Hartlepool
(05-10-2021, 10:56 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Except no one from Labour is saying, or has ever said, anything like that?

You need to spend more time with Labour activists. It's exactly what they think and exactly what they say.
Reply
(05-10-2021, 01:49 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-10-2021, 10:56 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Except no one from Labour is saying, or has ever said, anything like that?

You need to spend more time with Labour activists. It's exactly what they think and exactly what they say.

Sure is. And Councillors.
Reply
(05-10-2021, 01:49 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-10-2021, 10:56 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Except no one from Labour is saying, or has ever said, anything like that?

You need to spend more time with Labour activists. It's exactly what they think and exactly what they say.

And Tory activists are salt of the earth and in no way judgemental. I seem to recall you posting a photo of Farmfoods nuggets,  or similar in reply to me after you took a picture of your Eat Out To Help Out meal in the middle of the pandemic.  Wink
Reply
No-one is saying Tories are not judgemental - just that they are not judgemental about people then wonder why they don't vote for them!
Reply
(05-10-2021, 03:55 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: No-one is saying Tories are not judgemental - just that they are not judgemental about people then wonder why they don't vote for them!

Most understand that you don’t insult people if you want to change their opinion / get them to vote for you. However if you abandon your principles to the point where you will literally say anything to get votes, change someone’s mind, confirm their prejudices where does that leave politics and society? Populism which is where we are now as a country is a dangerous place for politics to go because there are no red lines politicians and voters won’t pass as long as their side win.
Reply
(05-10-2021, 11:07 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote:
(05-10-2021, 10:56 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Except no one from Labour is saying, or has ever said, anything like that? Labour isn't insulting anybody. The twitter parade who say those sort of things throw just as much shit Labour's way as they do the Tories.

I feel like the "thick, racist brexiter" narrative is a strawman being pushed by Brexiter's so they can use it as an excuse.


I won't concede the Labour throw "thick racist brexiteer" tropes at the Tories on twitter because it doesn't happen? This is my point. The people using this sort of language are not affiliated with Labour and they give the current Labour party just as much abuse as they do the Tories. 

The strawman is Tory/Brexiter types saying that they won't vote Labour because Labour is insulting them when it's not Labour doing it.
Five minutes searching throws up:
 
‘A Labour MP has branded Brexiteers “sh*tbag racist w*****s”. went on to claim that “fat old racists” would blame the EU if Brexit went wrong,’
Southwark Labour MP Noel Coyle.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/po...89776.html
 
‘LABOUR leadership contender Clive Lewis sparked a fiery backlash after he claimed that the Brexit campaign “had racism at its core” ‘
https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/122734...atest-news
 
A Labour MP campaigning for the UK to remain in the EU has apologised after being recorded calling a voter a "horrible racist".
Shadow Europe minister Pat Glass made the comments after an interview with BBC Radio Derby in Sawley, Derbyshire.
‘https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-de...e-36334488
 
Diane Abbott Criticised Over BBC Question Time Comments About Brexit And Racism
https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/diane-abbott-bbc-question-time-brexit-racism_uk_58e7451ce4b05413bfe1a259
 
“Brexiteers want to see less foreign looking people on the streets “. Dianne Abbot.
https://sq-al.facebook.com/LBC/videos/diane-abbott-said-that-brexit-voters-were-racist-an-angry-ian-collins-hits-back/10154328100721558/
 
And Just Today
‘Angela Rayner says Labour must 'deal with' anti-immigrant voters in Hartlepool’
www.express.co.uk/news/politics/1434194/labour-news-angela-rayner-immigration-keir-starmer-hartlepool-election-tory
Reply
Oof!!! Checkmate.

Great post JOK.
Reply
https://www.independent.co.uk/climate-ch...30732.html
Reply
This isn't an excuse, I can't read it because I use adblockers, what's it say?
Reply
In reply to JOK:

1) Clearly unacceptable- Obviously tweeting while pissed

2) "Not all Brexit voters are racist but there is an element of racism in the Brexit project and the rhetoric of those like Farage" - This doesn't seem enormously controversial to me but we may disagree

3) Some bloke was moaning about a local Polish family and calling them spongers while knowing nothing about them. Can't castigate her too much for calling a spade a spade.

4 & 5) Again, a very poor choice of words.

5) "Anti-immigrant voters in Hartlepool voted for the Tories and we (Labour) need to deal with that" - I don't see much wrong with this? She's saying that people who are anti-immigration lean more towards the Tories and Labour has to deal with that if they want to win their votes. She's right? Also the only source for this quote is the editor of HuffPost UK. Do we know what she actually said? I can't imagine the Express did much fact-checking.

I get what JOK is saying but I don't really agree that 2 notable incidents (imo) in 5 years is quite the 'gotcha' that Borto thinks it is.

As I said earlier, I do agree that the left-wing Twitterati hurling abuse is unhelpful if they want to turn people away from the Tories, but I don't think the blame for this can be laid at the door of the Labour Party. Let's be honest though there's as much abuse online thrown out about "woke, snowflakes" as there is about "thick, racists".

FWIW by the way, I don't 'wonder' why the electorate have turned away from Labour, I know exactly why. Nor am I on here trying to get anyone to vote Labour. Most on this bored are reasonably politically engaged and picked their side a long time ago. I come on here mostly to expose myself to different viewpoints and - occasionally - for a bit of catharsis!

PS. I don't know why anyone calls the politics bored an echo chamber. It's a bloody warzone Big Grin !

As a total aside - There are 9 food banks in operation in Hartlepool whereas 10 years ago there were none. Most people link this to the changes in Universal Credit brought in over recent years.

I completely agree that it is up to Labour to recognise the priorities and aspirations of the electorate - and then meet them - but you must admit it's a hard job when the electorate don't give a fig about lies, corruption or the destitution of their own people! It's not unreasonable to think people might give a shit about the fact they can't put food on the table anymore. Bloody hell.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: