Hartlepool
(05-12-2021, 09:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not saying it isn’t Fido, my concern is the reliance placed on it. We shouldn’t be in a position in one of the most developed economies in the world, and also one of the wealthiest, where we rely on donations and volunteers to feed the poorest and most vulnerable.

People do not trust Governments (of any shade) not to waste their money, and they have good reason to not trust them, the billions wasted by consecutive Governments on shit projects that are cancelled halfway through give testament to this.

People much prefer to target that which they wish to give to where they want it to go. 
As an instance - most of the scanners and a Da Vinci robot in the local hospital were funded by friends of the hospital, whilst Labour were wasting billions on shit IT projects and the Tories were giving to their mates.
Reply
(05-12-2021, 09:25 PM)strawman Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 09:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not saying it isn’t Fido, my concern is the reliance placed on it. We shouldn’t be in a position in one of the most developed economies in the world, and also one of the wealthiest, where we rely on donations and volunteers to feed the poorest and most vulnerable.

People do not trust Governments (of any shade) not to waste their money, and they have good reason to not trust them, the billions wasted by consecutive Governments on shit projects that are cancelled halfway through give testament to this.

People much prefer to target that which they wish to give to where they want it to go. 
As an instance - most of the scanners and a Da Vinci robot in the local hospital were funded by friends of the hospital, whilst Labour were wasting billions on shit IT projects and the Tories were giving to their mates.

It isn’t an either / or SM, individuals can provide as much support as they want, the government should be using the funds effectively to provide services to support the most vulnerable.

The failed IT project wasn’t the fault of the government or even the supplier (Fujitsu), it hit the buffers when individual NHS trusts couldn’t agree on the best solution and each wanted their own intricacies built in.
Reply
(05-12-2021, 09:38 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 09:25 PM)strawman Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 09:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not saying it isn’t Fido, my concern is the reliance placed on it. We shouldn’t be in a position in one of the most developed economies in the world, and also one of the wealthiest, where we rely on donations and volunteers to feed the poorest and most vulnerable.

People do not trust Governments (of any shade) not to waste their money, and they have good reason to not trust them, the billions wasted by consecutive Governments on shit projects that are cancelled halfway through give testament to this.

People much prefer to target that which they wish to give to where they want it to go. 
As an instance - most of the scanners and a Da Vinci robot in the local hospital were funded by friends of the hospital, whilst Labour were wasting billions on shit IT projects and the Tories were giving to their mates.

It isn’t an either / or SM, individuals can provide as much support as they want, the government should be using the funds effectively to provide services to support the most vulnerable.

The failed IT project wasn’t the fault of the government or even the supplier (Fujitsu), it hit the buffers when individual NHS trusts couldn’t agree on the best solution and each wanted their own intricacies built in.

There wasn't just one supplier there were a number Accenture, CSC, Atos Origin, Fujitsu and BT and I contracted to both Accenture and CSC on the storage requirements. You are right it broke down because each wanted their own intricacies built in, something they failed to bother asking the people who were actually going to use it before they went headlong into starting it. Never let a Government anywhere near an IT project.
Reply
Just read the last four pages of this where we're debating whether people want to use foodbacks or not, really?

On a basic level everyone has a right to have enough to live a dignified life where they don't have to rely on others scraps and handouts to feed their families. What is wrong with us when we see an increased demand and supply for charity handouts as a good thing.
Reply
(05-12-2021, 09:25 PM)strawman Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 09:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not saying it isn’t Fido, my concern is the reliance placed on it. We shouldn’t be in a position in one of the most developed economies in the world, and also one of the wealthiest, where we rely on donations and volunteers to feed the poorest and most vulnerable.

People do not trust Governments (of any shade) not to waste their money, and they have good reason to not trust them, the billions wasted by consecutive Governments on shit projects that are cancelled halfway through give testament to this.

People much prefer to target that which they wish to give to where they want it to go. 
As an instance - most of the scanners and a Da Vinci robot in the local hospital were funded by friends of the hospital, whilst Labour were wasting billions on shit IT projects and the Tories were giving to their mates.

+1. £1 going to a food bank means that the large majority of that £1 is received there. Putting £1 through taxables touches multiple hands ensuring that a much smaller percentage of it goes to where it was intended. You can't have all charities supported this way as the burden will be unfair re: affordability but the more the better.
Reply
(05-13-2021, 05:39 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Just read the last four pages of this where we're debating whether people want to use foodbacks or not, really?

On a basic level everyone has a right to have enough to live a dignified life where they don't have to rely on others scraps and handouts to feed their families. What is wrong with us when we see an increased demand and supply for charity handouts as a good thing.

Exactly it’s a ludicrous position to take and I’m being very diplomatic with my words. It is admiral of those who set up charities, work in the charity and voluntary sector but it’s certainly not something that should be accepted as normal and even worse to be celebrated as uplifting by the likes of Mogg! Having to rely on charity is not something the vast majority wish to do, it’s something that they are forced to do because there aren’t any alternatives. Muddying the water about government or council services not being adequate is true but that’s because on the main they are poorly resourced and used as a political football to appease people who think the bare minimum should be done, because they believe in a small state. It’s certainly not because they want better universally funded care for the most vulnerable, otherwise they would not advocate or describe the reliance on charity as uplifting, admirable or any other Victorianesque platitude.
Reply
(05-12-2021, 09:54 PM)strawman Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 09:38 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 09:25 PM)strawman Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 09:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not saying it isn’t Fido, my concern is the reliance placed on it. We shouldn’t be in a position in one of the most developed economies in the world, and also one of the wealthiest, where we rely on donations and volunteers to feed the poorest and most vulnerable.

People do not trust Governments (of any shade) not to waste their money, and they have good reason to not trust them, the billions wasted by consecutive Governments on shit projects that are cancelled halfway through give testament to this.

People much prefer to target that which they wish to give to where they want it to go. 
As an instance - most of the scanners and a Da Vinci robot in the local hospital were funded by friends of the hospital, whilst Labour were wasting billions on shit IT projects and the Tories were giving to their mates.

It isn’t an either / or SM, individuals can provide as much support as they want, the government should be using the funds effectively to provide services to support the most vulnerable.

The failed IT project wasn’t the fault of the government or even the supplier (Fujitsu), it hit the buffers when individual NHS trusts couldn’t agree on the best solution and each wanted their own intricacies built in.

There wasn't just one supplier there were a number Accenture, CSC, Atos Origin, Fujitsu and BT and I contracted to both Accenture and CSC on the storage requirements. You are right it broke down because each wanted their own intricacies built in, something they failed to bother asking the people who were actually going to use it before they went headlong into starting it. Never let a Government anywhere near an IT project.

Large projects are a nightmare whether they are run by the government or not. I think the Test and Trace system has proven that it isn't just government that can balls up big projects, and seeing as it appears we have both worked in the IT sector we both know that private sector can be equally as shit at delivering. The NHS system failing were as much about technology available at the time as anything and (I'm not in the industry anymore) but it appears that they have moved closer to the goal of a linked central database judging by the information I can get on my health records now being available - I'm guessing cloud has been the big leap forward.

The point being - the 'never let government near an IT project' is a tired dated cliche now, private sector can be equally shit at planning and delivering.

(05-13-2021, 06:39 AM)Fido Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 09:25 PM)strawman Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 09:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not saying it isn’t Fido, my concern is the reliance placed on it. We shouldn’t be in a position in one of the most developed economies in the world, and also one of the wealthiest, where we rely on donations and volunteers to feed the poorest and most vulnerable.

People do not trust Governments (of any shade) not to waste their money, and they have good reason to not trust them, the billions wasted by consecutive Governments on shit projects that are cancelled halfway through give testament to this.

People much prefer to target that which they wish to give to where they want it to go. 
As an instance - most of the scanners and a Da Vinci robot in the local hospital were funded by friends of the hospital, whilst Labour were wasting billions on shit IT projects and the Tories were giving to their mates.

+1. £1 going to a food bank means that the large majority of that £1 is received there. Putting £1 through taxables touches multiple hands ensuring that a much smaller percentage of it goes to where it was intended. You can't have all charities supported this way as the burden will be unfair re: affordability but the more the better.

Well lets hope so, because not funding social care through government means we will be more reliant on the handouts of charity. And if you think that people will donate to charity instead of paying taxes (something that can be done btw with charity donation receiving tax relief) on the scale that they pay tax then you are in a spiral to the death on this one. Supporting the most vulnerable should be one of the main priorities of any government. Obfuscating any discussion with 'well charities do a better job' is avoiding the failure of government by making excuses for them.
Reply
(05-13-2021, 07:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-13-2021, 05:39 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Just read the last four pages of this where we're debating whether people want to use foodbacks or not, really?

On a basic level everyone has a right to have enough to live a dignified life where they don't have to rely on others scraps and handouts to feed their families. What is wrong with us when we see an increased demand and supply for charity handouts as a good thing.

Exactly it’s a ludicrous position to take and I’m being very diplomatic with my words. It is admiral of those who set up charities, work in the charity and voluntary sector but it’s certainly not something that should be accepted as normal and even worse to be celebrated as uplifting by the likes of Mogg! Having to rely on charity is not something the vast majority wish to do, it’s something that they are forced to do because there aren’t any alternatives. Muddying the water about government or council services not being adequate is true but that’s because on the main they are poorly resourced and used as a political football to appease people who think the bare minimum should be done, because they believe in a small state. It’s certainly not because they want better universally funded care for the most vulnerable, otherwise they would not advocate or describe the reliance on charity as uplifting, admirable or any other Victorianesque platitude.

The NHS is used as a political football anyway. Politicians will get funding for the things that the majority will care out because it will win more votes. This would then leave other less well-known causes to flounder and would have to be picked up by voluntary contributions anyway. Government will never have enough money - full stop. The politico-economic dilemna is, and always will be, where to draw the line. You seem to naively think that more and more (and more) money should go to the government through taxation where an enormous sum will just be pissed away or poorly managed.
Reply
(05-13-2021, 07:54 AM)Fido Wrote:
(05-13-2021, 07:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-13-2021, 05:39 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Just read the last four pages of this where we're debating whether people want to use foodbacks or not, really?

On a basic level everyone has a right to have enough to live a dignified life where they don't have to rely on others scraps and handouts to feed their families. What is wrong with us when we see an increased demand and supply for charity handouts as a good thing.

Exactly it’s a ludicrous position to take and I’m being very diplomatic with my words. It is admiral of those who set up charities, work in the charity and voluntary sector but it’s certainly not something that should be accepted as normal and even worse to be celebrated as uplifting by the likes of Mogg! Having to rely on charity is not something the vast majority wish to do, it’s something that they are forced to do because there aren’t any alternatives. Muddying the water about government or council services not being adequate is true but that’s because on the main they are poorly resourced and used as a political football to appease people who think the bare minimum should be done, because they believe in a small state. It’s certainly not because they want better universally funded care for the most vulnerable, otherwise they would not advocate or describe the reliance on charity as uplifting, admirable or any other Victorianesque platitude.

The NHS is used as a political football anyway. Politicians will get funding for the things that the majority will care out because it will win more votes. This would then leave other less well-known causes to flounder and would have to be picked up by voluntary contributions anyway. Government will never have enough money - full stop. The politico-economic dilemna is, and always will be, where to draw the line. You seem to naively think that more and more (and more) money should go to the government through taxation where an enormous sum will just be pissed away or poorly managed.

I appreciate some charitable organisations need to exist because they don’t fit into government responsibility. However we have been talking about the use of food banks as a solution for people who can’t afford to feed themselves and their family for an example. Not Save the Pigeon or Happy Homes Gnomes. 

The problems in society that necessitate food banks, homeless shelters, disability charities should be solved or reduced at various points through the state. It’s not just throwing money at things but the pandemic has shown the folly of austerity, it’s about trying to address the problems caused by poor laws, failing or short sighted social service systems, cultural and environmental problems people face. These problems cannot be solved through the kindness of people giving to charity it’s a sticking plaster to gaping wounds. You are of course right it’s about choices but I’d rather have say a functioning and well thought out, fair social care system in this country rather than HS2 or a new Royal Yacht... I think that says a lot about our country, just as much as volunteers for the Olympics.
Reply
(05-13-2021, 06:39 AM)Fido Wrote:
(05-12-2021, 09:25 PM)strawman Wrote: People do not trust Governments (of any shade) not to waste their money, and they have good reason to not trust them, the billions wasted by consecutive Governments on shit projects that are cancelled halfway through give testament to this.

People much prefer to target that which they wish to give to where they want it to go. 
As an instance - most of the scanners and a Da Vinci robot in the local hospital were funded by friends of the hospital, whilst Labour were wasting billions on shit IT projects and the Tories were giving to their mates.

+1. £1 going to a food bank means that the large majority of that £1 is received there. Putting £1 through taxables touches multiple hands ensuring that a much smaller percentage of it goes to where it was intended. You can't have all charities supported this way as the burden will be unfair re: affordability but the more the better.

Fuck me. I never thought I'd read two posts like that on this board.

There is hope, after all.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)