Posts: 527
Threads: 0
Joined: Dec 2020
Reputation:
4
(05-23-2021, 08:07 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Expected better from him
Thought with his experience etc we could have stayed up
But he just never seemed bothered in my opinion
We went from being a poor team to an absolute pile of crap
For me it was only when he was forced to make a change due to injury did we start to play & get results
I thought Alan Pardew was bad
But SA was much worse
Is this a wind up? Pardew lost 8 games in a row. EIGHT. With a team that should have been comfortably mid-table.
Posts: 5,323
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(05-23-2021, 08:16 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: (05-23-2021, 08:07 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Expected better from him
Thought with his experience etc we could have stayed up
But he just never seemed bothered in my opinion
We went from being a poor team to an absolute pile of crap
For me it was only when he was forced to make a change due to injury did we start to play & get results
I thought Alan Pardew was bad
But SA was much worse
Is this a wind up? Pardew lost 8 games in a row. EIGHT. With a team that should have been comfortably mid-table.
There is no way that squad was going to be comfortably mid table.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
It had mid table and above in the preceding seasons and then we had a supposedly great transfer window.
It went to shit because Pulis wanted out and Evans was sulking about it getting his move to City. That side should never have been relegated.
Pardew was a disaster, Allardyce was a gamble that failed with a team that almost certainly was never really good enough to begin with.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
05-23-2021, 08:42 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-23-2021, 08:44 PM by Man from delmonte.)
(05-23-2021, 08:07 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Expected better from him
Thought with his experience etc we could have stayed up
But he just never seemed bothered in my opinion
We went from being a poor team to an absolute pile of crap
For me it was only when he was forced to make a change due to injury did we start to play & get results
I thought Alan Pardew was bad
But SA was much worse Pardew did untold damage to the club which will take years to undo. We had a decent Premer League quality side that was more than capable of staying in the league particularly when you think that atrocious Huddersfield side stayed up that season. Relegation put us on the backfoot financially which without wealthy investors is so difficult to come back from as well as obviously losing some of our best players (Rondon, J-Rod, Foster, Dawson etc) in the following year.
Whilst on the balance of things Allardyce didn't do a great job, he was working with a much poorer squad and one which was very unlikely to stay up which was clear from the start of the season. It is obviously a real disappointment that we went down so feebly though. I'm sure Sheffield United and Fulham fans are feeling exactly the same way.
(05-23-2021, 08:30 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (05-23-2021, 08:16 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: (05-23-2021, 08:07 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Expected better from him
Thought with his experience etc we could have stayed up
But he just never seemed bothered in my opinion
We went from being a poor team to an absolute pile of crap
For me it was only when he was forced to make a change due to injury did we start to play & get results
I thought Alan Pardew was bad
But SA was much worse
Is this a wind up? Pardew lost 8 games in a row. EIGHT. With a team that should have been comfortably mid-table.
There is no way that squad was going to be comfortably mid table. Why not? The same squad had been comfortably mid table in the preceding years (the Pepe Mel season aside).
Posts: 5,323
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Pardew was rubbish, but he took over a club that had won 3 of its previous 25 league games.
There was something obviously wrong before he turned up.
The squad was ageing, with a lack of goalscorers, and too many influential players who were not going to be inconvenienced by relegation.
You can put all the blame on Pardew, but that would be a mistake.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
Where to start?!
Firstly, it's embarrassing how much slack people gave Bilic. The man had no plan B and the players were shockingly, atrociously unfit.
I will repeat: we were trying to compete in the Premier League with a team stuffed full of players who could barely play 70 minutes. But Slav was a cool bloke, who jumped up and down on the touchline, so that was ignored.
A portion of blame has to go to Dowling and Ken. They are paid to make the tough choices and they left it far too late to sack Bilic. They, or at least Dowling, will have also known that the team that started the season was desperately deficient.
Allardyce coming in from two years out of football, in a Covid season (with the training restrictions and no fans) and a minimal budget...could anyone have done better? Possibly not. Does that mean Allardyce didn't make mistakes? There were issues with some of the in-match management, particularly of the crunch matches against the teams around us. But we did undoubtedly look better, even if the results didn't always reflect that.
I wanted him to stay. But he's chosen otherwise and now we can look for someone new. It would have made no sense bringing someone in for the end of the season, so it made little difference when he told us.
Anyone saying he did a worse job than Pardew needs their head checking. That was a mid-table Premier League team that ended up bottom of the table!
Posts: 17,081
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
I see the the ott criticism has reached peak nonsense on here.
The squad was never good enough, we essentially bought last years squad adding a young player in Gallagher and an OAP defender in the summer. It limped over the line to promotion with very little confidence or momentum. As good as the first half of the season was under Bilic the second half ranged from average to poor, and yet with the same players we expected collectively as a club to compete in the most competitive, richest league in the world?
Allardyce’s appointment was a consequence of poor form, poor recruitment, an owner unwilling to invest and perhaps even wanting to be the owner. It was a sensible decision by the club to go for a manager with a track record of keeping clubs in danger of getting relegated out of trouble. Sadly the imo impossible proved just that, impossible by the time he had any chance to turn the club around it was too late. The player and manager we bolstered the squad with in January did make a difference, but not enough to stay up.
Most clubs that go up survive either through spending millions, astute signings, or riding a crest of a wave in terms of squad confidence in many cases all three. We did none of those things and inevitably got relegated. Those now blaming Allardyce are lying to themselves if they believe he’s ultimately responsible or that there was a hero shaped young, progressive manager waiting in the wings who would have kept this squad up.
Allardyce is responsible for one major mistake and that is he believed his own hype with regards to keeping a team as disjointed and lacking in confidence up. I don’t know what he said after the match but it was never set in stone he would stay and the club would have been making contingency plans / alternatives for a new manager anyway.
The parameters for the next manager as far as I’m aware hasn’t changed we still have two years advantage over most teams to get back up, we still have an owner who wants to sell the club. There are no long term strategies at the club, it’s still promotion as fast as possible and hope we can stay up so Lai sells to who knows who.
Good luck with the fairytale manager and owner waiting in the wings to get us to the next level, we reached previously but wasn’t good enough for some of our fans.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(05-23-2021, 09:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I see the the ott criticism has reached peak nonsense on here.
The squad was never good enough, we essentially bought last years squad adding a young player in Gallagher and an OAP defender in the summer. It limped over the line to promotion with very little confidence or momentum. As good as the first half of the season was under Bilic the second half ranged from average to poor, and yet with the same players we expected collectively as a club to compete in the most competitive, richest league in the world?
Allardyce’s appointment was a consequence of poor form, poor recruitment, an owner unwilling to invest and perhaps even wanting to be the owner. It was a sensible decision by the club to go for a manager with a track record of keeping clubs in danger of getting relegated out of trouble. Sadly the imo impossible proved just that, impossible by the time he had any chance to turn the club around it was too late. The player and manager we bolstered the squad with in January did make a difference, but not enough to stay up.
Most clubs that go up survive either through spending millions, astute signings, or riding a crest of a wave in terms of squad confidence in many cases all three. We did none of those things and inevitably got relegated. Those now blaming Allardyce are lying to themselves if they believe he’s ultimately responsible or that there was a hero shaped young, progressive manager waiting in the wings who would have kept this squad up.
Allardyce is responsible for one major mistake and that is he believed his own hype with regards to keeping a team as disjointed and lacking in confidence up. I don’t know what he said after the match but it was never set in stone he would stay and the club would have been making contingency plans / alternatives for a new manager anyway.
The parameters for the next manager as far as I’m aware hasn’t changed we still have two years advantage over most teams to get back up, we still have an owner who wants to sell the club. There are no long term strategies at the club, it’s still promotion as fast as possible and hope we can stay up so Lai sells to who knows who.
Good luck with the fairytale manager and owner waiting in the wings to get us to the next level, we reached previously but wasn’t good enough for some of our fans.
I agree ... we were miles off being good enough before January even without the problem of fitness levels. After Jan we were closer to being competitive but quality and experience wise we were still worse than Newcastle, Brighton, Burnley.
Not saying Sam did a great job, I don't think his health was 100% and he didn't seem to have the same fire and energy as he used to have but he was far from the main reason we went down.
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(05-23-2021, 06:16 PM)Mish Wrote: It was an expensive gamble that failed. We recruited appallingly last Summer, essentially paying a fortune to keep the same side, with the exception of Grant who reinforced a position that we didn't need strengthening, as an attacking wide midfielder, we already had Robinson, Grosicki (who?) and Diangana to play that position.
Sam's positives - Furlong, Bartley and Townsend (especially) seemed to improve. In a season where, quite rightly, Pereira and Johnstone get the plaudits, I think Townsend has been fantastic. Yokuslu and AMN improved the side. Diagne frozen out after the Arsenal no-show. Snodgrass helped to win the game at Wolves and disappeared. He realised that Livermore and Sawyers were out of their depth of this level.
Sam's negatives - treatment of Robinson and O'Shea has been abysmal. We either drew or lost 'must-win' games due to excessive caution. Touchline persona looked like he couldn't be bothered. Eventually realised that Pereira wasn't a wide midfielder. We lost the season in the 5 or so games after he took charge where we became whipping boys, looked like he tried to change too much too soon. Throwing the club captain under the bus after the Villa game was a shit move and should have been done in private.
In summary : meh, fuck off Sam. Replacing Bilic wasn't a mistake. Replacing him with Allardyce was.
And while I'm feeling analytical, you fuck off too Lai. You utter twat.
Mish, this is an intelligent post and a keen analysis of the situation. What a shame you spoiled it with "Fuck off Sam" and "Fuck off too Lai. You utter twat". It really doesn't add anything either to the debate or to your credibility.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
05-23-2021, 10:18 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-23-2021, 10:21 PM by MassDebater.)
(05-23-2021, 06:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Cuzer, I'd say the opposite. The abuse Sam got from many was unacceptable. I thought the Bilic worship was more embarrassing. He'd lost it long before the end of last season. The close season recruitment was a farce.
The same close season recruitment that most on here were very, very happy (myself included) with? And in fact some of the signings were seen as unbelievably good value too...
(05-23-2021, 07:21 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (05-23-2021, 06:57 PM)MozzasRocket Wrote: (05-23-2021, 06:09 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Wow. What a problem some of you have.
I didn’t want him but he did improve us, albeit too late.
Move on instead of spewing bile about an appointment that didn’t work out.
+1
It’s the same ‘be kind’ brigade that come on here and spout the ‘fat’ abuse. I got called out the other day for calling Livermore a shit cunt, in hindsight it was out of order, I was merely fed up with his awful contribution to our team. However, constantly bringing up somebodies weight and using it in a negative connotation is bang out of order. He’s came in, tried his best. The players aren’t good enough, it’s that simple. Sam is a much better coach and manager than some of you understand. Either way, the fat stuff has to stop. It ain’t on, any abuse about somebodies weight, body, skin, hair colour, it’s all the same shit and needs to stop.
It’s amazing how many have shifted opinions from the Liverpool game. Let’s not forget we were without Pereira today as well.
I didn’t want Sam but his assessments were spot on. The defence has improved but apart from SJ and Townsend is a Championship defence.
I guess one of the reasons Sam turned us down is he doesn’t feel up to the rebuilding programme which will be bigger than some on here think.
Define - the defence has improved.... When the averages show that under Bilic we conceded 2 goals per game and under Allardyce we conceded 2 goals per game as well. In what World is that a defensive improvement? Allardyce led to around a 0.23 extra points per game and about 0.25 goals scored per game more... The defence was exactly the same. And there'll never be any factual evidence to say that things weren't 'improving' to the same levels under Bilic (not many got points off Man City this season for example).
|