How was that not a goal
#41
It shouldve been a goal. The keeper ain't getting to that even if Phillips is sitting in the Halfords.

Ridiculous decision. Justified by those trained and paid to find a way to justify it.


Complete and utter bullshit. Wrong, just plain wrong, however they try to spin it and however many people are dragged onside to justify it.
Reply
#42
(05-17-2021, 01:13 PM)UCEbaggie Wrote:
(05-17-2021, 01:05 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Two things for me, they took about 15 seconds to come to the decision, which is disgusting, I genuinely question if it was scored against us they would have took a lot longer and probably awarded it

For me if Ajayi scores then it's right to rule out the goal given Phillips position (feckin lazy of him mind) however when Ajayi heads it wide and Bartley stabs home it should stand, keeper has no chance of saving it and how does that really differ to a back post header across goal then being turned in by a player? If somebody is infront of the keeper when it's headed back across goal it's not an issue so how was ours any different?

I thought we were on the end of some woeful officiating yesterday in all honesty

Cuzer

Yep. Agree with all of that 100%

In full agreement as well. 

Honestly this is the only game where I can remember so outraged by a decision like this. My head says to let it go but given the evidence, this is the worst case of a lack of integrity as has happened in our 1 year tenure back. It's really been the 'fuck this I'd rather be in a different league' I needed before heading back to the championship.
Reply
#43
(05-17-2021, 01:16 PM)HLS Wrote:
(05-17-2021, 01:12 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(05-16-2021, 06:08 PM)HLS Wrote:
(05-16-2021, 06:03 PM)MrFizz Wrote: It was flagged offside. So VAR would only overturn if they can prove Allisons view wasnt obstructed, which they couldn't.

But without VAR it still wouldn't have stood. Not happy about it, but its 'one of them'. I'd want it disallowed if it was the other way around.

Of course you would but do you really think they can't prove Allison's view was obstructed?

[Image: Zke0xhfrSbm4R4k6RHCT_Video%20%2837%29.jpg]


I don't suppose anyone has this viewing angle from a moment before when the ball hit Ajayi's head?

I don't actually, but I know what you're getting at. Thing is, the ball was in the air. Do we have to compare heights to judge that Allison can't see over Phillips head or can we just assume that he is where he is because he chooses to be there? GK's fault for choosing to be behind the player at that point.

I absolutely agree with that and it's the exact point I've been making to 2 LFC fans that I'm arguing with online. From the point the corner was taken that ball was over 6 feet in the air until it landed at Bartley's feet. Phillips was in a convenient position for Becker to claim he was unsighted. Utter BS decision.
Reply
#44
(05-17-2021, 01:21 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(05-17-2021, 01:16 PM)HLS Wrote:
(05-17-2021, 01:12 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(05-16-2021, 06:08 PM)HLS Wrote:
(05-16-2021, 06:03 PM)MrFizz Wrote: It was flagged offside. So VAR would only overturn if they can prove Allisons view wasnt obstructed, which they couldn't.

But without VAR it still wouldn't have stood. Not happy about it, but its 'one of them'. I'd want it disallowed if it was the other way around.

Of course you would but do you really think they can't prove Allison's view was obstructed?

[Image: Zke0xhfrSbm4R4k6RHCT_Video%20%2837%29.jpg]


I don't suppose anyone has this viewing angle from a moment before when the ball hit Ajayi's head?

I don't actually, but I know what you're getting at. Thing is, the ball was in the air. Do we have to compare heights to judge that Allison can't see over Phillips head or can we just assume that he is where he is because he chooses to be there? GK's fault for choosing to be behind the player at that point.

I absolutely agree with that and it's the exact point I've been making to 2 LFC fans that I'm arguing with online. From the point the corner was taken that ball was over 6 feet in the air until it landed at Bartley's feet. Phillips was in a convenient position for Becker to claim he was unsighted. Utter BS decision.

Look where the ref is.  How can he not see that there is no obstruction of the keeper/keeper's view?  He can and should overrulr the lino's flag and give the goal.
Reply
#45
(05-17-2021, 01:21 PM)HLS Wrote:
(05-17-2021, 01:13 PM)UCEbaggie Wrote:
(05-17-2021, 01:05 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Two things for me, they took about 15 seconds to come to the decision, which is disgusting, I genuinely question if it was scored against us they would have took a lot longer and probably awarded it

For me if Ajayi scores then it's right to rule out the goal given Phillips position (feckin lazy of him mind) however when Ajayi heads it wide and Bartley stabs home it should stand, keeper has no chance of saving it and how does that really differ to a back post header across goal then being turned in by a player? If somebody is infront of the keeper when it's headed back across goal it's not an issue so how was ours any different?

I thought we were on the end of some woeful officiating yesterday in all honesty

Cuzer

Yep. Agree with all of that 100%

In full agreement as well. 

Honestly this is the only game where I can remember so outraged by a decision like this. My head says to let it go but given the evidence, this is the worst case of a lack of integrity as has happened in our 1 year tenure back. It's really been the 'fuck this I'd rather be in a different league' I needed before heading back to the championship.

Yep. Stuff the Premier League, pit of corruption.
Reply
#46
That's the view from my seat btw 

It shows how fucked that decision is, Allison had just pushed Phillips out of the way as well and him being 3 yards clear of the keeper means in no way is he obstructing unless Allison's eyes are in his ball sacks.
Reply
#47
(05-17-2021, 01:34 PM)hudds Wrote:
(05-17-2021, 01:21 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(05-17-2021, 01:16 PM)HLS Wrote:
(05-17-2021, 01:12 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(05-16-2021, 06:08 PM)HLS Wrote: Of course you would but do you really think they can't prove Allison's view was obstructed?

[Image: Zke0xhfrSbm4R4k6RHCT_Video%20%2837%29.jpg]


I don't suppose anyone has this viewing angle from a moment before when the ball hit Ajayi's head?

I don't actually, but I know what you're getting at. Thing is, the ball was in the air. Do we have to compare heights to judge that Allison can't see over Phillips head or can we just assume that he is where he is because he chooses to be there? GK's fault for choosing to be behind the player at that point.

I absolutely agree with that and it's the exact point I've been making to 2 LFC fans that I'm arguing with online. From the point the corner was taken that ball was over 6 feet in the air until it landed at Bartley's feet. Phillips was in a convenient position for Becker to claim he was unsighted. Utter BS decision.

Look where the ref is.  How can he not see that there is no obstruction of the keeper/keeper's view?  He can and should overrulr the lino's flag and give the goal.

The lino flags for offside. So the first question is, who was he flagging offside?
If it was Bartley, which it may have been given his movement in real time, then the lino was wrong and that mistake could easily be rectified.
If it was Phillips then the lino is saying that Phillips was interfering with play. So the next question is, how was he interfering with play?
Did the lino think that Phillips was blocking Allison's view of the ball? How could he come to that conclusion based on his own position?
When VAR looks at it and sees that Bartley is onside, it has to look at Phillips' position in relation to Allison and the ball. Is Phillips' head blocking Allison's  view of the ball when Ajayi heads it?
The only way to determine that is to look at the angles from behind and side on.
So did VAR think the side angle wasn't conclusive and therefore went with the original decision?
Or  b) did they just not bother their arse?
Reply
#48
(05-17-2021, 12:57 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(05-17-2021, 07:24 AM)steviedm Wrote:
(05-17-2021, 12:25 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I'm a committed supporter of  VAR because i firmly believe it is important to arrive at the correct decision - but days like today are hugely dispiriting.  The decision to disallow the goal was rotten, imO

So you genuinely believe VAR arrives at the correct decision? In a game as subjective as football, it's never going to happen. The majority of VAR decisions could easily be given the other way and there'll be arguments on both sides. It's just kicking the can down the road and asking someone miles away to adjudicate. VAR also largely supports original decisions and doesn't have the balls to overturn them so what's the point? If it worked, yesterday would have seen our goal given by VAR once it was established Allison's view was not impeded and possibly their first goal would be ruled out due to the ref allowing them to take a free kick incorrectly. In the women's Champions League final, the penalty awarded by the ref early on was clearly a shit decision yet again VAR did nothing to correct the error. Let the game be played as it always has been. Refs and linos will make mistakes, we'll berate them, it won't even itself out but at least we'll be spared this absolute monstrosity of a system.


Majority of decisions could easily be given the other way?  I don't think so. Some yes. But the more they get right, surely that's a good thing. I think there was an instance at the weekend where Anthony Taylor awarded a penalty and VAR told him to look again and he reversed it.

The problem with VAR is the rules and the people applying them. I'd give it 5 seasons and allow them the chance to refine the system. It's far from perfect but I do think it's a bit better than last season.

And as for this idea that these things even out across the season, do you really believe that? Whether consciously or subconsciously,  I think some refs are biased in favour of the big clubs (Webb and Styles spring immediatelyto mind). Plus their mistakes used to get scrutinised every week in the TV studios so I think it's only fair they are aided by video technology in trying to make the right decision.

Clearly not as my original post reads 'it won't even itself out'.  Smile

I watch a lot of non-league football these days (well, before lockdown) and I see some absolutely horrendous decisions. The players and managers have a moan at the time and then just get on with it. The games tend to have one very wide camera so looking at incidents again later doesn't add much to the debate. Everyone accepts that mistakes get made but none are deliberate just incompetent or a matter of interpretation. One man's good tackle is another man's sending off - the rules can say what they want but the bottom line is that there are different interpretations and different levels of football apply different standards. There's more tolerance in the non-league game - lower levels of skill lead to more honest errors by players when tackling but they also don't generally scream like two years old when someone gives them a slight nudge. 

VAR is going nowhere and at the top level will no doubt be finessed but there'll still be issues like yesterday's. The irony is that the linesman flagged and without VAR everyone would have been pissed off for a bit and cursing his ineptitude but it would've been more easily accepted. VAR just compounded the error.

I'm also sure that offside calls can be as objective as a ball over the line or many of the calls in cricket. The trouble is, if it means developing the game so that there are regular stoppages so someone can draw some lines on a screen to determine whether someone's big toe is further forward than someone else's arse while fans are unable to celebrate then I'm afraid I'm out and off to watch some proper football instead. 

The final irony is that if VAR was brought in to sort out contentious decisions and resolve debates then it's done exactly the opposite. It may just be my perception but it seems to have at least doubled the number of arguments about decisions. When it was originally mooted years ago, I was all for it and annoyed when Sepp Blatter said it'd never be brought in. Lampard's non-goal in the World Cup changed that but I realised from the moment I first saw it used in the Liverpool v Albion cup game that it takes away pretty much everything I've always loved about football. 
Reply
#49
biggest giveaway for me that it should have been overturned is that allison is pointing at bartley after the goal and not phillips.
Reply
#50
(05-17-2021, 01:21 PM)HLS Wrote:
(05-17-2021, 01:13 PM)UCEbaggie Wrote:
(05-17-2021, 01:05 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Two things for me, they took about 15 seconds to come to the decision, which is disgusting, I genuinely question if it was scored against us they would have took a lot longer and probably awarded it

For me if Ajayi scores then it's right to rule out the goal given Phillips position (feckin lazy of him mind) however when Ajayi heads it wide and Bartley stabs home it should stand, keeper has no chance of saving it and how does that really differ to a back post header across goal then being turned in by a player? If somebody is infront of the keeper when it's headed back across goal it's not an issue so how was ours any different?

I thought we were on the end of some woeful officiating yesterday in all honesty

Cuzer

Yep. Agree with all of that 100%

In full agreement as well. 

Honestly this is the only game where I can remember so outraged by a decision like this. My head says to let it go but given the evidence, this is the worst case of a lack of integrity as has happened in our 1 year tenure back. It's really been the 'fuck this I'd rather be in a different league' I needed before heading back to the championship.
Man U away was worse.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: