From an ITK source
(06-05-2021, 08:07 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: I have a couple of problems/concerns with appointing Appleton, namely the Blackpool & Blackburn craziness, his time at Oxford although wining promotion to league one (where perhaps Oxford should be anyway) and EFL Trophy finals, does not really sway it with me. He has done well with Lincoln, unlucky come up against Blackpool for the playoff final, but Lincoln are very well bank rolled and as mentioned have been given a lot of youth players.

I suppose what I'm trying to say is, he hasn't done anything astounding, or overly impressive - and that sits with me as a slight underwhelming appointment. Not that Fat Frank has done anything impressive either for that matter.

If we are going for a younger manager to bring in youth (I'd question that latter direction in a promotion chasing Champ season) then that's fine with me, but there are question marks for me on Appy - lovely bloke that he is like, just we're trying to get back to the Prem and quickly, do we a need this.
Lincoln really aren't very well bankrolled. They had one of the lower budgets in League 1. He has mainly brought in freebies and loans.
Reply
(06-05-2021, 07:07 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Barnsley manager Valerien Ismael gets a mention on "Google News" this morning.

Makes me laugh how many people on twitter want him who normally go on about playing football 'the right way'. He's rather agricultural. Decent manager, I'm certainly not against, but I find it amusing.
Reply
(06-05-2021, 08:31 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(06-05-2021, 07:07 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Barnsley manager Valerien Ismael gets a mention on "Google News" this morning.

Makes me laugh how many people on twitter want him who normally go on about playing football 'the right way'. He's rather agricultural. Decent manager, I'm certainly not against, but I find it amusing.

They also seem to ignore a very average career before that where he has rarely lasted a season anywhere he's been.
Reply
If there was no link with the club Appleton would be nowhere near the top of the betting. I understand the logic of having a manager / head coach with an affinity with the club and able to work within a DoF model but ultimately we are looking for the very best manager we can get to maximise the chance of going up and staying up. Is that Appleton? Is he any better than Ferguson at Peterborough? His record suggests not. We shall see, I imagine this is dragging because there are so many clubs currently without a manager so potential candidates are reluctant to commit until they have to.
Reply
(06-05-2021, 08:33 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If there was no link with the club Appleton would be nowhere near the top of the betting. I understand the logic of having a manager / head coach with an affinity with the club and able to work within a DoF model but ultimately we are looking for the very best manager we can get to maximise the chance of going up and staying up. Is that Appleton? Is he any better than Ferguson at Peterborough, his record suggests not. We shall see, I imagine this is dragging because there are so many clubs currently without a manager so potential candidates are reluctant to commit until they have to.

This is why, as I've said, I'm just keen the club do due diligence. If they've done that, I'll back their decision, whoever it is. 

Irvine wasn't appointed via a good process, neither was Pepe Mel. Bilic was to be fair, RDM and Mowbray were. Roy was, and fell into our lap really.
Reply
(06-05-2021, 08:37 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(06-05-2021, 08:33 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If there was no link with the club Appleton would be nowhere near the top of the betting. I understand the logic of having a manager / head coach with an affinity with the club and able to work within a DoF model but ultimately we are looking for the very best manager we can get to maximise the chance of going up and staying up. Is that Appleton? Is he any better than Ferguson at Peterborough, his record suggests not. We shall see, I imagine this is dragging because there are so many clubs currently without a manager so potential candidates are reluctant to commit until they have to.

This is why, as I've said, I'm just keen the club do due diligence. If they've done that, I'll back their decision, whoever it is. 

Irvine wasn't appointed via a good process, neither was Pepe Mel. Bilic was to be fair, RDM and Mowbray were. Roy was, and fell into our lap really.

As horrendous as Irvine was, if it was a choice between him and Sherwood I'm still not sure if they got it wrong!
Reply
https://www.footballinsider247.com/west-...der-plans/

ALBION TURN DOWN WILDER
Reply
(06-05-2021, 08:33 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2021, 08:31 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(06-05-2021, 07:07 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Barnsley manager Valerien Ismael gets a mention on "Google News" this morning.

Makes me laugh how many people on twitter want him who normally go on about playing football 'the right way'. He's rather agricultural. Decent manager, I'm certainly not against, but I find it amusing.

They also seem to ignore a very average career before that where he has rarely lasted a season anywhere he's been.

Alan Nixon seems to think whoever gets Ismael are getting the next Bielsa. It's a strange one why Nixon rates him so highly with such a patchy record.
Reply
(06-05-2021, 08:33 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If there was no link with the club Appleton would be nowhere near the top of the betting. I understand the logic of having a manager / head coach with an affinity with the club and able to work within a DoF model but ultimately we are looking for the very best manager we can get to maximise the chance of going up and staying up. Is that Appleton? Is he any better than Ferguson at Peterborough? His record suggests not. We shall see, I imagine this is dragging because there are so many clubs currently without a manager so potential candidates are reluctant to commit until they have to.

What people don’t factor in is we have very different owners to those of the past . I’m not in the Lai out camp they have run the club as they said from the outset it is sustainable but we don’t see or hear much of them. That said I’m under no illusions if we don’t get promoted in next couple of years we will see asset stripping start and then who knows what so we have to get this appointment right It is not the time for sentiment we have a limited window and must strive to get the best we can . I’m not sold on Appleton I think he’s found a club where he is settled and is probably at his level , he’s jumped ship too quickly in the past and should think carefully about his next move .
Reply
(06-05-2021, 08:55 AM)B36baggie Wrote:
(06-05-2021, 08:33 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2021, 08:31 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(06-05-2021, 07:07 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Barnsley manager Valerien Ismael gets a mention on "Google News" this morning.

Makes me laugh how many people on twitter want him who normally go on about playing football 'the right way'. He's rather agricultural. Decent manager, I'm certainly not against, but I find it amusing.

They also seem to ignore a very average career before that where he has rarely lasted a season anywhere he's been.

Alan Nixon seems to think whoever gets Ismael are getting the next Bielsa. It's a strange one why Nixon rates him so highly with such a patchy record.

He has a very impressive record of losing playoff tournaments! 

Ismael would be an absolute wildcard, who I can’t see working here. We do not have the players for a high press, high intensity, highly direct approach, and his background is very much one of a coach who works with the players he’s delivered.

Barnsley have a model... a central scouting network spread across several clubs in the group, and an expectation to play young players, improve them, sell them on and play a very intense pressing style. All of this suits Ismael, but certainly not us.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: