From an ITK source
Sounds good to me
Reply
(06-01-2021, 05:51 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Duffers Wrote:He’s got the best CV out of any realistic candidate so I’m fine with Wilder.

Is the answer in a nutshell….
It could be so much worse! Until last season he was probably one of the best managers in the league. Let's hope he is like Roy, determined to prove a point.

Yes i hope he is out to prove a point if so happy days ,but still have this feeling its not right for us cant explain why ,but maybe last season has scared him personally think we have seen the best of him ,but thats just my opinion and hopefully he will prove me wrong and ill be the first to gladly eat humble pie boing boing.
Reply
Looking at that interview with the Sheff U owner something was awry there for a while - hopefully Christopher is in the mood to show what he's made of.
Reply
I think it’s probably a wiser choice than Lampard. Also seems a good fit for where both parties are now.

It’s true Wilder had a setback last year, but let’s hope he learns from it. Also, it’s a bit rich of us to sit here and criticise another failure of last season’s Premier campaign (we hardly shone either really!). At least he’s no stranger to either division, and has achieved quite a few promotions.

Just hope he and Doweling get the balance of the squad right this term; and hopefully are better-still looking beyond that.
Reply
Wilder thing,
Make our hearts sing...
Reply
(06-01-2021, 07:01 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I think it’s probably a wiser choice than Lampard. Also seems a good fit for where both parties are now.

It’s true Wilder had a setback last year, but let’s hope he learns from it. Also, it’s a bit rich of us to sit here and criticise another failure of last season’s Premier campaign (we hardly shone either really!). At least he’s no stranger to either division, and has achieved quite a few promotions.

Just hope he and Doweling get the balance of the squad right this term; and hopefully are better-still looking beyond that.

Surely the point here is that we failed last season so why should we appoint a bigger failure of last season to manage us? Just seems odd to me, like when we replaced Pulis with Pardew, who at the time was the only manager with a worse recent record than Pulis.
Reply
(06-01-2021, 07:19 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote:
(06-01-2021, 07:01 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I think it’s probably a wiser choice than Lampard. Also seems a good fit for where both parties are now.

It’s true Wilder had a setback last year, but let’s hope he learns from it. Also, it’s a bit rich of us to sit here and criticise another failure of last season’s Premier campaign (we hardly shone either really!). At least he’s no stranger to either division, and has achieved quite a few promotions.

Just hope he and Doweling get the balance of the squad right this term; and hopefully are better-still looking beyond that.

Surely the point here is that we failed last season so why should we appoint a bigger failure of last season to manage us?

Name me a manager who hasn’t failed at some point. Especially one willing to work in the Championship.

Yes, Wilder had a bad season last year. Yes he made some questionable transfer decisions. But his work in the ten years or so preceding last year was excellent. 

As I’ve said, he’s not the most inspiring of picks, but he has the best CV and is the candidate that makes the most sense.
Reply
(06-01-2021, 07:19 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote:
(06-01-2021, 07:01 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I think it’s probably a wiser choice than Lampard. Also seems a good fit for where both parties are now.

It’s true Wilder had a setback last year, but let’s hope he learns from it. Also, it’s a bit rich of us to sit here and criticise another failure of last season’s Premier campaign (we hardly shone either really!). At least he’s no stranger to either division, and has achieved quite a few promotions.

Just hope he and Doweling get the balance of the squad right this term; and hopefully are better-still looking beyond that.

Surely the point here is that we failed last season so why should we appoint a bigger failure of last season to manage us? Just seems odd to me, like when we replaced Pulis with Pardew, who at the time was the only manager with a worse recent record than Pulis.

Because he didn’t fail the season before. Or the one before that. Or that...

I think the Pardew appointment isn’t really comparable TBH - don’t get the logic. That was a mid-season catastrophe few wanted, because it was clear Pulis didn’t really care anymore and had wanted to leave for a while. In fact as appointment-comparison goes, it’s closer to the one we saw before Wilder (borne out of desperation). 

By the same logic it could be argued Megson failed at Stockport not long before Stoke took him on and he ended up coming to us. Or Roy failed at Liverpool before coming to us. 

I don’t think there are too many better names. I don’t argue Wilder lost his way at Blades, and of course it’s a gamble; but when you look at the squad they had (which again won’t argue he wasn’t partly responsible for assembling) they were never good enough, just like we weren’t under two coaches. He’s also taken Blades up, and kept them there, so there is learning to do on all sides. 
Reply
(06-01-2021, 07:19 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote:
(06-01-2021, 07:01 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I think it’s probably a wiser choice than Lampard. Also seems a good fit for where both parties are now.

It’s true Wilder had a setback last year, but let’s hope he learns from it. Also, it’s a bit rich of us to sit here and criticise another failure of last season’s Premier campaign (we hardly shone either really!). At least he’s no stranger to either division, and has achieved quite a few promotions.

Just hope he and Doweling get the balance of the squad right this term; and hopefully are better-still looking beyond that.

Surely the point here is that we failed last season so why should we appoint a bigger failure of last season to manage us? Just seems odd to me, like when we replaced Pulis with Pardew, who at the time was the only manager with a worse recent record than Pulis. 

Because that failure from last season has 19 years previous of unabated success name another manager who we could have, with with his record. You can pick who you want but I bet his record won’t be as good as his.
Reply
(06-01-2021, 07:39 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(06-01-2021, 07:19 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote:
(06-01-2021, 07:01 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I think it’s probably a wiser choice than Lampard. Also seems a good fit for where both parties are now.

It’s true Wilder had a setback last year, but let’s hope he learns from it. Also, it’s a bit rich of us to sit here and criticise another failure of last season’s Premier campaign (we hardly shone either really!). At least he’s no stranger to either division, and has achieved quite a few promotions.

Just hope he and Doweling get the balance of the squad right this term; and hopefully are better-still looking beyond that.

Surely the point here is that we failed last season so why should we appoint a bigger failure of last season to manage us? Just seems odd to me, like when we replaced Pulis with Pardew, who at the time was the only manager with a worse recent record than Pulis.

Because he didn’t fail the season before. Or the one before that. Or that...

I think the Pardew appointment isn’t really comparable TBH - don’t get the logic. That was a mid-season catastrophe few wanted, because it was clear Pulis didn’t really care anymore and had wanted to leave for a while. In fact as appointment-comparison goes, it’s closer to the one we saw before Wilder (borne out of desperation). 

By the same logic it could be argued Megson failed at Stockport not long before Stoke took him on and he ended up coming to us. Or Roy failed at Liverpool before coming to us. 

I don’t think there are too many better names. I don’t argue Wilder lost his way at Blades, and of course it’s a gamble; but when you look at the squad they had (which again won’t argue he wasn’t partly responsible for assembling) they were never good enough, just like we weren’t under two coaches. He’s also taken Blades up, and kept them there, so there is learning to do on all sides. 

Didn't we appoint Allardyce based on the manager he used to be, rather than what he is now? The main problem I have with Wilder is not just that he failed last season but the manner of it and the fact that it was his boyhood club. He undoubtedly is the most successful manager we could have appointed but it just has the "Mourinho at Tottenham" feel to it for me.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)