Posts: 17,084
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-25-2021, 04:42 PM)Mayo Wrote: (05-25-2021, 03:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-25-2021, 09:42 AM)Mayo Wrote: (05-25-2021, 09:20 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I don't feel either of the managers did the best they could though, that's my complaint. We were always going to struggle to not be relegated, and therefore if Bilic had done the basics of his job, he would have seen out the season, regardless of league position.
Big Sam took far too long to have a positive impact and even then made some quite baffling decisions that meant we barely put up a fight.
Neither can say they did a decent job this season imo.
I agree - I didn't think we were doomed from the off and though perhaps was over optimistic as I tend to be (a football supporter thing), I still think we were capable of survival with the lower half of the prem not great regardless of their budgets. There were some promising performances under Bilic which showed we could compete - including his last game - and we had a few of the dodgy prem decisions against us early on which impacted points (Chelsea's last minute equaliser after handball for one). I would have given Bilic more time as he knew the squad the best and we were not adrift - but Sam was brought in as Bilic was deemed to be unlikely to succeed at that point.
He was brought in on the pretext he would keep us up, which he said he could, and he had time and resources to do so. But he was as awful as any new manager we ever had at the start with humiliating performances, and when we eventually saw improvements they were fleeting and too late - then back to fairly tame defeats. He failed badly and by a long way.
The only reason I wanted him to stay was that it would have signaled intent from the board to back him and retain the squad which is good enough for promotion - one I think could have competed far better in the prem. It turned out Sam lied about his intents though, and given his record this should not be a surprise. We need to look at character of the appointments as well as their managerial record surely now as we have been stung this way before.
So the excuses being made for him are weak as far as I am concerned, making a few players look fitter and better whilst being beaten and relegated by a mile is no great shakes based on his remit. It does mean the new manager can hardly be much worse in terms of integrity and achievement though, and I look forward to seeing who it is, hopefully soon. One thing I think Sam got right was his comment about a young and ambitious manager, but Wilder would do - he is still the latter at least.
How did you come to the conclusion that our Championship squad with an OAP defender and Gallagher added was in anyway good enough to compete in the Prem for half a season? It was barely good enough to get promotion for nearly half a season. I don't think Bilic, Allardyce, Merlin the Magician, the Sorceress from He-Man, Dumbledore of Gandalf could have kept us up. It's very weak argument to suggest that someone has abjectly failed because they took on a job that was pretty impossible to achieve. The fact is we weren't good enough under two managers and regardless of if's, but's and maybe's our squad simply wasn't up to the job of staying in the league and I'd argue the three clubs that went down had the three worst squads regardless of who was managing them.
I've explained in my post how I've reached my conclusion - based on performances and the rest of the prem- you are just repeating your same point over and over again on the same thread. It doesn't make it right and I don't agree with you. Last season you repeatedly attacked Bilic and said the squad was brilliant and should be top 2 easy and should not struggle in that regard. You might say the gulf in prem and championship is massive but it is not that massive and it didn't become a shite squad after promotion - you are hugely inconsistent. It was always going to be a struggle and relegation was on the cards but not by the margin Allardyce managed. He did a terrible job in the end.
I did not repeatedly attack Bilic, back up the accusation I attacked Bilic repeatedly by linking to these numerous ‘attacks’.
The squad was good enough to be top two it erm finished top two. The wage bill and budget was also top four.
It was by and large a Championship squad that started the season which is why we went down, I didn’t attack Bilic this season before he got sacked. I have said all season whoever was in charge couldn’t keep us up.
Posts: 3,903
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
Personally Dowling ,Bilic and Allardyce all share equal responsibility for a clusterfuck of a season ,but Lai should take his fair share of blame for failing to protect his investment. An injection of £15/20m in the jan window may have just seen us over the line who knows ,but then again does Lai have any money does he even own us?
Posts: 10,438
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(05-25-2021, 06:11 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: Personally Dowling ,Bilic and Allardyce all share equal responsibility for a clusterfuck of a season ,but Lai should take his fair share of blame for failing to protect his investment. An injection of £15/20m in the jan window may have just seen us over the line who knows ,but then again does Lai have any money does he even own us?
Spot on
Posts: 17,084
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-25-2021, 05:22 PM)Mayo Wrote: (05-25-2021, 05:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-25-2021, 04:42 PM)Mayo Wrote: (05-25-2021, 03:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-25-2021, 09:42 AM)Mayo Wrote: I agree - I didn't think we were doomed from the off and though perhaps was over optimistic as I tend to be (a football supporter thing), I still think we were capable of survival with the lower half of the prem not great regardless of their budgets. There were some promising performances under Bilic which showed we could compete - including his last game - and we had a few of the dodgy prem decisions against us early on which impacted points (Chelsea's last minute equaliser after handball for one). I would have given Bilic more time as he knew the squad the best and we were not adrift - but Sam was brought in as Bilic was deemed to be unlikely to succeed at that point.
He was brought in on the pretext he would keep us up, which he said he could, and he had time and resources to do so. But he was as awful as any new manager we ever had at the start with humiliating performances, and when we eventually saw improvements they were fleeting and too late - then back to fairly tame defeats. He failed badly and by a long way.
The only reason I wanted him to stay was that it would have signaled intent from the board to back him and retain the squad which is good enough for promotion - one I think could have competed far better in the prem. It turned out Sam lied about his intents though, and given his record this should not be a surprise. We need to look at character of the appointments as well as their managerial record surely now as we have been stung this way before.
So the excuses being made for him are weak as far as I am concerned, making a few players look fitter and better whilst being beaten and relegated by a mile is no great shakes based on his remit. It does mean the new manager can hardly be much worse in terms of integrity and achievement though, and I look forward to seeing who it is, hopefully soon. One thing I think Sam got right was his comment about a young and ambitious manager, but Wilder would do - he is still the latter at least.
How did you come to the conclusion that our Championship squad with an OAP defender and Gallagher added was in anyway good enough to compete in the Prem for half a season? It was barely good enough to get promotion for nearly half a season. I don't think Bilic, Allardyce, Merlin the Magician, the Sorceress from He-Man, Dumbledore of Gandalf could have kept us up. It's very weak argument to suggest that someone has abjectly failed because they took on a job that was pretty impossible to achieve. The fact is we weren't good enough under two managers and regardless of if's, but's and maybe's our squad simply wasn't up to the job of staying in the league and I'd argue the three clubs that went down had the three worst squads regardless of who was managing them.
I've explained in my post how I've reached my conclusion - based on performances and the rest of the prem- you are just repeating your same point over and over again on the same thread. It doesn't make it right and I don't agree with you. Last season you repeatedly attacked Bilic and said the squad was brilliant and should be top 2 easy and should not struggle in that regard. You might say the gulf in prem and championship is massive but it is not that massive and it didn't become a shite squad after promotion - you are hugely inconsistent. It was always going to be a struggle and relegation was on the cards but not by the margin Allardyce managed. He did a terrible job in the end.
I did not repeatedly attack Bilic, back up the accusation I attacked Bilic repeatedly by linking to these numerous ‘attacks’.
The squad was good enough to be top two it erm finished top two. The wage bill and budget was also top four.
It was by and large a Championship squad that started the season which is why we went down, I didn’t attack Bilic this season before he got sacked. I have said all season whoever was in charge couldn’t keep us up. You can link yourself and use the search function - I am getting older but my memory is sound. You were also against the appointment of Bilic and pro that of Sam which I think colours your analysis and excuses. Sam didn't just take us down, he failed by a mile to keep us up having stated he could do so. I had hoped he would and believe it was possible if we had a better replacement and a more honest one.
That’ll be a no then.
Posts: 13,263
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(05-25-2021, 05:22 PM)Mayo Wrote: (05-25-2021, 05:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-25-2021, 04:42 PM)Mayo Wrote: (05-25-2021, 03:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-25-2021, 09:42 AM)Mayo Wrote: I agree - I didn't think we were doomed from the off and though perhaps was over optimistic as I tend to be (a football supporter thing), I still think we were capable of survival with the lower half of the prem not great regardless of their budgets. There were some promising performances under Bilic which showed we could compete - including his last game - and we had a few of the dodgy prem decisions against us early on which impacted points (Chelsea's last minute equaliser after handball for one). I would have given Bilic more time as he knew the squad the best and we were not adrift - but Sam was brought in as Bilic was deemed to be unlikely to succeed at that point.
He was brought in on the pretext he would keep us up, which he said he could, and he had time and resources to do so. But he was as awful as any new manager we ever had at the start with humiliating performances, and when we eventually saw improvements they were fleeting and too late - then back to fairly tame defeats. He failed badly and by a long way.
The only reason I wanted him to stay was that it would have signaled intent from the board to back him and retain the squad which is good enough for promotion - one I think could have competed far better in the prem. It turned out Sam lied about his intents though, and given his record this should not be a surprise. We need to look at character of the appointments as well as their managerial record surely now as we have been stung this way before.
So the excuses being made for him are weak as far as I am concerned, making a few players look fitter and better whilst being beaten and relegated by a mile is no great shakes based on his remit. It does mean the new manager can hardly be much worse in terms of integrity and achievement though, and I look forward to seeing who it is, hopefully soon. One thing I think Sam got right was his comment about a young and ambitious manager, but Wilder would do - he is still the latter at least.
How did you come to the conclusion that our Championship squad with an OAP defender and Gallagher added was in anyway good enough to compete in the Prem for half a season? It was barely good enough to get promotion for nearly half a season. I don't think Bilic, Allardyce, Merlin the Magician, the Sorceress from He-Man, Dumbledore of Gandalf could have kept us up. It's very weak argument to suggest that someone has abjectly failed because they took on a job that was pretty impossible to achieve. The fact is we weren't good enough under two managers and regardless of if's, but's and maybe's our squad simply wasn't up to the job of staying in the league and I'd argue the three clubs that went down had the three worst squads regardless of who was managing them.
I've explained in my post how I've reached my conclusion - based on performances and the rest of the prem- you are just repeating your same point over and over again on the same thread. It doesn't make it right and I don't agree with you. Last season you repeatedly attacked Bilic and said the squad was brilliant and should be top 2 easy and should not struggle in that regard. You might say the gulf in prem and championship is massive but it is not that massive and it didn't become a shite squad after promotion - you are hugely inconsistent. It was always going to be a struggle and relegation was on the cards but not by the margin Allardyce managed. He did a terrible job in the end.
I did not repeatedly attack Bilic, back up the accusation I attacked Bilic repeatedly by linking to these numerous ‘attacks’.
The squad was good enough to be top two it erm finished top two. The wage bill and budget was also top four.
It was by and large a Championship squad that started the season which is why we went down, I didn’t attack Bilic this season before he got sacked. I have said all season whoever was in charge couldn’t keep us up. You can link yourself and use the search function - I am getting older but my memory is sound. You were also against the appointment of Bilic and pro that of Sam which I think colours your analysis and excuses. Sam didn't just take us down, he failed by a mile to keep us up having stated he could do so. I had hoped he would and believe it was possible if we had a better replacement and a more honest one.
oh come on! It's the same for the people who were against Allardyce's appointment!
Posts: 27,985
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
Allardyce turned our season from a humiliating one into merely a shit one.
Posts: 4,733
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
05-25-2021, 07:10 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-25-2021, 07:11 PM by Big Daddy Cool.)
The problem is when you absolve Allardyce from any blame. You can't defend the performances early on in his reign which were dreadful and worse than anything under Bilic. He cost us valuable points by playing a system which didn't suit the players we had. We improved when the new signings came in, which is to be expected and I'd have expected the same improvement from Bilic or any other manager when you get better players in the side. That being said we still ended the season with 7 games without a win and conceded 17 goals in them games.
If I told you when he was appointed that he would only win 4 in 26 games and take us from 3 points from safety to 13 points I doubt anyone would quite believe it. The feeling was he had the experience and know how to keep us up. It was a tough job but not impossible and for me not a good enough return from a man with his experience.
Posts: 17,084
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
05-25-2021, 07:30 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-25-2021, 07:45 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
I've explained in my post how I've reached my conclusion - based on performances and the rest of the prem- you are just repeating your same point over and over again on the same thread. It doesn't make it right and I don't agree with you. Last season you repeatedly attacked Bilic and said the squad was brilliant and should be top 2 easy and should not struggle in that regard. You might say the gulf in prem and championship is massive but it is not that massive and it didn't become a shite squad after promotion - you are hugely inconsistent. It was always going to be a struggle and relegation was on the cards but not by the margin Allardyce managed. He did a terrible job in the end.
[/quote]
I did not repeatedly attack Bilic, back up the accusation I attacked Bilic repeatedly by linking to these numerous ‘attacks’.
The squad was good enough to be top two it erm finished top two. The wage bill and budget was also top four.
It was by and large a Championship squad that started the season which is why we went down, I didn’t attack Bilic this season before he got sacked. I have said all season whoever was in charge couldn’t keep us up.
[/quote]
You can link yourself and use the search function - I am getting older but my memory is sound. You were also against the appointment of Bilic and pro that of Sam which I think colours your analysis and excuses. Sam didn't just take us down, he failed by a mile to keep us up having stated he could do so. I had hoped he would and believe it was possible if we had a better replacement and a more honest one.
[/quote]
That’ll be a no then.
[/quote]
Link me
[/quote]
The site is playing up so apologies if this is a repeat post. The burden of proof is in the one making the accusations. Link me!
I never blamed Bilic or Allardyce for our relegation this season as my argument has been entirely consistent we were relegated due to a lack of resources. There are other less important reasons but ultimately the squad was never good enough.
Give me one Prem squad outside of those relegated that have a weaker squad and less money than we do?
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(05-25-2021, 07:07 PM)Duffers Wrote: Allardyce turned our season from a humiliating one into merely a shit one.
After he turned it into a humiliating one first... It was by far and away the worst period of the entire season when he came in until near the end of January... Up til then it had been shit, then he made it humiliating and then got it back to shit again.
Posts: 17,084
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-25-2021, 08:09 PM)Mayo Wrote: (05-25-2021, 07:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I've explained in my post how I've reached my conclusion - based on performances and the rest of the prem- you are just repeating your same point over and over again on the same thread. It doesn't make it right and I don't agree with you. Last season you repeatedly attacked Bilic and said the squad was brilliant and should be top 2 easy and should not struggle in that regard. You might say the gulf in prem and championship is massive but it is not that massive and it didn't become a shite squad after promotion - you are hugely inconsistent. It was always going to be a struggle and relegation was on the cards but not by the margin Allardyce managed. He did a terrible job in the end.
I did not repeatedly attack Bilic, back up the accusation I attacked Bilic repeatedly by linking to these numerous ‘attacks’.
The squad was good enough to be top two it erm finished top two. The wage bill and budget was also top four.
It was by and large a Championship squad that started the season which is why we went down, I didn’t attack Bilic this season before he got sacked. I have said all season whoever was in charge couldn’t keep us up. You can link yourself and use the search function - I am getting older but my memory is sound. You were also against the appointment of Bilic and pro that of Sam which I think colours your analysis and excuses. Sam didn't just take us down, he failed by a mile to keep us up having stated he could do so. I had hoped he would and believe it was possible if we had a better replacement and a more honest one.
[/quote]
That’ll be a no then.
[/quote]
Link me
[/quote]
The site is playing up so apologies if this is a repeat post. The burden of proof is in the one making the accusations. Link me!
I never blamed Bilic or Allardyce for our relegation this season as my argument has been entirely consistent we were relegated due to a lack of resources. There are other less important reasons but ultimately the squad was never good enough.
Give me one Prem squad outside of those relegated that have a weaker squad and less money than we do?
[/quote]
You said "that'll be a no" - link me to where I said that
See how stupid it is? There is no burden of proof and no 'accusation' - you were anti Bilic and pro Sam in terms of appointments- we both know it - else Link me
Albion have gone up and not been relegated before as with Sheffield last year - it is not impossible - Sam said he could achieve it - he was miles off
List me all the teams that have gone down that were not promoted since the prem began and had more money than.promoted teams - as you are playing the 'make ridiculous requests of anyone with a different opinion" game
[/quote]
You accused me of lol ‘attacking’ Bilic repeatedly and I said show me some examples. I have never said I was in favour of Bilic’s appointment but show me these repeated attacks on him throughout the season.
|