Pensions tax raid
#11
I understand it isn't paid into a piggy bank. But the point remains, 50+ years of work and contributions buys a meagre state pension, let alone those many that do not make it to there. I think there are more worthy targets for taxation and I am surprised the generally more liberal on here think OAPs should be first port of call. I haven't yet reached retiring age but when (or if),I do then I will certainly not be feeling any guilt over any perceived privilege.
Reply
#12
(07-12-2021, 08:41 AM)strawman Wrote: Maybe the increase should be targeted at those less well off, it shouldn't be beyond  the wit of man or HMRC to use the tax code to do this.

You could at least increase the Pension Credit for the lowest income pensioners.
Reply
#13
(07-12-2021, 10:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-12-2021, 08:41 AM)strawman Wrote: Maybe the increase should be targeted at those less well off, it shouldn't be beyond  the wit of man or HMRC to use the tax code to do this.

You could at least increase the Pension Credit for the lowest income pensioners.

Sounds like one solution but it is reckoned that already 1.1 million pensioners are not claiming pension credit to the value of 1.6bn. 

I suppose you could say it's there own fault but it doesn't seem to be particularly well publicised. 
A lot of pensioners are too proud to claim the extra as well.

Regardless of all that I'm against taxing pension contributions. The deal was always you get tax relief on contributions and get taxed on the income. Totally hate retrospective tax law and stinks of double taxation.
Reply
#14
(07-12-2021, 09:57 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I understand it isn't paid into a piggy bank. But the point remains, 50+ years of work and contributions buys a meagre state pension, let alone those many that do not make it to there. I think there are more worthy targets for taxation and I am surprised the generally more liberal on here think OAPs should be first port of call. I haven't yet reached retiring age but when (or if),I do then I will certainly not be feeling any guilt over any perceived privilege.

Nobody is calling for a cut in the state pension? I'm pointing out that the government wants to increase the tax burden on workers by targeting something that is designed to save the public money (private pension contributions) by reducing the need for a state pension. In turn, the second largest thing the state spends money on, the state pension, is due to increase by 8% because incomes dropped last year. In the meanwhile, the government can't give a real terms wage increase to public servants like NHS workers and the police and are due to cut universal credit by £20. I'm not calling pensioners privileged, I'm pointing out an issue with the sustainability and the means that they're managing the sustainability instead of taxing wealth.
Reply
#15
(07-12-2021, 10:18 AM)strawman Wrote:
(07-12-2021, 10:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-12-2021, 08:41 AM)strawman Wrote: Maybe the increase should be targeted at those less well off, it shouldn't be beyond  the wit of man or HMRC to use the tax code to do this.

You could at least increase the Pension Credit for the lowest income pensioners.

Sounds like one solution but it is reckoned that already 1.1 million pensioners are not claiming pension credit to the value of 1.6bn. 

I suppose you could say it's there own fault but it doesn't seem to be particularly well publicised. 
A lot of pensioners are too proud to claim the extra as well.

Regardless of all that I'm against taxing pension contributions. The deal was always you get tax relief on contributions and get taxed on the income. Totally hate retrospective tax law and stinks of double taxation.

I don't disagree with any of that.
Reply
#16
(07-12-2021, 10:18 AM)strawman Wrote:
(07-12-2021, 10:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-12-2021, 08:41 AM)strawman Wrote: Maybe the increase should be targeted at those less well off, it shouldn't be beyond  the wit of man or HMRC to use the tax code to do this.

You could at least increase the Pension Credit for the lowest income pensioners.

Sounds like one solution but it is reckoned that already 1.1 million pensioners are not claiming pension credit to the value of 1.6bn. 

I suppose you could say it's there own fault but it doesn't seem to be particularly well publicised. 
A lot of pensioners are too proud to claim the extra as well.

Regardless of all that I'm against taxing pension contributions. The deal was always you get tax relief on contributions and get taxed on the income. Totally hate retrospective tax law and stinks of double taxation.

One of the issues is that poorer pensioners aren't claiming what they need but wealthier pensioners aren't paying their fair share due to our taxation system being based around income instead of wealth. Then there's the issues with social care which, again, penalises the pensioners closest to the poverty line.
Reply
#17
(07-12-2021, 10:43 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-12-2021, 10:18 AM)strawman Wrote:
(07-12-2021, 10:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-12-2021, 08:41 AM)strawman Wrote: Maybe the increase should be targeted at those less well off, it shouldn't be beyond  the wit of man or HMRC to use the tax code to do this.

You could at least increase the Pension Credit for the lowest income pensioners.

Sounds like one solution but it is reckoned that already 1.1 million pensioners are not claiming pension credit to the value of 1.6bn. 

I suppose you could say it's there own fault but it doesn't seem to be particularly well publicised. 
A lot of pensioners are too proud to claim the extra as well.

Regardless of all that I'm against taxing pension contributions. The deal was always you get tax relief on contributions and get taxed on the income. Totally hate retrospective tax law and stinks of double taxation.

One of the issues is that poorer pensioners aren't claiming what they need but wealthier pensioners aren't paying their fair share due to our taxation system being based around income instead of wealth. Then there's the issues with social care which, again, penalises the pensioners closest to the poverty line.

Which wealth are you talking about. 
Property ? 
It is possible to be asset rich and cash poor. 
I appreciate that many older people are sitting on property with equity far greater than what they paid for it, but with the increase in house prices that would/could apply to people of all ages. Do you want. a discriminatory tax that only applies over a certain age ? I suppose you could apply it to those without mortgages, but again that could be any age.
Equity in property is variable (investments can go down as well as up) and cannot really be  evaluated until a sale. Lots of the property will also be passed on to the next generations at which stage it may attract tax


Edit I've remove bit about rent increases where I stated they were based on CPI+1% - it was bollox - they are based on inflation+1% - Whoops Sad
Reply
#18
(07-12-2021, 11:01 AM)strawman Wrote:
(07-12-2021, 10:43 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-12-2021, 10:18 AM)strawman Wrote:
(07-12-2021, 10:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-12-2021, 08:41 AM)strawman Wrote: Maybe the increase should be targeted at those less well off, it shouldn't be beyond  the wit of man or HMRC to use the tax code to do this.

You could at least increase the Pension Credit for the lowest income pensioners.

Sounds like one solution but it is reckoned that already 1.1 million pensioners are not claiming pension credit to the value of 1.6bn. 

I suppose you could say it's there own fault but it doesn't seem to be particularly well publicised. 
A lot of pensioners are too proud to claim the extra as well.

Regardless of all that I'm against taxing pension contributions. The deal was always you get tax relief on contributions and get taxed on the income. Totally hate retrospective tax law and stinks of double taxation.

One of the issues is that poorer pensioners aren't claiming what they need but wealthier pensioners aren't paying their fair share due to our taxation system being based around income instead of wealth. Then there's the issues with social care which, again, penalises the pensioners closest to the poverty line.

Which wealth are you talking about. 
Property ? 
It is possible to be asset rich and cash poor. 
I appreciate that many older people are sitting on property with equity far greater than what they paid for it, but with the increase in house prices that would/could apply to people of all ages. Do you want. a discriminatory tax that only applies over a certain age ? I suppose you could apply it to those without mortgages, but again that could be any age.
Equity in property is variable (investments can go down as well as up) and cannot really be  evaluated until a sale. Lots of the property will also be passed on to the next generations at which stage it may attract tax


The other implication that hasn't yet been recognised is that some/many of the less wealthy or even the slightly more wealthy people (not only applies to pensioners)  is that social housing rent increases are calculated on CPI+1%.

So an 8% increase in, say a £170 a week pension is £13.60 a week, if your rent is also £170 a week that's a rent increase of £15.30, so that's a decrease in spendable income without increases in all sorts of other bills which will be coming along. No increase in tax allowances as well

If you are already in position where you are receiving benefits then it's covered to some extent but there are limits on it.
There's going to be a hell of a lot more people claiming housing benefit, council tax benefit and other benefits next year.

Property and other investments, savings etc.

What I want is for capital gains to be treated as equivalent to income tax and for there to be a land value tax. That would provide an income stream to supplement welfare to target those who are gaining from the increased value is assets while not increasing tax on those who aren't gaining. A land value tax would bypass the issue of property valuation as it only focuses on the undeveloped land.

I also want a more progressive state pension as per other European countries, as not only would it make giving state pension increases to the poorest pensioners easier but also would negate the need for an increase in the tax burden. In turn, I'd scrap pension credits and incorporate the entitlement to the progressive scale.
Reply
#19
Well, we're not far apart on this then!
I would add, my in laws became property rich/cash poor. A situation resolved when their care homes came knocking. There is a lot that needs sorting, starting with the very wealthy and finishing with those that ended up working for over 50 years.
Reply
#20
(07-12-2021, 09:57 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I understand it isn't paid into a piggy bank. But the point remains, 50+ years of work and contributions buys a meagre state pension, let alone those many that do not make it to there. I think there are more worthy targets for taxation and I am surprised the generally more liberal on here think OAPs should be first port of call. I haven't yet reached retiring age but when (or if),I do then I will certainly not be feeling any guilt over any perceived privilege.

I'd agree totally with that; UK state pensions are pretty wretched compared with those received in most comparable European economies. The same applies to a number of other benefits as well.

I'm out of date with all this now, but levels of employers' social security contributions in countries I used to visit for work (Belgium, France, Germany) dwarfed those in the UK. Sickness and unemployment benefits were correspondingly more generous.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)