-21-2021, 10:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The question is more: Are there any on £50k or even £40k.

The point is valid though about the youngsters but pitting young against old is another divide the country could do without. This is simply the wealthy being protected and benefitting again, nothing to do with their age.

No - by sticking 1p on NI it's about the wealthy being proetected AND about pensioners being protected regardless of their wealth.
Reply
#26
(07-21-2021, 10:33 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 10:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The question is more: Are there any on £50k or even £40k.

The point is valid though about the youngsters but pitting young against old is another divide the country could do without. This is simply the wealthy being protected and benefitting again, nothing to do with their age.

No - by sticking 1p on NI it's about the wealthy being proetected AND about pensioners being protected regardless of their wealth.

Using JOKs figures of average of £16k a year that is an extra 1p on £3.5k amounting to £35 for the c.10M pensioners equates to £350M (the old weekly payment to the EU coincidently Wink ) 

Taking into account the annual UK Tax income of £550Bn that is an extra 0.1% generated by taxing pensioners. Well worth it  Rolleyes
Reply
#27
(07-21-2021, 10:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 10:33 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 10:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The question is more: Are there any on £50k or even £40k.

The point is valid though about the youngsters but pitting young against old is another divide the country could do without. This is simply the wealthy being protected and benefitting again, nothing to do with their age.

No - by sticking 1p on NI it's about the wealthy being proetected AND about pensioners being protected regardless of their wealth.

Using JOKs figures of average of £16k a year that is an extra 1p on £3.5k amounting to £35 for the c.10M pensioners equates to £350M (the old weekly payment to the EU coincidently Wink ) 

Taking into account the annual UK Tax income of £550Bn that is an extra 0.1% generated by taxing pensioners. Well worth it  Rolleyes

May not be if those 4 out of 10 pensioners who don't claim pension credit amounting to 1.6bn a year decide to claim it.

Surely it would be more equitable to use income tax as a vehicle. Pensioners do pay income tax as opposed to NI so it would not be discriminatory and surely there could be a way of protecting those on lower incomes.
Reply
#28
(07-21-2021, 10:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 10:33 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-21-2021, 10:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The question is more: Are there any on £50k or even £40k.

The point is valid though about the youngsters but pitting young against old is another divide the country could do without. This is simply the wealthy being protected and benefitting again, nothing to do with their age.

No - by sticking 1p on NI it's about the wealthy being proetected AND about pensioners being protected regardless of their wealth.

Using JOKs figures of average of £16k a year that is an extra 1p on £3.5k amounting to £35 for the c.10M pensioners equates to £350M (the old weekly payment to the EU coincidently Wink ) 

Taking into account the annual UK Tax income of £550Bn that is an extra 0.1% generated by taxing pensioners. Well worth it  Rolleyes

That isn't how this works.

JOK's figures are irrelevant, you can't interpolate median incomes to tax distribution as you ignore compounded bands, a mean would be better but even then it's on a scale. You're also forgetting that everyone is liable to pay income tax. The Lib Dems already costed a penny in the pound income tax increase and it was £5bn per annum as per 2017 with everyone from pensioners to 18 year olds being liable instead of just those under 66. The issue of fairness is that the Tories want only those under 66 to pay for the costs of those over 66 instead of everyone helping to pay. That's not even to mention that people on lower incomes pay a higher proportion of NI from their salary than the wealthiest regardless.

If you want to justify tax increases to pay for social care, the only way it can possibly fair is for it to be based on income tax. Increasing NI is taking the piss and protecting the incomes of the wealthy and pensioners at the expense of young workers.
Reply
#29
I might have misinterpreted here, but I didn't take BB's £50K figure as being his idea of typical pensioner income, more that it wouldn't be unknown for a retired couple to be approaching that level in 2021. Which is true, particularly in those cases where both have worked and are in receipt of both state and defined benefit occupational pensions.

Perhaps my judgement is somewhat coloured by having a 100-year-old mother whose catchphrase (one of 'em, anyway) is "We worked all our lives". If I'm not in the mood for it I'm prone to reminding her that she hasn't worked at all for forty years. I don't resent the comfortable circumstances of some retirees, but I do think that - when it comes to raising income from the public - governments are often inclined to take the view that there are some places we can always look, and others which are forever out of bounds.

Might be just a perception.
Reply
#30
(07-21-2021, 01:02 PM)Ossian Wrote: I might have misinterpreted here, but I didn't take BB's £50K figure as being his idea of typical pensioner income, more that it wouldn't be unknown for a retired couple to be approaching that level in 2021. Which is true, particularly in those cases where both have worked and are in receipt of both state and defined benefit occupational pensions.

Perhaps my judgement is somewhat coloured by having a 100-year-old mother whose catchphrase (one of 'em, anyway) is "We worked all our lives". If I'm not in the mood for it I'm prone to reminding her that she hasn't worked at all for forty years. I don't resent the comfortable circumstances of some retirees, but I do think that - when it comes to raising income from the public - governments are often inclined to take the view that there are some places we can always look, and others which are forever out of bounds.

Might be just a perception.

Completely agree. When there are shortfalls in income v expenditure all options should be on the table but it's clear that some are held back. 

I think there should be an obligation to pay a higher proportion of salaries into pensions at an earlier age(I wish I had done so). You could even link that investment to the housing bonds Proth has spoken about before. It won't necessarily benefit the next generation of pensioners but it will need to be done at some point.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)