Nissan
#71
I see Vauxhall are getting their share of the money tree pot now following the dole outs to Nissan and JLR. That pot of cash that Boris found after Brexit is sure stretching a long way. What with the 350M a week to the NHS, handouts to any manufacturers that threaten to go elsewhere, dishing out contracts for ball all to their mates, furlough, the never abused government backed loan scheme - Brexit really has worked I pleased to see, who knew we'd uncover all of this spare cash once we'd stopped subsidising Farage and Widdecombe's jollies.
Reply
#72
(07-07-2021, 01:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I see Vauxhall are getting their share of the money tree pot now following the dole outs to Nissan and JLR. That pot of cash that Boris found after Brexit is sure stretching a long way. What with the 350M a week to the NHS, handouts to any manufacturers that threaten to go elsewhere, dishing out contracts for ball all to their mates, furlough, the never abused government backed loan scheme - Brexit really has worked I pleased to see, who knew we'd uncover all of this spare cash once we'd stopped subsidising Farage and Widdecombe's jollies.

Actually, the NHS will be receiving an additional £394 million per week by 23/24!
“Spending increases announced for NHS England’s budget mean that £20.5 billion more will be spent on it in 2023/24 than in 2018/19. That’s £394 million more a week by 2023/24. This money doesn’t cover all health spending.”
https://fullfact.org/health/nhs-england-394-million-more/
 
“So the claim about money going to the EU was never correct. But the Government has nonetheless found extra funding for the NHS. And it comes to more than the £350m a week, or £18.2 billion a year, that was promised.” (Though there was never a promise to spend an extra “£350 million on the NHS)
https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/blue-passports-nhs-funding-brexit-17649663
 
So, you consider it a bad idea to offer grants to industry? To try and ensure that the U.K. maintains an modern efficient industry. I’m not going to bother looking it up but I do recall some on here bemoaning the fact the government weren’t going to bail out Tata Steel. You don’t want us then to maintain jobs? You would be happy for us not to try and reduce any balance of payments deficit and a dependence of imports. (Seem to remember a few on here complaining it was a disgrace we didn’t produce enough PPE or pharmaceuticals in the U.K.) Would you prefer us to be paying for bridges to nowhere (Spain and Greece) or new, unused, airports? I assume you want us to still subsidise inefficient French farmers and chuck money at large landowners in Britain to leave land fallow.
I assume you don’t agree then that Britain should be producing its own EVs and the batteries to run them or is it you just think all the cost should be borne by private enterprise? Proth will be pleased with your new found belief in the market economy and Conservatism Angel  . Or perhaps it’s the fact that the, always honest, Remainers ‘certain fact’ that Nissan would pull out of the U.K. after Brexit, strangely, hasn’t come to fruition?
 
You don’t agree with Furlough then or emergency loan schemes ? It being abused is another matter and anyway lots of government (local and National) money is filched. Are you also ignoring that a quite a goodly sum of EU money is ‘siphoned off’ not only by individuals and businesses but also by governments?
“Greek politicians siphoning off money. While it's been difficult to point the finger at individuals, "there's a strong feeling that quite a lot of EU money has been misused," says Kevin Featherstone, a professor of Greek studies at the London School of Economics.” (And that's from the L.S.E. for Gawd's sake  Rolleyes  ) Or is that a perfectly acceptable abuse of public money as it’s a benefit of the EU?
https://www.newsweek.com/bridge-nowhere-127913
 
A lot of us realised that if you don’t export a large portion of the harvest of fruit of the ‘money tree’, that there would be a bit more for us to munch on.
 
Again, I take it that you don’t disapprove of the 705 remaining MEPs having “subsidised jollies”. Or, for that matter, you approve of the 19 Labour MEPs having had their jollies. Obviously, you are happy with all the Council and Commission members and the, more than, 46,000 civil servants in Brussels  and convinced they all work their fingers to the bone.
 
Reply
#73
I give up, you win, unless we post an absolutely factual based argument you go off into google research overdrive, no room for any casually fun comments about Farage or Widdecombe where you miss the point entirely. 

I have a major concern that this liar is just giving money away because it makes him look good now forsaking the future repayments because he won't be around to deal with them. The fact is we could have (and have done) all of those government subsidies / grants without leaving the EU, the money saved from leaving (if it exists) isn't the reason for us propping up industry - I was poking fun at the concept.
Reply
#74
"We don't build any wind turbines in the UK"
"Wind turbines are shit anyway"
https://www.yorkshirepost.co.uk/business...er-3299030
Reply
#75
(07-08-2021, 08:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I give up, you win, unless we post an absolutely factual based argument you go off into google research overdrive, no room for any casually fun comments about Farage or Widdecombe where you miss the point entirely. 

I have a major concern that this liar is just giving money away because it makes him look good now forsaking the future repayments because he won't be around to deal with them. The fact is we could have (and have done) all of those government subsidies / grants without leaving the EU, the money saved from leaving (if it exists) isn't the reason for us propping up industry - I was poking fun at the concept.
B1, I thought better of you. Surely, you’re not turning into a Dekka and preferring the use of anecdotes and twatter pronouncements to base your arguments? Is no one allowed to rebut your argument? Just because I prefer to research and back my arguments / points up and provide links to same, does that require censure?

Is this supposed to be a place for debate or just a space to offload, often, baseless bald statements?
 
What was the point I missed in singling out two ex MEPs for having jollies?  
 
I perfectly accept you are entitled to your views and suspicions about individuals and political parties but  I notice, in this instance,  like another poster, you have chosen to offer no rejoinder to my observations and  questions.  
If you were “poking fun” it was very vailed and trying to mask an obvious political point. In my opinion.
Reply
#76
My point was more about the position we are in as a country JOK, we have (rightly in a lot a cases) thrown money at a massive problem we are facing with covid. Furlough is a great way of helping the country survive, the contracts for mates is a scandal that is being brushed over as two examples.

The jibe at the expenses was tongue in cheek obviously - we haven't saved money on them (not to the extent it would matter) but I was jokingly saying that for us to be spending all of the money we are it must have come from somewhere, who'd have thought we'd have saved it from their expenses (it wasn't a serious point and clearly the expenses we don't pay for any more won't make a big difference).

At a point in time when we are cash strapped we are throwing money at car companies to keep them here. I, this won't surprise you, am in agreement with state subsidies however If the UK is that attractive after Brexit for these companies, why do you think we need to throw money at them. The answer is we aren't and we are being held to ransom - the government can't afford to lose them to other EU countries at this point because that will be a clear indicator that Brexit aint what it was painted as. So we are having to throw money at them to keep them. The extra burden on them to get supplies in and product out has put us at their mercy because of the politics of it all.

At a point in time when we have the highest debt to GDP ratio (99.2% according to the lefty BBC) what do you think the real reason for throwing money at Nissan, Vauxhall and JLR is for given that the UK is so attractive to them after Brexit supposedly?
Reply
#77
(07-09-2021, 08:24 AM)baggy1 Wrote: At a point in time when we are cash strapped we are throwing money at car companies to keep them here. I, this won't surprise you, am in agreement with state subsidies however If the UK is that attractive after Brexit for these companies, why do you think we need to throw money at them. The answer is we aren't and we are being held to ransom - the government can't afford to lose them to other EU countries at this point because that will be a clear indicator that Brexit aint what it was painted as. So we are having to throw money at them to keep them. The extra burden on them to get supplies in and product out has put us at their mercy because of the politics of it all.

Except that contention is absolute bollocks. Tesla is being given $1.2 billion to build a gigafactory in Germany. Is Germany so unattractive as a commercial destination that Tesla has to be bribed to locate there?

There won't be a gigafacttory built anywhere in Europe without subsidy.

What you also fail to recognise is that historically UK industrial subsidies have been (rightly) miniscule v German or French subsidies to industry.
Reply
#78
(07-09-2021, 08:47 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-09-2021, 08:24 AM)baggy1 Wrote: At a point in time when we are cash strapped we are throwing money at car companies to keep them here. I, this won't surprise you, am in agreement with state subsidies however If the UK is that attractive after Brexit for these companies, why do you think we need to throw money at them. The answer is we aren't and we are being held to ransom - the government can't afford to lose them to other EU countries at this point because that will be a clear indicator that Brexit aint what it was painted as. So we are having to throw money at them to keep them. The extra burden on them to get supplies in and product out has put us at their mercy because of the politics of it all.

Except that contention is absolute bollocks. Tesla is being given $1.2 billion to build a gigafactory in Germany. Is Germany so unattractive as a commercial destination that Tesla has to be bribed to locate there?

There won't be a gigafacttory built anywhere in Europe without subsidy.

What you also fail to recognise is that historically UK industrial subsidies have been (rightly) miniscule v German or French subsidies to industry.

You have no idea what I fail to recognise clearly - JOK is saying that subsidies are only available to companies by leaving the EU, you are saying that is not true. I agree with you.

So basically (over a couple of threads) we are all now in agreement that state subsidy would have been possible if we had stayed in the EU. The question that remains (no pun intended) is why, when we are at 99% debt to GDP and are so attractive having left the EU, are we throwing more money at Nissan, JLR and Vauxhall?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)