Pensions tax raid
#1
Hmmm

Give pensioners a 10% income increase by maintaining the triple lock but penalise private pension contributions by taxing them? Not sure that's very fair.
Reply
#2
I'm genuinely in two minds about the triple-lock. The fiscal conservative in me baulks at the baked-in cost, yet UK state pensions are exceptionally poor compared with most other developed nations. Who will benefit most? The low paid, and of course those yet to reach pensionable age - so on balance I'd swallow this year's increase.

However the continual attacks on private provision are absolutely outrageous and another sure sign that the Tories have lost touch with their traditional core.
Reply
#3
UK state pension incomes are low but, on the flipside, UK asset values (housing) for pensioners are significantly higher. Then there's the issue of other means of pension incomes (final salary pensions that don't exist for anyone under the age of 40 anymore, private pensions etc) that top up the state pensions. I'd rather we just shift test it to a means tested-scale and tie it to a double lock it instead of triple lock it.
Reply
#4
Predicted 8% state pension rise, yet my private pension contributions are being taxed...
Reply
#5
I think some forget that many pensioners have been paying in from aged 15, no gap year, university etc and now (woman) have to work an extra 6 years. This saves the government around 9k pa plus the additional tax revenue. I think there are many better placed to target than those that have worked more years than anyone else will ever have to.
Reply
#6
(07-11-2021, 02:44 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I think some forget that many pensioners have been paying in from aged 15, no gap year, university etc and now (woman) have to work an extra 6 years. This saves the government around 9k pa plus the additional tax revenue.  I think there are many better placed to target than those that have worked more years than anyone else will ever have to.

"Paying in" is the biggest taxation myth going. You don't pay into a pension pot with national insurance, it's just an additional revenue stream for the government like income tax and capital gains tax. Any money being paid out via the state pension is coming out of the budget at the time, as such they need to be held up be tax receipts and borrowing at the time. There needs to be a balance between ensuring the state pension doesn't put pensioners into absolute poverty, rises with living costs and is sustainable within the state budget.

I don't see how it's fair to tax workers more to uphold an unsustainable rise in the state pension, especially when people's wages haven't increased in real terms over the last decade. Especially given we have an aging population meaning more pensioners are being created every year than workers.
Reply
#7
(07-11-2021, 03:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-11-2021, 02:44 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I think some forget that many pensioners have been paying in from aged 15, no gap year, university etc and now (woman) have to work an extra 6 years. This saves the government around 9k pa plus the additional tax revenue.  I think there are many better placed to target than those that have worked more years than anyone else will ever have to.

"Paying in" is the biggest taxation myth going. You don't pay into a pension pot with national insurance, it's just an additional revenue stream for the government like income tax and capital gains tax. Any money being paid out via the state pension is coming out of the budget at the time, as such they need to be held up be tax receipts and borrowing at the time. There needs to be a balance between ensuring the state pension doesn't put pensioners into absolute poverty, rises with living costs and is sustainable within the state budget.

I don't see how it's fair to tax workers more to uphold an unsustainable rise in the state pension, especially when people's wages haven't increased in real terms over the last decade. Especially given we have an aging population meaning more pensioners are being created every year than workers.
OK, I see exactly where you are coming from. That was then, this is now?  Those people paid in,. The NHS, Nationalisation. Now you think the rug should be pulled.? The aging population you speak of have paid in. No amount of whataboutery can deny that.
Reply
#8
They haven't paid in, national insurance is a taxation income stream and when they were paying NI they were paying for the spending of the government at the time much the same as the NI I'm paying is being used to pay for the current pensions. It doesn't go into a ring fenced pot, when the Liberals brought it in they were explicit that it was to support social welfare at the time. I don't see how it's possibly fair that my private pension contributions get taxed, something that is designed to reduce future government expenditure, while the wealthiest pensioners don't get taxed appropriately on their capital gains that they've done nothing to increase the value of and I don't see how it's fair that the state pension is due to rise 8% while the government is cutting spending everywhere else to recover from the pandemic, like people on universal credit losing £20 a week, and public sector workers are given a real term wage cut.
Reply
#9
BB is right, Tom: the years you pay in give you an accumulated entitlement - at least for as long as the existing system endures - up to a maximum of 35 years (although you're still required to continue paying NIC contributions beyond the 35 years), but none of us accumulate a personal 'pot', for want of a better way of putting it. It's really just tax on income, called by another name.

My pension is effectively paid by my son and his mates. Look at it that way - you'll feel better.

Edit: Although I do still pay income tax (which is fair), but if I do paid work I'm exempt from NI contributions (which isn't really).
Reply
#10
(07-12-2021, 08:06 AM)Ossian Wrote: BB is right, Tom: the years you pay in give you an accumulated entitlement - at least for as long as the existing system endures - up to a maximum of 35 years (although you're still required to continue paying NIC contributions beyond the 35 years), but none of us accumulate a personal 'pot', for want of a better way of putting it. It's really just tax on income, called by another name.

My pension is effectively paid by my son and his mates. Look at it that way - you'll feel better.

Edit: Although I do still pay income tax (which is fair), but if I do paid work I'm exempt from NI contributions (which isn't really).

And when they were growing up you were effectively paying for their free education and anything else the state provides for children and the previous generation of pensioners.

What goes around comes around.

Approximately 20% of pensioners are living in poverty. 

Tax allowances are to be frozen over the next 5 years which means that even more pensioners (plus many more) will be even less well off.
 
Many of those on less income and not just pensioners will probably be renting and may already be claiming housing and council tax benefit and many more will be placed into the situation where they can claim it and the cost will just be transferred to different budgets.

Maybe the increase should be targeted at those less well off, it shouldn't be beyond  the wit of man or HMRC to use the tax code to do this.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)