Posts: 8,132
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
05-23-2021, 11:08 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-23-2021, 11:10 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Mish’s post about sums it up for me. Just a mess of a season where all in charge (from the very top to the club captain) just hadn’t a clue, or just weren’t up to it.
While I was happy to wish him well him rather than slate him while he was here, it was always a compromised decision to appoint him under the terms and timing we did; and therefore always a ‘wait-and-see’ with Big Sam as to whether or not I thought he should stay. Well, we waited, saw, and went down. So he failed. So I couldn’t care less that he’s gone.
It was a tall order due to the damage already done (mainly pre-season), but the plain-and-simple is that if we couldn’t tie him down beyond a relegation, he was only brought in to keep us up; and failed.
So it matters little that he wasn’t interested in a job he couldn’t craft. I’m glad he’s gone in that case.
There was improvement, as has been well highlighted above. But it wasn’t enough; and the rebound effect was zero. Also, there is nothing to say many of our improved players wouldn’t have at the same rate (or better) had we identified a better, longer-term replacement; or had the bollocks to sack Bilic sooner when it was clear that this side was going to struggle much earlier than a City game the club were banking on us losing.
It really wasn’t just Sam and Bilic who failed a number of times. Such a season to forget, just like the last catastrophic relegation. And whilst the Pardew parallels are very different in some aspects, the constant is that neither could lose personally; being appointed through big-money desperation midway through the season. It’s almost as if the lessons were never learned.
Anyway, we are Albion, we have a chance now to start again; and we’ll be here longer than Sam will be able to steal a living from his next club.
Posts: 1,816
Threads: 69
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(05-23-2021, 10:18 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (05-23-2021, 06:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Cuzer, I'd say the opposite. The abuse Sam got from many was unacceptable. I thought the Bilic worship was more embarrassing. He'd lost it long before the end of last season. The close season recruitment was a farce.
The same close season recruitment that most on here were very, very happy (myself included) with? And in fact some of the signings were seen as unbelievably good value too...
(05-23-2021, 07:21 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (05-23-2021, 06:57 PM)MozzasRocket Wrote: (05-23-2021, 06:09 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Wow. What a problem some of you have.
I didn’t want him but he did improve us, albeit too late.
Move on instead of spewing bile about an appointment that didn’t work out.
+1
It’s the same ‘be kind’ brigade that come on here and spout the ‘fat’ abuse. I got called out the other day for calling Livermore a shit cunt, in hindsight it was out of order, I was merely fed up with his awful contribution to our team. However, constantly bringing up somebodies weight and using it in a negative connotation is bang out of order. He’s came in, tried his best. The players aren’t good enough, it’s that simple. Sam is a much better coach and manager than some of you understand. Either way, the fat stuff has to stop. It ain’t on, any abuse about somebodies weight, body, skin, hair colour, it’s all the same shit and needs to stop.
It’s amazing how many have shifted opinions from the Liverpool game. Let’s not forget we were without Pereira today as well.
I didn’t want Sam but his assessments were spot on. The defence has improved but apart from SJ and Townsend is a Championship defence.
I guess one of the reasons Sam turned us down is he doesn’t feel up to the rebuilding programme which will be bigger than some on here think.
Define - the defence has improved.... When the averages show that under Bilic we conceded 2 goals per game and under Allardyce we conceded 2 goals per game as well. In what World is that a defensive improvement? Allardyce led to around a 0.23 extra points per game and about 0.25 goals scored per game more... The defence was exactly the same. And there'll never be any factual evidence to say that things weren't 'improving' to the same levels under Bilic (not many got points off Man City this season for example).
Is Furlong a better player under Allardyce ..... yes
Is Townsend a better player under Allardyce ......yes
O’Shea showed improvement but I think rightly was taken out of the firing line.
Stats can show a number of things but need to be put in context. The first 4 or 5 games under Allardyce showed a squad who could not adapt quickly to what he wanted and lacked any support from the midfield.
It’s nowhere near good enough for the Prem though as I said and we need a defender in the MaCauley mould.
I’ll give you Man City away but Under Bilic it didn’t look like it would improve with a labouring Sawyers and Livermore in front of them.
Posts: 2,431
Threads: 137
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(05-23-2021, 06:09 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Wow. What a problem some of you have.
I didn’t want him but he did improve us, albeit too late.
Move on instead of spewing bile about an appointment that didn’t work out.
+1.
We have to get over this destructive habit of blaming successive mangers.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(05-23-2021, 10:18 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (05-23-2021, 06:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Cuzer, I'd say the opposite. The abuse Sam got from many was unacceptable. I thought the Bilic worship was more embarrassing. He'd lost it long before the end of last season. The close season recruitment was a farce.
The same close season recruitment that most on here were very, very happy (myself included) with? And in fact some of the signings were seen as unbelievably good value too...
(05-23-2021, 07:21 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (05-23-2021, 06:57 PM)MozzasRocket Wrote: (05-23-2021, 06:09 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Wow. What a problem some of you have.
I didn’t want him but he did improve us, albeit too late.
Move on instead of spewing bile about an appointment that didn’t work out.
+1
It’s the same ‘be kind’ brigade that come on here and spout the ‘fat’ abuse. I got called out the other day for calling Livermore a shit cunt, in hindsight it was out of order, I was merely fed up with his awful contribution to our team. However, constantly bringing up somebodies weight and using it in a negative connotation is bang out of order. He’s came in, tried his best. The players aren’t good enough, it’s that simple. Sam is a much better coach and manager than some of you understand. Either way, the fat stuff has to stop. It ain’t on, any abuse about somebodies weight, body, skin, hair colour, it’s all the same shit and needs to stop.
It’s amazing how many have shifted opinions from the Liverpool game. Let’s not forget we were without Pereira today as well.
I didn’t want Sam but his assessments were spot on. The defence has improved but apart from SJ and Townsend is a Championship defence.
I guess one of the reasons Sam turned us down is he doesn’t feel up to the rebuilding programme which will be bigger than some on here think.
Define - the defence has improved.... When the averages show that under Bilic we conceded 2 goals per game and under Allardyce we conceded 2 goals per game as well. In what World is that a defensive improvement? Allardyce led to around a 0.23 extra points per game and about 0.25 goals scored per game more... The defence was exactly the same. And there'll never be any factual evidence to say that things weren't 'improving' to the same levels under Bilic (not many got points off Man City this season for example).
Just because the average is very similar doesn’t mean it didn’t improve.
It started awful and got better as we progressed. What hasn’t been eradicated and to an extent this is mainly down to the quality of player is individual mistakes. Even yesterday, a basic save from a free kick fluffed and a ridiculous handball. That’s nothing to do with how organised we are or not.
The same defence next season will make less individual errors as they’re most likely to be under less pressure.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 300
Threads: 44
Joined: Oct 2020
(05-23-2021, 09:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I see the the ott criticism has reached peak nonsense on here.
The squad was never good enough, we essentially bought last years squad adding a young player in Gallagher and an OAP defender in the summer. It limped over the line to promotion with very little confidence or momentum. As good as the first half of the season was under Bilic the second half ranged from average to poor, and yet with the same players we expected collectively as a club to compete in the most competitive, richest league in the world?
Allardyce’s appointment was a consequence of poor form, poor recruitment, an owner unwilling to invest and perhaps even wanting to be the owner. It was a sensible decision by the club to go for a manager with a track record of keeping clubs in danger of getting relegated out of trouble. Sadly the imo impossible proved just that, impossible by the time he had any chance to turn the club around it was too late. The player and manager we bolstered the squad with in January did make a difference, but not enough to stay up.
Most clubs that go up survive either through spending millions, astute signings, or riding a crest of a wave in terms of squad confidence in many cases all three. We did none of those things and inevitably got relegated. Those now blaming Allardyce are lying to themselves if they believe he’s ultimately responsible or that there was a hero shaped young, progressive manager waiting in the wings who would have kept this squad up.
Allardyce is responsible for one major mistake and that is he believed his own hype with regards to keeping a team as disjointed and lacking in confidence up. I don’t know what he said after the match but it was never set in stone he would stay and the club would have been making contingency plans / alternatives for a new manager anyway.
The parameters for the next manager as far as I’m aware hasn’t changed we still have two years advantage over most teams to get back up, we still have an owner who wants to sell the club. There are no long term strategies at the club, it’s still promotion as fast as possible and hope we can stay up so Lai sells to who knows who.
Good luck with the fairytale manager and owner waiting in the wings to get us to the next level, we reached previously but wasn’t good enough for some of our fans.
Yet you wanted Sam to stay even though it was clear to knowledgeable fans that he wasnt up to it and he didnt really give a toss
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(05-24-2021, 05:09 PM)Madness Wrote: (05-23-2021, 09:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I see the the ott criticism has reached peak nonsense on here.
The squad was never good enough, we essentially bought last years squad adding a young player in Gallagher and an OAP defender in the summer. It limped over the line to promotion with very little confidence or momentum. As good as the first half of the season was under Bilic the second half ranged from average to poor, and yet with the same players we expected collectively as a club to compete in the most competitive, richest league in the world?
Allardyce’s appointment was a consequence of poor form, poor recruitment, an owner unwilling to invest and perhaps even wanting to be the owner. It was a sensible decision by the club to go for a manager with a track record of keeping clubs in danger of getting relegated out of trouble. Sadly the imo impossible proved just that, impossible by the time he had any chance to turn the club around it was too late. The player and manager we bolstered the squad with in January did make a difference, but not enough to stay up.
Most clubs that go up survive either through spending millions, astute signings, or riding a crest of a wave in terms of squad confidence in many cases all three. We did none of those things and inevitably got relegated. Those now blaming Allardyce are lying to themselves if they believe he’s ultimately responsible or that there was a hero shaped young, progressive manager waiting in the wings who would have kept this squad up.
Allardyce is responsible for one major mistake and that is he believed his own hype with regards to keeping a team as disjointed and lacking in confidence up. I don’t know what he said after the match but it was never set in stone he would stay and the club would have been making contingency plans / alternatives for a new manager anyway.
The parameters for the next manager as far as I’m aware hasn’t changed we still have two years advantage over most teams to get back up, we still have an owner who wants to sell the club. There are no long term strategies at the club, it’s still promotion as fast as possible and hope we can stay up so Lai sells to who knows who.
Good luck with the fairytale manager and owner waiting in the wings to get us to the next level, we reached previously but wasn’t good enough for some of our fans.
Yet you wanted Sam to stay even though it was clear to knowledgeable fans that he wasnt up to it and he didnt really give a toss
I'm not sure "knowledgeable" and fan-boying beyond reason over Bilic because he looked bouncy on the touchline go together.
Posts: 17,084
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-24-2021, 05:09 PM)Madness Wrote: (05-23-2021, 09:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I see the the ott criticism has reached peak nonsense on here.
The squad was never good enough, we essentially bought last years squad adding a young player in Gallagher and an OAP defender in the summer. It limped over the line to promotion with very little confidence or momentum. As good as the first half of the season was under Bilic the second half ranged from average to poor, and yet with the same players we expected collectively as a club to compete in the most competitive, richest league in the world?
Allardyce’s appointment was a consequence of poor form, poor recruitment, an owner unwilling to invest and perhaps even wanting to be the owner. It was a sensible decision by the club to go for a manager with a track record of keeping clubs in danger of getting relegated out of trouble. Sadly the imo impossible proved just that, impossible by the time he had any chance to turn the club around it was too late. The player and manager we bolstered the squad with in January did make a difference, but not enough to stay up.
Most clubs that go up survive either through spending millions, astute signings, or riding a crest of a wave in terms of squad confidence in many cases all three. We did none of those things and inevitably got relegated. Those now blaming Allardyce are lying to themselves if they believe he’s ultimately responsible or that there was a hero shaped young, progressive manager waiting in the wings who would have kept this squad up.
Allardyce is responsible for one major mistake and that is he believed his own hype with regards to keeping a team as disjointed and lacking in confidence up. I don’t know what he said after the match but it was never set in stone he would stay and the club would have been making contingency plans / alternatives for a new manager anyway.
The parameters for the next manager as far as I’m aware hasn’t changed we still have two years advantage over most teams to get back up, we still have an owner who wants to sell the club. There are no long term strategies at the club, it’s still promotion as fast as possible and hope we can stay up so Lai sells to who knows who.
Good luck with the fairytale manager and owner waiting in the wings to get us to the next level, we reached previously but wasn’t good enough for some of our fans.
Yet you wanted Sam to stay even though it was clear to knowledgeable fans that he wasnt up to it and he didnt really give a toss
Arf what yes dear!
Posts: 17,084
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-24-2021, 05:09 PM)Madness Wrote: (05-23-2021, 09:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I see the the ott criticism has reached peak nonsense on here.
The squad was never good enough, we essentially bought last years squad adding a young player in Gallagher and an OAP defender in the summer. It limped over the line to promotion with very little confidence or momentum. As good as the first half of the season was under Bilic the second half ranged from average to poor, and yet with the same players we expected collectively as a club to compete in the most competitive, richest league in the world?
Allardyce’s appointment was a consequence of poor form, poor recruitment, an owner unwilling to invest and perhaps even wanting to be the owner. It was a sensible decision by the club to go for a manager with a track record of keeping clubs in danger of getting relegated out of trouble. Sadly the imo impossible proved just that, impossible by the time he had any chance to turn the club around it was too late. The player and manager we bolstered the squad with in January did make a difference, but not enough to stay up.
Most clubs that go up survive either through spending millions, astute signings, or riding a crest of a wave in terms of squad confidence in many cases all three. We did none of those things and inevitably got relegated. Those now blaming Allardyce are lying to themselves if they believe he’s ultimately responsible or that there was a hero shaped young, progressive manager waiting in the wings who would have kept this squad up.
Allardyce is responsible for one major mistake and that is he believed his own hype with regards to keeping a team as disjointed and lacking in confidence up. I don’t know what he said after the match but it was never set in stone he would stay and the club would have been making contingency plans / alternatives for a new manager anyway.
The parameters for the next manager as far as I’m aware hasn’t changed we still have two years advantage over most teams to get back up, we still have an owner who wants to sell the club. There are no long term strategies at the club, it’s still promotion as fast as possible and hope we can stay up so Lai sells to who knows who.
Good luck with the fairytale manager and owner waiting in the wings to get us to the next level, we reached previously but wasn’t good enough for some of our fans.
Yet you wanted Sam to stay even though it was clear to knowledgeable fans that he wasnt up to it and he didnt really give a toss
Arf!
Posts: 4,733
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
In conclusion he was appointed to keep us up but failed and then decided he couldn't be arsed to get us back up from the Championship as his massive ego wouldn't allow him to manage in that division.
Roll on next season with a new manager
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
05-24-2021, 06:36 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-24-2021, 06:37 PM by fuzzbox.)
If he had kept us up it would have been an amazing feat.
In truth, he never looked like achieving it.
Yes, the team got better, but it was still nowhere near to good enough.
His January purchases were improvements, but they still weren't close to good enough.
I guess what I'm saying is that he was better than Bilic, but still not good enough.
|