Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
(05-07-2021, 08:52 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The assumption that those who didn’t like Corbyn or this awful government are the problem and can be dismissed as middle class demonstrates how far this country has fallen in terms of political literacy.
Where as, you can write the lexicon on all things politic. How very humble of you to consider yourself far more knowledgeable, intelligent and politically aware than the majority.
If your not going to waste your time on a section of the electorate who ‘once hung a monkey’, why are you wasting your time participating in this thread?
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(05-07-2021, 09:03 AM)JOK Wrote: (05-07-2021, 08:52 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The assumption that those who didn’t like Corbyn or this awful government are the problem and can be dismissed as middle class demonstrates how far this country has fallen in terms of political literacy.
Where as, you can write the lexicon on all things politic. How very humble of you to consider yourself far more knowledgeable, intelligent and politically aware than the majority.
If your not going to waste your time on a section of the electorate who ‘once hung a monkey’, why are you wasting your time participating in this thread?
He's a centrist, actually doing something to affect change is too much like hard work (see Starmer). It's easier to just moan at everyone else and chastise them for not being as wise.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(05-07-2021, 08:52 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-07-2021, 07:35 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (05-07-2021, 07:31 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Hartlepool hung a monkey thinking it was a French spy. I think the area is simply regressing back to type.
And this just gives credence to their claims that the centre of the Labour party is led by smug London elitists.
Are you James O'Brien? Why won't these thick people vote for moi?!
I’m not a Labour supporter or member, I have voted for them and Lib Dem’s previously but I don’t have any fervent loyalty to them like a football supporter has to their team. So my opinion is far from neutral but it’s not party political and certainly not based on what is good or bad for the Labour Party. My observation of the Labour Party is it’s more interested in arguing amongst itself than defeating the opposition. Childish bickering and naval gazing about minority issues, a vacuum of vision for the future, Brexit and Covid vaccine rollout is why they are where they are.
That said if your average Hartlepool voter is going to put their trust in a party that has cut public services to the bone for a decade, has a distant relationship with the truth, awarded friends and associates billions in contracts, hobbled the country with Brexit and seen one of the worst death rates from Covid in the western world then more fool them. Pandering to those who vote against their own best interests and their families, on a wave of popularism is not something I’m going to waste my time on. The assumption that those who didn’t like Corbyn or this awful government are the problem and can be dismissed as middle class demonstrates how far this country has fallen in terms of political literacy.
The trouble is Derek from what I read is that a lot of voters in hartlepool blame the local council (labour) for their woes rather than the government. Misguided maybe but that's what a lot seem to think
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
05-07-2021, 09:22 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-07-2021, 09:23 AM by Protheroe.)
Can I suggest you put this on your weekend reading list guys? It'll explain everything.
And you Dekka, after your comments on here today really need to read it.
Posts: 509
Threads: 19
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation:
0
(05-07-2021, 08:31 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Looking like an impossible task, as much as Hartlepool might have voted for Corbyn the country didn't. Corbyn was fodder for the press that Starmer had to do something about, his past with the IRA connections and his views on Israel were easily used by the press to portray him having terrorist sympathies when it was a lot more complex than that, but to the working class man of England all they read was IRA sympathiser / Jew hater.
Doing some analysis of the figures. The Tory vote in Hartlepool was just over 15.5k which will probably be made up from the 22.5k in 2019 that voted Tory or Brexit so basically 70% of the 2019 vote, whereas the Labour vote was 8.5k of the 15.5k from the 2019 vote (55%) - the overall vote was 73% of the 2019 numbers. There were a big number of voters that voted independent for other parties this time, nearly 6k compared to just over 3k last time.
Brexit is the boil that can't be lanced - the stance taken by Corbyn and now Starmer is damaging the short term prospects of the party but maybe the view is that it will benefit long term by not falling t=into the Tory trap of going along with everything - if (when) it goes bad the the Tories could point towards Starmer agreeing with the steps they took if he isn't careful.
Timing is everything but as everyone has forgotten the mistakes of last year that caused the deaths of 10s of thousands and can only see the vaccine rollout success then we appear to be in a world of short term voting. Let's see where this goes but one thing is for certain, Starmer has to start performing and attacking where it hurts which is worrying because this should be easy - Tory sleaze / corruption is at its worst I've ever known, they are literally taking the piss; Johnson just lies his way through everything; When the Tory party lose stalwarts like Proth they are in trouble in theory but for every Proth they lose they seem to pick up a LIQ.
Who knows, maybe we just get what we deserve. Corrupt unaccountable politicians in it for themselves who are so far removed from the people that vote for them it doesn't matter to them any more. The revelation that Johnson earned over three quarters of a million in the year before he became prime minister tells you how much a 'man of the people' he is. It also tells you why he had to borrow the money for his flat redecoration, his tax bill took his PM salary. I'm guessing he'd either blown the money he earned or invested it offshore somewhere.
1. In which ways is it complex? I am not saying he is necessarily either of those things, but the explanations are of interest as to why this perception exists, according to you
2. You can't criticise anyone for lies when you not just failed to condemn the lies from remain but repeated a few, yesterday. And if you think Corbyn didn't lie, there's news for you
3. I am less concerned with who paid for The PM's wallpaper than I am the bill Starmer ran-up using chauffeurs when he was DPP because I paid for that
4. What's LIQ mean?
5. I couldn't care less what the PM earned before he became PM. Any comment on what Tony Blair has earned, and from what, since he stood down as one?
6. A massive mistake Labour made was taking people for thick, again. Why was it telling people that a vote for them yesterday was a vote for the NHS? Do they think people are so dim that they don't realise that yesterday's vote has little impact on it?
7. I don't think your ananlysis should be any consolation. We are 11 years (in effect) into Conservative rule. We are in a pandemic that the Government has been relentlessly attacked over (some maybe justified, some less so). The media has been hammering 'TORY SLEAZE!!!' for 2-3 weeks. Hartlepool is a traditionally solid Lab seat. They should have absolutely obliterated the Tories. And it didn't
8. Starmer's stance on Brexit won't be moved-on from when Remain is keeping the issue alive. They will never learn
Posts: 830
Threads: 1
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
Make devastating cuts to an area under the guise of balancing the books and then get rewarded with a big majority with the promise of trying to 'level up' the area, it's unbelievable.
Posts: 509
Threads: 19
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation:
0
Or, call people thick racists and wonder why they don't vote for you.
Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
I see Dudley council is now Tory run (from no overall control).
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(05-07-2021, 09:45 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: (05-07-2021, 08:31 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Looking like an impossible task, as much as Hartlepool might have voted for Corbyn the country didn't. Corbyn was fodder for the press that Starmer had to do something about, his past with the IRA connections and his views on Israel were easily used by the press to portray him having terrorist sympathies when it was a lot more complex than that, but to the working class man of England all they read was IRA sympathiser / Jew hater.
Doing some analysis of the figures. The Tory vote in Hartlepool was just over 15.5k which will probably be made up from the 22.5k in 2019 that voted Tory or Brexit so basically 70% of the 2019 vote, whereas the Labour vote was 8.5k of the 15.5k from the 2019 vote (55%) - the overall vote was 73% of the 2019 numbers. There were a big number of voters that voted independent for other parties this time, nearly 6k compared to just over 3k last time.
Brexit is the boil that can't be lanced - the stance taken by Corbyn and now Starmer is damaging the short term prospects of the party but maybe the view is that it will benefit long term by not falling t=into the Tory trap of going along with everything - if (when) it goes bad the the Tories could point towards Starmer agreeing with the steps they took if he isn't careful.
Timing is everything but as everyone has forgotten the mistakes of last year that caused the deaths of 10s of thousands and can only see the vaccine rollout success then we appear to be in a world of short term voting. Let's see where this goes but one thing is for certain, Starmer has to start performing and attacking where it hurts which is worrying because this should be easy - Tory sleaze / corruption is at its worst I've ever known, they are literally taking the piss; Johnson just lies his way through everything; When the Tory party lose stalwarts like Proth they are in trouble in theory but for every Proth they lose they seem to pick up a LIQ.
Who knows, maybe we just get what we deserve. Corrupt unaccountable politicians in it for themselves who are so far removed from the people that vote for them it doesn't matter to them any more. The revelation that Johnson earned over three quarters of a million in the year before he became prime minister tells you how much a 'man of the people' he is. It also tells you why he had to borrow the money for his flat redecoration, his tax bill took his PM salary. I'm guessing he'd either blown the money he earned or invested it offshore somewhere.
1. In which ways is it complex? I am not saying he is necessarily either of those things, but the explanations are of interest as to why this perception exists, according to you
2. You can't criticise anyone for lies when you not just failed to condemn the lies from remain but repeated a few, yesterday. And if you think Corbyn didn't lie, there's news for you
3. I am less concerned with who paid for The PM's wallpaper than I am the bill Starmer ran-up using chauffeurs when he was DPP because I paid for that
4. What's LIQ mean?
5. I couldn't care less what the PM earned before he became PM. Any comment on what Tony Blair has earned, and from what, since he stood down as one?
6. A massive mistake Labour made was taking people for thick, again. Why was it telling people that a vote for them yesterday was a vote for the NHS? Do they think people are so dim that they don't realise that yesterday's vote has little impact on it?
7. I don't think your ananlysis should be any consolation. We are 11 years (in effect) into Conservative rule. We are in a pandemic that the Government has been relentlessly attacked over (some maybe justified, some less so). The media has been hammering 'TORY SLEAZE!!!' for 2-3 weeks. Hartlepool is a traditionally solid Lab seat. They should have absolutely obliterated the Tories. And it didn't
8. Starmer's stance on Brexit won't be moved-on from when Remain is keeping the issue alive. They will never learn
1. Israel / Palestine is complex, it has been since my Dad served there and it will be for year to come.
2. Johnson and his crew lie, everyone knows it and everyone accepts it for some reason - you think whataboutery makes it better then so be it
3. Johnson gets 30k a year to pay for redecoration - his girlfriend told him she wanted better, you paid for it through the massive government contract that his donor received and then provided him with a 'loan' in return. Are you suggesting the DPP (whoever it is) should drive himself around? More whataboutery
4. Former poster
5. The amount he earned is directly relating to the reason he needed a loan, his PM salary went on taxes due. My question was where did the 750k go that he earned the year before which meant he had to borrow and put himself in a position of owing a favour.
6. If you say so, they didn't though.
7. And 6 months ago they were neck and neck according to the polls, vaccine roll out and the Tories move ahead with a feel good factor.
8. He doesn't need to - Brexit will unravel as time goes on, the Tory trap is to get Labour on board now before it goes wrong. No need to go with that one, just wait it out.
Posts: 2,502
Threads: 567
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
Derek Hardballs Wrote:Ted Maul Wrote:Derek Hardballs Wrote:Hartlepool hung a monkey thinking it was a French spy. I think the area is simply regressing back to type.
And this just gives credence to their claims that the centre of the Labour party is led by smug London elitists.
Are you James O'Brien? Why won't these thick people vote for moi?!
I’m not a Labour supporter or member, I have voted for them and Lib Dem’s previously but I don’t have any fervent loyalty to them like a football supporter has to their team. So my opinion is far from neutral but it’s not party political and certainly not based on what is good or bad for the Labour Party. My observation of the Labour Party is it’s more interested in arguing amongst itself than defeating the opposition. Childish bickering and naval gazing about minority issues, a vacuum of vision for the future, Brexit and Covid vaccine rollout is why they are where they are.
That said if your average Hartlepool voter is going to put their trust in a party that has cut public services to the bone for a decade, has a distant relationship with the truth, awarded friends and associates billions in contracts, hobbled the country with Brexit and seen one of the worst death rates from Covid in the western world then more fool them. Pandering to those who vote against their own best interests and their families, on a wave of popularism is not something I’m going to waste my time on. The assumption that those who didn’t like Corbyn or this awful government are the problem and can be dismissed as middle class demonstrates how far this country has fallen in terms of political literacy.
Yet you spend hours on a football message board pontificating.
|