Hartlepool
(05-13-2021, 04:52 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-13-2021, 04:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Housing bonds would be a winner with interest rates on the floor, i've put my spare cash in Premium Bonds as there is so little to lose (doing ok btw) so they would be snapped up, but there would be the labour problem (small L Proth  Wink ), how would that be overcome?

All suitable and available public land should be developed by local housing corporations (LA / HA consortia) with clean up underwitten by public authorities. Public land should exchange at a value commensurate with a "living rent" outturn for the particular locality.

All land where a landowner doesn't start discharging planning conditions within 6 months of consent or doesn't finish them within an agreed period with the LPA should be forfeited at undeveloped value with local housing corporations having first dibs.

For the labour issue (and the green agenda) the state should back and scale prefabricated timber framed housing companies - so most of the non-automated labour is production line factory based, with site labour needing to be far less specialised. If you can drop a prefab bathroom into an Ibis, why not into a house? You could base factories in Hartlepool, or Batley & Spen and show you mean what you say about levelling up.

The state could also lead on the roll out of heat pumps / microwave boilers reducing the price for all and invest in neighbourhood heating to sell to the market at a profit.

I'm not a fan of intervention in the economy, but where the state has largely created the problem through decades of insane housing policy - then only the state can lead the sorting out.

All good ideas and definitely would solve the main problem of house supply and affordability. The problem would come from this being a landlord, landowner, banking backed party in power that would never go for this - welcome to the dark side, I knew you had it in you  Wink 

You see we can agree
Reply
(05-13-2021, 04:57 PM)baggy1 Wrote: All good ideas and definitely would solve the main problem of house supply and affordability. The problem would come from this being a landlord, landowner, banking backed party in power that would never go for this - welcome to the dark side, I knew you had it in you  Wink 

You see we can agree

As a child my mum lived in one of the first council houses in Garretts Green (built under a Tory government). Her former family home was two rooms in Sparkbrook.

Can you imagine the difference that environment made to her well being and life chances?

If you want to change things, don't piss about at the margins. Aim at the centre of everything. A home.
Reply
(05-13-2021, 05:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-13-2021, 04:57 PM)baggy1 Wrote: All good ideas and definitely would solve the main problem of house supply and affordability. The problem would come from this being a landlord, landowner, banking backed party in power that would never go for this - welcome to the dark side, I knew you had it in you  Wink 

You see we can agree

As a child my mum lived in one of the first council houses in Garretts Green (built under a Tory government). Her former family home was two rooms in Sparkbrook.

Can you imagine the difference that environment made to her well being and life chances?

If you want to change things, don't piss about at the margins. Aim at the centre of everything. A home.

Agree entirely - we all have experiences that drive us and yours is clear. My start was a care home but I was lucky to move quickly into a home and stable family life. It's frustrating to see how hard it is for my kids generation to get on the housing ladder, although selfishly I could look the other way as both mine have a pretty decent start in that situation. The problem will be the wider impact of that generation being in rented for potentially their whole life and as their income fades so will their lifestyle - that is a problem we are banking for the future.
Reply
(05-13-2021, 05:35 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Agree entirely - we all have experiences that drive us and yours is clear. My start was a care home but I was lucky to move quickly into a home and stable family life. It's frustrating to see how hard it is for my kids generation to get on the housing ladder, although selfishly I could look the other way as both mine have a pretty decent start in that situation. The problem will be the wider impact of that generation being in rented for potentially their whole life and as their income fades so will their lifestyle - that is a problem we are banking for the future.

And I'd hope any government isn't daft enough to ignore that approaching polarisation. Unfortunately both sides view planning as some sort of panacea, and seem obsessed with short term gimmicks to support the market when none are required at all.

Imagine how everyone would win from Housing Bonds, fixed 4% coupon for investors on a 10 year term - allow them into SIPPS / Junior ISAs etc.
Reply
(05-13-2021, 04:52 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-13-2021, 04:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Housing bonds would be a winner with interest rates on the floor, i've put my spare cash in Premium Bonds as there is so little to lose (doing ok btw) so they would be snapped up, but there would be the labour problem (small L Proth  Wink ), how would that be overcome?

All suitable and available public land should be developed by local housing corporations (LA / HA consortia) with clean up underwitten by public authorities. Public land should exchange at a value commensurate with a "living rent" outturn for the particular locality.

All land where a landowner doesn't start discharging planning conditions within 6 months of consent or doesn't finish them within an agreed period with the LPA should be forfeited at undeveloped value with local housing corporations having first dibs.

For the labour issue (and the green agenda) the state should back and scale prefabricated timber framed housing companies - so most of the non-automated labour is production line factory based, with site labour needing to be far less specialised. If you can drop a prefab bathroom into an Ibis, why not into a house? You could base factories in Hartlepool, or Batley & Spen and show you mean what you say about levelling up.

The state could also lead on the roll out of heat pumps / microwave boilers reducing the price for all and invest in neighbourhood heating to sell to the market at a profit.

I'm not a fan of intervention in the economy, but where the state has largely created the problem through decades of insane housing policy - then only the state can lead the sorting out.

Disappointed you didn't mention an LVT to discourage land banking...
Reply
(05-13-2021, 12:47 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-13-2021, 09:11 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-13-2021, 08:55 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-13-2021, 08:51 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So we've moved from the social and political failures that have left us in a developed wealthy country where the most vulnerable need handouts to get by, to patting ourselves on the back because we've solved the problem and it's simple as we just need more charitable institutions where those that have can give some scraps off the table if they are that way inclined.

Well done boys, you've excelled yourselves.

No. The more rational amongst us have noticed that the third sector has, for more than two centuries, been exceptionally effective in delivering services at a local level to those in need - and that it might, just might - be better to rely in some part on the inate generosity of the human spirit than for the state to continually pick peoples' pockets and deliver an inferior outcome.

Absolute nonsense. Charities as big / well known as Acorns for example who look after life children who are genuinely the most vulnerable in society nearly went to the wall in the Black Country through a lack of funds over the last three years. That is not uplifting it’s a very sad reflection on our society that it ever came close to having to be closed or indeed needed the generosity of people in the first place to exist. The quote... "How a society treats its most vulnerable is always the measure of its humanity."

Acorns Walsall was saved by public generosity. One of the organisations I belong to donated £5,000 alone out of £24,000 donated in the last year to hospices around the West Midlands.

Is there another example you'd like to use to prove my point?

You haven’t proved any point. The Black Country branch of the hospice was going to close down. The charity had to do an emergency appeal to keep it open because it couldn’t meet its running costs. It’s only through good will of people that it stayed open. Relying on good will should not be the main way to support children and families that suffer with severe disabilities and mean their lives as a result are cut short. If you genuinely believe that core government funds should not be set aside for charities such as this then I think we shall have to very impolitely disagree.
Reply
(05-13-2021, 06:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You haven’t proved any point. The Black Country branch of the hospice was going to close down. The charity had to do an emergency appeal to keep it open because it couldn’t meet its running costs. It’s only through good will of people that it stayed open. Relying on good will should not be the main way to support children and families that suffer with severe disabilities and mean their lives as a result are cut short. If you genuinely believe that core government funds should not be set aside for charities such as this then I think we shall have to very impolitely disagree.

The issue was addressed, I fail to see what your beef is beyond the idea that the state should fund services by coercion rather than the third sector by voluntary contribution.

Sad.
Reply
(05-14-2021, 07:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-13-2021, 06:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You haven’t proved any point. The Black Country branch of the hospice was going to close down. The charity had to do an emergency appeal to keep it open because it couldn’t meet its running costs. It’s only through good will of people that it stayed open. Relying on good will should not be the main way to support children and families that suffer with severe disabilities and mean their lives as a result are cut short. If you genuinely believe that core government funds should not be set aside for charities such as this then I think we shall have to very impolitely disagree.

The issue was addressed, I fail to see what your beef is beyond the idea that the state should fund services by coercion rather than the third sector by voluntary contribution.

Sad.

It certainly is sad that you advocate a hospice for disabled children should have to rely on the good will of people donating to it without any additional government financial support.
Reply
(05-14-2021, 08:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-14-2021, 07:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-13-2021, 06:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You haven’t proved any point. The Black Country branch of the hospice was going to close down. The charity had to do an emergency appeal to keep it open because it couldn’t meet its running costs. It’s only through good will of people that it stayed open. Relying on good will should not be the main way to support children and families that suffer with severe disabilities and mean their lives as a result are cut short. If you genuinely believe that core government funds should not be set aside for charities such as this then I think we shall have to very impolitely disagree.

The issue was addressed, I fail to see what your beef is beyond the idea that the state should fund services by coercion rather than the third sector by voluntary contribution.

Sad.

It certainly is sad that you advocate a hospice for disabled children should have to rely on the good will of people donating to it without any additional government financial support.

If the charity gets more funds via the former isn't that a good thing? 

1) £1 given attracts 25p from charitable contribution by government (voluntary + govt working in tandem)
2) £1 given to government by tax-payer loses value along the chain, might not even get to the right place

You have highlighted one charity in this example but you seem to be implying that every single charity that cares for human beings should be funded via taxation or it at least the greater proportion. That just sounds incredibly inefficient/unworkable to me.
Reply
(05-14-2021, 09:46 AM)Fido Wrote:
(05-14-2021, 08:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-14-2021, 07:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-13-2021, 06:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You haven’t proved any point. The Black Country branch of the hospice was going to close down. The charity had to do an emergency appeal to keep it open because it couldn’t meet its running costs. It’s only through good will of people that it stayed open. Relying on good will should not be the main way to support children and families that suffer with severe disabilities and mean their lives as a result are cut short. If you genuinely believe that core government funds should not be set aside for charities such as this then I think we shall have to very impolitely disagree.

The issue was addressed, I fail to see what your beef is beyond the idea that the state should fund services by coercion rather than the third sector by voluntary contribution.

Sad.

It certainly is sad that you advocate a hospice for disabled children should have to rely on the good will of people donating to it without any additional government financial support.

If the charity gets more funds via the former isn't that a good thing? 

1) £1 given attracts 25p from charitable contribution by government (voluntary + govt working in tandem)
2) £1 given to government by tax-payer loses value along the chain, might not even get to the right place

You have highlighted one charity in this example but you seem to be implying that every single charity that cares for human beings should be funded via taxation or it at least the greater proportion. That just sounds incredibly inefficient/unworkable to me.

I haven’t implied anything of the sort. But carry on.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)