Posts: 509
Threads: 19
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation:
0
(05-10-2021, 01:12 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: An idea right from the Republican Party school of ways to suppress the vote.
And how would it work with postal voting.
Also Govt looking to get rid of the supplementary vote for mayoral elections, a system which cost them the cambridge etc mayoral election
Interestingly no move to change Scottish and Welsh elections to a first past the post system, as pr benefits conservatives in those elections.
They are not subtle are they?.
How will it suppress the vote? Did it have that effect when inrouduced in NI?
Supplementary vote is a ridiculous and totally illogical system. There are at least arguments in favour of PR-based systems. I can't think of many persuasive ones in favour of SV.
A FPTP system for Mayoral elections would not have changed the result in London, West Yorks or Bristol so where would it have done so had it applied this time around? Supplementary vote is also not a system of PR.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(05-10-2021, 02:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: How is it problem solved when there's no problem to solve?
And you know there's no problem to solve in voter impersonation, how?
The vast majority will go unreported simply because it isn't discovered due to low turnouts.
Personally I'd make voting and voter ID compulsory.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(05-10-2021, 02:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Free issue photo ID. Problem solved.
Though I'd much rather do something about scandalous postal vote farming.
Seems a lot of money to invest for a very small problem.
And i doubt they will do anything about postal votes, as their voters tend to favour this method (nothing wrong in that).
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-10-2021, 02:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-10-2021, 02:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: How is it problem solved when there's no problem to solve?
And you know there's no problem to solve in voter impersonation, how?
The vast majority will go unreported simply because it isn't discovered due to low turnouts.
Personally I'd make voting and voter ID compulsory.
How very Libertarian of you.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(05-10-2021, 02:13 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: (05-10-2021, 01:12 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: An idea right from the Republican Party school of ways to suppress the vote.
And how would it work with postal voting.
Also Govt looking to get rid of the supplementary vote for mayoral elections, a system which cost them the cambridge etc mayoral election
Interestingly no move to change Scottish and Welsh elections to a first past the post system, as pr benefits conservatives in those elections.
They are not subtle are they?.
How will it suppress the vote? Did it have that effect when inrouduced in NI?
Supplementary vote is a ridiculous and totally illogical system. There are at least arguments in favour of PR-based systems. I can't think of many persuasive ones in favour of SV.
A FPTP system for Mayoral elections would not have changed the result in London, West Yorks or Bristol so where would it have done so had it applied this time around? Supplementary vote is also not a system of PR.
Well i am in favour of PR, think it works well in Scotland and Wales, and it undoubtedly benefits the Conservatives there. So if it is good for Scotland and Wales devolved assemblies, why can't we have it for UK General Elections.
On supplementary vote i am not in favour particularly, but i do see its merits when electing positions such as a mayor. Without it you could get a situation where a minority of voters get a mayor they wanted, who is detested by the majority.
It did make a difference in the mayoralty for Cambridgeshire and Peterborough, but not in any other race. In that one on the first round the Conservative was quite ahead on the first round, but once the supplementary votes were counted, he was beaten in the second round. I am sure the electors of cambs etc didn't detest the tory candidate, but neither did a majority seem to want him (actually it could have been a her)
I do think the use of ID cards will suppress voting, which is already too low. It's just another barrier for an already somewhat apathetic electorate to surmount. And it will no doubt affect the disadvantaged who would have no particular need for either a driving licence or a passport. And what would be the point when you wont need photo id to cast a postal vote.
There are already too many people not on the electoral roll for a variety of reasons, why do we want to disenfranchise another raft of people because they do not want to go to the time and expense of getting photographic id.
Posts: 509
Threads: 19
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation:
0
05-10-2021, 03:44 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-10-2021, 03:48 PM by Bortolazzi's Barnet.)
I used to be in favour of PR. FPTP is far from perfect but (for me) it's the best that there is. As for your view regarding supplementary vote I think that's an argument against FPTP rather than a strong reason for SV. It could also lead to a situation where the winning candidate secured neither the highest number of 1st preference votes nor the highest number of 2nd prefernce votes, which seems barking.
If voting ID was limited to those with passports or driving licences I'd agree but you will be able to get voter ID cards for free if you have neither. The only reservation I have there is the cost of passport photos, to some that may be prohibitive.
EDIT - in relation to what Proteroe says, I would not ever support compulsory voting for 2 reasons:
1. I think it's (maybe paradoxically to a level) a democratic right to *not* have a say in the democratic process and to *npt* influence the course of democracy
2. Votes without any conviction behind them choose who is elected
Voter turnout is a concern, one of the arguments for a PR system is that it may increase participation, whether that is the reality I don't know.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(05-10-2021, 03:44 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: I used to be in favour of PR. FPTP is far from perfect but (for me) it's the best that there is. As for your view regarding supplementary vote I think that's an argument against FPTP rather than a strong reason for SV. It could also lead to a situation where the winning candidate secured neither the highest number of 1st preference votes nor the highest number of 2nd prefernce votes, which seems barking.
If voting ID was limited to those with passports or driving licences I'd agree but you will be able to get voter ID cards for free if you have neither. The only reservation I have there is the cost of passport photos, to some that may be prohibitive.
EDIT - in relation to what Proteroe says, I would not ever support compulsory voting for 2 reasons:
1. I think it's (maybe paradoxically to a level) a democratic right to *not* have a say in the democratic process and to *npt* influence the course of democracy
2. Votes without any conviction behind them choose who is elected
Voter turnout is a concern, one of the arguments for a PR system is that it may increase participation, whether that is the reality I don't know.
I agree, but more than that, for a lot of people they are not that interested in politics, just the effort of having to go and get a photo and making an application to attain id just to vote will be too much of a faff. We should be encouraging people to engage, not putting barriers in the way of people getting involved.
And if we are not doing anything about postal votes, what is the point?
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(05-10-2021, 02:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-10-2021, 02:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: How is it problem solved when there's no problem to solve?
And you know there's no problem to solve in voter impersonation, how?
The vast majority will go unreported simply because it isn't discovered due to low turnouts.
Personally I'd make voting and voter ID compulsory.
Because the data says there is no problem, and the checks and balances we have due to the nature of our voting system and traceable ballots make it nearly impossible.
That's how I know.
Posts: 509
Threads: 19
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation:
0
05-10-2021, 07:16 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-10-2021, 07:20 PM by Bortolazzi's Barnet.)
(05-10-2021, 04:22 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (05-10-2021, 03:44 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: I used to be in favour of PR. FPTP is far from perfect but (for me) it's the best that there is. As for your view regarding supplementary vote I think that's an argument against FPTP rather than a strong reason for SV. It could also lead to a situation where the winning candidate secured neither the highest number of 1st preference votes nor the highest number of 2nd prefernce votes, which seems barking.
If voting ID was limited to those with passports or driving licences I'd agree but you will be able to get voter ID cards for free if you have neither. The only reservation I have there is the cost of passport photos, to some that may be prohibitive.
EDIT - in relation to what Proteroe says, I would not ever support compulsory voting for 2 reasons:
1. I think it's (maybe paradoxically to a level) a democratic right to *not* have a say in the democratic process and to *npt* influence the course of democracy
2. Votes without any conviction behind them choose who is elected
Voter turnout is a concern, one of the arguments for a PR system is that it may increase participation, whether that is the reality I don't know.
I agree, but more than that, for a lot of people they are not that interested in politics, just the effort of having to go and get a photo and making an application to attain id just to vote will be too much of a faff. We should be encouraging people to engage, not putting barriers in the way of people getting involved.
And if we are not doing anything about postal votes, what is the point?
My initial thought was, "Well, if they are not that interested in politics then they shouldn't be voting," but that's a blinkered view. I agree we should be encouarging participation.
As for postal votes, what changes would you like to see brought in? I agree that it seems that this is where most fraid seems to occur and where there is the biggest risk.
However, there was an electoral lawyer (of all people) on Twitter who was the victim of personation on Thursday, when he turned-up to vote he was told he already had!
That did make me wonder, some people KNOW others won't vote - I wonder if any crook takes advantage of that? I can't imagine that it doesn't happen, though I wouldn't think massively.
(05-10-2021, 05:22 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (05-10-2021, 02:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-10-2021, 02:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: How is it problem solved when there's no problem to solve?
And you know there's no problem to solve in voter impersonation, how?
The vast majority will go unreported simply because it isn't discovered due to low turnouts.
Personally I'd make voting and voter ID compulsory.
Because the data says there is no problem, and the checks and balances we have due to the nature of our voting system and traceable ballots make it nearly impossible.
That's how I know.
Absence of evidence is not always evidence of absence, however.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(05-10-2021, 07:16 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(05-10-2021, 05:22 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (05-10-2021, 02:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-10-2021, 02:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: How is it problem solved when there's no problem to solve?
And you know there's no problem to solve in voter impersonation, how?
The vast majority will go unreported simply because it isn't discovered due to low turnouts.
Personally I'd make voting and voter ID compulsory.
Because the data says there is no problem, and the checks and balances we have due to the nature of our voting system and traceable ballots make it nearly impossible.
That's how I know.
Absence of evidence is not always evidence of absence, however.
Completely ignoring the point about how our voting system and traceable ballots make in person voter fraud pretty much functionally impossible, which is then supported by the data.
|