Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
If we had been looking for a manager in the Summer and Wilder was a potential would people's opinion have been different then? Is it this past season that has soured people's opinion of him? I can see why it would. Especially the Burke signing!
However, I don't think Sheffield United were absolutely awful this past season. Just that their finishing was!
If he has the hunger still, and I see no reason to think why he wouldn't as he is still young and has had his first managerial slap in the face, then Wilder is probably the best option out of the names listed so far.
How he would fit in with our set up though is the big question for both him and the club. With the experience of our Summer signings I have a feeling Dowling and the club will be a bit more "hands-on" regarding who we sign and who we don't. Wilder may have players in mind that the club might decide don't fit the bill, which Wilder could obviously see as undermining him.
That might also become a problem for any of the other names linked with us.
If we give it a couple of weeks a surprise (as in a GOOD surprise!) name might throw their name in the hat.
Posts: 8,078
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
I really don’t think Wilder is that bad a first choice. I think it’s a much safer option than a Lampard or even an Appleton.
I think he messed up on Burke, but very few managers get every signing right. With retrospect it did us a favour. As long as we’ve learned our lessons in the transfer market since last summer (where I feel there was way too much division between the coach and the TD), and he’s learned his, I don’t see any real reason to be pessimistic about Wilder.
Posts: 7,412
Threads: 124
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
He's definitely not the first manager to mess up on Burke, & probably wont be the last, I'm pretty sure there's probably still someone out there, that thinks Burke's a footballer.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
05-29-2021, 04:09 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-29-2021, 04:10 PM by Squid.)
(05-29-2021, 12:16 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: No arguments that the most impressive CV of a pretty unimpressive bunch (still waiting Cuzer’s 5 ), belongs to Wilder.
There’s just something. Maybe it’s that he’s had his first taste of failure, how will he react? Also he’s managed his boyhood club, does he still really have the same drive?
Picking managers on the way up rather than down generally serves us better (uncle Roy aside who was just class). I’m not saying Wilder is on his way down, there’s just a whiff of him achieving his best, taking his boyhood team to the PL, the fact it’s us interested and not PL teams probably tells him he’s never going to get to the very top and maybe he’s had his best moment.
He’s the safe choice by the club, if there’s such a thing, it all stacks up on that front. I just feel there’s something missing...
Yes. I feel like this. I know Wilder had the experience, but does he have to hunger and has he fully dealt with Sheffield Utd blowing up in his face?
My first choice is Appleton, because I think he's a very, very talented coach. But I could also could see a case for Lampard too.
Posts: 3,903
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(05-29-2021, 11:58 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: The only doubt I have with Wilder is that he’s an old fashioned, English manager who wants to wield complete control at the club. In the lower leagues this was absolutely fine, and pretty much par for the course for the majority of clubs, and as a result he could have a resounding amount of success.
At Sheff Utd, he inherited a broken, League One club that needed dragging out of the doldrums and his sheer force of personality coupled with his tactical acumen was the driving force behind their rise to the PL. Unfortunately momentum only works for so long, and when Sheff Utd tried to adapt to a new model alleviating some of the back of house scouting and recruitment tasks away from Wilder he wasn’t happy, and they had the same kind of success rate in the summer we had.
If appointed, I think Wilder would get us back up and would bring some of the values around hard work, determination and fitness back we’ve lacked for while back to the side, however I’m just not convinced he’s a good fit for a club with as prominent a DoF as we are with Dowling, especially as I’m just not sure who calls the shots above him.
If our sole objective is to get up inside 2 years, then it’s hard to see past Wilder from the CVs available... however, I think the summer after promotion things would start to fall apart again pretty quickly. This is my view to could see us coming straight back down even more embarrassingly than this season.
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(05-29-2021, 04:55 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (05-29-2021, 11:58 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: The only doubt I have with Wilder is that he’s an old fashioned, English manager who wants to wield complete control at the club. In the lower leagues this was absolutely fine, and pretty much par for the course for the majority of clubs, and as a result he could have a resounding amount of success.
At Sheff Utd, he inherited a broken, League One club that needed dragging out of the doldrums and his sheer force of personality coupled with his tactical acumen was the driving force behind their rise to the PL. Unfortunately momentum only works for so long, and when Sheff Utd tried to adapt to a new model alleviating some of the back of house scouting and recruitment tasks away from Wilder he wasn’t happy, and they had the same kind of success rate in the summer we had.
If appointed, I think Wilder would get us back up and would bring some of the values around hard work, determination and fitness back we’ve lacked for while back to the side, however I’m just not convinced he’s a good fit for a club with as prominent a DoF as we are with Dowling, especially as I’m just not sure who calls the shots above him.
If our sole objective is to get up inside 2 years, then it’s hard to see past Wilder from the CVs available... however, I think the summer after promotion things would start to fall apart again pretty quickly. This is my view to could see us coming straight back down even more embarrassingly than this season.
I'd rather worry about the "summer after promotion" once we've actually won promotion!
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(05-29-2021, 04:58 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (05-29-2021, 04:55 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (05-29-2021, 11:58 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: The only doubt I have with Wilder is that he’s an old fashioned, English manager who wants to wield complete control at the club. In the lower leagues this was absolutely fine, and pretty much par for the course for the majority of clubs, and as a result he could have a resounding amount of success.
At Sheff Utd, he inherited a broken, League One club that needed dragging out of the doldrums and his sheer force of personality coupled with his tactical acumen was the driving force behind their rise to the PL. Unfortunately momentum only works for so long, and when Sheff Utd tried to adapt to a new model alleviating some of the back of house scouting and recruitment tasks away from Wilder he wasn’t happy, and they had the same kind of success rate in the summer we had.
If appointed, I think Wilder would get us back up and would bring some of the values around hard work, determination and fitness back we’ve lacked for while back to the side, however I’m just not convinced he’s a good fit for a club with as prominent a DoF as we are with Dowling, especially as I’m just not sure who calls the shots above him.
If our sole objective is to get up inside 2 years, then it’s hard to see past Wilder from the CVs available... however, I think the summer after promotion things would start to fall apart again pretty quickly. This is my view to could see us coming straight back down even more embarrassingly than this season.
I'd rather worry about the "summer after promotion" once we've actually won promotion!
I don’t disagree Prag, he’s my first choice because I think he’s the best option to get us up, I’m merely stating that I can understand why people have some reservations around him.
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(05-29-2021, 11:58 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: The only doubt I have with Wilder is that he’s an old fashioned, English manager who wants to wield complete control at the club. In the lower leagues this was absolutely fine, and pretty much par for the course for the majority of clubs, and as a result he could have a resounding amount of success.
At Sheff Utd, he inherited a broken, League One club that needed dragging out of the doldrums and his sheer force of personality coupled with his tactical acumen was the driving force behind their rise to the PL. Unfortunately momentum only works for so long, and when Sheff Utd tried to adapt to a new model alleviating some of the back of house scouting and recruitment tasks away from Wilder he wasn’t happy, and they had the same kind of success rate in the summer we had.
If appointed, I think Wilder would get us back up and would bring some of the values around hard work, determination and fitness back we’ve lacked for while back to the side, however I’m just not convinced he’s a good fit for a club with as prominent a DoF as we are with Dowling, especially as I’m just not sure who calls the shots above him.
If our sole objective is to get up inside 2 years, then it’s hard to see past Wilder from the CVs available... however, I think the summer after promotion things would start to fall apart again pretty quickly.
So he wasn't behind the Burke swap then and the spunking millions on Brewster and McBurnie as that was the new scouting set up?
He's just gone up in my estimation then as before last season he'd done a fine job!
Posts: 206
Threads: 40
Joined: Apr 2025
(05-28-2021, 02:48 PM)yeoman lai Wrote: Not arsed so long as he doesn't get antwhere near B71.
Good assessment
|