Bye Bye the Fat Fraud
#61
(05-25-2021, 09:20 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I don't feel either of the managers did the best they could though, that's my complaint. We were always going to struggle to not be relegated, and therefore if Bilic had done the basics of his job, he would have seen out the season, regardless of league position.

Big Sam took far too long to have a positive impact and even then made some quite baffling decisions that meant we barely put up a fight.

Neither can say they did a decent job this season imo.

I think thats right. It's not a binary "you're either for Billic or for Allardyce" its way more nuanced and really the blame needs to be shared pretty equally around the whole club. I'm not ITK, so I don't know the split in terms of identification and pursuit of players but the lads signed in the close season (with the exeption of Gallacher) just weren't good enough. The loan signing of Krov a particular low point. Bloke was barely good enough in a decent championship side last season, struggled to nail down a regular first team place, but for what appeared to be little more than sentimental reasons, he was signed and wasted a whole squad space for the first half of the season.

Billic needs to take a shit load of blame for the appalling finish to last season and the fact that this year we just didn't look as fit as our opponents. As a promoted side, short on quality, the one area you need to compete is on fitness. Outrun, outwork the oppo and you may get something.

I'd have probably stuck with Billic a bit longer, but I think that is an emotional thing based on liking the bloke and wanting him to do well, despite the facts in front of me suggesting we were regressing. I think a fair few felt similar.

Once Bilic went and big Sam came in I accepted, rather than welcomed, the appointment. I think he was surprised by the lack of fitness and quality in the squad, suggesting to me that his primary motivation was the big pay cheque and he didn't do his due dilligence on us.

For someone who declares himself a football genius he appeared to be stumped on how to make the best of what he had at his disposal. We were shit at the back and tightening us up made sense but he tried to achieve this at the expense of any real attacking intent and in the time taken to improve us defensively we went through that awful phase of being shit at the back and not offering anything in the attacking third. That was a recipe for a series of frankly humiliating tonkings.

I thought we had a good winter transfer window - those signings, had the been made at the start of the season, with Fat Sam in charge would, I think, have kept us up.

My conclusion is I think we could have stayed up had three things happened:

1. Bilic got the chop at the end of last season (but realistically who was asking for that in the summer? Certainly not me!)
2. Allardyce was appointed and had a pre-season with the players
3. We didn't squander time money and effort bringing in the wrong players in the summer (Dowling/Bilic to blame? Who fucking knows?)

Thats all hypothetical Aunty had bollocks stuff and I'm not giving Allardyce  free pass. The way the season panned out he takes a huge chunk of the blame but probably no more than Bilic and Dowling.
Reply
#62
What never ceases to amaze me is the lack of awareness of where we sit in the footballing food chain at any given time from an element of one-eyed fans.
Fact is promoted sides tend to struggle, with 1 or 2 almost certainly relegated each year. Based on that we were going to have trouble add to the fact we stumbled over the line thanks to Brentford losing their bottle.
Only now with hindsight we can see how poor the acquisitions were- I feel sorry for Grady though. I hope he can come back stronger this year.
Allardyce did make us better, but there's no excuse just how pitiful we were for too long under him at the start. Those home thumping were the worst set of performances I ever recall. I'm only grateful we didn't get some record thumping- the day we were hammered by Leeds 8 or 9 looked possible.
Now, with a new season to look forward to, we are in a far stronger position than even when Bilic came in. We've Championship knowhow added to Prem parachutes and probably a huge wedge in the kitty selling one or both of our prized assets.
Reply
#63
(05-25-2021, 09:55 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote:
(05-25-2021, 09:20 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I don't feel either of the managers did the best they could though, that's my complaint. We were always going to struggle to not be relegated, and therefore if Bilic had done the basics of his job, he would have seen out the season, regardless of league position.

Big Sam took far too long to have a positive impact and even then made some quite baffling decisions that meant we barely put up a fight.

Neither can say they did a decent job this season imo.

For someone who declares himself a football genius he appeared to be stumped on how to make the best of what he had at his disposal. We were shit at the back and tightening us up made sense but he tried to achieve this at the expense of any real attacking intent and in the time taken to improve us defensively we went through that awful phase of being shit at the back and not offering anything in the attacking third. That was a recipe for a series of frankly humiliating tonkings.
I can’t find anywhere were Allardyce described himself as a ‘football genius’. I can find reports of Pep Guardiola referring to him as such.
Reply
#64
(05-25-2021, 10:05 AM)JOK Wrote:
(05-25-2021, 09:55 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote:
(05-25-2021, 09:20 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I don't feel either of the managers did the best they could though, that's my complaint. We were always going to struggle to not be relegated, and therefore if Bilic had done the basics of his job, he would have seen out the season, regardless of league position.

Big Sam took far too long to have a positive impact and even then made some quite baffling decisions that meant we barely put up a fight.

Neither can say they did a decent job this season imo.

For someone who declares himself a football genius he appeared to be stumped on how to make the best of what he had at his disposal. We were shit at the back and tightening us up made sense but he tried to achieve this at the expense of any real attacking intent and in the time taken to improve us defensively we went through that awful phase of being shit at the back and not offering anything in the attacking third. That was a recipe for a series of frankly humiliating tonkings.

I can’t find anywhere were Allardyce described himself as a ‘football genius’. I can find reports of Pep Guardiola referring to him as such.

Well let's be fair, Pep knows absolutely fuck all, compared to some of the knowledgeable posters on here.   Rolleyes
Reply
#65
(05-25-2021, 10:05 AM)JOK Wrote:
(05-25-2021, 09:55 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote:
(05-25-2021, 09:20 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I don't feel either of the managers did the best they could though, that's my complaint. We were always going to struggle to not be relegated, and therefore if Bilic had done the basics of his job, he would have seen out the season, regardless of league position.

Big Sam took far too long to have a positive impact and even then made some quite baffling decisions that meant we barely put up a fight.

Neither can say they did a decent job this season imo.

For someone who declares himself a football genius he appeared to be stumped on how to make the best of what he had at his disposal. We were shit at the back and tightening us up made sense but he tried to achieve this at the expense of any real attacking intent and in the time taken to improve us defensively we went through that awful phase of being shit at the back and not offering anything in the attacking third. That was a recipe for a series of frankly humiliating tonkings.
I can’t find anywhere were Allardyce described himself as a ‘football genius’. I can find reports of Pep Guardiola referring to him as such.

You’re right to call me up on that. I’ve not phrased it well.  What I would say, if I was to be arsed to edit my original post is:

“For someone who, it can be inferred from his previous public statements, has a particularly high opinion of his own material abilities, he appeared to be stumped on how to make the best of what he had at his disposal.”

How’s that for you, ok?
Reply
#66
(05-25-2021, 09:56 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: What never ceases to amaze me is the lack of awareness of where we sit in the footballing food chain at any given time from an element of one-eyed fans.
Fact is promoted sides tend to struggle, with 1 or 2 almost certainly relegated each year. Based on that we were going to have trouble add to the fact we stumbled over the line thanks to Brentford losing their bottle.
Only now with hindsight we can see how poor the acquisitions were- I feel sorry for Grady though. I hope he can come back stronger this year.
Allardyce did make us better, but there's no excuse just how pitiful we were for too long under him at the start. Those home thumping were the worst set of performances I ever recall. I'm only grateful we didn't get some record thumping- the day we were hammered by Leeds 8 or 9 looked possible.
Now, with a new season to look forward to, we are in a far stronger position than even when Bilic came in. We've Championship knowhow added to Prem parachutes and probably a huge wedge in the kitty selling one or both of our prized assets.

Since the start of the PL, 46% of newly promoted clubs have been relegated the following season.
Reply
#67
(05-25-2021, 01:36 PM)Supamart Wrote:
(05-25-2021, 09:56 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: What never ceases to amaze me is the lack of awareness of where we sit in the footballing food chain at any given time from an element of one-eyed fans.
Fact is promoted sides tend to struggle, with 1 or 2 almost certainly relegated each year. Based on that we were going to have trouble add to the fact we stumbled over the line thanks to Brentford losing their bottle.
Only now with hindsight we can see how poor the acquisitions were- I feel sorry for Grady though. I hope he can come back stronger this year.
Allardyce did make us better, but there's no excuse just how pitiful we were for too long under him at the start. Those home thumping were the worst set of performances I ever recall. I'm only grateful we didn't get some record thumping- the day we were hammered by Leeds 8 or 9 looked possible.
Now, with a new season to look forward to, we are in a far stronger position than even when Bilic came in. We've Championship knowhow added to Prem parachutes and probably a huge wedge in the kitty selling one or both of our prized assets.

Since the start of the PL, 46% of promoted clubs have been relegated the following season.
So basically it's as near a 50/50 chance as you'll get. I wonder if you broke it down to the last decade what you'd get as the gap seems to have got wider. I also wonder how many promoted clubs without oodles of cash survive?
Reply
#68
Anyone would think we'd had plenty other players beating a path to sign for us last season. People are making out like we got in the players instead of other choices. Our dependency upon loan deals says that's nonsense. We simply pick what we consider to be the best we can afford that are willing to sign. Some higher profile managers might alter these facts slightly but the same applies to luring them here. "What's my transfer budget?, click burrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr"
Reply
#69
(05-25-2021, 09:42 AM)Mayo Wrote:
(05-25-2021, 09:20 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I don't feel either of the managers did the best they could though, that's my complaint. We were always going to struggle to not be relegated, and therefore if Bilic had done the basics of his job, he would have seen out the season, regardless of league position.

Big Sam took far too long to have a positive impact and even then made some quite baffling decisions that meant we barely put up a fight.

Neither can say they did a decent job this season imo.

I agree - I didn't think we were doomed from the off and though perhaps was over optimistic as I tend to be (a football supporter thing), I still think we were capable of survival with the lower half of the prem not great regardless of their budgets. There were some promising performances under Bilic which showed we could compete - including his last game - and we had a few of the dodgy prem decisions against us early on which impacted points (Chelsea's last minute equaliser after handball for one). I would have given Bilic more time as he knew the squad the best and we were not adrift - but Sam was brought in as Bilic was deemed to be unlikely to succeed at that point.

He was brought in on the pretext he would keep us up, which he said he could, and he had time and resources to do so. But he was as awful as any new manager we ever had at the start with humiliating performances, and when we eventually saw improvements they were fleeting and too late - then back to fairly tame defeats.  He failed badly and by a long way. 

The only reason I wanted him to stay was that it would have signaled intent from the board to back him and retain the squad which is good enough for promotion - one I think could have competed far better in the prem. It turned out Sam lied about his intents though, and given his record this should not be a surprise. We need to look at character of the appointments as well as their managerial record surely now as we have been stung this way before. 

So the excuses being made for him are weak as far as I am concerned, making a few players look fitter and better whilst being beaten and relegated by a mile is no great shakes based on his remit. It does mean the new manager can hardly be much worse in terms of integrity and achievement though, and I look forward to seeing who it is, hopefully soon. One thing I think Sam got right was his comment about a young and ambitious manager, but Wilder would do - he is still the latter at least.

How did you come to the conclusion that our Championship squad with an OAP defender and Gallagher added was in anyway good enough to compete in the Prem for half a season? It was barely good enough to get promotion for nearly half a season. I don't think Bilic, Allardyce, Merlin the Magician, the Sorceress from He-Man, Dumbledore of Gandalf could have kept us up. It's very weak argument to suggest that someone has abjectly failed because they took on a job that was pretty impossible to achieve. The fact is we weren't good enough under two managers and regardless of if's, but's and maybe's our squad simply wasn't up to the job of staying in the league and I'd argue the three clubs that went down had the three worst squads regardless of who was managing them.
Reply
#70
I think that’s all very true, Derek.

Allardyce brought improved discipline and fitness, and the signings were a shot in the arm no doubt; but it sadly proved never enough. But I’m not really convinced Sam would have kept us up this season had he come in on day one, because under two thirds of his stewardship we were only marginally less shite.

We haven’t had a prolific striker all season, and have shipped a fuck ton of goals under both regimes. Only during one brief patch (when, coincidentally enough, Sam began to play Periera in his preferred position) did we ever look like we had any kind of hope, but by then sadly the lack of a rebound effect rendered that unsustainably brief period of better form look anything more than a hope to win the lottery.

The lack of residual quality just simply never meant it was possible to stay up this year; and in spite of an improved approach under Sam, our overall form under him didn’t surpass Bilic by a great deal. We were awful for 6 games when he joined, and still finished the season with 4 straight defeats, no win in 8 since the Saints game (6 losses permeated only by two draws against local rivals, at least one of which we should have taken more from). Furthermore the basic errors were beginning to creep back in.

Whilst things were unlikely to improve whatsoever under Bilic, the fact Allardyce began and ended his reign so poorly proves he wasn’t worth the punt, and that they both failed. As has been mentioned above the ‘either/or’ debate is of tedious note. The club failed from top to bottom this season really, with nobody of any seniority delivering, and I’m afraid that all began straight after a first lockdown everyone expected a team of reported Avenger-like tenacity to hit the field again. Bilic and Allardyce are easy to blame, but neither were ever likely to succeed, and I’m afraid the necessary rebuild required following what will see practically all of our best talent bar perhaps Townsend depart is testament to that.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)